Fantasy baseball closer tiers for the Top 50 relievers, plus seven sleepers to know
Context can be as crucial as the rote number when placing closers into tiered rankings. Relying on a rank creates potential disappointment and criticism. However, it's part of the valuation process leading up to fantasy baseball drafts. After much thought and consternation, I've put together my Top 50 closer rankings for 2025, with some caveats.
Here are some baseline numbers using 12-team league trends for setting saves targets. In the NFBC overall championship, these are the 80th- and 90th-percentile save totals since 2021:
Beginning your draft preparations with a target of 70 or more saves should ensure success in the category. There will be changes throughout the season, which makes some wary of paying for saves, but from NFBC leagues, here are the trends in saves among the top-25 finishers in this same timeframe:
Last year represented a shift toward accruing more saves. There is more than one way to win a league, but punting saves was not among them in this format.
Now for my tiers, with context:
1. Josh Hader (HOU)
2. Mason Miller (ATH)
3. Emmanuel Clase (CLE)
Two of the five qualified relievers with over 100 strikeouts lead the way in my updated rankings. Clase has been such a stabilizing force among closers, but can he record more than 70 innings and 40 saves in a fourth straight season? If yes, he will make history.
Advertisement
4. Edwin Díaz (NYM)
5. Ryan Helsley (STL)
6. Devin Williams (NYY)
7. Raisel Iglesias (ATL)
There is a chance Díaz could be pitching for a new contract since he can opt out at the end of the season. Unless he receives an extension, Helsley will be moved before this year's trade deadline but was last year's breakout among his peers. Williams will bring his vaunted 'Airbender' to the Bronx and gets to keep his beard. But will his back hold up? Iglesias also features a plus changeup and will be a free agent at the end of 2025.
8. Jhoan Duran (MIN)
9. Andrés Muñoz (SEA)
10. Ryan Walker (SF)
11. Jeff Hoffman (TOR)
This tier features less stability but teems with upside. Duran's velocity remains a hot topic, but if he's throwing above 101 miles per hour, his stuff remains elite. With Muñoz, it's always about health. He's tinkering with a 'kick-change,' which may provide more whiffs this year. Walker took over as the closer for the Giants during the second half of last year, and he enters 2025 in the role. The only worry is that his manager misses using him as the highest-leveraged reliever (HLR). Hoffman signed a three-year contract with the Blue Jays to take over the ninth inning. Do not overthink this.
12. Tanner Scott (LAD)
13. Félix Bautista (BAL)
Here are two more elite strikeout relievers who are a bit further down but could finish higher if their save totals net out at or above 30. However, this is not assured. Scott will receive the 'brunt' of save chances with the Dodgers. His projected total could increase if he takes on a larger save share. Bautista's returning from Tommy John surgery, and the team has said his workload will be monitored closely early this season. Once the training wheels come off and his split-finger fastball finds its form, 'The Mountain' will be a tremendous fantasy asset, though fantasy managers must remain patient.
Advertisement
14. David Bednar (PIT)
15. Jordan Romano (PHI)
16. Ryan Pressly (CHC)
17. Kenley Jansen (LAA)
Welcome to the unsexy veteran tier of closers. Not only does this tier feature 'Dad' bods, but it comes with some inherent risk. Bednar lost the closer role in the second half and has not been named his team's closer as of this writing. However, he's one year removed from tying for the NL lead in saves. Soft tissue injuries (oblique) have not been his friend, but with health, he could be a steak at his current price point.
Romano likely fills the vacated preferred save share role filled by Craig Kimbrel in 2023 for the Phillies. Fantasy managers cannot forget about Rob Thomson's 'floating closer' philosophy, which keeps Romano's save ceiling from possibly reaching its full potential. Pressly waived his no-trade clause for a chance at closing again with the Cubs. Many prefer Porter Hodge, but the all-time postseason saves leader for the Astros should do well pitching for a contract. Jansen has his eyes set on moving up the all-time saves list, and he will get his chance with the Angels. Just note his innings totals and save totals from the previous two seasons — you should not be disappointed. Sometimes, slow and steady wins the race.
18. Carlos Estévez (KC)
19. Trevor Megill (MIL)
20. Robert Suarez (SD)
21. Pete Fairbanks (TB)
We've entered the tiers of uncertainty. Estévez signed a contract that pays him like the team's closer, but his team said roles would be fluid during leverage innings. I'm still taking him for 22-25 saves, but he must perform well in those opportunities. Megill led the Brewers in saves last year but has also never thrown more than 50 MLB innings in a season. His second-half dip in K-BB and whiff rate were associated with a back issue, but if this lingers, he may not be closing by July. The same goes for Suarez, who recorded 36 saves last season but had half-season split issues, pointing toward either fatigue or the league adjusting:
22. Justin Martinez (ARI)
23. A.J. Puk (ARI)
24. Kyle Finnegan (WSH)
25. Alexis Díaz (CIN)
26. Chris Martin (TEX)
Advertisement
Currently in a camp battle for the closer role in Arizona, Martinez or Puk could be a sneaky pick at their current cost in draft capital, but they could also be busts if they are not securing saves. Worse, Kevin Ginkel could be a dark horse in this contest. Finnegan may not record 95 percent of his team's saves this year, but with some migration toward the mean and better command of his four-seam fastball, he may be a stable option in a build — just be sure to monitor your ratios. Alexis Díaz may not mesh well with Terry Francona, given his propensity for issuing free passes. Martin has always been 'the guy behind the guy,' with 14 career saves in 369 appearances, but he opens the year as the Rangers' penciled-in closer. Age and workload may necessitate changes in this role as the year progresses.
27. Mike Clevinger (CHW)
28. Liam Hendriks (BOS)
29. Aroldis Chapman (BOS)
30. Seth Halvorsen/Victor Vodnik/Tyler Kinley (COL)
31. Beau Brieske (DET)
32. Calvin Faucher/Jesús Tinoco/Anthony Bender (MIA)
Because most try to accrue saves rather than use relievers for ratio protection, this tier features the remaining four unresolved closer situations. Hendriks has been working with reduced velocity this spring (though he has touched 96 miles per hour), and his contact rate allowed represents some risk. He has pedigree, but can he be the Red Sox closer with less velocity and more guts and guile? Chapman has struggled with walks this spring, and despite his strong second half last year, he has not posted a walk percentage below 15 since 2021.
While the Rockies try to determine their closer, it has been reported the team prefers one of its younger flamethrowers. That said, Kinley has had the best spring results. Stay tuned. Predicting who gets the next save for Detroit can be challenging enough daily, but Brieske broke out in September and was the preferred leverage option with Will Vest in the postseason. It may not matter who wins the closer role for the Marlins, but Bender remains a sleeper among the listed triumvirate. This may seem bizarre, but Clevinger, the preferred save option for the White Sox, may work out.
33. Griffin Jax (MIN)
34. Cade Smith (CLE)
35. Edwin Uceta (TB)
36. Jason Adam (SD)
37. Bryan Abreu (HOU)
38. Lucas Erceg (KC)
39. José Alvarado (PHI)
40. Luke Weaver (NYY)
Relievers within this group could zoom up the rankings if they become the closer at some point in 2025. Jax, Uctea, Erceg, Alvarado and Weaver will get ancillary saves, which enhances their fantasy appeal. If anything happens in their leverage ladders, Abreu, Smith and Adam are potential closer replacements.
41. Justin Slaten (BOS)
42. Tyler Holton (DET)
43. Orion Kerkering (PHI)
44. Kevin Ginkel (ARI)
45. Ben Joyce (LAA)
46. Jeremiah Estrada (SD)
47. Camilo Doval (SF)
48. Robert Garcia (TEX)
49. Kirby Yates/Blake Treinen (LAD)
50. Yennier Cano (BAL)
Advertisement
Here are more potential replacement relievers for saves if the opportunity presents itself, along with a couple still in the mix for the closer role with opening day on the horizon. If either Hendriks or Chapman does not emerge as the closer in Boston, keep tabs on Slaten.
I have included projections for saves, holds, and SOLDS for The Athletic readers only. They do not have rankings attached — SGP does this based on the numbers, though they do not align with our tiers above.
Use this link: Jewett's projected Saves, Holds, and SOLDS
Greg Jewett: Closer expert for The Athletic; Owner of Reliever Recon and Closer Monkey
Statistical Credits: Fangraphs.com; Baseball-Reference.com; BaseballSavant.com; BrooksBaseball.net
Steamer projections of Steamerprojections.com on Fangraphs; ZiPS DC courtesy of Dan Szymborski; OOPSY Projections courtesy of Jordan Rosenblum
(Top photo of Devin Williams: Nathan Ray Seebeck / Imagn Images)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
4 days ago
- USA Today
What's ESPN replacing Around the Horn with? Here's a (temporary) answer.
What's ESPN replacing Around the Horn with? Here's a (temporary) answer. ESPN has a hole to fill now that Around the Horn has ended its 23-year run -- last week, host Tony Reali explained the scoring system and gave us one last Goodfellas opener -- in the 5 p.m. ET timeslot before Pardon the Interruption. But what will the Worldwide Leader do in that spot now that ATH is no more? The answer we have is short-term, not long-term, so we'll see what kind of programming ESPN comes up with for that late-day placement. For now, per the Hollywood Reporter, "Beginning on Tuesday, May 27, a 30-minute SportsCenter, anchored (from Bristol, of course) by Matt Barrie and Christine Williamson, will temporarily air in its place." That's it for now, and with the additional changes at the network -- no more SportsCenter LA -- viewers will have some things to get used to.
New York Times
4 days ago
- New York Times
Once their biggest question, the Astros' bullpen is now their bedrock
HOUSTON — The Houston Astros' bedrock is a bullpen of waiver claims and castoffs, an eight-man embodiment of the franchise's elite pitching infrastructure. Half of them throw left-handed, including the highest-paid reliever in the sport. A minor-league Rule 5 pick with a righteous mustache and meager velocity builds the bridge to him. Advertisement 'We don't have the traditional bullpen,' Josh Hader acknowledged on Sunday afternoon. The construction bucks convention, but is calming the biggest concern many harbored before this season began. Four more scoreless innings on Sunday lowered the Astros' bullpen ERA to 2.75. No American League relief corps has one lower. None allows a lower batting average, either. Only the San Francisco Giants and Minnesota Twins entered Monday with a lower bullpen WHIP than the Astros, who salary-dumped their setup man this winter and signed no reliever to a major-league contract in response. 'I'd be lying if I said it didn't exceed my expectations, but we had high hopes,' pitching coach Josh Miller said. 'We knew we had talented guys, it was just (about) who was going to fill the last few spots.' Those that have are keeping the Astros afloat, allowing their tepid lineup ample runway to correct itself while the team remains above .500. Bullpens house the most volatile position group in baseball, so sustaining this level of success will be borderline impossible. That Houston is missing three starters from its season-opening rotation — and two who threw 312 1/3 innings last season — will only make the task harder. Workloads will grow, wear will wreak havoc and the same surprising unpredictability that Houston has witnessed with this group across 53 games could reverse course. Still, ballclubs are buoyed by different positions during prolonged stretches of every 162-game season. Houston just completed a run of 17 consecutive games without an off day, a span in which starters Ronel Blanco and Hayden Wesneski suffered serious injuries. Across that 17-game span, Houston's bullpen posted a 2.66 ERA while stranding 82.8 percent of the runners it inherited. Of the 18 earned runs Astros relievers allowed, six came during a 13-9 loss to the Cincinnati Reds on May 10: a game in which starter Lance McCullers Jr. secured one out. The two pitchers who permitted six runs in relief are no longer on the active roster. Advertisement 'These guys are getting opportunities to throw important pitches, and when you have success in those situations, you can build that confidence,' Hader said. 'Pitching, in general, once you have solid confidence in your stuff, it's really hard to beat when you can know you're throwing a pitch that you have full confidence in — one that you can either throw in the zone or get swing-and-miss with it.' Hader is the lone household name, though new setup man Bryan Abreu has been among the sport's most unheralded relievers for the past two seasons. That Abreu has the highest WHIP in his own bullpen underscores the depth Houston has accrued around him. Twenty qualified relievers entered Monday with a WHIP lower than 0.90. Houston's bullpen houses three of them: Hader, Bryan King and Steven Okert. No other American League team has more than one. Houston's Kaleb Ort has a 0.84 WHIP, too, but hasn't thrown enough innings to qualify. No qualified reliever in the sport boasts a lower WHIP than Okert, a man who arrived in spring training on a minor-league deal and without any guarantees of a spot on Houston's active roster. Pitching coaches helped him improve the ride on his four-seam fastball to complement an already sublime slider. Okert has struck out 27 batters across his first 23 2/3 innings. The 16.7 percent swinging strike rate he is generating is the 14th highest of any reliever in baseball, but third inside his own bullpen. Both Hader and Bennett Sousa are inducing swinging strikes higher than 18 percent of the time. Sousa, Okert, King and Hader are all left-handed, a fact that would make former manager Dusty Baker faint, but now offers his successor so many options. Hader's role as a $19 million closer makes him platoon neutral by nature, but both Okert and King are faring better against right-handed hitters this season than lefties. Even Sousa is limiting right-handed hitters to a .630 OPS. Advertisement As a result, Houston's bullpen has faced the most left-on-right matchups in baseball. Righties have a .168/.220/.265 slash line against them. As a whole, Houston's bullpen — half of which is left-handed — is holding right-handed hitters to a .183 batting average and .261 on-base percentage. Both are the lowest in the major leagues. Only the Los Angeles Dodgers' bullpen has more strikeouts against righties than the Astros. 'It makes the job easy for Josh and Joe to navigate through lineups and strategically put guys in certain spots,' Hader said. 'When you have guys being able to throw secondaries for strikes, expand and also command the zone with their heater, it makes it harder.' Take, for example, Sunday afternoon. Both Abreu and Hader had pitched on Friday and Saturday, thrusting that moustached minor-league Rule 5 pick into the biggest spot of the season. King saw five right-handed hitters. He retired four of them, flummoxing them with a sweeper below the barrel and the 'funky' four-seam fastball the Astros have implored him to throw. King likes to say that before arriving in the Astros' system, he'd never been told he had a good fastball. Now, according to Baseball Savant's run value metric, it is the best-performing four-seamer in the American League's best bullpen. Only the Chicago Cubs — King's previous organization — boast a bullpen that throws a higher percentage of fastballs than Houston's. Astros relievers average just 93.8 mph on their fastballs, the eighth-slowest mark in the sport. Still, only the Toronto Blue Jays' bullpen has allowed less contact and generated more swing-and-miss. As Hader said, it's not traditional. 'Pitching, in general, once you have solid confidence in your stuff, it's really hard to beat when you know you're throwing a pitch that you have full confidence in,' Hader said. Advertisement That fastball King throws averages just 91.9 mph. On Sunday, Randy Arozarena saw three that neared 94. He watched the last one halve home plate for strike three, keeping King unscored upon in 10 of his past 11 outings. 'The guy's got some,' Espada said, pausing before something unprintable came from his mouth. 'He's not afraid. He's not afraid. He's going to go after you. You're either going to hit me or I'm going to get you out. When you come in from the pen, you have to have that mindset. He has that mindset.' He's not alone. (Top photo of Bryan Abreu: Alex Slitz / Getty Images)
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
A's catcher MacIver gets go-ahead hit, throws out runner to end game in big league debut at age 28
Athletics pitcher Mason Miller points to catcher Willie MacIver after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics pitcher Hogan Harris, left, and catcher Willie MacIver, right, walk to the dugout during the seventh inning of a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics catcher Willie MacIver, left, high-fives pitcher Mason Miller, right, after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics catcher Willie MacIver throws the ball to the pitcher during the fifth inning of a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics pitcher Mason Miller points to catcher Willie MacIver after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics pitcher Mason Miller points to catcher Willie MacIver after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics pitcher Mason Miller points to catcher Willie MacIver after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics pitcher Hogan Harris, left, and catcher Willie MacIver, right, walk to the dugout during the seventh inning of a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics catcher Willie MacIver, left, high-fives pitcher Mason Miller, right, after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics catcher Willie MacIver throws the ball to the pitcher during the fifth inning of a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) Athletics pitcher Mason Miller points to catcher Willie MacIver after winning a baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies, Sunday, May 25, 2025, in West Sacramento, Calif. (AP Photo/Sara Nevis) WEST SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — Willie MacIver hit a go-ahead single in the eighth inning of his major league debut. Minutes later, the 28-year-old catcher threw out a runner trying to steal second for the final out that ended the Athletics' 11-game losing streak. 'I woke up hoping for a Gatorade bath at the end of the game and, man, I've never felt such a good feeling with such cold water,' he said after the A's beat Philadelphia 5-4 on Sunday and stopped the Phillies' nine-game win streak. Advertisement MacIver was among five players brought up from the minors on Friday. He started Sunday in place of Shea Langeliers in the day game after a night game. 'This is part of the talk that we had in spring training, it was going to take the whole army that was in the room,' said manager Mark Kotsay, who watched the end from the clubhouse following his first ejection this season. MacIver, hitting .389 with two homers and 30 RBIs at Triple-A Las Vegas, grounded out in the second and fourth against Jesús Luzardo, then struck out in the sixth. After Trea Turner homered in the eighth off Hogan Harris for a 4-3 lead, another Friday call-ups sparked the rally. Advertisement Logan Davidson walked and scored on Lawrence Butler's triple against Matt Strahm. MacIver fouled off a fastball, then drove a cutter into center field to bring home the go-ahead run. 'I'm always upset about walks,' Strahm said. 'I just feel like I've had too many too close together.' A day after blowing a ninth-inning lead, Mason Miller allowed a two-out single in the ninth to Alec Bohm. Johan Rojas pinch ran and MacIver, who had been in the minors since 2018, threw to shortstop Jacob Wilson, who tagged the sliding Rojas on an elbow. 'I had family here, friends, teammates, ex-teammates,' MacIver said. 'It's a dream come true. I can't even put it into words.' Advertisement Rojas at 29.9 feet per second has the fifth-highest sprint speed in the majors among players with 10 or more opportunities, according to Statcast. MacIver was selected by Colorado in the ninth round of the 2018 amateur draft from the University of Washington. He played in the 2021 Futures Game with Bobby Witt Jr., Julio Rodríguez and Spencer Torkelson. MacIver became a minor league free agent last November and signed a minor league contract with the Athletics a month later. 'I'm so grateful for my family and for my support system,' he said. 'They've been everything to me and I obviously wouldn't be here without them and like I can't thank them enough. ... The fact that they could be here and see my first hit and how that game ended, man, it's awesome.' Advertisement Davidson started at first a day after Nick Kurtz left the game because of a left hip issue. He had two hits and two RBIs a day after a forgettable debut. Davidson entered as a pinch runner for Kurtz in the 10th inning. He was thrown out at the plate, called for obstruction and ended a 9-6 loss by striking out. 'There's a lot of confidence that I have in this kid,' Kotsay said. 'I've invested a lot of time, we've had a lot of conversations through the last two seasons about what it was going to take for him to be a big leaguer and he has not backed down from anything that I've given him and to see the reward come today and just his first start and contributing and having such an impact to the win, was awesome.' ___ AP MLB:
