A French icon falls: Gérard Depardieu's guilt will make his films hard to watch
It seems strangely appropriate that 76-year-old French movie star Gérard Depardieu was found guilty of sexual assault and given an 18-month suspended prison sentence on the eve of the 78th edition of the Cannes film festival. Both Cannes and Depardieu, born in the 40s, belong to an old world, but it seems only one of them has managed to adapt to the times we live in, especially since the #MeToo movement.
For anyone who followed the trial closely, it was never in doubt that justice would prevail and that a French monument was about to fall. Once the accusers, two female technicians who worked as set-dresser and assistant director on the film Les Volets Verts in 2021, had pressed charges and the facts been exposed in court, there was little doubt as to the dignity of the victims and the veracity of the sexual assaults. But what was particularly striking was how Depardieu behaved throughout the trial. His attitude was an aggravating factor for the public but also the court. Unrepentant, uncomprehending, lamenting that he didn't understand this new world, Depardieu pretended to be physically frailer than he was, and lacked gravitas.
For this French citizen, there was one particularly revealing moment in the trial, when 76-year-old actor Fanny Ardant (who starred alongside Depardieu in François Truffaut's The Woman Next Door) testified in support of her friend Depardieu. She made her entrance in a long black dress and white collar, and delivered a passionate monologue about the art of acting. 'I know we are here to search for the truth, but I would like to broaden the debate and say why Gérard Depardieu is such a great actor. He is a genius at giving his characters depth and richness, and a complexity with its share of contradiction, good and evil, light and shadow. Any genius carries in them something extravagant, rebellious and dangerous (…) If he is loved all over the world it is because everyone can recognise themselves in the characters he plays. (…) Yes, he has a big mouth, yes, he shouts obscenities, yes, he plays the fool. Without taking risks, one is no more an artist, one is just a servant.'
Ardant ended: 'I know the world has changed, I know we now find intolerable what we used to tolerate and that institutions are here to transform society, but fear should not become the new morality.' The court's president thanked Ardant for 'this beautiful portrait of Gérard Depardieu' and, implacable, reminded the actor that 'we are not here for morality purposes; we are here to apply the law. And to look at facts of sexual assaults.' Indeed. There was never a better reminder, especially in France, that facts prevail and that even genius cannot be a shield any more.
On Tuesday, Depardieu's lawyer declared they would appeal against the court's decision. However, the film industry sentenced him a long time ago. The actor, arguably one of the greatest of the 20th century, hasn't shot a film in the last three years and his rare performances on stage have been disrupted by protesters. In light of this judgment his career could be finished and his reputation profoundly tarnished. What remains is his work: more than 200 films and TV series. They exist, in people's memories and in celluloid, and they cannot be erased.
This cinephile will not banish masterpieces such as Bernardo Bertolucci's 1900, Truffaut's The Last Metro and The Woman Next Door, Andrzej Wajda's Danton, Maurice Pialat's Under the Sun of Satan, and Jean-Paul Rappeneau's Cyrano from her personal cinematic pantheon. A film is a sum of many talents, in front of and behind the camera and the acts of one individual should not taint the work of another hundred. However, to say that the fall of Depardieu will have no impact on our experience as viewers is of course deluded. Cinephiles are also citizens, they don't live in a vacuum-packed world. Watching those films again may prove a bittersweet experience, just like watching postwar French films with actors who chose to collaborate with the enemy during the second world war. Unsavoury and sad.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
School killings leave stunned Austria and France searching for answers
Two shocking attacks within two hours of each other, in France and Austria, have left parents and governments reeling and at a loss how to protect school students from random, deadly about 08:15 on Tuesday, a 14-year-old boy from an ordinary family in Nogent, eastern France, drew out a kitchen knife during a school bag check and fatally stabbed a school long afterwards in south-east Austria, a 21-year-old who had dropped out of school three years earlier, walked into Dreierschützengasse high school in Graz at 09:43, and shot dead nine students and a teacher with a Glock 19 handgun and a sawn-off both countries there is a demand for solutions and for a greater focus on young people who resort to such has never seen a school attack on this scale, but the French stabbing took place during a government programme aimed at tackling the growth in knife crime. Austrians ask about gun laws and a failed system The Graz shooter, named by Austrian media as Arthur A, has been described by police as a very introverted person, who had retreated to the virtual "great passion" was online first-person shooter games, and he had social contacts with other gamers over the internet, according to Michael Lohnegger, the criminal investigation chief in Styria, the state where it happened.A former student at the Dreierschützengasse school, Arthur A had failed to complete his at the school, he put on a headset and shooting glasses, before going on a deadly seven-minute shooting spree. He then killed himself in a school owned the two guns legally, had passed a psychological test to own a licence and had several sessions of weapons training earlier this year at a Graz shooting has sparked a big debate in Austria about whether its gun laws need to be tightened – and about the level of care available for troubled young has emerged that the shooter was rejected from the country's compulsory military service in July ministry spokesman Michael Bauer told the BBC that Arthur A was found to be "psychologically unfit" for service after he underwent tests. But he said Austria's legal system prevented the army from passing on the results of such are now calls for that law to be changed. Alex, the mother of a 17-year-old boy who survived the shooting, told the BBC that more should have been done to prevent people like Arthur A from dropping out of school in the first place."We know… that when people shoot each other like this, it's mostly when they feel alone and drop out and be outside. And we don't know how to get them back in, into society, into the groups, into their peer groups," she said."We, as grown-ups, have got the responsibility for that, and we have to take it now."President Alexander Van der Bellen raised the possibility of tightening Austria's gun laws, on a visit to Graz after the attack: "If we come to the conclusion that Austria's gun laws need to be changed to ensure greater safety, then we will do so."Austria has one of the most heavily armed civilian populations in Europe, with an estimated 30 firearms per 100 there have been school shootings here before, they have been far smaller and involved far fewer mayor of Graz, Elke Kahr, believes no private person should be able to have weapons at all. "Weapons licences are issued too quickly," she told Austria's ORF TV. "Only the police should carry weapons, not private individuals."What we know about Austria school shootingGraz in shock and grief after attack French focus on mental health as well as security Armed gendarmes were present at the entrance to the Françoise Dolto middle school in Nogent, 100km (62 miles) east of Paris, when a teenager pulled out a 20cm kitchen knife and repeatedly stabbed Mélanie G, who was 31 and had a four-year-old boy accused of carrying out the murder told police that he had been reprimanded on Friday by another school assistant for kissing his girlfriend. As a result he had a grudge against school assistants in general, and apparently had made up his mind to kill one. Schools were closed on Monday for a bank holiday, and Tuesday was his first day state prosecutor's initial assessment was that the boy, called Quentin, came from a normal functioning family, and had no criminal or mental health record. However, the child also appeared detached and emotionless. Adept at violent video games, he showed a "fascination with death" and an "absence of reference-points relating to the value of human life". The Nogent attack does not fit the template of anti-social youth crime or gang violence seen in France until is there any suggestion of indoctrination over social to the prosecutor, the boy did little of that. He had been violent on two occasions against fellow pupils, and was suspended for a day each time. There is no family breakdown or deprivation and school officials described him as "sociable, a pretty good student, well-integrated into the life of the establishment".This year he had even been named the class "ambassador" on all the calls for greater security at schools, this crime took place literally under the noses of armed gendarmes. As Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau put it, some crimes will happen no matter how many police you more information on the boy's state of mind, we must wait for the full psychologist's report, and it may well be that there were signs missed, or there are family details we do not yet know the face of it, he is perhaps more a middle-class loner, and his apparent normality suggests a crime triggered by internalised mental processes, rather than by peer-driven association or emulation. That is what strikes the chord in France. If an ordinary boy can turn out like this from watching too many violent videos, then who is next?Significantly, the French government had only just approved showing the British Netflix series Adolescence as an aid in schools. There are differences, of course. The boy arrested for the killing of a teenage girl in the TV series yields to evil "toxic male" influences on social media – but there is the same question of teenagers being made vulnerable by isolation the political spectrum, there are calls for action but little agreement on what should be the priority, nor hope that anything can make much the killing, President Emmanuel Macron had angered the right by saying they were too obsessed with crime, and not sufficiently interested in other issues like the environment. The Nogent attack put him on the back foot, and he has repeated his pledge to ban social media to under there are two difficulties. One is the practicality of the measure, which in theory is being dealt with by the EU but is succumbing to endless procrastination. The other is that, according to the prosecutor, the boy was not especially interested in social media. It was violent video games that were his Minister François Bayrou has said that sales of knives to under-15s will be banned. But the boy took his from home. Bayrou says airport-style metal-detectors should be tested at schools, but most heads are populist right wants tougher sentences for teenagers carrying knives, and the exclusion of disruptive pupils from regular classes. But the boy in Nogent was not a problem the only measure everyone says is needed is more provision of school doctors, nurses and psychologists in order to detect early signs of pupils going off the of course will require a lot of money, which is another thing France does not have a lot of.
BBC News
6 hours ago
- BBC News
Judge hears closing arguments in hockey sexual assault trial
Closing arguments have concluded in the trial of five Canadian ice hockey players accused of sexually assaulting a woman, with both sides offering competing stories on what had unfolded on the evening of the alleged accused men, all former players for Canada's world junior hockey team, have pleaded not guilty to the charges. Their fate now rests with a judge. Their lawyers argued that the woman consented to engaging in sexual acts with the players at a hotel room in London, Ontario, in 2018, while attending a hockey woman testified that she had consensual sex with one player that night, but did not agree to sexual acts with the others who had entered the hotel room. The accused are Michael McLeod, Dillon Dubé, Cal Foote, Alex Formenton and Carter Hart. All were professional players with the National Hockey League (NHL) when the assault allegations woman is known as EM due to a publication ban on her name. She was 20 years old at the time of the testified that she had met Mr McLeod at a bar in June 2018, where he and other players were celebrating after the gala. In her testimony, she told the court that she had agreed to go to Mr McLeod's hotel room and they had consensual lawyer Meaghan Cunningham argued that the woman was later put in a "highly stressful and unpredictable" situation after Mr McLeod invited other players by text message to the room for a "three-way". She feared for her safety, the lawyer said, and felt pressured to perform sexual acts to protect herself, including having sex with one player and oral sex with three others. Over days of testimony, EM said that she went on "auto-pilot" mode as the men demanded sex acts from Cunningham referenced a video shot by Mr McLeod at the end of the night of the woman, where he can be heard asking her "You're OK with this, though, right?" and she responds: "I'm OK with this."She argued that the way the question is framed suggests EM had not agreed to what had just transpired. "I want to ask Your Honour to think carefully about those words and what they tell us about what was happening at that point in time," Ms Cunningham told Justice Maria lawyers told the court a different story, focusing on her credibility and reliability as a witness. They argued it was EM who was the instigator and demanded sex acts from the men in the room. Defence lawyers also argued her actions that night made them believe she was consenting and zeroed in on one part of her testimony, where she said she had adopted a "porn star persona" as a coping mechanism during the incident. They said that the Crown had failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the woman did not consent."This alone warrants an acquittal against all of these defendants," said lawyer Lisa Carnelos, who represented Mr Dubé.The closing arguments mark the end of the month-and-a-half long trial, which featured a declaration of a mistrial early on and the dismissal of the jury mid-way verdict will be decided by Justice Carroccia alone. It is scheduled to be delivered on 24 July.
Daily Mail
7 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Small boats? Now migrants are coming by luxury yacht, writes SUE REID. So are the numbers arriving EVEN WORSE than we think?
A luxury yacht named Tacoma sailed out of a smart French marina in April, supposedly for a jaunt along the Brittany coast. The sleek blue and white vessel worth £70,000 had been hired by man with an Austrian passport from a reputable boat charter company operating at a quayside office in Brest. 'The renter's credentials were checked by us,' Valery Roue, co-owner of the Eridan charter company, told the Mail this week. 'His passport, his identity details, his maritime certificate. Everything seemed in order. This Austrian hired the yacht for a two-week local sailing holiday with friends. Or that is what he told us.' What actually happened next to the six-berth Tacoma is a shocking tale that exposes how pleasure yachts hired in France are being stolen by criminal gangs to bring illegal migrants here. Today, the 'Austrian' who hired the vessel has disappeared. He is being hunted by British and French police across Europe and the Balkans because one of the documents he used for the yacht hire shows he originally hails from North Macedonia. Far from pottering along the Brittany coast, the 23ft yacht was soon spotted by Monsieur Roue, using a vessel tracking device, leaving French waters to head for Cornwall. He alerted the UK Border Force who pounced on the yacht as it reached the mouth of the Helford River, near Newquay, on Sunday, April 13. Hiding inside the cabin were 17 Albanian migrants, including one woman, hoping to slip illegally into Britain. They are thought to have been picked up by the Tacoma from a secret location along the Brittany coast soon after the yacht sailed from Brest with three men, including a skipper, on board. Roue explained: 'I became suspicious after my yacht left Brest. I watched its route and found her sailing across the Channel. Border Force stopped it at Newquay but the "Austrian" was not there.' This week, we found the Tacoma back in Brest, a couple of hundred yards from Roue's office. After 52 days impounded in Cornwall by Border Force, she was sailed back to France by a crew from the charter company a few days ago. The incident has led British and French immigration authorities to sound the alarm over French charter yachts being targeted to bring migrants into the UK. A 'high alert' has been sent out by the French customs authority to all charter boat companies along the Brittany coast, warning them to be vigilant about migrant- smuggling gangs who may try to hire, or simply steal, their yachts. Meanwhile, British Border Force is using extra surveillance to check pleasure craft arriving at UK ports, private marinas and remote inlets from France, Belgium and the Netherlands. The force is responsible for securing the 11,000 miles of British coastline. 'We patrol 24/7, carrying out proactive, as well as reactive, operations,' Charlie Eastaugh, its director of maritime, told the BBC after the Tacoma incident. But he added that there are hundreds of harbours and marinas in the UK, and it would not be a reasonable expectation to have a 'fixed presence' in all of them. A recent BBC exposé about a British ex-soldier and yachtsman known by the pseudonym of Nick, who smuggled hundreds of clandestine passengers – many Albanian and Vietnamese – into private marinas at seaside towns across south-east England, had also identified 'vulnerabilities' in the system, said Mr Eastaugh. A Home Office statement about the Tacoma migrants explained: 'This case shows that while small-boat Channel crossings remain under close scrutiny, people- smuggling gangs are adapting their methods, using pleasure craft to try to evade detection.' The Mail has discovered that this vessel is not the only Brittany yacht used for migrant journeys this spring. On May 8, according to authorities, a second vessel hired at a marina 14 miles from the picturesque French port of La Trinite-sur-Mer was found abandoned near Falmouth, Cornwall. The yacht was 'very similar in design and size to the Tacoma' and it is suspected that illegals on board simply jumped off on arrival and disappeared into the UK. Our French sources told us those on this second vessel are also likely to have been from Albania, a country whose citizens now face deportation from the UK if they arrive on smugglers' small boats across the Channel. 'They are prepared to pay for a yacht crossing because they do not want to be caught up in the lengthy British asylum system or deported. Most pay huge prices to enter Britain secretly by sea to work on the black market or survive by crime,' they added. The Albanian passengers on the Tacoma have been interviewed by police from the National Crime Agency – Britain's FBI – by immigration authorities and Border Force officers. They are likely to face deportation. Meanwhile, an investigation is under way into the crew who sailed the boat to Britain. Two of them are Albanian men in their 30s who have been named publicly and pleaded guilty in April at Bodmin magistrates' court to breaching previous UK deportation orders. They are due to be sentenced in the near future. As for the missing 'Austrian' mastermind of the Tacoma operation (which stood to reap £250,000 from the migrants on board), he may never be found. The passport and maritime certificate he handed over to Mr Roue's charter boat company could have been faked or stolen. 'They looked genuine, but we just don't know,' Mr Roue said. 'Although I was the person who alerted your British Border Force, it has charged us for every day the Tacoma was impounded in Cornwall during a police investigation. 'When we sailed the yacht back, she was in good order considering how many Albanian migrants were found below deck on a sea journey that takes at least 20 hours.' His company has been operating boat charters for nearly 40 years. 'This is the first time that we have had a yacht taken by gangsters.
