BBC accused of 'spurious' defence over Gaza documentary axe
BBC's 'spurious' defence after axing documentary
THE BBC has come under fire for 'censoring' the accounts of medics and aid workers in Gaza after axing a documentary about Israel's brutal bombardment.
Gaza: Doctors Under Attack explored the destruction of the health service in Gaza and was reportedly ready to be broadcast in February.
We told how the documentary was shelved last month following the controversy around How To Survive A Warzone, which featured the son of a Hamas official.
The production firm behind Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, Basement Films, said at the time that the BBC had postponed airing its film until after a review into How To Survive A Warzone is complete.
However, despite the fact that this review remains ongoing, the BBC has now officially scrapped plans to show the documentary after concluding that it "risked creating a perception of partiality" over the corporation's coverage of Israel and Gaza.
READ MORE: Ex-Unionist party leader backs Scottish independence referendum
Tom Chivers, who works for the Media Reform Coalition, said the BBC's excuse for shelving the documentary was 'spurious', adding it had 'abandoned any pretence' that it gives 'equal regard' to the lives of Palestinians.
He told The National: 'This is only the latest failure by the BBC to provide accurate, impartial and independent reporting on Israel's siege in Gaza and the appalling humanitarian crisis it has created.
'By censoring these accounts from medics and aid workers in Gaza, the BBC has abandoned any pretence that it gives equal regard to the lives and experiences of Palestinians.
'The BBC's excuse for refusing to broadcast the documentary rests on a completely made-up phrase. A 'perception of bias' has no basis whatsoever in the BBC's editorial guidelines.
'If this 'perception' test was applied to other topic of reporting, it would be impossible for the BBC to broadcast any news at all.
'This spurious, unjustifiable defence proves that the BBC is completely cowed by, and overly sensitive to, the objections of Israeli officials and those who wish to ignore or silence any reporting on the atrocities taking place in Gaza.'
The BBC said it was transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films, and that the documentary had "not undergone the BBC's final pre-broadcast sign-off processes", as some reports had suggested.
Basement Films said it was 'relieved' that the BBC has released the film back to the company 'so that we can release it to the world'.
The company said the BBC had confirmed the film had been approved for broadcast and gave out six different release dates before eventually dropping it.
A Basement Films statement said: 'We would like to thank all the BBC people who worked on this film, those who approved it, those who praised and lauded it, and the scores of BBC staff members; on air editors, correspondents, producers, managers, technical staff and freelancers who told us to keep fighting and gave us sound advice, wrote group letters to their bosses, and asked us to keep fighting to have the film released as approved.
'Although the BBC are now taking their names off this film, it will remain theirs, and we hope it serves to open up the debate on how the nation's broadcaster covers what is happening in Gaza, and that people feel free to speak up and speak out, rather than stay silent or leave, and at some point get the journalistic leadership they deserve.
'But most of all we would like to thank the doctors and contributors and survivors, and to apologise for not believing them when they said the BBC would never run a film like this. It turned out they were right.'
Sky News reporter slated for Israeli ambassador interview
Elsewhere, Sky News reporter Wilfred Frost has been criticised for an interview he carried out with Israeli ambassador to the UK, Tzipi Hotovely.
Frost challenged Hotovely about Gazan children dying amid Israel's assault on the enclave.
Tzipi Hotovely: "We are not there to kill anyone, rather than the terrorists, but in the end of the day its Hamas that is creating this horrible architecture of children & people as human shields"
Wilfred Frost: "I think there's no doubt about that & I'm not questioning that" pic.twitter.com/8xF8nGB4il — Saul Staniforth (@SaulStaniforth) June 23, 2025
But he has been slated for suggesting he was 'not questioning' a statement by Hotovely that Hamas is to blame for using 'children and people as human shields'.
Appearing on Sky News on Monday, Hotovely said: "We are not there to kill anyone, rather than the terrorists, but in the end of the day it's Hamas that is creating this horrible architecture of children and people as human shields.'
READ MORE: UK not selectively applying international law, Labour minister insists
Frost replied with: 'I think there's no doubt about that and I'm not questioning that"
Also in the interview, Frost said 'we can both agree resoundingly about that' when Hotovely said 'they need to blame Hamas for creating this reality for the Palestinians'.
On the exchange, Chivers told The National: 'It's not the job of reporters to demure to government officials and repeat their propaganda, their job is to challenge them and report the truth.'
TV producer Richard Sanders described the interview as 'appalling'.
He said on Twitter/X: 'This is absolutely appalling and Sky should retract.
'There is not a scrap of evidence Hamas uses civilians as human shields. There is a mass of evidence that Israel does precisely this.
'We dealt with this issue at length in our Al Jazeera Investigative Unit film GAZA. This lie continues to be the principal justification for the slaughter of civilians in Gaza.'
On social media, Frost was accused of 'parroting propaganda', while one user said it was an example of 'why people are losing faith in traditional media'.
Sky News has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
24 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Nigel Farage slams ‘two-tier' justice system after Labour councillor cleared by jury
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp compared it to the case of Lucy Connolly, the wife of an ex-Tory councillor who pleaded guilty to stirring up racial hatred amid the riots Nigel Farage and top Tories have been condemned after labelling a jury verdict"unacceptable" and 'two tier justice'. It comes after Labour councillor, Ricky Jones, who called for far-right activists' throats to be cut at an anti-racism rally in the wake of the Southport murders was found not guilty of encouraging violent disorder on Friday. Mr Farage questioned the courts, as did the Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp. Shadow Housing Secretary James Cleverly also took to X to slam the verdict, despite it coming from a jury. Reform UK leader Mr Farage said: "This is another outrageous example of two-tier justice." Mr Cleverly said: "Perverse decisions like this are adding to the anger that people feel and amplifying the belief that there isn't a dispassionate criminal justice system." Mr Philp compared it to the case of Lucy Connolly, the wife of an ex-Tory councillor who pleaded guilty to stirring up racial hatred for vile posts amid the riots following the Southport murders. He said: 'It is astonishing that Labour councillor Ricky Jones, who was caught on video calling for throats to be slit, is let off scot free - whereas Lucy Connolly got 31 months prison for posting something no worse. The development of two tier justice is becoming increasingly alarming.' The criticism comes despite Connolly pleading guilty, and a juror finding Mr Jones not guilty. Connolly had posted 'mass deportation now, set fire to all the f****** hotels full of the b******* for all I care… if that makes me racist so be it.' The criticism also puts them at odds with the Shadow Justice Secretary MP Robert Jenrick, who said earlier this year that juries were Britain's 'gift to the world '. Responding on X, barrister Joanna Hardy-Susskind said: 'Lucy Connolly pleaded guilty & was sentenced. Ricky Jones pleaded not guilty & was acquitted by a jury. 'That is not two-tier justice. It is legally illiterate to imply one was punished & the other 'let off scot free' - when one of them was quite literally acquitted after trial.' Former Tory cabinet minister Jacob Rees-Mogg also questioned the language used by his former colleagues. He said: "This is self-evidently not an example of two-tier justice as this Councillor was cleared by a jury. Lucy Connolly offered a guilty plea so did not have a jury trial, although she probably could have done had she pleaded not guilty. There was also condemnation from a source in the legal system, who warned 'we must respect the verdict of the jury and it must be right whatever it is'.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Charity boss offers Jenrick 'olive branch' over xenophobia row
Charity boss and theologian Krish Kandiah has offered what he called an "olive branch" to Robert Jenrick after accusing the shadow justice secretary of "xenophobia" on BBC Radio 4 Today programme's Thought for the Day slot on to the claim, Jenrick said listeners had been told that "if you're concerned about the threat of illegal migrants to your kids, you're racist".The BBC later apologised and edited out the comment from the segment on the BBC Sounds catch-up Friday, in a message on social media to Jenrick, Kandiah said he would "love to find a way we could work together to de-escalate the fear and anger many are feeling in our country". "I believe we need to focus on the real challenges that are making people worried – housing, jobs and the cost of living – rather than ramping up anti-immigrant sentiment."I worked with you when you [Jenrick] were housing minister and the UK welcomed over 200,000 people from Hong Kong. I was grateful for your support and compassion during that time."Jenrick's team has been contacted for a response. Kandiah runs the refugee charity Sanctuary Foundation which has previously helped refugees from Ukraine and Afghanistan. During his Thought for the Day segment, Kandiah referenced an article in the Mail on Sunday in which Jenrick had written: "I certainly don't want my children to share a neighbourhood with men from backward countries who broke into Britain illegally, and about whom we know next to nothing."Kandiah said: "These words echo a fear many have absorbed – fear of the stranger. The technical name for this is xenophobia. All phobias are, by definition, irrational. Nevertheless, they have a huge impact."It is understandable that many people are scared by the unknown, especially if they've been told illegality and unfairness are part of the story. "However, over the past year, xenophobia has fuelled angry protests outside hotels housing asylum seekers, deepening divisions in our communities."In response, Jenrick, who has three daughters aged 10, 12 and 14, posted: "On BBC Radio 4 this morning listeners were told that if you're concerned about the threat of illegal migrants to your kids, you're racist. Wrong. You're a good parent."A BBC spokesperson said: "While its reflection on fear in society from a faith perspective is broadly in line with expectations of Thought for the Day, some of the language it used went beyond that and we apologise for its inclusion."It is understood the BBC was apologising for the inclusion of an opinion in a place where it was inappropriate, not passing judgement on the rights or wrongs of the opinion.
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
Why I said the BBC is complicit in genocide live on air
Mary Nest Lawrence, 23, from Manchester, accused the Labour Government and the BBC of being "complicit in the Palestinian genocide" before she was promptly cut off by the host during a segment on wedding speeches on BBC Radio 2 on Thursday. Lawrence said: "Hi there, I'm just calling, thank you so much for putting me on. The BBC and the UK Government are complicit in the Palestinian genoc–" She was promptly cut off before she could say the end of the word "genocide", as radio host Tina Daheely went on to say: "Oh, okay, not about wedding speeches at all. Cut that one off there because I've no idea what else they were going to say." A BBC spokesperson said at the time: 'During a specific item on wedding speeches, a caller began to give personal views unrelated to the subject matter, so we swiftly moved on to the next listener's opinion.' Speaking to The National, Lawrence (below) revealed that the disruption was part of a coordinated effort by campaign group Youth Demand, which is planning on taking more action against the BBC in the coming months. Mary Nest Lawrence is a 23-year-old activist with Youth Demand (Image: Supplied) Lawrence said the group were targeting the BBC because of their coverage of Israel's genocide in Gaza, pointing towards a recent report from the Centre for Media Monitoring (CfMM), found that the BBC gave Israeli deaths 33 times more coverage per fatality, despite Gaza suffering 34 times more casualties than Israel. The broadcaster was also found to have interrupted or dismissed claims of genocide more than 100 times – while only 3% of articles analysed by the CfMM used the terms "war crimes" in relation to Israeli violence against Palestinians. READ MORE: BBC Scotland breached accuracy standards with Labour peer on Debate Night Lawrence told The National that the BBC is where "everyone gets their information from", particularly if they are less politically active. "Information is such a tool – how are people who aren't necessarily political supposed to know what's going on if the BBC is not telling anybody about it?", she said. "We disagree with the UK Government for continuing trade with Israel, for allowing all of these people to die despite the fact that Netanyahu's been tried as a war criminal. "And the BBC is not showing any of this. They're not doing their job, they're not providing everybody with all the facts." Lawrence said that a group of seven campaigners had tried to get on the BBC's phone-in on Thursday. "I was the only one who got on, but we're going to keep trying," she said. Mary Nest Lawrence (Image: Supplied) Lawrence added that the presenter's response was "crazy", as she said that she did not realise that she had been cut off so promptly until she saw clips of the exchange circulate online. "It's ironic I got halfway through the word 'genocide' and then they cut me off," she told The National. A similar incident involving the BBC also took place on Thursday, when a student opening their A-Level results in England was cut off after saying "free Palestine, end the genocide and the BBC's complicity". Lawrence said that it was "bonkers" to see a similar scenario unfold on the same day, but added that it was also "so positive". READ MORE: Robin McAlpine: Why I won't be reading Nicola Sturgeon's book She told The National: "Young people don't really have a platform in the media. If I was a young person and I heard that kind of stuff in the media I'd be like, 'oh great, so people are mad, people are angry and they disagree with what's going on'." Youth Action has previously targeted the BBC through various sit-in protests, and has also disrupted several major events including this year's Eurovision Song Contest and London Pride, where activists blocked the float of US-based technology company Cisco over its alleged ties with Israel. However, in the coming months, The National understands that the non-violent direct action group are planning on focusing their efforts more on the BBC – such as through more phone-in disruptions and sit-ins – in the hope that the BBC will change the way it reports on Gaza. Mary Nest Lawrence (left) has previously taken part in action against the BBC (Image: Supplied) "They definitely need to be reporting statistics," Lawrence said. "You go on the Al Jazeera website and the first thing you're confronted with is how many people we've lost overnight. "We should be bombarded by what's happening, we shouldn't be allowed to look away, we shouldn't be listening to [segments on] awkward wedding speeches when people are being gunned down while they queue for aid. "They're offering no accurate representation of the world and they claim to be a news channel. They're lying by omission."
