Tech boss points to ‘bigger problem' for companies pushing workers back to offices
The Australian boss of a major tech company says businesses that argue working from home hampers productivity need to address bigger concerns.
A mandate to work from the office is unlikely to fix a 'bigger problem' of employees who won't do their jobs without a manager 'hovering over them', HP Australia director Brad Pulford has told NewsWire.
Research from the Australian HR Institute shows working-from-the-office mandates have peaked in the Australian economy.
Released in April, the research finds mandates for a certain number of in-person days are now falling.
Multinationals and Australia's biggest homegrown firms represent a broad spectrum of policies.
Amazon, Dell and Tabcorp have ordered workers into the office five days a week.
Coles has tightened the reins on its administrative staff, with one day in-person minimums becoming a three-day mandate this year. Woolworths office staff need to show up three days a week too.
Commonwealth Bank and ANZ staff need to rock up for half of all working days per month. At National Australia Bank, the rank and file need to show face three times a week, and managers only get one day at home per week.
On paper, the NSW public service is the biggest employer in the country.
Public servants in that state were sent a memo last year saying they would 'principally' need to be in the office, but different agencies are mandating different rules. The availability of actual desks is cited online by workers as a tangible factor at each agency.
Mr Pulford points to HP's own analysis, which shows 73 per cent of people think it's important that staff are empowered to work in the way that best suits their personal needs and maximises their effectiveness.
However, Australian workers do not think they are entitled to flexible working arrangements, the HP analysis shows.
Among Australian 'knowledge workers', 92 per cent would take a pay cut to work where and when they want, or for a better work-life balance.
'There are real and persistent concerns over team collaboration, organisational culture and performance management,' Mr Pulford said.
'Some professions require in-person creativity. Others have a physical component that can't be replicated. But these problems can be managed.
'The businesses that are going against the grain usually cite productivity as their main justification. But if your employees won't do their job without a manager hovering over them, arguably you have a bigger problem,' he said.
HP employs 435 people in Australia and New Zealand. Mr Pulford said flexible working arrangements were 'not a free-for-all' at the tech firm, but an issue to be managed 'carefully and thoughtfully'.
'Our employees are at times required to connect in person at our HP sites to further business goals.'
The Australian job market had clearly adapted with one-third of people working remotely at least some of the time, he said.
'We think the entire conversation around hybrid work needs to shift. If the debate hasn't been decided entirely, we think those in favour of hybrid work definitely have the upper hand at this point.'
'We should spend less time arguing about whether it's acceptable and more time thinking about how we can use it to drive growth by creating better workplaces,' Mr Pulford said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
26 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Shyla Heal's WNBA hopes
Shyla Heal speaks to Matt Logue about her plan for setting herself up financially and if the WNBA is on the horizon.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Australians struggling to pay energy bills face 'major inconsistencies' in retailer responses
Energy customers struggling to keep up with their bills face "major inconsistencies" in how retailers respond, leaving many missing out on support, a survey of financial counsellors has found. That's despite formal hardship frameworks being a legal requirement for energy retailers. An Australia-wide survey of 400 financial counsellors, who work on behalf of consumers facing financial difficulty, has revealed inconsistent practices by retailers. Key failings include a lack of proactive support, burdensome eligibility checks for assistance schemes, inflexible repayment plans and misused disconnection processes. "It's a wake-up call for regulators and industry and governments to think about the impact energy prices and the quality of energy hardship support has on customers," said Zyl Hovenga-Wauchope, the chief executive of Financial Counselling Victoria, which organised the survey. The report, which received input from financial counselling peak associations around the country, scored each energy retailer, and has ranked them from best to worst. Western Australia's Synergy was the top performer, while French-owned ENGIE performed poorly. "ENGIE is a strong example of poor performance across a range of factors," Mr Hovenga-Wauchope said. Counsellors rated the performance of retailers on a 10-point scale. A score was established by taking the percentage of high ratings and subtracting the percentage of low ratings, before the retailers were ranked by score. The major reasons the survey respondents gave for rating retailers poorly included rejection of hardship arrangements and inflexibility, and difficult-to-access schemes. Sarah Duane, a financial counsellor working in the Western suburbs of Melbourne, has seen firsthand the varying responses of retailers to energy customers. She described one of the worst examples she had seen, involving a small energy company refusing to engage with counsellors on behalf of a customer, and instead continuing to "contact the traumatised client directly with demands for payment, when the client had already been evicted from her home and was living in her car". The case was only resolved and the debt waived after a complaint to the Energy and Water Ombudsman in Victoria. However, Ms Duane has also encountered instances of hardship processes working well for people experiencing family violence. "Some retailers will respond empathetically and provide very reasonable payment plans, and in some cases, debt waivers — without requiring excessive evidence of their hardship," she said. In the survey, the primary reasons given by counsellors for higher ratings included empathy and flexibility shown towards customers experiencing difficulty, as well as a positive experience working with the hardship teams. It comes at a time when around 40 per cent of Australians are finding it difficult to pay their home energy bill, according to data analysed by advocacy body Energy Consumers Australia. Despite many customers reporting financial stress when it comes to power prices, a far smaller portion have access to official hardship measures. "About 1 to 1.5 per cent of customers generally fall into the definition of hardship," Louisa Kinnear, chief executive of the Australian Energy Council, which represents retailers, told ABC News. Last month, the Australian Energy Regulator released its default market offer, which limits what retailers can charge customers, which could see prices lift anywhere from 0.5 per cent to 9.7 per cent, depending on where users are located. While the federal government's energy bill relief has been extended until the end of the year, Ms Kinnear said it will be an adjustment for customers as it rolls off. "We wouldn't necessarily expect a significant increase in hardship numbers, but that's certainly something that retailers monitor and that we're very aware of. "We need to make sure that communications with customers at the time that the relief does come off are clear and customers understand the impacts of that." The survey found the energy industry performs worse in responding to financial hardship compared to other sectors. Only 12 per cent of financial counsellors rated energy companies as "excellent" at responding to hardship, compared to 36 per cent for water providers and 31 per cent for banks. "We're looking at our friends in banking and water … what they're doing well and where we can learn from them," Ms Kinnear said. Customers who have issues with the way their retailer responds can contact the energy ombudsman scheme in their state or territory. Financial counsellor Ms Duane also noted that people experiencing issues paying energy bills could be facing financial hardship more broadly. Consumer advocates say there must be reforms in the energy sector to better protect customers. "Different state regulators have different requirements of what hardship looks like," Financial Counselling Victoria's Mr Hovenga-Wauchope noted, saying the complex regulatory environment complicated the situation for consumers and retailers. The Australian Energy Council's Ms Kinnear argued that in some cases, state-based regulations, particularly around the language staff must use when communicating with customers, meant the assistance offered couldn't be well tailored to individual needs. "It can actually be counterproductive for those experiencing hardship. The scripting that's required, based on the regulations on the East Coast, often is difficult for customers in hardship to understand," she said. "We've certainly been engaging with regulators and consumer groups around how we can actually improve those regulations so that they actually help customers rather than hinder them. The report called for retailers to do more to identify customers at risk of financial hardship by using the data available to them, as well as improve training. "Retailers should train their staff in trauma-informed and culturally safe practices, proactively apply concessions and grants, offer flexible payment plans, and provide tailored energy efficiency advice," it recommended. It reiterated that disconnections should be a "genuine last resort", which Ms Kinnear agreed should already be the case. "Certainly, I think we can look at ways to ensure more consistency about how retailers approach disconnection. But my experience is that the majority of retailers don't look to disconnection until there's basically no engagement from the customer."
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
See the hidden shortcuts to winning the apartment race
At 25 years old, pharmacist Amelia Wootten managed to secure an apartment of her own – but with an increasingly competitive market and rising prices, it took a little help to get one she could afford. Having moved back to Brisbane in 2024 after several years in Rockhampton, Ms Wootten said she was eager to find a home without the constant presence of housemates or family. But when she started to look for apartments, she found she was competing with too many people to find an affordable home in an area close to her job. 'There was a super original place in Nundah, and that had, I reckon, 40 or 50 people going through it,' she said. 'It felt very disheartening, I think, for a young buyer to be looking at how many people were going through and going, 'I'm just not going to get anything'.' Ms Wootten's search came as apartment price growth across Brisbane was found to vastly outpace that of houses, according to research from Nuestar and Hotspotting. The research found 76.3 per cent of apartments across the city were showing stronger growth than houses over the 12 months preceding June. 'I think that with the rate going down and everything, it got a little bit more competitive,' Ms Wootten said. 'I think there's a lot more people looking for apartments rather than houses.' 'A lot of the [Rockhampton] houses were priced at what apartments would be here … what you're getting for 500k is a lot more, but obviously it's living in a regional area.' Place New Farm agent Karen McBryde, who was able to find Ms Wootten a Stafford apartment off the plan, said she could see the gap between house and unit prices in the suburb 'already closing'. 'Amelia paid $500,000 for a one-bedroom unit,' she said. 'An entry level, very basic post-war house in the area is a minimum of about $900,000. So even just that comparison alone, it appears to me like a one-bedroom unit is fairly unaffordable still.' 'My biggest piece of advice would be to communicate with the agents that you're dealing with, so that you can find what options are available,' she said. 'When you make an inquiry, do include your phone and your email address in your inquiry. Make sure you're providing the agent the information to send you back any listings that they have.' Ms Wootten said communicating with agents and family, and getting the chance for private opportunities, was what finally allowed her to get the unit she dreamt of having. 'It's helpful having people around you that have done it, or that know what they're doing,' she said.
