logo
Altered news report falsely claims victim of Duterte's drug crackdown 'still alive'

Altered news report falsely claims victim of Duterte's drug crackdown 'still alive'

AFP09-04-2025
The TikTok video shared on March 18 shows a screenshot of a broadcast news report with a woman holding the portrait of an alleged drug war victim.
The clip also appears to show the same man -- who claimed to be her ex-boyfriend -- saying she lied that he was killed during Duterte's drug crackdown.
"You even told people that I was dead when I am just here working," he said in Visayan.
The Tagalog-language news chyron says: "Family members of drug war victims believe justice will be served".
The clip also shows text that reads, "Another victim that they claim to be dead but is still alive."
Image
Screenshot of the false TikTok post, taken on April 7, 2025
Duterte's supporters published dozens of online posts targeting the families of drug war victims, seeking to discredit their accounts of extrajudicial killings after the former president's arrest (archived link).
Sheerah Escudero, the woman in the video, said people on social media had accused her of being a liar and a drug addict, with some even sending personal messages telling her she deserved to be killed and beheaded.
Her brother Ephraim was found dead in 2017 at the height of the crackdown.
Escudero and other kin of drug war victims filed complaints with Philippine authorities on April 4, demanding an investigation into the threats.
The false video spread elsewhere on TikTok and Facebook.
Comments suggest some users believed the man in the false post was related to Escudero and was still alive.
"File charges on that person who misused your picture...you're not an addict but they made you appear one," one user said.
"They say 30,000 were victims of EJK (extrajudicial killings). And then they show a picture of someone who's still alive," another wrote.
Edited photo
Google keyword searches of the news chyron in the false video found it originated from a report aired by Philippine broadcaster News5 on March 15, 2025 (archived link).
It shows Escudero holding a different picture.
News5 said on its official Facebook page that the false video was edited from "a report aired on #FrontlineWeekend on March 15 about the loved ones of the victims of the drug war" (archived link).
It asked the public to be more critical of social media posts.
Image
Screenshot comparison of the altered post (left) and the News5 video, with altered elements enlarged using the image magnifier tool from The Verification Plugin, also known as InVID-WeVerify
Subsequent keyword searches led to the same video in a Facebook post uploaded on the account of a digital creator named Jay Borge Mercado Ugay on March 17 (archived link).
A photo similar to the one in the altered video can be seen on his account (archived link).
Escudero took to social media on March 18 to dismiss the false video (archived link).
"When did you become my ex, Jay Borge Mercado Ugay?" she said. "Also, look at that face -- it looks nothing like Ephraim."
Duterte's arrest sparked a firestorm of online misinformation, many of which AFP has debunked.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Video shows crime scene reconstruction in Tehran, not 'Iran parading Israeli spies'
Video shows crime scene reconstruction in Tehran, not 'Iran parading Israeli spies'

AFP

time3 hours ago

  • AFP

Video shows crime scene reconstruction in Tehran, not 'Iran parading Israeli spies'

The video, comprising two short clips appearing to show people in prison garb escorted down a street and someone being hanged, was shared on Weibo on July 2, 2025 by Chinese newspaper Reference News. Simplified-Chinese text superimposed on the video reads: "Iran executes Mossad spies. Before the execution, they were paraded on the streets in handcuffs and shackles." It has been viewed over 152,000 times. Image Screenshot of false Weibo post captured on August 6, 2025, with a red X added by AFP The clip's caption adds that the video was originally shared by Iranian news anchor Sahar Emami on July 1 -- though an archive of the post shows it was in fact published by a "commentary account" impersonating the TV presenter (archived link). The impostor account has since been suspended. Similar posts were also shared in multiple languages on Threads, TikTok, Facebook and Instagram. They surfaced after Iran and Israel exchanged fire in June, which left more than 1,000 people dead in Iran and 29 in Israel (archived link). A ceasefire announced by the United States has been in place since June 24. Activists warned that Iranian authorities had unleashed a "wave of repression" following the war, accusing the Islamic republic of using fear to compensate for weaknesses revealed by the conflict (archived link). The Norway-based NGO Iran Human Rights said six men had been hanged on charges of spying for Israel since the start of the conflict on June 13. The video circulating online, however, does not show "spies" paraded through Iran. Crime scene reconstruction A reverse image search on Google using keyframes from the first falsely shared clip led to the same footage posted on Instagram on March 27 (archived link). Its Persian-language caption indicates it was filmed where a university student was murdered in Tehran . Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared clip (left) and the Instagram video from March 27 (right) Subsequent keyword searches led to a similar video published by the Iranian Students' News Agency (ISNA) with a title saying it shows a crime scene reconstruction with the suspect (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared clip (left) and the ISNA video (right), with corresponding elements highlighted by AFP AFP reported that the murder of Amir Mohammad Khaleghi, a 19-year-old business student at Tehran University, sparked outrage and student protests for better security on campus (archived link). According to local media reports, Khaleghi was killed by robbers near the university's dormitory on February 12. News website Iran Front Page reported on February 20 that police reconstructed the crime scene with the murder suspects in the presence of court and law enforcement officials and forensics experts (archived link). "The reconstruction aims to provide a clearer understanding of the events and assist in completing the investigation," the report said. Iran's official Islamic Republic News Agency also reported on the reconstruction (archived link). The false clip was earlier debunked by the Arab fact-checking platform Misbar (archived link). Backstage footage The second falsely shared clip has also previously been debunked by AFP. A reverse image search led to longer footage published on YouTube on April 16, 2024, titled "Hanging the actor backstage" (archived link). The full clip shows the actor raising his head after the scene. Image Screenshot comparison of falsely shared video at 0:04 mark (L) and the YouTube video Another version of the clip was shared on Instagram on January 3, 2025 with the caption, "Behind the scenes of the execution of the Bi Badan film" (archived link). The entertainment database IMDb says the 2024 Farsi-language film is an adaptation of a famous criminal case in the 1990s "which went back and forth several times until the execution stage" (archived link). The execution scene can be seen from a different angle between the movie's four to five-minute marks, an AFP journalist found. The Iran-Israel war triggered a wave of misinformation, some of which AFP has debunked here.

Decade-old photo misrepresented as South Korean reaction to Trump's tariffs
Decade-old photo misrepresented as South Korean reaction to Trump's tariffs

AFP

time3 hours ago

  • AFP

Decade-old photo misrepresented as South Korean reaction to Trump's tariffs

The photo of a joyous crowd, superimposed with Korean-language text that reads "Response to 15 percent tariffs", was shared on Facebook on August 7, 2025. The photo is contrasted with an image of a protest, which is labelled "Response to 0 percent tariffs". The comparison circulated after Trump's July 30 announcement of a 15 percent tariff on South Korean imports -- below a 25 percent tariff that the US president had threatened earlier -- after extensive trade negotiations with Seoul (archived link). South Korean President Lee Jae Myung of the centre-left Democratic Party called the agreement the "first major trade challenge" since his administration came into power in June after the impeachment of Yook Suk Yeol from the conservative People Power Party (archived link). Opinion polling shows that a significant proportion of South Koreans believed Lee had fared well in negotiations, crediting him with avoiding a collapse in trade talks and preventing even harsher measures (archived link). Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on August 8, 2025, with a red X added by AFP The image comparison was also shared in similar posts elsewhere on Facebook and Threads, as well as on right-wing forum Ilbe. "That's why we say leftists are brain-dead," read a comment on one of the posts. Another said: "What are those people thinking?" But the image comparison misleadingly uses a photo unrelated to any trade agreement between Washington and Seoul. Impeachment rally A reverse image search on Google found the photo of the celebrating crowd in a report published by The Korea Economic Daily on December 10, 2016 -- nearly a decade before Trump's tariff demands (archived link). According to its caption, the photo shows citizens cheering the impeachment of then-president Park Geun-hye, who was embroiled in a corruption scandal (archived link) The taken shortly after lawmakers passed the impeachment bill, following months of peaceful mass protests calling for Park's removal. Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared image (left) and The Korea Economic Daily's photo published in December 2016 (right) A reverse image search of the protest photo used in the false posts led to an article published in left-wing online newspaper Newscham on January 16, 2007 (archived link). Its caption says it shows protesters in Seoul rallying the US-Korea free trade agreement (FTA), which was signed later that year (archived link). Opponents of the FTA feared it would flood the Korean market with cheap US agricultural products, threatening the livelihoods of domestic farmers (archived link). Lee and his administration are frequent targets of disinformation online, which AFP has debunked multiple times.

Israel confirms strike killing 5 Al Jazeera journalists in Gaza
Israel confirms strike killing 5 Al Jazeera journalists in Gaza

LeMonde

time5 hours ago

  • LeMonde

Israel confirms strike killing 5 Al Jazeera journalists in Gaza

Al Jazeera said two of its correspondents, including a prominent reporter, and three cameramen were killed in an Israeli strike on their tent in Gaza City on Sunday, August 10. The Israeli military admitted in a statement to targeting Anas al-Sharif, the reporter it labeled as a "terrorist" affiliated with Hamas. The attack was the latest to see journalists targeted in the 22-month war in Gaza, with around 200 media workers killed over the course of the conflict, according to media watchdogs. "Al Jazeera journalist Anas al-Sharif has been killed alongside four colleagues in a targeted Israeli attack on a tent housing journalists in Gaza City," the Qatar-based broadcaster said. "Al-Sharif, 28, was killed on Sunday after a tent for journalists outside the main gate of the hospital was hit. The well-known Al Jazeera Arabic correspondent reportedly extensively from northern Gaza." The channel said that five of its staff members were killed during the strike on a tent in Gaza City, listing the others as Mohammed Qreiqeh, along with camera operators Ibrahim Zaher, Mohammed Noufal and Moamen Aliwa. The Israeli military confirmed that it had carried out the attack, saying it had struck Al Jazeera's al-Sharif and calling him a "terrorist" who "posed as a journalist." "A short while ago, in Gaza City, the IDF struck the terrorist Anas Al-Sharif, who posed as a journalist for the Al Jazeera network," it said on Telegram, using an acronym for the military. "Anas Al-Sharif served as the head of a terrorist cell in the Hamas terrorist organization and was responsible for advancing rocket attacks against Israeli civilians and IDF troops." 'Journalists are civilians' Al-Sharif was one of the channel's most recognizable faces working on the ground in Gaza, providing daily reports as part of regular coverage. Following a press conference by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday, where the premier defended approving a new offensive in Gaza, al-Sharif posted messages on X describing "intense, concentrated Israeli bombardment" on Gaza City. One of his final messages included a short video showing nearby Israeli strikes hitting Gaza City. In July, the Committee to Protect Journalists issued a statement calling for his protection as it accused the Israeli military's Arabic-language spokesperson Avichay Adraee of stepping up online attacks on the reporter by alleging that he was a Hamas terrorist. Following the attack, the CPJ said it was "appalled" to learn of the journalists' deaths. "Israel's pattern of labeling journalists as militants without providing credible evidence raises serious questions about its intent and respect for press freedom," said CPJ Regional Director Sara Qudah. "Journalists are civilians and must never be targeted. Those responsible for these killings must be held accountable." The Palestinian Journalists' Syndicate condemned what it described as a "bloody crime" of assassination. Israel and Al Jazeera have had a contentious relationship for years, with Israeli authorities banning the channel in the country and raiding its offices following the latest war in Gaza. Qatar, which partly funds Al Jazeera, has hosted an office for the Hamas political leadership for years and been a frequent venue for indirect talks between Israel and the militant group. With Gaza sealed off, many media groups around the world, including AFP, depend on photo, video and text coverage of the conflict provided by Palestinian reporters. Media watchdog Reporters Without Borders (RSF) said in early July that more than 200 journalists had been killed in Gaza since the war began, including several Al Jazeera journalists. International criticism is growing over the plight of the more than two million Palestinian civilians in Gaza, with UN agencies and rights groups warning that a famine is unfolding in the territory. The targeted strike comes as Israel announced plans to expand its military operations on the ground in Gaza, with Netanyahu saying on Sunday that the new offensive was set to target the remaining Hamas strongholds there.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store