Anti-competitive practices in power sector: CCP raids on offices of four companies suspected of bid rigging in tenders
The coordinated raids were carried out by CCP's authorised officers in Lahore and Gujranwala, targeting suppliers who are alleged to have colluded in manipulating the bidding process. These companies were found to be quoting identical prices and engaging in tender rotation — a classic hallmark of cartel behaviour.
The action follows a formal complaint lodged by the Lahore Electric Supply Company (LESCO), which observed suspicious bidding patterns in recent procurement cycles. LESCO reported that multiple firms submitted bids with identical rates for various items, raising red flags regarding possible collusion. In response, the CCP initiated a formal enquiry under Section 4 of the Competition Act, 2010, which prohibits agreements that restrict competition, including bid rigging under Section 4(2)(e).
A preliminary analysis of the bidding data revealed that certain companies appeared to be coordinating their bids to ensure pre-determined outcomes in tender awards. In some cases, these suppliers were found rotating their wins while maintaining price parity, thereby undermining the competitive tendering process and harming public procurement efficiency.
This is not the first time CCP has uncovered such practices in the transformer materials market. In 2020, the Commission concluded a similar enquiry involving bid rigging by multiple vendors supplying transformer bushings and reclamation items to DISCOs, including LESCO, MEPCO, and GEPCO. In that case, CCP found collusion among at least five firms, and imposed significant penalties.
The recurrence of such practices underscores systemic vulnerabilities in the public procurement mechanisms of the power sector and the need for stronger oversight by procuring agencies.
If the ongoing investigation confirms collusive conduct, the Commission is empowered to issue show-cause notices to the implicated firms and proceed with hearings. Upon establishing contravention, CCP may impose penalties of up to 10% of annual turnover or PKR 75 million, whichever is higher.
In addition, the Commission can recommend structural or behavioural remedies to prevent recurrence and restore market integrity.
The CCP has urged the public, including procurement officers, business insiders, and concerned citizens, to come forward with credible information about cartelization or bid rigging. The Commission's Whistleblower Reward Scheme offers cash rewards ranging from PKR 200,000 to PKR 2 million, based on the quality and value of the information provided.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Navigating Pakistan's debt quagmire through Islamic finance
Pakistan faces formidable economic headwinds amidst the dual debt challenges that threaten to undermine its progress. The nation's determination is being tested as it confronts the pressing issues of stagnant GDP growth, soaring unemployment, persistent inflation, and a lagging Human Development Index (HDI). Yet, within this crucible of challenge lies an opportunity for Pakistan to forge a new path forward, one that is guided by visionary leadership, innovative economic strategies, and a steadfast commitment to the well-being of its people. Pakistan's economic landscape is characterized by a substantial debt portfolio; with the country's total public debt obligations reaching a staggering USD 271.29 (PKR 76.01 trillion), as per the Economic Survey of Pakistan 2024-25. This monumental figure comprises USD 183.88 (PKR 51.52 trillion) in domestic debt, underscoring the government's significant reliance on internal borrowing, and USD 79.13 (PKR 24.49 trillion) in external debt (32.2% of the total), highlighting the country's exposure to global financial markets. However, the debt from IMF stands at USD 8.28 (PKR 2.319 trillion). The aggregate debt and liabilities have skyrocketed to a staggering USD 320.65 billion (PKR 89.834 trillion), underscoring the imperative for prudent fiscal management and strategic debt restructuring. Beyond the government's narrative of economic resurgence, anchored by a projected GDP growth rate of 2.7% in the forthcoming fiscal year, lies a far more pressing concern for the average citizen struggling to make ends meet. The quintessential question on everyone's mind is: how can Pakistan escape the grip of high inflation, unemployment (8.0), and an ever-increasing debt burden, which threatens to undermine the very fabric of the nation's economic stability and prosperity? The answer to this million-dollar question holds the key to unlocking a brighter future for 44.7 % of Pakistan's population (approx.107 millions) living below the poverty line, and it is imperative that policymakers and stakeholders work in tandem to devise effective solutions to alleviate these pressing economic challenges. The adoption of cash and asset-based Waqf, a time-tested Islamic financial instrument, presents a viable solution to Pakistan's economic conundrums. Waqf, as a socio-financial approach in Islam, refers to the dedication of property or wealth for religious or charitable purpose. With its roots in the prophetic era, Waqf has evolved over centuries, demonstrating remarkable resilience and efficacy. During the Caliphate period, Umayyad and Mamluk eras, and notably, the Ottoman Empire, Waqf played a pivotal role in fostering economic growth, social welfare, and infrastructure development. By leveraging Waqf's potential, Pakistan can unlock new avenues for sustainable development, poverty alleviation, and economic stability, thereby harnessing the power of Islamic finance to drive inclusive growth and prosperity. Waqf stands as a shining cornerstone of Islamic finance, with its landscape in numerous countries. From the oil-rich nations of Qatar and Saudi Arabia to the vibrant economies of Malaysia and Indonesia, Waqf has been successfully integrated into diverse financial ecosystems. Singapore, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates have also harnessed its potential, showcasing Waqf's versatility and impact. As a testament to its enduring value, Waqf continues to inspire innovative financial solutions, fostering economic growth, social welfare, and sustainable development worldwide. By combining the redistributive power of cash and asset-based financing of Waqf with Zakat, visionary nations have synergized the potent forces. By harmonizing these two pillars of Islamic finance, countries have created a powerful framework for poverty alleviation, economic empowerment, and sustainable development. This strategic fusion has yielded remarkable outcomes, demonstrating the immense potential of integrated Zakat and Waqf models. In a compelling critique of conventional financial frameworks, the book 'Beyond the IMF (2024)' masterfully articulated the limitations of traditional financial paradigms, paving the way for a revolutionary concept: the Muslim Common Waqf. This visionary idea, coupled with Pakistan's pioneering National Waqf Common Pool, offers a beacon of hope for Muslim countries seeking greater financial autonomy and self-sufficiency. By harnessing the collective potential of Waqf, nations can break free from the shackles of sovereign and domestic financial dependency; unlock new avenues for economic growth and prosperous future. As Pakistan's debt trajectory hurtles towards a precarious PKR 87 trillion by FY 2026, the imperative for innovative debt management strategies has never been more pressing. To avert this financial precipice, it is crucial to devise visionary plans that can effectively mitigate the debt burden, unlock new revenue streams, and catalyze sustainable economic growth. As the Government of Pakistan contemplates the privatization of 24 State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), a critical question arises: can the nation's economic sovereignty be compromised for the sake of fiscal expediency? Allowing foreign entities and potentially hostile interests to assume control of strategic assets would be a perilous gamble, undermining the country's economic autonomy. The resounding answer is a thunderous 'NO!' to the wholesale privatization of vital SOEs. The establishment of the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC) marks a significant milestone in Pakistan's economic reform agenda. By providing a platform for streamlined facilitation and coordination, SIFC aims to foster a conducive investment environment, attracting both B2B and G2G investments. This initiative is expected to yield substantial benefits, including enhanced economic activity, job creation, and accelerated growth, ultimately contributing to the nation's long-term economic prosperity. We harbor boundless optimism and soaring aspirations for the SIFC, envisioning it as a transformative catalyst that will unlock Pakistan's vast economic potential. In tandem with its economic reform initiatives, Pakistan can shatter the shackles of crippling domestic debt, amounting to PKR 51.52 trillion, a staggering 67.8% of the total debt burden by unlocking the potential of Waqf. By harnessing the transformative power of the Waqf Fund (WF), the nation can envision a debt-free future, liberated from the weight of internal borrowing. Well beyond a financial mechanism, strategic mobilization of Waqf assets is a farsighted way to fiscal sustainability, inclusive growth, and intergenerational equity. Leveraging this Islamic economic instrument could not only alleviate the short-term budget pressure but also restore public confidence, advance socio-economic justice, and propel long-term national strength. With proper policy commitment and institutional setup, Waqf is poised to emerge as a game-changer and revolutionary pillar of Pakistan's economic rejuvenation which turns tradition into transformation, and religion into a bedrock of sustainable prosperity. (The writer is PhD (Management) from PBS-UPM, Malaysia. Policy Researcher / Policy Analyst and a writer of Political Economy of Bureaucracy in Pakistan-2020)Email:[email protected] Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Delegation of South Korea visits UAF
FAISALABAD: A South Korean delegation visited the University of Agriculture Faisalabad (UAF) and called on deans and directors to discuss the areas of mutual concerns. On the directives of UAF Vice Chancellor Prof Dr Zulfiqar Ali the meeting was held at the Office of Research, Innovation and Commercialization (ORIC). The delegation included AJOU Motor College Dean International Cooperation Centre and Department Prof Dr Kwonse Kim and Director International Cooperation Office Kim Tae Hyoung, OAKS CAF Chairman Seo Young Oak, CEO Lee Jae Ho and Company's Secretary Dr Abdul Ghaffar Director ORIC Prof Dr Muhammad Imran Arshad highlighted UAF's legacy as one of the leading agricultural institutions in Asia, known for its tangible research and strong community engagement. He stresses upon the collaborations in agriculture and food security. He said that UAF sub-campuses across the Punjab, various research centers and specialized departments contributing to multidisciplinary education and development. Director External Linkages Dr Tehseen Azhar said that said that partnership with South Korea will open new horizons for joint research and global academic exposure for students and faculty as well. Prof Dr Kwonse Kim said that AJOU Motor College focuses on practical learning, technical innovation and student-centered facilities. He said we equip students with hands-on experience in the automotive sector. He said that AJOU has strong interest in developing academic linkages with UAF. He offered a proposed student exchange program, ensuring mutual learning and cultural exchange. Dr Abdul Ghaffar said that through exchange program and scholarships, AJOU is offering the students an opportunity to have international exposure and cultural understanding. Dean Faculty of Agriculture Engineering and Technology Prof Dr Anjum Munir said that advancements in farm machinery and power systems being developed at UAF are playing vital role in advancing agriculture and enhancing the efficiency and productivity. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
HBL wins ‘Best Bank in Pakistan 2025' award
KARACHI: Euromoney Awards for Excellence 2025 has awarded HBL the accolade of 'Pakistan's Best Bank'. The Bank has also won 'Pakistan's Best Bank for Large Corporates' and 'Pakistan's Best Investment Bank'. Euromoney is a global English-language publication focused on business and finance. These awards are the most prestigious recognition in the banking industry, globally. The Euromoney citation acknowledges that 'HBL remains an undisputed leader as Pakistan's best bank, demonstrating once again standout financial growth and continuous improvement in the digital space.' The citation went on to note, 'HBL remains one of the key players in Pakistan's agriculture sector, a vital part of the country's economy, highlighting the Bank's commitment to the economic development of Pakistan.' Commenting on the recognition, Muhammad Nassir Salim, President & CEO – HBL said, 'HBL is proud to serve its valued clients who have made these wins possible. These wins are a tribute to our millions of clients' continued trust and confidence in HBL.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
