'One-Sided Beneficiary Classes': BJP Takes On Mamata Govt Over OBC List In Bengal, TMC Hits Back
The TMC hit back at the BJP to "stop misleading the people" and said the party's "only agenda" was "divide and rule" with an eye on the 2026 assembly elections
A day after West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee said backwardness is the only benchmark to decide OBC status, the ruling TMC and opposition BJP exchanged barbs over the inclusion of beneficiaries under the category.
The BJP, in a detailed post on social media, accused the Trinamool Congress (TMC) of 'appeasement politics". It said for the Bengal government, OBC expanded to 'One-Sided Beneficiary Classes" and not Other Backward Classes.
The TMC hit back at the BJP's claims about the new list and to 'stop misleading the people with your lies". It said the saffron party's 'only agenda" is 'divide and rule" with an eye on the assembly elections in 2026.
On Tuesday (June 10), Mamata Banerjee told the state assembly that there is no connection with religion in deciding the inclusion of any person in the OBC category. She said the only benchmark to decide this in the state is backwardness and a commission set up by the state government is holding a survey on 50 new subsections for inclusion in that category.
Banerjee addressed the House after laying the annual report of the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes for the financial year 2024-25.
WHAT DID THE BJP SAY?
In a post on social media, opposition leader Suvendu Adhikari claimed to 'fact check" Banerjee's speech on the floor of the state assembly.
He said this was 'peak appeasement politics" by the state government. 'OBC = Other Backward Classes. In West Bengal it means One-Sided Beneficiary Classes," he said in a post on X.
Adhikari alleged that the reservation list is prepared with the intention of providing 'exclusively to Muslims" and 'deliberately depriving" Hindus and other religious communities.
He said the government has increased the reservation for OBCs in state services and posts to 17 per cent, including 10 per cent reservation for 'more backward' and 7 per cent for 'backward' classes categories. Before this, he added, a 7 per cent reservation had been in place since 1997.
'Now, who are going to reap the benefits of the increased reservation for the OBCs? Muslims, as simple as that," he wrote.
OBC = Other Backward Classes In West Bengal it means One-Sided Beneficiary Classes.Mamata Banerjee, said yesterday on the floor of the West Bengal Legislative Assembly that OBC List not prepared on the basis of religion.Let's Fact Check her claim. Just look at the Peak of… pic.twitter.com/9EzhBT55ec — Suvendu Adhikari (@SuvenduWB) June 11, 2025
The BJP leader said in December 2024, the Supreme Court had observed reservation must not be based on religion. This was while it was hearing an appeal filed by the West Bengal government against the Calcutta High Court judgment striking down its policy to include several castes, largely Muslim communities, in the state's OBC list.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
22 minutes ago
- Indian Express
‘Direct attack on India's secular, democratic values': Documentary screening at TISS to mark Partition Horrors Remembrance Day draws flak from student bodies
The Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS) in Mumbai held a screening of the documentary Demography is Destiny on Thursday to mark Partition Horrors Remembrance Day, drawing criticism from multiple student organisations who alleged the film promotes a biased and communal narrative. In a statement issued to announce the programme earlier, TISS said the film explores India's shifting demographic trends through census data, historical records, and regional case studies. It highlights a decline in the majority community's population from 82 per cent in 1881 to approximately 79 per cent in 2011, with future projections estimating a drop to 67 per cent. The statement said documentary — directed by National Award-winning filmmaker Kamakhya Narayan Singh and produced by Ravindra Sanghvi — also focuses on regions such as Kashmir, Assam, Bengal, and Western Uttar Pradesh, where it claims significant increases in the Muslim population, partly attributed to illegal immigration. The documentary, the statement said, also discusses themes of infiltration, religious conversions, and the declining Hindu fertility rate. Sunil Ambekar, Akhil Bharat Prachar Pramukh of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), was the chief guest. As the news of the screening spread on campus, it prompted backlash from students. Five student organisations — the Ambedkar Students' Association (ASA), Muslim Students' Federation (MSF), All India Students Federation (AISF), Progressive Students' Forum (PSF), and Satyashodhak Vidyarthi Sanghatna (SVS) — issued statements condemning the event. They called the film 'agenda-driven' and raised questions on the academic and secular values of TISS, a prominent social science institute. In their public statements, the students' groups claimed that the documentary spreads fear through unverified claims about religious conversions and infiltration, with the AISF calling it 'a direct attack on India's secular, democratic values.' ASA described it as aligning with an 'RSS worldview,' while PSF stated it aimed to 'create religious hatred and communal polarisation.' SVS raised concerns about the credibility of the data used in the film and questioned its relevance in an academic setting. Questioning the choice of chief guest for the event, Amir Kazi, Mumbai President, AISF, said, 'The institute has been discouraging student-led political activity while inviting a political figure to campus.' Despite the criticism by student organisations, the TISS administration said there was no opposition to the event. 'We have not received any letter of opposition from any student organisation. In fact, the event was held smoothly without any protest,' a TISS source said.
The Hindu
25 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Vote theft through scientific means is dangerous to democracy in all States: Congress MP
'Vote theft' through scientific means by the Bharatiya Janata Party is dangerous to democracy in all States, said Virudhunagar MP B. Manickam Tagore. Addressing reporters here on Thursday, Mr. Tagore said that Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, has exposed how one lakh votes were added in Bengaluru Central Lok Sabha constituency before the 2024 Parliamentary election. 'This had led to the BJP winning the seat with a small margin of 30,000 votes,' he said. The BJP had claimed that it would win 400 seats in the Lok Sabha election, but ended up winning only 239 seats. Similar, 'vote theft' had been done in 48 other constituencies too, he said. Hence, the BJP Government should not be allowed to continue in power in the Centre, he said. When the opposition parties pointed to this irregularity and sought to discuss the issue, their demand was rejected in the Parliament. Three hundred MPs of the opposition parties marched towards the Election Commission office in Delhi. However, the Election Commission did not meet them to clarify, he said. The Congress MP said that it was anti-democratic exercise to conduct Assembly election in Bihar after deleting 18% of the votes of the opposition parties by way of Special Intensive Revision of voters list. In this backdrop, Mr. Rahul Gandhi has planned to take out 'Voters' Right' yatra in Bihar for 17 days from August 17. 'While the BJP partyman gets five votes in the election, it is only one for the common man. For the opposition parties, even that one vote is denied,' he said. Stating that such scientific way of stealing votes was dangerous in other States where BJP was in power, he said the Election Commission was hand in glove with the BJP in such an irregularity.
New Indian Express
25 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Mamata plans ‘special celebration' for Kanyashree Diwas in 2026 if beneficiaries cross one crore
KOLKATA: Exuding confidence that the Trinamool Congress government will return to power in West Bengal for the fourth consecutive term after the Assembly polls due next year, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Thursday said she wants to celebrate 'Kanyashree Diwas' on a large scale in 2026. Currently, more than 93 lakh girl students in West Bengal are receiving the benefits of Kanyashree. Banerjee said that if the number of beneficiaries reaches one crore next year, a 'special celebration' will be organised for Kanyashree. Addressing the 'Kanyashree Diwas' programme at Dhanadhanya Auditorium in Alipore, she informed that the state government has already spent Rs 17,000 crore on this programme. If the Assembly elections are held on time next year, the new government is expected to be sworn in around May or June. 'Kanyashree Diwas' is celebrated on August 14. As a result, the 'special celebration' she spoke about on Thursday will take place after the elections. According to political observers, Banerjee's advance announcement of the 'special celebration' after the elections by setting targets is politically significant, as she allegedly wanted to convey that her government will return to power in 2026. In this context, many in the state administration are referring to the Chief Minister's administrative meeting in Birbhum a few weeks ago. In that meeting, speaking about the housing project, she said, 'I have already given money for the 'Banglar Bari' project to 12 lakh people. Another 16 lakh people will get the first instalment next December. Whatever is left, I will pay in three-four years.' This indicates that, beyond the special celebration of 'Kanyashree Diwas', Banerjee has allegedly begun outlining what she will do after the elections. In 2013, the West Bengal government launched the 'Kanyashree' project to prevent child marriage and to help girls from economically backward families pursue their education. Initially, it was only for schoolgirls, but later, girl students of colleges and universities were also included.
