Peaceful Assembly Act under review after clause ruled unlawful
Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail said the government is examining all provisions of the Act to ensure they align with democratic principles, human rights, and the nation's current needs.
"Any decision regarding the Act will be made with careful consideration, taking into account the right to peaceful assembly as guaranteed by the Federal Constitution.
"This will also include considerations related to maintaining public order, national security, and the rights of others," he said.
Saifuddin was responding to Jimmy Puah Wee Tse (PH–Tebrau), who asked whether the government was prepared to abolish the Act in light of the court ruling.
On July 1, the Federal Court ruled it was unconstitutional to criminalise the failure to notify the police five days in advance before holding a peaceful assembly.
Former Chief Justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat said Section 9(5) of the Peaceful Assembly Act 2012 imposes a penalty that goes beyond what is allowed under Article 10(1)(b) of the Federal Constitution, which guarantees the freedom of speech, assembly, and association.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
4 hours ago
- The Sun
Peaceful Assembly Act review must uphold constitutional rights
KUALA LUMPUR: The Alliance for a Safe Community has urged a review of the Peaceful Assembly Act 2012 to ensure it fully respects constitutional freedoms. This follows a Federal Court ruling that struck down a provision of the law as unconstitutional. Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye, the alliance's chairman, said the decision highlights the need for laws to align with fundamental liberties under the Federal Constitution. 'We also fully support the call by the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (SUHAKAM) for the government to engage civil society groups, legal experts, and all relevant stakeholders in this review process,' he said. Lee stressed that inclusive consultations are crucial to ensure amendments are balanced and reflect democratic values. He outlined key principles for the review, including alignment with Article 10 of the Federal Constitution, which guarantees peaceful assembly rights. The amended law should avoid excessive penalties that discourage lawful assemblies, he added. Clear and reasonable procedures must be established to prevent administrative hurdles from restricting constitutional rights. Lee emphasised that restrictions must be proportionate and minimally intrusive to achieve legitimate aims. The law should also protect participants from harassment and provide clear enforcement guidelines prioritising dialogue. Peaceful assembly is a democratic right and should not be viewed as a threat, Lee noted. He urged the government to amend the law in line with the court's ruling and reinforce Malaysia's commitment to human rights. - Bernama
Borneo Post
4 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Opposition mounts against proposed inclusion of PH and BN
CHIEF Minister Datuk Seri Panglima Hajiji Hj Noor's proposal for GRS to collaborate with Pakatan Harapan (PH) in the upcoming general election was made with good intentions. He had assured this writer that BN will not be joining the GRS plus PH team, and rationalised that the inclusion of PH is a most pragmatic and logical approach to the 17th State Election (PRN17) strategic planning, aimed at ensuring the current government continues its rule in Sabah. Anwar However, several negative factors have begun to disrupt this 'ideal' formula. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, initially excluding BN from the discussions, unexpectedly announced that arrangements would be made 'to ensure that PH and BN do not clash' in any constituency. This new development has injected BN into the already volatile situation, increasing the opposition to the inclusion of PH manifolds, thus spiking the confusion to a different level. Anwar didn't say BN will be part of the team, but by ensuring PH and BN don't clash in any area in practice means it's already a GRS plus PH plus BN – rather a sleek way to trap GRS into an unwilling cooperation! Immediately, the GRS component parties felt betrayed and see the Chief Minister has been cornered into an unwilling compliance, again. So now, the 73 state assembly seats must be divided not only between GRS and PH, but also with BN. Various seat allocation predictions have circulated on social media, placing GRS component parties in difficult positions. National parties (and PGRS) are expected to demand a majority share, leaving other GRS about one-third of the total. If Gagasan takes most of these remaining seats then the other GRS components will have to be satisfied with token numbers of seats, or peanuts. Pandikar Within USNO, a surprising development unfolded when its President, Tan Sri Pandikar Amin Mulia, who previously vehemently condemned any collaboration with Peninsular parties, stating that 'anyone working with parties from across the sea is a traitor. I don't want to be a traitor,' unexpectedly made a U-turn, announcing USNO's support for Hajiji's proposed arrangement to work with PH. His rationale: 'Let the people judge me and USNO, as long as I don't lead the people of Sabah into hardship.' And he told this writer, 'We must look at political reality, Datuk!' His supporter, Adey Liun, further explained the rationale in a Facebook post, stating: 'The decision by USNO President Tan Sri Pandikar Amin Mulia to support the collaboration between GRS and PH is not a reckless act or an act of betrayal as portrayed by some. This action is the result of in-depth research and analysis of the current political landscape conducted by the USNO Media and Propaganda Unit. It stems from current realities, not empty political rhetoric. 'In Sabah's case, despite increased revenue compared to previous years, the state remains heavily reliant on allocations from the Federal Government. In the 2023 Federal Budget, Sabah received RM6.5 billion in development allocation – a sum larger than the state's own development budget, which only recorded RM1.362 billion. This means that a large portion of development projects in Sabah, such as roads, water supply, electricity, bridge construction, and rural facilities, are still funded by the Federal Government. Jeffrey 'Furthermore, the central government also bears important subsidies for Sabah, including electricity tariff subsidies (through SESB), price equalization of essential goods in the interior, the operation of rural flights (RAS), and various school and dilapidated clinic improvement programs. This proves that Sabah's dependence on external funding is still high, compared to Sarawak, which is now able to finance the construction of major infrastructure such as 16 large bridges using its own funds of RM12 billion…' Meanwhile, PBS and STAR have become the subject of ridicule for seemingly abandoning their slogans of 'Sabah for Sabahans,' 'reject Peninsular Malaysian parties,' and 'going solo.' STAR, in particular, is in a tight dilemma, viewing the inclusion of PH and, worse the sudden adoption of BN, as a betrayal, trapping STAR in a situation that could lead STAR to political suicide. One WhatsApp article by a STAR member even described the situation as STAR riding a donkey condemned to the slaughter house. Although PBS reaffirmed its loyalty to GRS through a courtesy visit by its Supreme Council to the Chief Minister, STAR now faces a real threat of losing supporters and voters if it accepts the arrangement unilaterally made by the Prime Minister. Many senior STAR leaders still believe that remaining with GRS is the wisest and most pragmatic choice, many second-tier leaders realize that if they agree to Anwar's formula, they will no longer be able to shout out the pro-Sabah patriotic slogans in the future. STAR will have lost its face with the people. The patriotic song containing the lyrics 'Kalau berani jangan takut-takut' (If you are daring don't behave cowardly way) and 'Ini kalilah!' (This is the time!) will also lose its meaning. Rather the other part of the lyric 'Kalau takut jangan berani-berani' (If you are afraid then don't be daring) would be more apt for the party member to sing. One STAR leader says that if this happens, Dr Jeffrey's long and consistent struggle since the 1980s will have been meaningless and will end in disgrace. These STAR leaders who reject Anwar's formula realize that it would be preferable to fight the election under the banner of patriotism and perhaps lose, rather than becoming part of a future government under which it will have decades-old principles shattered, their dreams for the people broken in irredeemable shame. As it is now, truth be told, calls for STAR to withdraw from the state government coalition are growing louder by the minute! It's significant that STAR President, Datuk Dr Jeffrey G. Kitingan, had missed the meeting of the GRS component parties' presidents meeting in Kota Kinabalu on August 2 to discuss pre-election preparation. Masiung Many observers also believe that GRS leaders have been warned by their voters that 'If you cooperate with Peninsular parties, we will no longer vote for you.' Even LDP, which has been silent for a long time, has advised that it is better for GRS to go solo. A stronger voice emerged from Gagasan itself, with its Vice President and Kuamut assemblyman, Datuk Masiung Banah, rejecting Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's proposal to include BN in the GRS and PH team to face PRN17, stating that it will confuse the people. Meanwhile, the mosquito parties are celebrating the confusion in GRS, seeing more hope for themselves, more and more confusion is brewing in panicky discussions within the ruling parties. Will there be more dissenting voices, ala Masiung, emerging in the coming days?
New Straits Times
8 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Sabah polls: Warisan going solo to avoid interference, says Shafie
PENAMPANG: Parti Warisan Sabah chose to go solo in the state election to minimise interference, said president Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal. "If you discuss with Umno, they want 26 (state seats). If you discuss with Pakatan Harapan (PH), they want 23. And with Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS), they want 40. "But is that important to the people? No, it's not. It is about water, electricity and jobs. "There has been too much interference from Kuala Lumpur, whether it is about our wealth, our system or even our schools. Featured Videos "We do not want to be tied up with people with an agenda," he said during the DSSA with Kapayan programme at Wisma Kinsabina here. Last week, Umno vice-president Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan said Barisan Nasional aimed to contest at least one state seat in each of the 25 parliamentary constituencies in Sabah. Sabah PKR chief Datuk Mustapha Sakmud said Sabah PH was eyeing more than 20 state seats. GRS chairman Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor had demanded for the coalition to have a majority of the 73 state seats. Currently, GRS holds 39 seats, Warisan holds 14, Umno holds 11 and PH holds 7. Previously, Shafie, who is former chief minister, said Warisan had identified candidates for 73 state seats. "It will be them (voters) who will decide (the results)."
