Injured homeless woman sleeps in her car on hospital grounds in Rotorua
Rotorua Hospital.
Photo:
Felix Desmarais/LDR
A homeless woman in Rotorua was forced to sleep in her car on hospital grounds after being discharged with injuries which made it impossible for her to drive.
Nicola was attacked on Friday evening, 13 June. In severe pain and realising something was wrong with her, she drove with difficulty to Rotorua hospital the next morning, leaving her car in a disabled car space in the hospital parking.
She said she received excellent care in the hospital where her broken ankle was put in a cast.
"When I went through the ED they were amazing, and Rotorua hospital staff are amazing, so I had a very good experience," she said.
The problem came on Monday afternoon, 16 June when it was suddenly announced she was being discharged.
"I said 'look, I can't go. If I go now, I'm going to go to WINZ and they aren't going to be able to help me' because it's 4pm on a Monday afternoon and they close at 5pm'."
After speaking to several people, she was given permission to stay one more night and go to Work and Income's Rotorua office in the morning.
On Tuesday, having been given the resources to take a taxi to Work and Income, Nicola visited community housing hub Te Pokapū. She was left with the impression that she had not lived in Rotorua for long enough to receive emergency housing help.
Ministry of Social Development's (MSD) Regional Commissioner Jacob Davies said eligibility for an emergency housing grant did not specify that a person must have lived in a given area for two years.
"If someone asks for housing assistance, we discuss their situation with them and how we may be able to help," he said.
However, MSD does consider whether someone seeking emergency housing had unreasonably contributed to their immediate emergency housing need.
Davies said Nicola left an existing tenancy in Putāruru and moved to Rotorua, first visiting MSD on 5 June to ask for emergency housing.
"She was still receiving financial assistance from Work and Income to pay for her tenancy in Putāruru, but she told us she had left there and moved to Rotorua about three weeks earlier, to house sit a property. However, that arrangement did not eventuate.
"At Te Pokapū, [Nicola] was informed she wouldn't be eligible for emergency housing because she had left Putāruru and her tenancy there.
"We acknowledge that a more detailed conversation with Nicola, about her options for MSD housing support, may have ensured greater clarity about what was available to her and why," he said.
Nicola is 51-years-old and said for many years her life had been stable and she was employed. This changed in the last few years after moving towns to live with a partner in what became an abusive relationship.
After leaving the relationship, she had several temporary living arrangements but was unable to keep working and for the last month has been living in her car. RNZ has chosen not to use her last name to protect her from her previous abusive partner.
After leaving hospital and again being turned down for emergency housing, Nicola found a friend who was able to give her a lift back to the hospital where she said she stayed in her parked car until Thursday, 19 June.
Health New Zealand (HNZ) Lakes District Acting Group Director of Operations Kathy Rex said Health New Zealand (HNZ) is responsible for the health-related needs of patients.
"We encourage anyone who needs assistance with housing or living support to seek help from relevant agencies," she said.
If required, HNZ will help connect patients and whānau with community agencies and appropriate support.
Nicola said she received at least two warnings that she was not allowed to be in her car at the hospital and would be towed or the police called. She continued to make it clear that due to her injuries she was unable to physically and legally drive the car.
"I'm not trying to stay or to be disruptive - I don't want to be here in the carpark at the hospital, I don't want to be taking up a space that a disabled person could be in, but I also thought, I am actually disabled, I have a cast on my leg, and I can't walk properly."
Nicola said that on the 19 June she was visited again, this time by the hospital facilities manager and security. After again making it clear she could not drive, it was agreed a security guard could move the car for her to a different carpark nearby.
Rex said owners of vehicles parked in a disability carpark at Rotorua Hospital without a disability permit are asked to move to one of the visitor car parks provided.
"Our staff are available to help with this if someone is unable to move their vehicle on their own," she said.
On Wednesday, 18 June, unsure what to do, Nicola begun calling people in Parliament. The first to answer her call and offer help was the office of Labour spokesperson for Mental Health, MP Ingrid Leary.
Leary said her office is trying to help Nicola and had been in communications with the hospital who she felt had let Nicola down.
She said it was a heartless situation, brought about by stressed out services due to underfunding and cuts.
"My concern is that when a hospital discharges someone they need to ensure they are going somewhere safe and that they will be safe and well for the immediate future and that hasn't happened in this case," Leary said.
She said government appropriation for emergency hospital had reduced by $225 million this year.
"The result is what we see in this case - someone who clearly needs emergency accommodation who has been kicked to the curb."
MSD said on 19 June, Nicola was approved for an Accommodation Costs in Advance Grant to help her pay for a backpackers, which was arranged by a social worker for her. Davies said Nicola told them that she did not want to accept this support.
Nicola said there is no way she could pay that grant back, and that the backpackers did not have space for her to park her car. Leary also said backpackers are not always the safest place to accommodate vulnerable women.
Instead, Nicola organised to stay in a motel which cost the same amount per night as the backpackers and allowed her to park her car. It was still unclear how this is going to be paid for.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Panel with Deborah Hart and Richard Pamatatau Part 2
Tonight on The Panel, Wallace Chapman is joined by panellists Deborah Hart and Richard Pamatatau. This half hour the panel hears about GPs and nurse practitioners have been given the green light to diagnose and treat ADHD. They also talk to a Clyde primary school teacher has gone viral on social media asking for strangers from around the world to send postcards to her class as a part of their inquiry learning. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Christchurch Prison fuel leak: 23 properties unable to use bore water
Thousands of litres of diesel leaked after the hatch of a fuel tank was left open. Photo: Luke McPake / The Wireless Twenty-three properties around Christchurch Men's Prison are unable to drink water from their private bores, a month after a fuel leak was discovered, Corrections has confirmed. About 14,000 litres of diesel leached into the ground at the prison last month after the hatch of a fuel tank was left open as part of a programme to replace two of the three fuel tanks on site. An investigation is underway to determine how the leak happened. Corrections commissioner of custodial services Leigh Marsh said staff initially visited around 40 properties near the prison on 6 June, almost two weeks after the fuel leak. It found many properties were vacant or unoccupied, but eight were using water from private bores. Resident were told not use water for drinking, cooking or feeding stock or animals. Marsh said it had since identified a further 14 households that have been told not to drink the water. Affected properties had all been offered water; 11 households had been supplied with about 1700 litres of bottled drinking water and one property had been given two 1000-litre containers for livestock. "A small amount of the bottled water was initially provided by Corrections from stock we had on-hand, but otherwise this is all being supplied and funded by Downer and has so far cost them approximately $3000," Marsh said. Soil testing from a bore drilled where the spill happened returned a positive result on 12 June, showing diesel at a depth of three to six metres but there was no diesel present in the soil samples taken from other bores. Marsh said groundwater samples taken from the bore at the spill site had all tested clear for any hydrocarbons. A positive water sample came from a bore around 300 metres from the spill site on 28 May, but further samples from that bore and the others had consistently returned clear results. National Public Health Service medical officer of health Annabel Begg said it continued to work with technical experts from Environment Canterbury and Taumata Arowai to assess the risk to the affected residents reliant on private bore water. She said water sampling and testing was ongoing to assess the risk to nearby, downgradient water supplies. The public heath service would continue to take a precautionary approach until it could be confidently established that the leak was contained within the prison boundary. "At this stage there is no change to the advice to discontinue using your private supply for drinking water, tooth brushing and for food preparation. However, it is safe to continue showering or bathing and washing clothes with water," she said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nelson Hospital's heating fully powered by landfill gas
Nelson Hospital. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Nelson Hospital is not burning coal this winter for the first time since the late 1800s, with its hot water and heating now fully powered by landfill gas. The chimney tower of the hospital's coal boiler, which was deemed earthquake-prone almost 10 years ago, is being dismantled after further investment in the York Valley Landfill meant enough methane was being captured to meet the hospital's needs. The hospital has been using a mix of coal and landfill gas for heating since 2002. It comes after community groups and individuals petitioned the Nelson City Council and former Nelson Marlborough District Health Board for years to end industrial coal use in the region. In 2019, Nelson GP Dr Ngaire Warner called on the health board to stop burning coal, given the environmental and health concerns it posed. She said it was "long overdue" but she was delighted that Nelson Hospital was no longer burning fossil fuels. "It's ironic and really quite disheartening that a health facility continued to burn a fuel well known to have a negative impact on the health of individuals and our wider community for such a long time," Dr Warner said. "There is extensive research showing that coal burning contributes to lung disease and respiratory illnesses, so every small change that corporations can implement to the reduce the burden of disease in our community is a win for everyone." In 2003, open fires were banned in Nelson and tough regulations on woodburner use were introduced from 2010 to improve the city's air quality as it struggled to comply with national air quality standards. Nelson's mayor Nick Smith said end of coal use at the hospital would make a big difference to the city's greenhouse gas emissions and reduce particulate pollution to a negligible level. "Nelson South was one of the most polluted areas anywhere in New Zealand 20 years ago and council's made a big effort in reducing the number of log burners. So, it's improved hugely, but the coal burnt at the hospital remained the largest source of particulate pollution." Nelson mayor Nick Smith. Photo: Max Frethey / LDR He said the chimney also posed a seismic risk and in a large earthquake, was at risk of collapsing onto Waimea Road, disrupting access on one of the main arterial routes to the city and access to the hospital. It had been issued with an earthquake-prone building notice in 2019 which required it to have seismic work completed by 2028. In 2023, Te Whatu Ora Health NZ applied for consent from the Nelson City Council to burn up to 4000 tonnes of coal a year, for another seven years, to heat and power its buildings. This was despite the government aiming to phase out the boilers in hospitals by the end of 2025. Health NZ later withdrew the application, and Smith said it had agreed to work with the council to increase the use of landfill gas to meet its heating and electricity needs. Nelson City Council and Tasman District Council, through the Nelson Tasman Regional Landfill Business Unit (NTRLBU), jointly invested $2.4 million in the landfill in recent years. An additional 69 gas wells had been installed that had tripled the amount of methane collected at the landfill, along with a new compressor and chiller system and upgrades to the pipes to the furnace at the hospital. Of that investment, Smith said $800,000 had been spent on buying the rights to capture the landfill gas from Pioneer Energy along with the pipeline, the boilers and pumps. NTRLBU now sells landfill gas to Health NZ and Smith said it expected that 2 million cubic metres of landfill gas would be used by the hospital each year, amounting to about 40 percent of the gas recovered from the landfill. Smith said Nelson's total greenhouse gas emissions were 260,000 tonne CO2 equivalent per year and the end of coal use at the hospital meant that had been reduced by around a third (80,000 tonne CO2e a year). The contract between the council and Health NZ to use landfill gas expires next April, and Smith said the two organisations were in the process of negotiating a new contract. "The preferred outcome would be to continue to use the landfill gas, but that will need to be worked through with Health New Zealand," Smith said. Health Minister Simeon Brown said in May a new energy centre would be built to house critical hospital infrastructure as part of the hospital's $500 million redevelopment, but Health NZ said it was "too soon" to comment on whether it would use landfill gas or what it would look like. Te Whatu Ora Te Waipounamu regional head of infrastructure Dr Rob Ojala said coal had been burnt at Nelson Hospital since the late 1800s, and the current boiler house and chimney were built in 1959 to replace a previous boiler house. As part of its transition to cleaner energy, the deconstruction of the Nelson Hospital chimney began five weeks ago and was estimated to take around two months, with about five meters of concrete crushed each day. The work was expected to cost around $300,000 and was funded through EECA's State Sector Decarbonisation Fund. Ojala said the boilers would now burn landfill gas, with diesel as a backup fuel if needed. Consent to use landfill gas sat with NTRLBU, who own the main boiler, and Ojala said the plan was for ownership to change to Health NZ at a later date. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
