Injured homeless woman sleeps in her car on hospital grounds in Rotorua
Photo:
Felix Desmarais/LDR
A homeless woman in Rotorua was forced to sleep in her car on hospital grounds after being discharged with injuries which made it impossible for her to drive.
Nicola was attacked on Friday evening, 13 June. In severe pain and realising something was wrong with her, she drove with difficulty to Rotorua hospital the next morning, leaving her car in a disabled car space in the hospital parking.
She said she received excellent care in the hospital where her broken ankle was put in a cast.
"When I went through the ED they were amazing, and Rotorua hospital staff are amazing, so I had a very good experience," she said.
The problem came on Monday afternoon, 16 June when it was suddenly announced she was being discharged.
"I said 'look, I can't go. If I go now, I'm going to go to WINZ and they aren't going to be able to help me' because it's 4pm on a Monday afternoon and they close at 5pm'."
After speaking to several people, she was given permission to stay one more night and go to Work and Income's Rotorua office in the morning.
On Tuesday, having been given the resources to take a taxi to Work and Income, Nicola visited community housing hub Te Pokapū. She was left with the impression that she had not lived in Rotorua for long enough to receive emergency housing help.
Ministry of Social Development's (MSD) Regional Commissioner Jacob Davies said eligibility for an emergency housing grant did not specify that a person must have lived in a given area for two years.
"If someone asks for housing assistance, we discuss their situation with them and how we may be able to help," he said.
However, MSD does consider whether someone seeking emergency housing had unreasonably contributed to their immediate emergency housing need.
Davies said Nicola left an existing tenancy in Putāruru and moved to Rotorua, first visiting MSD on 5 June to ask for emergency housing.
"She was still receiving financial assistance from Work and Income to pay for her tenancy in Putāruru, but she told us she had left there and moved to Rotorua about three weeks earlier, to house sit a property. However, that arrangement did not eventuate.
"At Te Pokapū, [Nicola] was informed she wouldn't be eligible for emergency housing because she had left Putāruru and her tenancy there.
"We acknowledge that a more detailed conversation with Nicola, about her options for MSD housing support, may have ensured greater clarity about what was available to her and why," he said.
Nicola is 51-years-old and said for many years her life had been stable and she was employed. This changed in the last few years after moving towns to live with a partner in what became an abusive relationship.
After leaving the relationship, she had several temporary living arrangements but was unable to keep working and for the last month has been living in her car. RNZ has chosen not to use her last name to protect her from her previous abusive partner.
After leaving hospital and again being turned down for emergency housing, Nicola found a friend who was able to give her a lift back to the hospital where she said she stayed in her parked car until Thursday, 19 June.
Health New Zealand (HNZ) Lakes District Acting Group Director of Operations Kathy Rex said Health New Zealand (HNZ) is responsible for the health-related needs of patients.
"We encourage anyone who needs assistance with housing or living support to seek help from relevant agencies," she said.
If required, HNZ will help connect patients and whānau with community agencies and appropriate support.
Nicola said she received at least two warnings that she was not allowed to be in her car at the hospital and would be towed or the police called. She continued to make it clear that due to her injuries she was unable to physically and legally drive the car.
"I'm not trying to stay or to be disruptive - I don't want to be here in the carpark at the hospital, I don't want to be taking up a space that a disabled person could be in, but I also thought, I am actually disabled, I have a cast on my leg, and I can't walk properly."
Nicola said that on the 19 June she was visited again, this time by the hospital facilities manager and security. After again making it clear she could not drive, it was agreed a security guard could move the car for her to a different carpark nearby.
Rex said owners of vehicles parked in a disability carpark at Rotorua Hospital without a disability permit are asked to move to one of the visitor car parks provided.
"Our staff are available to help with this if someone is unable to move their vehicle on their own," she said.
On Wednesday, 18 June, unsure what to do, Nicola begun calling people in Parliament. The first to answer her call and offer help was the office of Labour spokesperson for Mental Health, MP Ingrid Leary.
Leary said her office is trying to help Nicola and had been in communications with the hospital who she felt had let Nicola down.
She said it was a heartless situation, brought about by stressed out services due to underfunding and cuts.
"My concern is that when a hospital discharges someone they need to ensure they are going somewhere safe and that they will be safe and well for the immediate future and that hasn't happened in this case," Leary said.
She said government appropriation for emergency hospital had reduced by $225 million this year.
"The result is what we see in this case - someone who clearly needs emergency accommodation who has been kicked to the curb."
MSD said on 19 June, Nicola was approved for an Accommodation Costs in Advance Grant to help her pay for a backpackers, which was arranged by a social worker for her. Davies said Nicola told them that she did not want to accept this support.
Nicola said there is no way she could pay that grant back, and that the backpackers did not have space for her to park her car. Leary also said backpackers are not always the safest place to accommodate vulnerable women.
Instead, Nicola organised to stay in a motel which cost the same amount per night as the backpackers and allowed her to park her car. It was still unclear how this is going to be paid for.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Young people speak on the impact of having concussions
sport health about 1 hour ago An expert in traumatic brain injuries is calling for consistent protocols when dealing with concussions in schoolyard sport to prevent debilitating long-term impacts. While there's greater awareness about the risks associated with concussion, Pat Hopkins from the Laura Fergusson Brain Injury Trust said that too often, head knocks are treated differently if they occur during lower-level sports. Checkpoint spoke to young people who've been concussed playing sport at school and university, and continue to suffer consequences for years afterwards. Bella Craig reports.
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
More needed to tackle schoolyard sport concussions, expert says
Photo: NICK VEASEY/ SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY / AFP Warning: This story discusses suicide. An expert in traumatic brain injuries is calling for consistent protocols when dealing with concussions in schoolyard sport to prevent debilitating long-term impacts. While there's greater awareness about the risks associated with concussion, Pat Hopkins from the Laura Fergusson Brain Injury Trust said that too often, head knocks are treated differently if they occur during lower-level sports. Checkpoint has spoken to young people who've been concussed playing competitive sport throughout school and university and continue to sufferer the consequences for years afterwards. They want others to know about the the mental and physical toll that concussion can have and the gruelling rehabilitation process that's required. Moses Bygate-Smith was in a freak accident while trialling for a national ice hockey team in 2018. He was told he had a severe concussion, his third in 18 months. In the months that followed his injury, he said the symptoms took over his life. "If there was even just a pamphlet, for example, with a couple of words, or even just a short sentence on it, I couldn't read that sentence without getting an excruciating headache. When I'd have conversations with people, I would be halfway through a sentence, and I would actually forget what I was saying." He said he experienced depression and anxiety during the months of his recovery. "There were thoughts of sort of suicide at that time just because I guess it was very hard to think that potentially this was going to be the state of my life, for the for the rest of my life." He was unable to read, listen to music or exercise as he grappled with giving up the sport he dedicated so much of his life to. "Being sort of a person that lived and breathed ice hockey as much as the concussion was hard. I think what was a driving factor of the difficulty was the identity crisis that sort of comes with the changes you have to make from a head injury, especially for people [who] are athletes or involved with sports." Bygate-Smith has come a long way since his injury and has gone on to complete a master's degree in sports science. But the impact of his injury lingers to this day. Georgia Hendry grew up racing horses competitively and suffered multiple concussions while riding. She'd find it hard to study and struggled with exhaustion. After a car crash in 2021, things became even worse. "I went to the doctors, and I was like something's not right. I can't even sit in a lecture and obtain information; I'm having to go home and rewatch the lectures and then pause the lectures so I could keep up with the person speaking." She said not being able to play sport impacted her mental health. She's come a long way since her injury and is now working full time as a preschool teacher. But she said the recovery process was long and gruelling. "It's not an easy recovery and it's a very long recovery. It's not like a broken bone, it's your brain." Hopkins said the Christchurch-based Laura Fergusson Brain Injury Trust is seeing three times more clients than a few years ago. "The recognition of concussion has improved a lot over recent years and the awareness, so I think people and things like the blue card system in rugby have helped. "It's not just 'oh you'll be right' anymore, it's still out there a little bit, but it's changed." But she said it's in lower grade sports, where more could be done to protect younger people from sustaining concussions. Currently, the cost of seeing a doctor deters many people from getting checked. Hopkins said she wants consistent protocols for schoolyard and lower-level sports. "The kids just want to play and so it sometimes takes a strong coach to say, 'well, no, you can't play, you may be feeling okay, but it hasn't been enough time since your injury." "If the protocols and rules were more established that might help that." Over the past four years, new concussion injury claims lodged to ACC have increased from just over 39,000 in 2022 to 47,000 in 2024. There's been over 24,000 concussion injuries claimed so far this year. A claim to ACC may include multiple injuries. ACC estimates 30 percent of concussions go unreported. The highest number of concussion claims are from falls, followed by sports-related injuries. If it is an emergency and you feel like you or someone else is at risk, call 111. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Health Minister Simeon Brown slams striking health workers for 'playing politics'
Simeon Brown has called for the cancellation of proposed strikes next month. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ Health Minister Simeon Brown has criticised the nurses' union on Thursday afternoon, saying health workers are playing politics with patients' lives. The NZNO union cancelled a two-hour strike for perioperative, theatres and radiology services in Christchurch about 45 minutes before it was due to begin on Wednesday In a statement, Health New Zealand said there was no time to re-instate postponed appointments, affecting 85 patients. Health NZ confirmed nurses had, in July, been offered a pay increase of two percent this year and one percent next year on top of step-progression increases, with two additional "lump sum" payments of $325 over the next two years. Brown called a media conference with less than three hours' notice to call for the cancellation of more strikes planned for next month, saying they would "cause real, avoidable harm to more than 13,000 patients across the country". "As a direct result of the union's actions, more than 2200 surgeries will be canceled," he said. "Around 3600 first-specialist appointments will be delayed and about 8000 critical follow-up specialist appointments will be pushed back." He said the union had "put politics ahead of patients". The cancellation of the Christchurch strike was also "staggering" and he focused particularly on a social-media comment posted by one union member. "While union members walked back into work and collected a full day's pay, those patients lost the care they desperately needed. "A recent post on the New Zealand Nurses Organisation Facebook group suggested the late notice was a deliberate tactic to 'create chaos and keep health New Zealand guessing', even praising it as 'bloody beautiful tactics, comrades'." He claimed such tactics were "unacceptable" and "needs to be called out". "I ask them to tell that to the faces of the 13,000 patients, who are having their care cancelled, because they will see this as, frankly, them losing out on the care that they've already been waiting far too long for. "This is, quite frankly, playing politics with people's lives and it makes me furious. We value our nurses and the vital care that they provide." He pushed back, when reporters pointed out it was just one post by a member in a private group, rather than a statement from the union itself. "Well, I'm sorry, that is what the union did," he said. "The union cancelled the strike 45 minutes before the strike came into effect and that meant that 85 patients in Canterbury yesterday could not have their care rebooked. "If you look at their Facebook group, it was all about making sure that they kept health New Zealand guessing." Brown's statements followed Education Minister Erica Stanford and Public Service Minister Judith Collins saying secondary school teachers striking was "premeditated" and a "political stunt" . The union plans to strike next Wednesday over a one percent pay-rise offer, but the ministers said striking was deeply unfair on parents and students. Collins told Morning Report that teacher strikes were becoming a "yearly attack" on them . The government has recently cracked down on non-strike industrial action, but Brown said the union should be working with Health NZ and negotiating in good faith, rather than striking. "Ultimately, these are public servants who work in hospitals, and their role is to care for patients and put patients first," he said. "That is not what they're doing. "It's an incredibly important point that these union contracts not only have the increase that is on offer, but also have annual step increases, which those staff get, based on how many years that they are in the job, and that's a point that media don't highlight." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
