George Cardenas: Property tax burden has shifted to homeowners, but businesses are still in distress
The recent report issued by Treasurer Maria Pappas presents just one part of the property tax assessment system in Cook County — the appeals process. While raising important points about regressivity, the report makes brief mention of the broader context, but for the rising property tax bills, that is where the focus needs to be.
To begin with, the assertion that nearly $2 billion in property taxes has shifted from businesses to homeowners through the appeals process neglects the significant economic distress currently affecting commercial properties.
The COVID-19 pandemic dramatically devastated the valuation of commercial properties nationwide, particularly in downtown Chicago, resulting in unprecedented vacancies, reduced rental income and a general economic downturn for businesses. As anyone can see, downtown Chicago has dramatically changed during the last four years. There are fewer places to eat, many retail shops on Michigan Avenue and the Loop have closed, and workers have not fully returned. All the above absolutely had an impact on market valuation.
As a point of fact, according to the Cook County assessor's office in January 2021: 'The adjustment process (the COVID-19 factor) for the City of Chicago started with an understanding of where current market values stand relative to recent sales. In a sales ratio study of 2018 estimated market values conducted by the International Association of Assessing Officers, many commercial properties were already under assessed when compared to 2018 market sales and therefore further decreases to reflect the effects of COVID-19 were not needed.' Thus, even though commercial properties in Chicago were dramatically impacted by COVID, the assessor's office provided little relief through the COVID factor.
Decisions by the assessor's office, such as the ill-designed COVID-19 factor, necessitated careful consideration of the real value of property by the Board of Review. Upon appeal to the Board of Review in 2021, the resulting decreases from the assessor's office increases were justified to reflect actual market conditions.
Moreover, the focus of discussion needs to be the other major contributors to property tax increases: the significant growth in property tax levies from various taxing bodies, most notably Chicago Public Schools.
According to the Cook County clerk, CPS alone increased its property tax levy from 2014 to 2023 from $2.4 billion to $3.8 billion, respectively. By focusing on appeals, are we missing the primary drivers of property tax increases?
Additionally, the disparities in appeal rates among neighborhoods highlighted by the treasurer's report largely stem from inequities in information access and education regarding the appeals process, rather than just the appeals mechanism itself.
The Board of Review actively promotes homeowner education and conducts numerous outreach efforts, particularly aimed at underserved communities. Last year, the Cook County Board of Review's 1st District hosted 50 town halls, where the board accepted approximately 7,400 appeals. Pappas' office, as the issuer of tax bills, can assist in this essential role in addressing these disparities by proactively notifying homeowners of appeal opportunities in multiple languages already available through Cook County.
The Cook County Board president commissioned a thorough study by Josh Myers Valuation Solutions, titled 'Analysis of Commercial Valuation Practice in the Cook County Property Tax System,' published in December. This comprehensive report recommended improvements including standardizing valuation methodologies, improving data sharing between the assessor and the Board of Review, and enhancing overall assessment accuracy and uniformity. These solutions directly address the core issues within our property tax system, unlike the treasurer's focus solely on appeals outcomes.
Lastly, the report raises valid concerns about the regressive nature of the property tax system but offers no practical or comprehensive solutions. The Cook County Board of Review has consistently advocated for reforms to improve initial assessments and ensure equitable outcomes for all taxpayers. Real and lasting change will require collaboration across all county offices, including the treasurer's office, to enhance transparency, fairness and equity in the assessment and appeals processes.
We invite Pappas and all relevant stakeholders to partner constructively with the Board of Review in developing and implementing comprehensive reforms that address the root causes of property tax regression and promote fairness for all Cook County residents.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Bobby Harrison: MS revenue is anemic even before new tax cut takes effect
It should not be a surprise that what was touted as the largest tax cut in state history might be resulting in less revenue to fund Mississippi's vital services such as education, law enforcement and health care. Perhaps a bit of clarification is needed. In recent years, three separate tax cuts have been touted by leaders as 'the largest tax cut in state history': a $416 million tax cut in 2016 and a $525 million tax cut in 2022. But neither is no longer the state's largest tax cut. That was passed earlier this year during the 2025 legislative session. The 2025 tax cut has not yet gone into effect. So, in other words, three times in less than a decade, legislators have passed 'the largest tax cut in state history.' Mississippi's current anemic revenue collections can be attributed to one of three things: an economic slowdown, those major tax cuts, or a combination of the two. The economic slowdown seems logical. After all, billions of federal dollars flowing into the state as part of COVID-19 pandemic relief are drying up. Then there is the issue of the tax cuts. In the 2016 session, the Legislature approved a tax cut for corporations and on personal income totaling $416 million in 2016 dollars. The portion of that tax cut currently being phased out is for corporations. The 2022 tax cut, though, was all on personal income. Based on the May 2025 revenue report released by the staff of the Legislative Budget Committee, corporate taxes for the current fiscal year are down a staggering $237.5 million or 29% with one month left in the fiscal year. No doubt, there are other factors contributing to such a large decrease, but it is safe to assume the reduction in the corporate tax passed in 2016 is a contributing factor. Despite the income tax cut also being phased in, income tax collections are up slightly this year: $34 million or 1.7%. But do not get too excited. Over the prior two years, income tax collections dropped by $253 million. In fiscal year 2023, the income tax accounted for 35% of general fund revenue compared to 28% for the last fiscal year. The goal of legislative leaders and of Gov. Tate Reeves is to eliminate the income tax, and that most likely will occur by 2040 under the massive tax cut passed earlier this year. Meanwhile, buoyed by the drop in the corporate tax, it is likely that the state will end the fiscal year on June 30 collecting less revenue than it did the previous year for only the sixth time since 1970. Revenue collections normally go up just as in most years there is inflation instead of deflation. Inflation drives higher tax collections. Overall, through 11 months of the fiscal year, revenue collections are down $78.7 million or 1.1%. There is a chance that decrease could be offset in the month of June, but it is not likely. Even if it is offset, it cannot be disputed that revenue is slowing. The last fiscal year and this fiscal year, the collections have been bolstered by interest earnings on the state's deposits. For the current fiscal year, the state is collecting $20 million or 15.8% more in interest earnings than it did the previous year. And that is saying something since in the previous year the state collected $68.7 million or 84.4% more than it did the year before that. Proponents have argued that the tax cuts would spur the economy and result in higher revenue collections in other areas such as on the sales tax. But there is not clear evidence of that occurring. Despite what seems like many flashing warning signs, lawmakers who supported the massive 2025 tax cut would tell you there is nothing to see here, no need to be concerned. Lawmakers and Reeves like to point out that the state has more than $1 billion in reserves. They cite those funds and say, of course, we have the money to eliminate more than one-third of the state revenue stream. But they have consistently discounted the billions in federal funds that have poured into the state because of the pandemic. Those funds, which are no longer available, helped build that surplus they dwell on. Because of that surplus, the state in the short term can absorb any lost revenue from the tax cuts. And, incidentally, Reeves can go on national television and brag about 'eliminating' the income tax. But the question is what will be the impact of the tax cuts in 10 years when Reeves and most of the legislators responsible for the tax cut have retired from public services and are drawing their state retirement benefits? Will they still be bragging about passing the state's largest tax cuts three times? This column was produced by Mississippi Today, a nonprofit news organization that covers state government, public policy, politics and culture. Bobby Harrison is the editor of Mississippi Today Ideas.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Johnstown city council informs public of park renovation project
JOHNSTOWN, Pa. (WTAJ) — Members of the Johnstown City Council helped inform the public about the approved renovation project of Central Park. Councilman Taylor Clark set up a stand at the gazebo in the park to lay out the project plans, design and other features for the residents to learn about the upcoming park renovations that cost $8 million. Members of the public came to the stand to hear what the councilman had to say. 'We got a design for the park that's going to be not just something that's going to modernize it, but it's going to be something that will be more inclusive for everyone, especially people with disabilities,' Clark said. 'ADA compliance is a huge deal, and modernization is a huge deal, while remembering the history of the park itself.' Plans included a patio place for people to sit down at, a new pavilion for entertainment and a new water feature. The prominent feature, the water fountain in the center of the park, will move over to Sandyvale Park. 'When we put the park back together, there will be new sidewalks, there'll be new benches,' Clark added. 'There'll be a lot of new features of the park that will be more communal for everyone to be able to use.' However, the session did come with a counter protest across the way from the gazebo. Republican nominee for city mayor John DeBarcola and Republican nominee for city council Joe Tartano set up a table to share their perspective as to why the project should not happen. 'They've tried this before,' Tartano said. 'They told everybody when they reduce Main Street and Central Park, it's going to bring people downtown. It's not. It didn't before. It's history. Look into it. After the flood, they redid everything, and it hasn't.' Residents flocked to the park to hear from both sides of the issue. While some picked at bits and pieces of the design, others took strong stances on one side or the other. 'If you had a home, you'd redo your kitchen,' resident Sandy Grodziski said. 'You don't wait 60 years to remodel your house.' 'The park is a great place to meet people. The plans are just incredibly stupid,' resident Catherine-Anne McCluskey said. A main point for those who are against the park renovations is the amount of money going into it. At a price tag of $8 million, they feel the money could have gone elsewhere. 'The money could go to the public safety building,' DeBarcola said. 'The money can go into blight removal. They had so many options on how they could spend this money, and they failed to do that.' Clark has expressed his displeasure with the invoice for the renovations, also saying that the money granted to them by the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) during the COVID-19 pandemic could have been allocated elsewhere. The deadline to move the money elsewhere passed in December 2024, which means that the city has to use it before giving it back to the federal government. 'Not only would that be an embarrassment for the city if we were able to do that, it would be very difficult then to move forward, trying to get targeted federal and state funding,' Clark said. 'They're living in the past, and I'm living in the future, so I keep moving up,' Grodziski added. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Class of 2025 shows increase in kids involved in extracurriculars in line with Spokane Public Schools' efforts to engage
Jun. 7—Some of the colorful cords that adorn the hundreds of Spokane Public Schools' graduates this year represent their involvement in one of the school district's 1,024 unique activities. Still feeling the side effects of COVID-induced school closures, school staff have made an effort to boost nonacademic offerings to foster community in schools, an element staff hope will benefit attendance, mental health and reduce time kids spend on screens. Through the past three school years, students have steadily become more engaged in the district, measured by involvement with a sport, club, the arts or a community group at school. In the 2022-23 school year, 29% of kids were engaged. The next year, it was just over half of students. This school year, nearly 65% of students were engaged, and 64% of the senior class was involved in something nonacademic at school, according to the district. For graduate Nermin Omar, Rogers High School senior class president, clubs enriched her experience at high school; she was, involved in her school's Amnesty International club, multicultural club, National Honors Society, Key Club and leadership. "You can't just go to school and be like, 'I'm just going here for education,' " she said. "I think of school as my second home, I'm that nerd." Favorites of hers, which she arduously selected from her extensive resume, were Amnesty International and multicultural club — both gatherings of peers from diverse cultural backgrounds, many hailing from other countries. This year, over 200 seniors joined "belonging-focused" clubs like this. Omar became Amnesty International's president her freshman year. An immigrant from Syria, she relished the chance to show off her culture. Omar is Kurdish, an ethnic group that resides in a region that encompasses parts of Syria, Iran, Iraq and Turkey . Omar and her family fled the civil war in Syria when she was young, living in Turkey and eventually settling in Spokane, where she attended Logan Elementary as a fourth -grader and finally "started dreaming," she said. Her Kurdish background is integral to Omar's identity, and the clubs gave her the space to express and explain her culture, beyond just saying she's from Syria, with peers who felt the same about their cultural identity. "I need to show this to the school; we can't be known as just one simple country," she said. Sports were another popular means to participate outside of academics among the class of 2025, with 127 seniors playing volleyball, 100 running in cross country, 85 playing baseball and 300 each in basketball and track and field, according to the district. One of those 300 was Rogers' Daeante Bedford, who uses the latter two sports to keep in shape for football, his true athletic passion. After graduation, he's bound for a school in Iowa to play football. Playing sports in high school helps motivate him with school, keeping his grades up so he stays academically eligible for the teams. It's also changed his attitude measurably, he said. "If something didn't go my way, really I'd just get kind of mad about it. I had a short fuse, but I learned to have a lot more patience with people and help out people, too," Bedford said. While clubs intend to foster belonging at school, On Track Academy graduates Hailey Bjornstad and Caitlynn Forech expressed a cycle that kept them from wanting to participate before transferring to On Track. Each said they didn't feel welcome at the traditional schools they attended before transferring to On Track, an option high school that focuses on project-based learning for those who don't thrive in the classic classroom setting. "I wasn't really interested in anything; I low -key skipped a lot," Forech said. "I was home, that was low -key when I was depressed too. I was going through a lot that year." Because they didn't feel they belonged at school, there was nothing motivating them to join a club or activity. Part of the reason they don't feel connected at school was a lack of buy-in to the community, they said — something that the district aims to foster through clubs and activities. After enrolling in On Track and finding their passions in teaching and stained glass, they now feel much more comfortable at school with friends and teachers to whom they've grown close. Though a majority involve themselves outside of class, some are just trying to stay afloat with schoolwork and see graduation. That's the case for Rogers graduates Jasmine Contreras, Sarah Dahl and Dakota Nipp, three friends who don't have any regrets abstaining from clubs or sports in their high school careers. "I feel like since COVID, a lot of us just kind of gave up on social cues, socializing, doing clubs and stuff," Conteras said; the class of 2025 were in middle school when the schools closed from the pandemic. "It was maybe social anxiety; it's not really like the community like it used to be," Dahl said. Though their high school careers were focused on passing classes rather than joining extracurriculars, they don't feel they've missed out. Conteras, enrolled at Spokane Falls Community College to study teaching, said she may consider clubs at that level. Maybe something in photography, an interest sparked through a class at Rogers. When the class of 2027 crosses the graduate stage in two years, district staff have made it their goal to involve 78% of their students in an extracurricular activity. Elena Perry's work is funded in part by members of the Spokane community via the Community Journalism and Civic Engagement Fund. This story can be republished by other organizations for free under a Creative Commons license. For more information on this, please contact our newspaper's managing editor.
