Rural TD calls for urgent reform of Fair Deal scheme
If you are approved for Fair Deal, you pay a certain amount towards the total cost of nursing home care and Health Service Executive (HSE) pays the balance.
For example, if the amount you've been told to pay is €400 a month and the nursing home costs €1,200 a month, HSE will pay the balance of €800.
Independent Ireland leader, Deputy Michael Collins has warned that thousands of farm and small business families are facing financial devastation due to what he has described as 'outdated and unfair' rules within the system.
Deputy Collins claimed that the current structure of the Nursing Homes Support Scheme — commonly known as Fair Deal — fails to reflect the realities of family farming and small enterprise in rural Ireland, and risks forcing families to sell their land or businesses to cover spiralling nursing home costs.
'The Fair Deal scheme is no longer fit for purpose when it comes to farm and business families,' Deputy Collins said.
'People who spent a lifetime building up their land or family business, often with the intention of handing it on to the next generation, are now being punished by a system that doesn't recognise how rural life and long-term leasing works.'
Fair Deal scheme
Under current rules, families may apply for a cap that limits the contribution of farm or business assets to nursing home costs to three years, but only if strict conditions are met.
One of those conditions is that the farm or business must be 'actively operated'. The successor must commit to farming the land for six years from the time Fair Deal is approved.
However, according to Deputy Collins, this excludes thousands of landowners who leased out land in good faith, often under long-term lease agreements actively encouraged by the state to promote land mobility and generational renewal.
'These people did the right thing,' Deputy Collins said. 'They followed state advice, entered into long-term leases to give younger farmers a chance, and now they're being penalised for it. That's indefensible.'
The Independent Ireland TD referenced recent figures that reveal that mroe than 13,000 individuals who have land under long-term lease arrangements are likely to be excluded from the three-year cap.
'As a result, they face annual nursing home charges that can exceed €70,000, and in some cases reach €120,000, without the protections offered to others,' he stated.
He claimed that the financial burden has already led to some families being forced to sell land to meet the cost of care.
Deputy Collins is calling for a full review and amendment of the Fair Deal rules to ensure that long-term leased land is recognised as part of an 'actively farmed' holding, particularly where the lease was encouraged under state-supported schemes.
He is also asking for a path for families to nominate a successor, even where the farm was leased, without losing eligibility for the three-year asset cap.
'We are simply asking for fair treatment for families,' Deputy Collins said.
'The Fair Deal should not be a trap for decent people trying to do right by their families.
'If the state encouraged long-term leasing for good policy reasons, it cannot now turn around and punish those same families when they need care,' the TD concluded.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
21 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill to deliver annual Michael Collins address at Béal na Bláth
The Michael Collins Commemoration is an annual event which takes place at Béal na Bláth, located near the village of Crookstown to honour the memory of General Michael Collins, the Irish revolutionary leader who was shot at the location on August 22, 1922, at the age of 31. Each year, a commemoration is held at the site of his death on the Sunday closest to August 22. Ms Carroll MacNeill said: 'It is an extraordinary honour to have been asked by the Michael Collins Commemoration Committee to speak at this year's Béal na Bláth commemoration. 'This significant event allows us to remember and honour the legacy of Michael Collins, whose vision, leadership, and unwavering dedication to our country and its people continue to inspire us all,' she added. Ms Carroll MacNeill continued: 'His legacy of leadership and dedication to public service is something I see as I visit our healthcare community around the country and their unwavering dedication to caring for people. 'I am really looking forward to speaking at the commemoration and reflecting on Collins's legacy and values,' she said. The address last year was delivered by then taoiseach Simon Harris, while in August 2023 the main address was delivered by former RTÉ northern editor, the late Tommie Gorman. In August 2022, there was an historic address by the Fianna Fail leader Micheal Martin when he became the first Fianna Fail Taoiseach to speak at a commemoration for Mr Collins. He was joined by the then Tánaiste Leo Varadkar in delivering a joint oration. Mr Collins was part of the delegation which signed the Anglo-Irish treaty in 1921, leading to a split in the Irish parliament and to the Irish Civil War. Michael Collins was shot and killed during an ambush by anti-Treaty forces on August 22, 1922. The identity of the shooter remains a mystery nearly 123 years later. Descendants of Mr Collins will travel from across the world to attend the commemoration. They will join the thousands of people who will travel from across Ireland to mark the anniversary of his death.
Agriland
2 days ago
- Agriland
Government urged to consider Fair Deal proposals as farmers seek reform
Farmers are seeking an urgent reform of the Fair Deal scheme. The Irish Farmers' Association (IFA) has told Agriland it is seeking a meeting with the Government to discuss the Fair Deal and ask for immediate changes to the scheme that it says are necessary to prevent people losing their farms. Under the Nursing Homes Support Scheme, also referred to as Fair Deal, financial support is offered to people in long-term nursing home care. Nursing home residents pay part of the nursing home fees according to their means, and the HSE pays the balance. The IFA is seeking a number of changes to the Fair Deal. The association has proposed to reduce the five-year land/business transfer clause to three years in line with the 'three-year cap', to allow more farmers to benefit from the Fair Deal. The IFA has proposed that land leased under Fair Deal should be classed as 'actively farmed' for the purposes of meeting succession criteria. The IFA is also seeking an increase in the ancillary state support loan payback to a minimum of five years to allow sufficient time to repay the costs. The current cash asset disregard for a single person is €36,000 and €72,000 for a couple; IFA is asking for these to be increased to €44,000 and €88,000 respectively. The IFA has said that the assessment period for the family home under Fair Deal should be reduced from three years to two, with a maximum contribution of 15% of the home's value, instead of the current cap of 22.5%. The IFA has also proposed that income from leased farmland should be excluded or at least partially disregarded in the Fair Deal financial assessment. IFA farm family and social affairs committee chairperson Teresa Roche told Agriland that the association is putting emphasis on "how unfair" the Fair Deal is for family farms, and that people "with assets are being penalised." Under current rules, families may apply for a cap that limits the contribution of farm or business assets to nursing home costs to three years, but only if strict conditions are met. The three-year cap was introduced in 2021 for qualifying family farms and businesses, limiting the asset-based contribution to the total of 22.5% (7.5% a year, for three years). After three years, the value of family-owned farms and businesses is not considered when calculating the cost of a person's nursing home care. Roche said that the Fair Deal criteria needs to be urgently changed, in order to protect family farms. It is understood that thousands of individuals who have land under long-term lease arrangements are likely to be excluded from the three-year cap. Roche said this is putting farms with leased land "in huge jeopardy". She said there is a threat to food production in Ireland as a result of people being "forced to sell" farms to cover the costs of nursing home care. Roche said the IFA is seeking a full review of the Fair Deal, which the association believes is overdue. "We're waiting for a meeting with the government to discuss this," she added. The Department of Health told Agriland that discussions in relation to its annual budget are underway, and any changes to the Fair Deal "would need to be considered as part of the annual estimates process which is ongoing at the moment". "The department has regular engagement with key nursing home stakeholders from the sector regarding the Nursing Homes Support Scheme," it added. Related Stories Rural TD calls for urgent reform of Fair Deal scheme Cork TD Colm Burke asked the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon recently to provide an update on his department's engagement with the Department for Health in relation to examining the Fair Deal to ensure it does not impede succession planning and recognises the distinctive position of agricultural land. The minister said that farm succession is a "complex issue and there are many factors that impact farmers' decisions". "Last October, an independent Commission on Generational Renewal in Farming was established. The commission is taking an objective, evidence-based approach examining the range of factors involved that contribute to the age demographic in the sector," the minister replied. "I am expecting the commission to report to me on policy options shortly."
Extra.ie
5 days ago
- Extra.ie
Food Safety Authority of Ireland enforced closures of several businesses this summer
A Dublin branch of German supermarket giant Lidl and a popular tourist hotel in Tralee, County Kerry are just two of the businesses that were forced to close their doors under orders issued by the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) in July. Ten closure orders in total were handed out by the FSAI last month, including the Lidl store on the Sallynoggin Road in Glenageary, Dublin, where the entire premises was ordered to close after rodent droppings were found in multiple locations across the shop floor and the store room. The report also detailed what was described as 'extensive food debris' on the floor of the store room, and 'large amounts of foodstuffs' in areas where rodent droppings were visible on the floors. Photo: Sam Boal/ A live mouse was even observed scampering across the floor in the store room by two environmental health officials, inspecting the store. The order on the store, issued on July 29th, was lifted on August 1st and the HSE conducted a review and approved the store for reopening. In response to the order, a spokesperson for Lidl said 'providing a clean, safe and enjoyable shopping experience for all of our customers is of the utmost importance to us' and the retail giant takes food safety issues 'extremely seriously'. A live mouse was even observed scampering across the floor in the store room by two environmental health officials, inspecting the store. Pic: Shutterstock Lidl has stated that it has since fully collaborated with the HSE and taken necessary steps, including hiring a professional pest control service, conducting a deep clean and full sanitation of the store, and pest-proofing the premises to prevent future issues. Lidl has also reasssured customers that a full internal review of processes has been carried out to ensure cleanliness and food safety at the store. 'We understand and apologise for the concern this has caused and would like to assure our customers that the issue was addressed fully and efficiently', Lidl said. Pic: Getty Images Meanwhile, a popular hotel in Tralee, County Kerry was at the centre of a cockroach infestation, resulting in the closure of its kitchen for a time. The Brandon Hotel suffered what's been described as a 'significant cockroach infestation' in a number of areas of the hotel, including dead roaches in the main kitchen, under fridges, and on the floors of the wash-up area and even the staff canteen. Live cockroaches were even seen in the hotel's restaurant. The closure order was lifted on July 25th. Pic: Getty Images Meanwhile, even theme parks do not escape the scourge of the pests, with a storage unit at the rear of a coffee dock in Emerald Park in Ashbourne, Co Meath closed for a time on July 14th after rat droppings were found in the unit. Environmental inspectors found rodent droppings in an area used for storing food and items like cups, lids, straws, food containers and trays and their report noted that the unit was not pest-proof, with holes in the walls. A number of other businesses hit with closure orders over the past number of weeks include a Londis store on Connaught Street in Athboy, County Meath, Creeds foodstore in Cahir, County Tipperary, and KRS Catering Stall in Clonmel, County Tipperary. Tim Nessa on John's Street in Limerick was served a closure order, as was the Costa Coffee on Dublin's Dawson Street. Wakami Sushi and Asian and Hidden Dojo Asian Streetfood, both based on Phibsborough Road in Dublin, were also forced to close. Pic: Shutterstock The Food Safety Authority of Ireland said that recent incidents involving foodstuffs serve as a stark reminder of the need for businesses handling food to maintain the highest standards of food safety, and that customers are entitled to expect that the food they purchase is safe. The report from the FSAI went on to say that 'Every food business must take its responsibility to comply with food safety law seriously. The FSAI can provide support and advice to food businesses to help them meet their obligations.' 'However, as demonstrated by the enforcement actions this month, where food businesses do not comply with their obligations, we will take action.'
