
Estimated assessments: Sars's new ‘cash-cow-grabbing' norm?
Sars often prepares these estimates 'by comparing deposits into a bank account to turnover declared on the tax return'. Picture: AdobeStock
The South African Revenue Service (Sars) has the power to raise estimated assessments when the information supplied by a taxpayer is considered incorrect or inadequate.
The apparent subjectivity of the parameters used when issuing estimated assessments make the provision subject to abuse, argues Nico Theron, founder of Unicus Tax Specialists.
The Tax Administration Act authorises Sars to issue an estimated assessment if a taxpayer fails to submit a return; submits a return or relevant material that is incorrect or inadequate; or fails to respond to requests for relevant material, even after multiple reminders.
If any of these requirements is unmet, Sars may issue an estimated assessment, which is then based on its own calculations of the taxpayer's liability, says MaxProf auditor Debora Motana in a published article.
ALSO READ: Are you making money with crypto assets? Sars is looking for you
Troubling …
Theron finds the subjective nature of the parameters for inaccurate returns or information or inadequate returns or information troublesome.
'If, for example, the taxpayer submits detailed information, but the Sars auditor does not understand it, is the information inaccurate? Perhaps not. Is it inadequate? Well, perhaps, for that auditor but perhaps not for the next one.'
He says hypothetically the provision can be relied on when an accurate assessment is objectively speaking possible – but subjectively, the auditor may be snowed under or lack the expertise to get to an accurate assessment and revert to an easy way out, thereby shifting the workload to the taxpayer.
ALSO READ: Economists say they are confident in Sars
Methodology
Theron notes that Sars often prepares these estimates by comparing deposits into a corporate taxpayer's bank account to turnover declared on the tax return.
'If the deposits are higher, they will typically propose to tax the difference. They will propose this even though it is trite that the sum of deposits in a bank account will seldomly yield the same number as turnover.
'This much, frankly, is ridiculously obvious to anybody with a basic understanding of commerce and accounting.'
When Sars estimates a taxpayer's tax bill by comparing bank statements to turnover, the onus is on the taxpayer to prove – on a deposit-by-deposit basis – why the difference is not taxable.
Theron argues that accurate assessments are to be preferred and that estimated assessments should only be raised as a last resort and not simply if the taxpayer failed to file a return, failed to respond to multiple requests, or submits information or a return that is inadequate or incorrect.
Motana warns taxpayers to be vigilant in adhering to the requirements outlined in the provision (Section 95 of the act) that grants the power to Sars to make an estimated assessment.
She also notes that the onus is on the taxpayer to demonstrate whether the assessment is valid or needs adjustment.
ALSO READ: Tax season now open: Sars pays out R10bn in refunds after auto-assessments, you could be owed
Court case
Motana refers to an appeal case before the tax court in Johannesburg where Taxpayer RPC took an estimated assessment on appeal. It was not satisfied with the methodology used by Sars in determining the assessments.
In its judgment in favour of Sars's methodology, the court quoted from the Africa Cash & Carry v Sars case where the tax court stated that an estimated assessment 'by its very nature' is subject to change based on an evaluation of the evidence and any information that becomes available.
The tax court must place itself in the shoes of the functionary to determine whether the methodology followed and the assumptions on which the estimated assessments are based, are reasonable and produce a reasonable result.
In the Taxpayer RPC case the court found that the methodology used by Sars is not expected to be precise, as long it satisfies the objective test.
ALSO READ: Looming tax deadline and glitches cause frustration
'Cash-cow-grabbing norm'
Theron says an organ of state such as Sars must act within the four corners of its empowering provisions.
He questions whether the raising of estimated assessments is used as a last resort to protect the fiscus or whether it is used because it is effective and convenient.
'I can understand, from a business perspective, that estimated assessments might be used as cash-cow-grabbing norm. Indeed, we are seeing an increase in estimated assessments.'
* Sars announced last week that it has issued auto-assessments to 5.8 million taxpayers, up from five million last year. Taxpayers have from 21 July until 20 October to file their tax returns or make changes to their auto-assessments. Provisional taxpayers have until 19 January to file their tax returns.
This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Citizen
6 hours ago
- The Citizen
SARS launches 2025 tax filing with enhanced auto assessments and speedy refunds
The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has opened the 2025 tax filing season. Individual taxpayers can file returns from July 21 to October 20, while provisional taxpayers have until January 19, 2026. This year marks a significant expansion of SARS' auto assessment process, with 5.8 million taxpayers receiving automated assessments – up from 5 million in 2024. Of these, 99.6% have not been changed by taxpayers, reflecting accuracy and trust in the system. SARS has already paid out R10.6b in refunds within 72 hours of assessment. ALSO READ: SARS disrupts illicit fuel trade with operations across three provinces The auto assessment process uses third-party data to evaluate taxpayer returns without requiring further input from most individuals. Taxpayers only need to take action if their information is incomplete, which they can correct via eFiling or the SARS MobiApp. SARS commissioner Edward Kieswetter praised the ongoing digital transformation of SARS, calling the auto assessment process 'a game changer' that aligns with the vision to 'make tax just happen'. He added that the growing use of artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning and data science continues to reduce the need for in-person visits to SARS service centres. Following the auto assessment period, which ran from July 7 to 20, the broader tax filing season is now underway. Most online submissions receive an assessment outcome in less than five seconds, with SARS using advanced AI to detect risks and prevent fraudulent refunds. Digital engagement with SARS continues to rise. More than 10.2 million unique users accessed the SARS eFiling platform or the MobiApp since July 4. SARS handled over 2.1m queries digitally – 1.1 million via the SARS Online Query System, 707 000 through WhatsApp, and 290 000 with the Lwazi Chatbot. To ensure a smooth filing season, SARS urges taxpayers to file accurate information promptly. ALSO READ: SARS enhances eFiling for 2025 season Only refunds over R100 will be automatically paid into taxpayers' verified bank accounts within 72 hours of assessment. Taxpayers who owe SARS should pay promptly or make arrangements to avoid penalties. SARS also warned the public to remain vigilant against scams. SARS reminds taxpayers that it will never send clickable links via SMS or email to request sensitive information. Report suspicious messages to [email protected], and the latest scam alerts are available at Kieswetter emphasised the convenience of digital platforms and advised taxpayers to avoid unnecessary visits to service centres. He encouraged all taxpayers to use eFiling and other digital services for quicker and more secure compliance. For more information, visit or contact SARS via WhatsApp on 0800 117 277, or dial 1347277#.


The South African
17 hours ago
- The South African
SARS makes key changes for non-resident taxpayers
The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has introduced a new interim process to simplify tax return submissions for individuals who are not tax residents of South Africa, but earn South African-sourced income. The move follows growing confusion among non-resident taxpayers over how to correctly complete their returns, with some required sections not automatically activating on the SARS eFiling platform. In response, SARS announced an interim solution via its SARS Online Query System (SOQS), allowing non-residents to request access to the correct tax return format. 'A more permanent solution directly on the tax return through the tax return 'wizard' will be introduced later,' SARS stated. To activate the non-resident section of the tax return: Visit the SARS website and click on the SOQS icon. Navigate to 'Non-Resident Tax Return Type.' Fill in the requested personal details. A One-Time Pin (OTP) will be sent to the contact details on record. Select the 2025 tax year and answer SARS's prompted questions. The return will then be formatted accordingly and accessed through the normal eFiling process. SARS noted that the information will be retained for use in subsequent years unless a taxpayer's residency status or other relevant details change. South Africa operates under a residence-based tax system, meaning: Residents are taxed on their worldwide income are taxed on their Non-residents are taxed only on income sourced from within South Africa 1. Salary income Salaries earned in South Africa by non-residents are subject to normal tax, unless a Double Taxation Agreement (DTA) provides relief. DTA conditions typically exempt tax if the employer is foreign, has no permanent establishment in South Africa, and the individual has not been present in the country for more than 183 days. 2. Pensions and annuities Only amounts related to services rendered within South Africa are taxed. 3. Rental income Non-residents earning rental income from South African properties must pay normal tax on that income. Certain property-related expenses, like repairs and municipal charges, may be deductible. 4. Interest Interest from South African sources is generally exempt from normal tax unless the non-resident was in the country for over 183 days or has a debt tied to a local entity. However, withholding tax of 15% may apply. 5. Dividends Dividends paid by South African companies are subject to a 20% dividend withholding tax, which may be reduced under applicable DTAs. 6. Royalties Royalties are taxed at 15% withholding, but this may be replaced by normal tax if residency thresholds are met. 7. Capital Gains Tax (CGT) Non-residents are only subject to CGT on: Immovable property (homes, land, farms, etc.) Shares or trust interests linked to South African property Assets of a permanent establishment in the country SARS acknowledged the potential for double taxation, where income is taxed in both South Africa and the taxpayer's country of residence. To mitigate this, DTAs are in place with many countries to determine tax jurisdiction and reduce duplication. These agreements can exempt or reduce taxes on salaries, pensions, dividends, interest, and royalties, depending on the circumstances and treaty provisions. SARS Commissioner Edward Kieswetter urged all non-resident taxpayers to ensure their information is up to date on eFiling and to make use of the SOQS until the full functionality is integrated into the main return platform. Further information, including conditions for estate duties and taxes on foreign entertainers and sportspersons, can be found on the SARS official website: Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.

The Star
18 hours ago
- The Star
SARS introduces new enhancements for non-resident taxpayers in 2025 tax return process
The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has moved to make things easier for non-resident taxpayers earning income from South African sources by introducing new enhancements to the 2025 tax return process . These changes include updates to the ITR12 tax return form to help ensure non-residents complete the correct sections and submit accurate returns. "These enhancements aim to ensure that non-residents complete the correct required fields in the return. An interim solution to activate this part of the tax return has been introduced via the SARS Online Query System (SOQS)," SARS said. "This allows non-resident taxpayers to request the non-resident section of the tax return. A more permanent solution, directly on the tax return through the tax return 'wizard', will be introduced later. To use SOQS to enable the non-resident section of the tax return: On the SARS website homepage, click on the SOQS icon , and navigate to the ' Non-Resident Tax Return Type '. Complete the personal details as prompted. Once SARS has validated the information, a One-Time Pin (OTP) will be sent to the contact details on record. Choose the 2025 tax year and answer yes or no to the questions that will follow. Depending on your answers, your tax return will now be in the correct format and can be retrieved through eFiling in the normal way. According to the revenue service, the "taxpayer's information will be stored and used in the subsequent year of assessment unless the taxpayer's circumstances have changed subsequently".