HMRC bills workers for tax it abolished last year
Class 2 National Insurance (NI) contributions were effectively scrapped for self-employed people in April 2024. However, workers have reported that HMRC is still adding the levy of £179.40 to their tax bill despite now being exempt. Some have been told to pay twice this amount – £358.80.
Experts said it was 'ridiculous' that HMRC was getting self-employed NI calculations wrong when it was quick to fine workers for errors navigating the 'complex' tax system.
A source told The Telegraph there were indications the problem was 'very widespread'. HMRC said it was 'working urgently' to resolve the issue.
The reason for the error is unknown, but the problem is understood to have arisen as a result of the changes announced in the autumn 2023 Budget that came into effect for the 2024-25 tax year.
The rule change means self-employed workers now receive a credit for Class 2 NI, which boosts entitlement to 'contributory' benefits such as the state pension, as long as their profits are above £6,725.
As a result, they do not need to pay Class 2 NI, but can still use the credit to improve their entitlements.
Anyone with profits below £6,725 can opt to pay the tax voluntarily at a rate of £3.45 per week, adding up to £179.40 a year.
The Association of Taxation Technicians (ATT), a professional body for the tax compliance industry, said its members had reported receiving one of three letters containing errors from HMRC.
The first said the Class 2 NI tax sum had been 'amended' to zero, which made the letter unnecessary. The second wrongly demanded £179.40 in tax, while the third demanded twice this amount.
Michelle Denny-West, a tax partner with accountancy firm Moore Kingston Smith, said: 'The National Insurance Contribution (NIC) system for self-employed individuals has always been confusing, but the fact that HMRC cannot get this right is ridiculous.
'It's frustrating that taxpayers are expected to navigate such a complex tax system and can be charged penalties and interest for mistakes – yet they are now also expected to correct HMRC's mistakes.
'The risk here is that some individuals will unwittingly pay the additional NICs without realising it's a bill they should not be paying.'
Helen Thornley, of the ATT, said: 'Our members have reported a number of problems with national insurance calculations for 2024-25. Most self-employed individuals are not required to pay Class 2 contributions following changes announced at last year's Budget.
'However, many have received letters from HMRC which have added charges of almost £180 in Class 2, and in some instances double that amount.
'We have reported all examples to HMRC, who have assured us that this is being investigated 'as a matter of urgency'.
'However, it is still not clear what the reason behind the issue is. In the meantime, anyone affected should contact HMRC to ask for a resolution.'
An HMRC spokesman said: 'We apologise to those affected and we're working urgently to resolve this issue.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
an hour ago
- Bloomberg
Gabbard Unveils Plan to Slash Top Spy Agency by 40% This Year
Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard announced plans to shrink her agency by 40% by the end of the year in what she called an effort to make the office more efficient, even as she clashes with the national security community she leads. The overhaul would save taxpayers $700 million per year by eliminating 'redundant missions, functions and personnel' at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Gabbard said in a statement. The ODNI oversees the US's 18 intelligence agencies.
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
As Michigan lawmakers miss budget deadlines, Gov. Whitmer takes education funding message to schools
For weeks, Michigan lawmakers have blown past deadline after deadline to pass a new budget, while the state is on the brink of a government shutdown. One point of contention is education funding. Gov. Gretchen Whitmer spoke on the issue Wednesday as she toured a home-based preschool in Romulus to tout the benefits of her administration's Pre-K for All program. "We've gotten the job done, no matter who's there. Going into this year this late, I am concerned about it," Whitmer said. "We know that the investments that we make in the first three to five years of a child's life pay dividends over the course of their lifetime, they'll earn more, they will have a healthier life," said Whitmer. Taking a closer look at the last budget, the $23.4 billion education budget the governor signed into effect last July included enough money to enroll nearly 60,000 children into the state's Great Start Readiness Program. While she has seen progress, Whitmer says the budget delays could threaten that work. "We've made headway on all of those fronts, but we're not at 100% and there's always going to be more good work to do," said Whitmer. Whitmer spent part of the morning reading stories to some of the pupils of Beyond the Bell Preschool. "We're just a family where we actually educate children and teach the whole child where they are," Michelle Cook, director of Beyond the Bell, said. Cook started the at-home daycare program after working in her local school district. "I finally decided that I didn't want to be in the school district anymore because I wanted to be more personable. I wanted to know about my parents. I wanted to help my parents more than just the classroom," Cook said. Alondrianna Burns' daughter, Riley, has been attending daily for more than two years. Burns, a single mother, says the rising costs of daycare pushed her to find an affordable option that didn't sacrifice on quality. "It's like more one-on-one care, not a lot of children-to-teacher ratio, and it's a very good communication balance," said Burns. Burns hopes lawmakers understand the benefits of early childhood education and the difference it has made in the lives of families like hers. "We need it to strive. We're trying to just work, and we just need a little help. We're not trying to live off the state. We just need assistance," said Burns. With the new fiscal year starting on Oct. 1, Whitmer says the budget needs to be on her desk at least two weeks before to make sure everything runs on schedule.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
I'm a Financial Advisor: How You Can Stop Living Paycheck-to-Paycheck
According to a 2023 survey published by Forbes, roughly 78% of Americans' budget is paycheck to paycheck. When Forbes Advisor dug into its own research, it found that 'nearly 70% of respondents either identified as living paycheck to paycheck (40%) or–even more concerning–reported that their income doesn't even cover their standard expenses (29%).' While these numbers are concerning, they don't fully articulate the fear of living inside that reality. Wondering if one accident or illness might lead you into financial catastrophe, or if you'll never get out of the cycle of playing Tetris with your bank account to make sure you can afford everyday expenses. Discover More: Find Out: Getting out of the cycle of living paycheck to paycheck is crucial to your long-term financial quality of life. But starting the process may seem insurmountable for people who have been in it for most of their working lives. Fortunately, GOBankingRates has insights from financial experts who can help you break the cycle. Understand Where Your Money's Going When you feel the pressure of keeping the lights on and the bills paid, you might not even know where all your money goes every month. You just know it's going out of your account. However, sitting down with your bills to determine how much you're spending, and on which services, every month, can give you the knowledge you need to save more effectively. Trending Now: 'You can't manage what you can't measure, so the first thing you need to do is figure out exactly where your money is going,' said Taylor Kovar, CFP, the founder and CEO of 11 Financial and CEO of The Money Couple. 'Once you have an idea of what money you have coming in each month and where it is going out to, then you can start chipping away at various expenses.'Kovar shared that even small actions, like calling your phone provider to see if they have available discounts, cutting out unnecessary subscriptions and investigating cheaper gas and electric providers make a big impact. He said people need to find any way possible to create a margin in their budget. By adding an extra $5, $10, or $100 a week to your budget, you can eventually save enough to keep the equivalent of a full paycheck in savings. Create a Budget It's easy to be overwhelmed by the pressures of keeping afloat when you feel like your financial life raft has sprung a leak. But to reach calmer waters in your money matters, take the time – and a deep breath – and create a budget. According to Tyler Meyer, CFP and founder of the budget doesn't have to be mind-bendingly complex. You can start by tracking expenses and determining a realistic approach to spending. 'Differentiate between needs and wants, and allocate funds accordingly,' he said. 'This helps prioritize essential expenses while identifying areas where spending can be reduced or eliminated.' Reduce Your Debt When you're trying to keep a roof over your head, the thought of paying down debt might seem, well, laughable. But Meyer said that reducing debt is a key part of enjoying financial freedom – and you don't have to tackle everything all at once. 'Develop a strategy to tackle existing debt systematically. Start by paying off high-interest debt first while making minimum payments on other accounts,' he said. 'Consider consolidating debt or negotiating with creditors for lower interest rates or repayment plans.' Create an Emergency Fund One of the most important things you can do to evolve beyond living paycheck to paycheck is to build up your emergency fund. 'Aim to save at least three to six months' worth of living expenses in a readily accessible account,' said Meyer. 'This fund provides a financial safety net for unexpected expenses or emergencies, reducing reliance on credit cards or loans.' Live Below Your Means Frugality is the name of the game when it comes to living beyond one's paycheck. 'Adopting a frugal lifestyle and living below your means is key to breaking the paycheck-to-paycheck cycle,' said Meyer. 'Cut unnecessary expenses, seek out affordable alternatives, and resist the temptation to overspend. Redirect savings toward debt repayment, emergency savings, and long-term financial goals.' More From GOBankingRates 5 Ways Trump Signing the GENIUS Act Could Impact Retirees10 Unreliable SUVs To Stay Away From Buying This article originally appeared on I'm a Financial Advisor: How You Can Stop Living Paycheck-to-Paycheck Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
