49ers injury designations give disgruntled WR more leverage in contract talks
Ricky Pearsall and Brandon Aiyuk both went on the PUP list as they recover from injuries ahead of training camp. Aiyuk starting camp on PUP isn't a surprise. He tore his ACL and MCL, and took additional damage in his knee in Week 7 last season. It doesn't sound like the club is eager to rush him back, so a training camp return isn't likely.
Pearsall landing on PUP changes the dynamic of the 49ers WR room and gives Jennings additional leverage as he seeks a contract extension with San Francisco.
We've already explored the 49ers' shaky WR depth and how there's a strong chance Jennings could land in the WR1 role like he did last season when he led the team's WRs with a career-best 975 yards. A potential holdup for the 49ers in dishing out a more lucrative contract to the 2020 seventh-round pick is what his role looks like in the future. Paying him as a WR1 or WR2 isn't something they were banking on after giving Aiyuk a massive extension last offseason and drafting Pearsall in the first round of last year's draft.
There were question marks about Pearsall's ability to stay healthy after he missed virtually all of last year's camp with hamstring and shoulder injuries. Those question marks resurfaced again in OTAs this year when Pearsall sat out because of a hamstring injury. Head coach Kyle Shanahan indicated during OTAs that Pearsall's absence was cautionary and that he'd be ready for training camp.
That Pearsall is on PUP to start camp is a significant red flag for the second-year WR. It also puts the top of the 49ers WR depth chart into more flux. Jennings' claim to a new contract hinges on the stability he brings to a group clouded by uncertainty. He's been on the 49ers' active roster for four seasons and has played in 60 games. In 2023 he missed four total games, but outside of that he's never missed more than two in a season.
It appears going into camp this year that Jennings will be the 49ers' WR1 by a significant margin. Even if Pearsall returns and has a strong preseason, his injury questions will linger and there's still no certainty around Aiyuk for this season and beyond.
The 49ers may have been able to justify not extending Jennings if they could stand behind Pearsall as WR1 and Aiyuk as an eventual WR2 this season. That becomes much more difficult to do with Pearsall out to begin camp. There's a significant risk in potentially losing or rocking the boat with Jennings and sending the 49ers' WR corps into a tailspin that derails their offense into 2025. That dramatically outweighs the risk of financial complications with a new contract for Jennings.
If the answer wasn't clear for San Francisco before, the PUP list designations should help.
More 49ers: 49ers need huge year from their non-QB MVP if they're going to return to playoffs in 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
8 minutes ago
- New York Times
Trent Williams navigates going out on top, while guiding a young 49ers tackle behind him
SANTA CLARA, Calif. — Trent Williams, the best left tackle in the NFL, turned 37 last month and has talked this training camp about trying to gauge where the cliff is. He doesn't see it — the potential fall-off and end of his career — but most players in the NFL never do, as the cliff not only moves but sometimes teams just flat chuck you over it without warning. Advertisement Williams is in great shape, and he goes against former Defensive Player of the Year Nick Bosa every day at 49ers practice, which gives him a good measuring stick. 'He can play as long as he wants — there is no drop-off,' offensive line coach Chris Foerster said Sunday. 'And that's something I haven't seen with a guy who is 37 in all my years of coaching.' Williams is also busy pulling teammates like backup tackle Spencer Burford up the mountain, which helps keep the veteran young at heart and in mind. Burford was drafted out of Texas-San Antonio by the 49ers in the fourth round in 2022 and mentioned right after how excited he was to play with Williams. Williams reached out his hand the first time he met his fellow native Texan. 'Obviously, we clicked,' Williams said Friday. 'He's like a little brother to me now. I love him to death.' (The two actually share a birthday on July 19, which is great for Burford, as Williams owns his own jet and likes to spoil himself. 'He goes big,' Burford said, smiling, 'and I get to hang out in the background sometimes too.') Burford said that Williams 'guides me in the right direction, on and off the field,' but working out with the veteran in the offseason did take some getting used to. 'It's like working out with a coach,' Burford said. 'A lot of guys, when they approach you to work out, it's just to get it done, it's something that they have to do. But with Trent, he loves it — it's a lot more details, a lot more focus and a lot more attention. Everything you do is intentional — whether it's 16 steps this way, 16 steps that way, how you eat, how you sleep.' The two have been working out together in Houston in the offseason, and this summer, both Williams and Foerster think something really clicked. The 6-foot-4, 300-pound Burford has returned to tackle — where he played in college — after starting 29 games at guard his first two seasons with the 49ers. Advertisement Williams holds a camp for young offensive linemen at his gym in Houston, and Burford showed up weeks earlier than usual. 'He was just there working out with my trainer and stuff, just from the jump,' Williams said. 'As soon as the offseason kicked off, he was in there grinding.' And it's paid off at training camp so far. 'You can see a noticeable change in his body — he put on more muscle and you can tell he worked on his explosiveness,' Williams said. 'He worked his butt off and you can just tell, he's got a step.' Burford said, 'when a future Hall of Famer shows you the road, it's hard not to follow.' Foerster has coached Williams for four years after he was drafted in Washington and then the last three in San Francisco, and has really enjoyed watching the veteran help guide Burford. 'I think it's been great,' Foerster said. 'Trent's good with all the guys. He likes coaching and he likes mentoring, and it's a cool dynamic to watch with Spence. As much as I can coach a player, to have Trent come behind — or before, they're gonna listen. Sometimes it's exactly what I'd say. Sometimes it's a little bit different, but it does help.' As for Burford, Foerster said he's 'weathered the storm well' after some early-career struggles, 'and he's come out the other end a lot more mature.' Burford said that he had to learn that you can't copy everything that Williams does. The 6-foot-5, 320-pound 11-time Pro Bowler has uncanny strength and agility and has some violent run-blocking techniques that are also unique. 'There's things that he can do that people can't replicate,' Burford said. Williams smiled when he heard that. 'I beg to differ,' he said. 'I mean, I think he possesses the athleticism in his body. He has the foot movement. He has a great strike. He moved to tackle this camp and you can see it, man. He's playing in space and everyday he's taking a stride.' Advertisement Now that Burford has moved over from guard, he can watch what Williams does in drills and try to immediately duplicate it. Williams, meanwhile, has discovered that he has a passion for coaching. 'I always felt like offensive line was kind of an underserved position,' he said. 'There are 32 teams in the NFL and I think there are probably only four or five great O-line coaches. I always felt like this position was kind of slower evolving than all the rest … so that became my thing, giving back to the game I love by working with players.' It's that added element to his playing career that may help Williams keep putting the pads on until he is 40. Because it's the offseason workouts and meetings that get to most players in their mid- to late thirties. 'How many more meetings can you sit in after 15 years of hearing the same play put in, and most of that is from my voice,' Foerster said. 'It's mind-numbing sometimes. Now, when it gets to the season, the players start competing every week. That's not the problem … 'As Trent said to me one day, 'You know, when I'm out here on this field, I play forever.' It's all the other things that lead to getting out on that field, which eventually chase guys out.' Spot the pattern. Connect the terms Find the hidden link between sports terms Play today's puzzle
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
49ers' Brandon Aiyuk joins Ricky Pearsall, 4 teammates on PUP list
The post 49ers' Brandon Aiyuk joins Ricky Pearsall, 4 teammates on PUP list appeared first on ClutchPoints. Fans hoping for a quick injury recovery from Brandon Aiyuk may have to temper their expectations. With training camp roughly one week away, the San Francisco 49ers placed Aiyuk, Ricky Pearsall and four others on their Physically Unable to Perform injury list. The 49ers also placed Malik Mustapha, Yetur Gross-Matos, Andre Dillard and Curtis Robinson on the PUP list, they announced on Friday. Aiyuk and Pearsall were placed on the list as they continue their respective recoveries from injury. Both Aiyuk and Pearsall had their 2024 seasons cut short by injuries. Aiyuk tore his ACL and MCL against the Kansas City Chiefs in Week 7, which he is still recovering from. Pearsall was notably shot in the chest during the preseason, delaying his debut. However, Pearsall is currently on the PUP list due to a hamstring injury he obtained during offseason workouts. After missing OTAs and minicamp with their respective injuries, Aiyuk and Pearsall will now miss training camp. Pearsall was initially expected to be back by training camp, but it seems to have suffered a setback. Conversely, Aiyuk remains without a timetable and appears slated to miss the beginning of the 2025 season. 49ers' injuries drag rocky offseason into training camp The 49ers' rough offseason continues with Brandon Aiyuk and Ricky Pearsall sidelined. San Francisco entered the summer with multiple contract dilemmas on hand and continues to be plagued by the injury bug. Following lengthy negotiation processes, the 49ers were able to extend Brock Purdy and George Kittle. They did so after trading Deebo Samuel to the Washington Commanders and re-negotiating Kyle Juszczyk's deal. While all three situations were eventually handled, none were done in a way the front office likely imagined. Coming off a disappointing 2024 season, the 49ers desperately need to rebound in 2025. San Francisco has still won the NFC West in two of the last three seasons but faces an interesting crossroads, with most of its star players beginning to age out of their physical primes. Related: 49ers' $10.3 million move expected to have ripple effect across NFL Related: 49ers place rookie on active non-football injury list
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
49ers make pair of WR moves
The post 49ers make pair of WR moves appeared first on ClutchPoints. The San Francisco 49ers already feature a changed wide receiver room for 2025. Now they're bringing in a past 1,000-yard performer while releasing another WR. Per ESPN NFL insider Adam Schefter Sunday, the franchise have brought in Robbie Chosen. The veteran WR worked through drills on Saturday. He even fired off the signal that he would soon join S.F. Chosen shared via X (formerly Twitter) that his workout went great with the Niners. Now that he's on board, S.F. released Marquez Callaway to clear room for Chosen. Callaway previously spent four seasons with the New Orleans Saints from 2020 to 2023. Including delivering a six-touchdown campaign in his second NFL season. He last played for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2024. But he hasn't caught a pass since the 2022 season. State of 49ers WR room ahead of 2025 Chosen comes in during a critical time for the franchise. Jauan Jennings is facing a concerning injury during NFL Training Camp. He's still dealing with his calf injury from minicamp. And general manager John Lynch still has Jennings' contract situation to sort through. Jennings demanded a trade if a deal isn't done by the 49ers' front office. Jennings is fresh off a career-best campaign that nearly saw him eclipse 1,000 yards for the first time in his career. But there's more beyond Jennings' situation in the WR room. Deebo Samuel landed with the Washington Commanders via trade. His departure opens up a new versatile weapon to emerge for Kyle Shanahan and his offense. Brandon Aiyuk is another absent. Aiyuk landed on the PUP (physically unable to perform) list. His absence has created a thin WR room in the Bay Area. Last year's first rounder Ricky Pearsall is another on PUP. Ex-Los Angeles Rams and Kansas City Chiefs WR Demarcus Robinson is getting acclimated with the 49ers. Now Chosen joins in to boost the veteran side for this unit. Related: 49ers' perfect Micah Parsons trade proposal Related: 49ers legend Steve Young, Giants legend Barry Bonds join Morgan Wallen for epic concert walk-out
