Police Scotland ‘not recording ethnicity correctly' on DNA database
Former Chief Constable Sir Iain Livingstone said Police Scotland 'is institutionally racist and discriminatory', months before retiring in August 2023.
However the Scottish Biometrics Commissioner, Dr Brian Plastow, called on Police Scotland and the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) to review procedures for recording ethnicity when it collects DNA or other biometric data following arrest – and issued a report saying failure to do so correctly was 'concerning'.
Less than 1,000 crimes a year in Scotland are solved using DNA – typically murders, assaults and sex offences – and Police Scotland was told to develop a biometrics strategy including cost, to be approved and in place before October 31.
Biometric data includes DNA and fingerprints, and publicly available information on the UK's National DNA Database allows scrutiny to see if any ethnic group is over-represented – with black citizens accounting for 7.5%, despite being 4% of the UK population according to the 2021/22 census.
The 2022 Scottish census noted that 1.3% of the population is of black heritage – however, no details about ethnicity are recorded on the Scottish DNA Database (SDNAD), which is almost 30 years old, meaning experts were unable to establish if there was over-representation.
A decade after a £6 million investment in world-class DNA technology in the Scottish Crime Campus in Gartcosh, North Lanarkshire, the benefits 'have not been fully realised', and 70% of the profiles are of a lower scientific standard due to a failure to re-test offenders, the report warned.
Properly recording data would support Police Scotland's equality duties and help maintain public confidence, amid allegations of 'institutional racism', supported by Chief Constable Jo Farrell, it was said.
Dr Plastow said: 'SPA Forensic Services and Police Scotland were unable to provide us with any reliable management information on the ethnicity of anyone held within SDNAD as the database is nearly 30 years old and not designed to record this information.
'Failing to properly record and publish data on ethnicity of arrested people whose biometric data is held is concerning, against the context of the former and current chief constables having stated that institutional racism persists.
'We have been unable to establish whether there is over-representation on grounds of ethnicity or any protected characteristic.'
As an alternative, Police Scotland were asked to provide ethnicity data from its National Custody System, for arrests from 2023 to 2024 where DNA was taken. However, this mandatory information was 'incomplete' and 'unreliable', Dr Plastow said.
He added: 'The data extract obtained by Police Scotland was incomplete and so heavily caveated to render it unreliable.'
Seven recommendations were made after a joint review with the SPA and the Leverhulme Institute of Forensic Science, on the acquisition, retention, use and destruction of DNA.
Dr Plastow said: 'DNA provided a potential investigative lead in only 0.34% of recorded crime in Scotland in 2023 to 2024, but those investigative leads can be spectacular.'
The report highlighted that where a criminal has been re-arrested, no fresh DNA sample is routinely taken if a lower standard DNA profile was recorded predating 2014 – despite investment that year which gave Police Scotland access to the most advanced DNA analysis facilities available internationally.
In 2014, after the establishment of Police Scotland and the SPA, the Scottish Government spent £6 million on the new DNA testing facility, but a decision not to re-test samples predating 2014, means less than a third of offenders' profiles are currently of the newer DNA24 standard, it was warned.
Dr Plastow said: 'When the new facility opened there were more than 250,000 samples A decision was taken on the grounds of cost and laboratory capacity not to do any bulk back record conversion, as it would have cost more than £10 million.
'More than 10 years after the introduction of DNA24, 69.9% of profiles held are still of a lower scientific standard.'
Police Scotland was urged to review its DNA Confirmed policy to increase DNA24 profiles, for more effective investigations, and to develop a biometrics strategy including capital expenditure before October 31.
Dr Plastow said: 'Holding DNA24 profiles would lead to more effective and efficient investigations and eliminate innocent suspects more quickly.
'Without such a plan, there is no clear vision of what Police Scotland hopes to achieve with DNA, fingerprints, facial images, or other biometric enabled technologies including retrospective facial search.'
Police Scotland and the SPA have been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
Body found in search for man missing in River Tay
A body has been found following searches for a man who went missing in the River Tay at Perth. Emergency services had launched the search for a 27-year-old who went missing near Moncreiffe Island at about 7.45pm on Thursday. Three men had got into difficulty in the water, with two being traced and checked by paramedics. Police Scotland said on Friday a body had been found and enquiries are ongoing to establish the identity. Emergency services remain in attendance.
Boston Globe
20 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Nicholas Alahverdian wanted to be ‘relevant.' Now he's a convicted rapist.
This is a tragic understatement, but it turns out Alahverdian – who has also gone by Nicholas Rossi and then Arthur Knight when he was on the lam in Scotland – had a much more sinister history than any of the reporters he called incessantly over the years ever realized. Advertisement It has to be a relief for at least one of his victims that Alahverdian is going to serve a substantial prison sentence – potentially for the rest of his life. But it's difficult to avoid looking in the mirror and wondering about the role of Rhode Island's media in amplifying his claims and looking the other way when seemingly obvious red flags emerged. Get Rhode Island News Alerts Sign up to get breaking news and interesting stories from Rhode Island in your inbox each weekday. Enter Email Sign Up If you don't know Alahverdian's story, it's every bit worthy of a movie script. That's why there have been multiple The short version: He was an advocate for reforming the child welfare system in Rhode Island, and led a secret life as a criminal who conned multiple people out of money. And, it turns out, he was a rapist. He was finally caught when he landed in a Scottish hospital with COVID-19 while living under an alias, and was extradited to Utah, where he was wanted for rape. Advertisement Alahverdian popped on my radar in 2010 when I was a young reporter; in fact, I was still bartending to make ends meet at the time, and we met when he brought a date to Gregg's in Providence, where I was working. No one disputes that Alahverdian had a rough upbringing – a dysfunctional family life that led to even more dysfunctional stints in foster care, which ultimately led him to sue the state of Rhode Island. Along the way, he became obsessed with local politics, became a State House intern, and became a fierce advocate for reforming the Department of Children, Youth, and Families. I found him to be polished, intense, and strangely needy for someone in his early 20s. But he had the vibe of a poser in a middle school cafeteria – the type who laughed a little too loudly at jokes, sucked up to the cool kids, and just wanted to be accepted as 'relevant' – that was a word he enjoyed using. Sometime in 2011, I remember having a drink at Local 121, a popular politico bar in Providence that no longer exists. The room was filled with current and former elected officials, operatives, and journalists, and Alahverdian was there working the room. He wasn't exactly part of the group, but he wasn't exactly unwelcome, either. No one was eager to be his friend, but no one minded that he was there. It was like he was trying to will himself into the picture, even if he didn't quite fit the frame. Advertisement He latched onto reporters like me because he thought we could make him more relevant – and many of us took the bait. I've always taken some pride in not writing about him or his terrifying stories of abuse while in state care, but I can't really attribute those decisions to impeccable instincts. I liked exclusive stories, and he was a fixture on the 6 p.m. news. I did, however, pick up the phone when he called, and he called a lot… for years. I can't speak for every reporter who covered him, but I don't think they simply fell for his ruse. He had a story to tell: It mostly checked out, and busy journalists found him to be highly quotable and always available. Still, there were warning signs. A quick background check on Alahverdian showed he had legal problems in the past, although the details were vague. He had spent some time in both Ohio and Utah, but didn't talk much about those experiences. It turns out he was a registered sex offender, based on an incident at a community college in Ohio. He also had a stint as a student at Harvard's extension school, but he spoke about attending Harvard as though he was an undergraduate. I remember asking another journalist in town about Alahverdian's criminal record, and they were more sympathetic. Anyone who experienced what he did as a child could fall off track as an adult, the reporter reasoned. Besides, it didn't make his story any less true. What we didn't know at the time was that a rape kit from 2008 was sitting on a shelf in Utah waiting to be tested. By the time it was, Alahverdian was mostly out of sight and out of mind in Rhode Island. Advertisement It's unclear exactly when he landed in Scotland, but law enforcement now believes that was an effort to evade rape charges in Utah, and a federal fraud investigation out of Ohio. It had been at least a year since I had heard from Alahverdian when I received a press release on Jan. 10, 2020, claiming that he was diagnosed with late-stage non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. I remember feeling bad for him, but also thinking, very cynically, that at least I wouldn't have to answer his phone calls anymore. Of course, I was wrong about that, because I ended up having to talk with a woman named She was irate that the Globe wouldn't run Alahverdian's obituary. We actually initially published an Associated Press story on his death, but I asked for it to be taken down because something didn't seem right. I had no reason to believe he was a criminal in hiding, but I wouldn't put it past him to fake his own death and seek attention from local journalists – and all the details were coming from an unknown person. Law enforcement officials now believe Alahverdian was seeking to use all the attention he got for his death to throw them off his scent. In the end, Alahverdian's story fell apart. He has since admitted that he faked his own death, although he claimed he was hiding out because of threats made against him in Rhode Island – none of which appear to be true. Advertisement For years, Alahverdian fought to control his own narrative – to make himself matter, to keep himself in the headlines, to make sure he was the one telling the story. But in that Utah courtroom this week, none of the spin, aliases, or theatrics mattered. The jury didn't see an advocate or a victim. They saw a rapist. He once told me he just wanted to be 'relevant.' Now he is, for all the worst reasons – and in a way he'll never be able to rewrite. Dan McGowan can be reached at
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
Man accused of faking his death to evade charges found guilty of rape in Utah
A Rhode Island conman accused of faking his death and fleeing the United States to avoid rape and sexual assault allegations has been convicted of felony rape in the first of two criminal cases against him in Utah, prosecutors said. A jury in Salt Lake County found Nicholas Alahverdian, 38, guilty of the first-degree rape of a 26-year-old Salt Lake County woman in 2008, according to the Salt Lake County District Attorney's Office. The jury reached the guilty verdict on Wednesday, Aug. 13, following a three-day trial. 'We are grateful to the survivor in this case for her willingness to come forward, years after this attack took place," Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill said in a statement. "We appreciate her patience as we worked to bring the defendant back to Salt Lake County so that this trial could take place and she could get justice. It took courage and bravery to take the stand and confront her attacker to hold him accountable." Alahverdian's conviction stems from charges that he raped his then-girlfriend, a woman whom he had met online, according to prosecutors. Shortly after the two began dating, prosecutors said Alahverdian told the woman they should get married and they purchased wedding rings. But Alahverdian soon became verbally and emotionally abusive, prosecutors said. An argument at a shopping mall turned violent, and when the couple returned to Alahverdian's apartment, he refused to let her leave and then raped her, according to prosecutors. The charge is punishable by five years to life in the Utah State Correctional Facility, according to the Salt Lake County District Attorney's Office. He is scheduled to be sentenced on Oct. 20. Alahverdian, who was charged under his former surname Rossi, also faces additional rape charges involving a different woman in Utah in 2008. He has yet to go to trial on those charges. What to know. Nicholas Alahverdian extradited to US four years after faking his death. Nicholas Alahverdian extradited to U.S. in 2024 Alahverdian has been held without bail in a Utah county jail since January 2024, when authorities extradited him from Scotland. He had spent three years in Scotland pretending to be "Arthur Knight," a former Irish orphan and victim of misidentification, in an outlandish pretense that played out before international media and an extradition court. A Scottish judge, who had tolerated Alahverdian's charade during hearings on his identity, cleared the way for Alahverdian's return to the United States − concluding that he 'is as dishonest and deceitful as he is evasive and manipulative.' Alahverdian finally gave up his hoax in November 2024 while asking a Utah District Court judge for bail. During the hearing, he alleged that his years of deception and name changes were part of an effort to protect himself from 'death threats' and not because he was evading authorities. Prosecutors argued that Alahverdian, who uses oxygen and a wheelchair, remained a flight risk despite his physical condition. The judge denied bail, noting that Alahverdian's English wife was still providing him money 'that could assist him in potential flight." UK court could help decide: Is he a Utah rape suspect named Nick or an Englishman named Knight? Why did Nicholas Alahverdian fake his own death? Alahverdian, who grew up in foster care and later became a critic of Rhode Island's child welfare system, has alleged that he received death threats from unnamed state politicians for his advocacy work for children in state care a decade earlier. In 2017, he took a one-way fight to Ireland to escape those alleged threats and to pursue public relations work before he eventually made his way to Scotland. Prosecutors said Alahverdian tried to fake his own death and fled the United States to avoid being located. By 2019, Alahverdian was attempting to get his name removed from a registered sex offenders list, which requires offenders to keep police informed on their current address. During that time, the FBI also began investigating Alahverdian for credit card fraud after his former foster father told authorities that Alahverdian had spent $200,000 on cards taken out using his foster father's name and financial records. In January 2020, Alahverdian started to spread the word to Rhode Island media outlets that he had late-stage non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. The following month, a woman who described herself as Alahverdian's wife and a foundation under his name notified reporters that he had died. Then in September 2020, Utah County authorities issued an arrest warrant for Nicholas Rossi, which is the last name of his stepfather. Investigators later tracked him to Scotland after searching his iCloud account and bank records, and he was arrested at a hospital in December 2021 after waking up from a coma caused by COVID. Alahverdian, who has used several different aliases, has appealed in recent weeks to the judge in his Salt Lake County case that he now be charged under his birth name, Alahverdian. The judge has denied the request. What is Alahverdian accused of in Utah? Alahverdian was previously convicted of groping a woman at an Ohio community college in 2008, according to authorities. He then attempted to sue the woman for libel and had his appeal request tossed when his key piece of supposedly new evidence was ruled a fake blog post. Investigators said DNA from that case connected Alahverdian to the rape of a 21-year-old woman in Orem, Utah, in September 2008. The trial this week, which began on Aug. 11, stems from allegations that he raped his former girlfriend in November 2008. No DNA evidence tied him to that incident, investigators have said, but she came forward after recognizing Alahverdian during his international extradition case. As in the Orem case, authorities say Alahverdian met the Salt Lake City woman online. They dated briefly before the relationship quickly sped up and they bought wedding rings. But after a violent argument at a shopping mall − Alahverdian threatened to call the police and report that she had hit him if she didn't let him back in her car − the two returned to his apartment, where he raped her, police said. Nicholas Alahverdian case: American who faked his own death could return to US after bizarre trial ends in Scotland
