Sydney's huge Gaza protest shows there's now no stopping the tide of public opinion
Why aren't they listening? How is this horror continuing unabated with impunity? Why won't Australia impose sanctions and call for arms embargos against Israel's senseless murder of civilians, unleashed by some of the most methodical and lethal autonomous weaponry on Earth and AI machines directing bombs, as claimed by intelligence sources?
As doctors, aid workers and social media feeds document the livestreamed ruins of cities, we watch the killing of children, people killed in tents while sleeping, starving people fired upon and killed at aid stations, forced by their hunger to play Russian roulette with their lives.
Sixty thousand human souls, around half of them women and children, dead and tens of thousands more maimed, injured without mercy or relief. Twenty one months of a nightmare for Palestinians that beggars belief.
A year of protests on Sundays at Hyde Park fountain feels like secular church to me, group therapy where I meet with my Readers Against Genocide group, listen to Palestinian leaders and collectively bang pots, grieve and wonder why some weeks the protests feel smaller than others. We lament colleagues doxed, fired, threatened, stripped of funding, forced to resign.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
As Israel breaks new records in the number of journalists killed –at least 225 Palestinian journalist witness bearers, according to the Palestinian Journalists Syndicate – we try to brace ourselves against a growing climate of fear and intimidation prevailing in Australian arts, media and academia, where Orwellian tone policing codes dominate. It's not the killing, but speaking out and protesting against these violations, and the manner it is done, that is absurdly surveilled and seen as a source of harm and violence, and is met with censure and punishment.
Sunday felt different. The whole city turned up, not just students and activists, but middle class grandmothers and parents with prams. What was most striking were the children. Parents with toddlers astride their shoulders, holding little ones gently by the hand as they stood patiently in raincoats in the crowds, or cradling their small sleeping heads on their shoulders, holding signs, all saying the same thing: killing and starving children, children just like ours, is wrong and we do not consent.
We do not consent to New South Wales premier Chris Minns' beefed up protest laws that presaged former Greens candidate Hannah Thomas allegedly being punched in the face, leaving her at one stage at risk of being blinded in one eye. We do not consent to a vast population being killed by starvation and malnourishment as Israel deliberately blocks plentiful supplies of life-saving food and aid.
For the first time in two years, I felt like I was in the majority. It also gave the majority a picture of what these maligned and villainised protests really are: peaceful, powerful, loving declarations of freedom and democracy in action.
As police helicopters buzzed overhead, and police text messages and speaker phones blasted messages that the bridge opening to the north was now blocked and to go back, it felt like a divide was both breached and dissolved. In a city of wealth divided – geographic, cultural and economic – where your postcode can determine your future, it felt like there was no more wealthy, white east, ethnic west, Shire south or privileged north. There was just a collective us.
Emboldened and peaceful crowds kept calm through the confusion, moving with strength and power like a colourful cloud of umbrellas over this harbour city. There was no stopping this tide, and it's a message that our governments, media and arts leaders need to take heed of: they can no longer isolate and censure the dissenting voices in their ranks, because behind them swell millions.
Sarah Malik is a journalist and author of Desi Girl: On Feminism, Race, Faith and Belonging and Safar: Muslim Women's Stories of Travel and Transformation
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Inside Paris's latest migrant camp
Advertisement Families have been seen sleeping on the floor beneath tarpaulin sheets outside the Paris City Hall as they await housing. Nearly 200 migrants, mostly women, children and families, have been gathered on the square in front of the building since August 5 amid a protest organized by the Utopia56 association. The French based humanitarian association claims the move's aim is to find the migrants shelter while condemning the 'increasingly aggressive' expulsions taking place in France since its 2024 Olympic Games. Images from the scenes show migrants with blankets and their belongings in plastic shopping bags as they sit under blue tarpaulin sheets. 'We will not move until a lasting solution is found,' Nathan Lequeux, coordinator of the Utopia56 association's Paris branch, told InfoMigrants . After nights in front of the town hall, wrapped in blankets and sleeping bags on the ground, the migrants, some of whom are legally resident in France, were seen shouting: 'We want housing! Zero children on the streets!' The association has been distributing breakfast to the people who had slept outside the city hall as the numbers of migrants began to increase. While some migrants left for work or for meetings in the capital, nearly 150 people remained in the square on Friday. The number had increased to 230 people on Saturday morning. 'We just finished distributing lunch, the temperatures are beginning to rise, and the most vulnerable people are already starting to suffer,' said Lequeux over the weekend. Among the people present in the square, 'nearly half are children,' he said, with 90 minors present in total. Of the 90 children present, Utopia56 counted 'thirty children under the age of three'. One family - Maria, her husband, and four-month-old daughter had been living on the streets for a month, reported AFP. 'We've had more and more single women in recent months, sometimes between 70 and 90 per evening. Now, it's mostly families,' said Lequeux. 'The numbers fluctuate and depend on how many people are end up on the streets.' There were also 11 unaccompanied minors among the group of migrants on the square, some of whom were young females who had previously been housed by Utopia56. But during the summer, the housing association loses two-thirds of its volunteers resulting in the closing of one of its main shelters, in Bagnolet, on the evening of August 5. 'Half of our solidarity accommodation area is made up of citizen hosts and it's the same thing for volunteers, they are absent and go on vacation. As a result, we lose around 60 accommodation places every night,' Lequeux explained. This lack of accommodation isn't spoken of 'as often in the summer as there are more children on the streets,' Eleonore Schmitt, a coordinator of the Collective of housing associations, told AFP. She also blamed budget cuts. 'The elimination of 6,500 accommodation places for asylum seekers, passed in the 2025 Finance Law, is having an impact on the ground.' A spokesperson for Paris City Hall said that it continues to open 'centers in both summer and winter to shelter people and their families.' 'In total, more than 1,000 people under state care are currently sheltering in converted municipal facilities or gymnasiums, in addition to the care of more than 3,000 people with families,' the city hall added Tuesday evening. It comes after French riot police clashed with migrants and their supporters in March after they cleared a Paris theatre that had been occupied by hundreds of homeless Africans. Violence broke out outside the Gaîté Lyrique – one of the French capital's most historic arts venues – soon after dawn on March 18. Mainly young men had been moving in since last December when the management gave them free tickets to a 'Refugees Welcome in France' conference. Performances were soon cancelled – losing the theatre thousands in revenue – as makeshift beds were placed around the stage and auditorium. By March 18, there were 446 people living inside illegally, most of them claiming they are minors under the age of 18 who deserve permanent housing. CRS (Republican Security Companies) officers armed with tear gas and batons gathered outside the theatre at 5am, and then moved in at 6am.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
‘I risked everything': remembering six media workers killed by Israel in Gaza
Journalists have been prominent among casualties since the war in Gaza was triggered by Hamas's incursion into Israel in October 2023. Some were working for well-known international media, others were employed by local news organisations. Several were high-profile veterans, but many were newcomers to the profession. The Committee to Protect Journalists, an independent non-profit organisation based in the US that promotes press freedom worldwide, says at least 186 journalists and media workers have been killed in Gaza, the West Bank, Israel and Lebanon since the war began, making it the deadliest period for journalists since it began gathering data in 1992. Most have been Palestinians in Gaza, where more than 60,000 people, mostly civilians, have been killed in Israel's continuing offensive. Others put the toll higher. The CPJ accuses Israel of directly targeting and killing 20 journalists and media workers. Any deliberate attack on a civilian could constitute a war crime, experts say. Israel, which has refused to let international media into Gaza, denies the accusation. Anas al-Sharif was killed in a tent for journalists outside al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City on Sunday night. Seven people were killed in the attack, including another Al Jazeera correspondent, Mohammed Qreiqeh and the camera operators Ibrahim Zaher, Mohammed Noufal and Moamen Aliwa, according to the Qatar-based broadcaster. Sharif, 28, is one of the most high-profile media casualties of the war in Gaza so far, reaching huge audiences with his reports for Al Jazeera and with more than 500,000 followers on X. His father was killed by an Israeli strike on the family home in that Jabaliya refugee camp in Gaza City in December 2023. Sharif said at the time that he would continue to report and refused to leave northern Gaza. In a July broadcast he cried on air as woman behind him collapsed from hunger. 'I am taking about slow death of those people,' he said. His final post on X read: 'Relentless bombardment … For two hours, the Israeli aggression has intensified on Gaza City.' He leaves a wife and two young children. The Israeli military, citing 'intelligence and documents from Gaza, including rosters, terrorist training lists and salary records', said Sharif was 'a Hamas operative integrated into Al Jazeera'. Ismail Abu Hatab, 32, was killed in an Israeli airstrike on al-Baqa cafe on the seashore in Gaza City in June, along with 33 other people. The photographer and film-maker, a graduate of Gaza's University College of Applied Sciences, had sustained serious injuries to his leg in a November 2024 attack on his office in the al-Ghifari tower in Gaza City but had made a slow, painful recovery. He had worked for numerous international media organisations, exhibited in the US and Spain, and launched a platform to bring art by Palestinians in Gaza to an international audience. He had also curated an exhibition in Los Angeles which portrayed life in Gaza during the war. 'I have seen so much death. The mass graves and the final farewells, these things affect me deeply,' he told an Indian reporter in October 2024. 'How can one group of people decide the fate of another and kill them in this way?' . The Israeli military said the strike on the cafe had targeted a meeting of Hamas commanders. Fatma Hassouna, 25, a photographer and film-maker, was killed in an Israeli airstrike that hit her home in northern Gaza in April, just months before her wedding. Six members of her family, including her pregnant sister, were also killed. Hassouna, who graduated shortly before the war with a degree in multimedia, had spent 18 months documenting airstrikes, the endless displacement and the killing of 11 family members. Her work was published by the Guardian and other international outlets, and received much attention on social media. 'If I die, I want a loud death,' she had written. 'I don't want to be just breaking news, or a number in a group, I want a death that the world will hear, an impact that will remain through time, and a timeless image that cannot be buried by time or place.' A film made with Hassouna was accepted for screening by the Cannes film festival the day before she was killed. The Israeli military said its attack had targeted a Hamas member involved in attacks on its soldiers and civilians. Hossam Shabat, 23, was killed in March, shortly after Israel definitively ended a two-month ceasefire with a wave of airstrikes. A correspondent for the Al Jazeera Mubasher channel, he died in an airstrike on his car in the ruined northern town of Beit Lahiya as he was conducting interviews. He was also a contributor to the US-based Drop Site News. Friends described an enthusiastic and brave reporter, who 'touched people's pain with his camera and his voice'. The Israeli military said it had 'eliminated [a] terrorist' who had been a Hamas sniper, and cited documents soldiers had found in Gaza as evidence for the accusation. Hours after he was killed, Shabat's team posted a message on X that he had written to be published in the event of his death. 'I documented the horrors in northern Gaza minute by minute … Each day was a battle for survival,' he wrote. 'I fulfilled my duty as a journalist. I risked everything to report the truth, and now, I am finally at rest – something I haven't known in the past 18 months.' Hassan Aslih, 37, was being treated for injuries from a previous Israeli strike when he was killed in drone attack on the emergency department of Nasser hospital in Khan Younis in southern Gaza in May. Israel has accused the photographer, who had a vast following on social media, of taking part in the 7 October 2023 attack. Aslih documented the attack and followed fighters into Israel, taking photographs that were published worldwide. He denied Israel's allegations. Hamza al-Dahdouh, 27, a journalist for Al Jazeera, was killed along with a freelance cameraman working for Agence France-Presse in an Israeli drone strike on their car in southern Gaza in January 2024. The eldest son of the well-known Al Jazeera bureau chief in Gaza, Wael al-Dahdouh, his mother, brother, sister and nephew had been killed in an Israeli airstrike just weeks before. His father described his son as 'kind, generous, ambitious'. The US secretary of state, Antony Blinken, who was in Doha at the time, called the death an 'unimaginable loss'. The Israeli military claimed Dahdouh had been targeted 'as a terrorist operating an aircraft that posed a threat to IDF troops', a reference to a small drone the reporter used to gather footage.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Israel plans to widen coming offensive beyond Gaza City into last areas not under its control
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel plans to widen its coming offensive beyond Gaza City to the last areas not yet under Israeli control, and where most of Gaza's 2 million residents have sought shelter as the territory slides toward famine. The mobilization of forces is expected to take weeks, and Israel may be using the threat of a wider offensive to try to pressure Hamas into releasing more hostages or surrendering after 22 months of war sparked by its Oct. 7, 2023, attack into Israel. Any expansion of Israeli operations is likely to bring even more death and destruction to the war-ravaged territory, around 75% of which is already largely destroyed and controlled by Israel. A wider offensive would also force more people to flee and further disrupt the delivery of humanitarian aid during a severe hunger crisis. The plans have also sparked controversy in Israel. Families of the remaining hostages fear another military escalation could doom their loved ones, while former senior security officials have said there is little to be gained militarily. Netanyahu says Israel will go into the central camps Israel announced last week its plans to take over Gaza City, where it has already carried out major raids and heavy bombardment throughout the war. On Sunday, Netanyahu told a news conference that operations would be expanded into the 'central camps" and beyond. He appeared to be referring to the built-up Nuseirat and Bureij camps in central Gaza that date back to the 1948 war surrounding Israel's creation. Israel has carried out near-daily airstrikes in the camps since the start of the war but no major ground operations. Netanyahu referred to Gaza City, the central camps and Muwasi — a vast cluster of displacement camps along the coast — as Hamas strongholds. These areas, along with the central city of Deir al-Balah, are the only parts of Gaza that have not been almost completely destroyed in previous Israeli operations. They are also areas where Hamas may be holding hostages in tunnels or other secret locations. An Israeli official, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss aspects of the plans that have not been made public, said the operation will not begin immediately and will take a significant amount of time to scale up. One indication will be the potential mobilization of thousands of reservists. The official said the announced plans were partly aimed at putting pressure on various parties. Few places left to flee Netanyahu said Israel will allow civilians to flee to 'designated safe zones,' where 'they will be given ample food, water and medical care, as we have done before.' He did not say where they would go. Israel designated Muwasi as a humanitarian zone earlier in the war. The barren stretch of sandy coastline was soon filled with tents housing hundreds of thousands of people with little in the way of food, running water, toilets or trash collection. Israel has regularly carried out airstrikes against what it said were militants hiding out there, often killing women and children. Last month, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz reportedly floated the idea of transferring Gaza's population to a so-called 'humanitarian city' that the military would build on the ruins of the southernmost city of Rafah — now a largely uninhabited Israeli military zone — on the border with Egypt. Netanyahu has vowed to eventually relocate much of Gaza's population to other countries through what he refers to as voluntary emigration. The Palestinians and much of the international community see it as forcible expulsion because Israel's offensive has made much of Gaza uninhabitable. They fear that concentrating people in the south would be a step toward implementing such plans. A possible negotiating tactic Netanyahu has said he will end the war if Hamas gives up power, lays down its arms and releases the remaining 50 hostages — around 20 of whom are believed by Israel to be alive. Israel would still maintain open-ended security control over Gaza and facilitate the departure of those who wish to leave, according to Netanyahu. He has said Arab forces friendly to Israel would administer the territory, but none are known to have volunteered, aside from an Israeli-backed armed group known for looting aid. Hamas has said, in line with international demands, that it would release the remaining hostages in return for a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. The militant group says it is willing to hand over power to other Palestinians but will not give up its weapons as long as Israel occupies lands the Palestinians want for a future state. Israel may hope that ratcheting up pressure will yield further concessions from Hamas in U.S.- and Arab-mediated talks that appear to have broken down last month. But the hostages are Hamas' only remaining bargaining chip, and it is unlikely to give them up if it believes that Israel will then resume the war, attempt to eradicate the group and carry out plans to depopulate Gaza. Israel ended a previous ceasefire in March that had facilitated the release of 25 hostages and the remains of eight others. Since then, it has imposed a 2 1/2 month blockade that pushed the territory toward famine, launched daily airstrikes across Gaza, expanded its buffer zone and ordered mass evacuations. Hamas has only released one hostage during that time, as a gesture to the United States. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 others in the 2023 attack. More than half of the hostages have been released in ceasefires or other deals. Israel's offensive has killed around 61,500 Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. The ministry, which is part of the Hamas-run government and run by medical professionals, does not say how many of those killed were civilians or combatants, but it says women and children make up around half of the fatalities. The agency's numbers are considered a reliable estimate by the U.N. and independent experts. Israel disputes them but has not offered its own figures. ___ Associated Press Writer Melanie Lidman in Tel Aviv, Israel, contributed to this report. ___
