Irish lawyer quits European rights watchdog after being told Gaza ‘out of our mandate'
Gaza
.
Michael Farrell, who spent 14 years at the
European Commission against Racism and Intolerance
(ECRI), said the body would lose respect on other issues if it did not change course.
'You cannot work in an organisation that is concerned with human rights … and ignore
what is going on in Gaza
... It certainly is a genocide," Mr Farrell, a veteran lawyer and civil rights activist, said.
The ECRI is the independent human rights monitoring body of the Council of Europe, which is distinct from the European Union.
READ MORE
Farrell submitted his resignation last month after the latest plenary meeting in which he says his proposed motion to draft 'a very, very moderate recommendation' for the commission to publish was not approved.
In brief, the draft made the point that 'Israel should stop their attacks, they should allow the food and aid to come in [to Gaza], it should be dealt with by the international bodies, and also that Hamas should hand over the remaining hostages,' according to Mr Farrell. He said the debate on the draft lasted over the course of two days, and the commission 'just wouldn't move'.
'The argument being put up, and there wasn't much discussion from the leadership or from the chair, was just: 'this is out of our mandate',' Mr Farrell said, although he doesn't accept this rationale.
'In presuming that what they meant by that is that they were only able to deal with the things that were going on within the European area, I made the argument that a number of European countries are financing this, providing all the weapons for it. They're playing a major part in this, and, therefore, we are entitled to criticise them for it.'
[
Israel's Gaza City plan greeted with widespread international criticism
Opens in new window
]
A spokesperson for the ECRI secretariat told The Irish Times that the organisation was 'mandated to monitor state action against racism, intolerance and related forms of discrimination in Europe'. The situation in the Middle East has 'not been considered by ECRI members as falling within their mandate'.
Meanwhile, Mr Farrell said he received support from a small number of other representatives on the commission after his resignation, and that he did not criticise others for joining him in his stand.
'People are afraid of losing their jobs, there were people who were in bodies which are funded by the state, and they were afraid if they spoke out on this that the state wouldn't draw in the money from the organisations that they work in, which do good work,' he said.
Mr Farrell was the first Irish lawyer to advocate on behalf of a client in front of the United Nations Human Rights Committee (UNHCR) and the European Courts of Human Rights (ECHR).
He was a driving factor behind Dr Lydia Foy's campaign to legally change her sex, and further advocated on issues pertaining to transgender people in Ireland.
A native of Magherafelt, Co Derry and a graduate of Queen's University Belfast, he worked as a journalist before his legal career, highlighting the campaign to free the
Birmingham Six
and
Guilford Four
.
During his time with the ECRI, Farrell acted at times as the commission's vice-chair and also chaired its working group on LGBTI rights.
Dr Lydia Foy with solicitor Michael Farrell outside the High Court after it ruled that the State had breached her rights. Photograph: Frank Miller
Since Hamas's 2023 attack on Israel, in which 1,200 Israelis were killed and 251 taken hostage, more than 60,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza due to the military conflict in the region.
The UN General Assembly has condemned Israeli use of 'starvation as a method of warfare' as the conflict continues, with aid distribution controlled by Israel.
Mr Farrell is steadfast in his belief that 'if they don't deal with this, apart from the fact that they should simply because there's so many people being killed, they will lose the level of respect on other human rights issues'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
12 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Unity must be part of presidential election debate, says former SDLP leader
The unification of Ireland debate will be a key issue in coming years and must be part of the presidential campaign because the next officeholder could serve for 14 years, former Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) leader Colum Eastwood has declared. The Derry MP has made clear his interest in running in the October election, though an overture to Fianna Fáil leader, Micheál Martin , in June met with a cool response, and no action since by the party. However, Mr Eastwood appears still to believe that a nomination could be secured from four city and county councils in September, perhaps with a signal from Mr Martin to Fianna Fáil councillors to support him. 'We've had a lot of potential candidates and a lot of people talking about how great they would be as individuals, but not a lot of people are talking about their vision for the country,' he told The Irish Times. READ MORE 'The next president could be there for 14 years. We need somebody in post who is prepared to talk about, think about and lead on the issue of bringing the people of Ireland back together again. 'Given how long the term is, potentially if it's two terms, the idea of not having somebody who has thought about that deeply, or is not prepared to lead on it as our president, would be pretty bizarre,' he said. Speaking at the Féile an Phobail festival in west Belfast last weekend, Mr Eastwood said 'the cat is out of the bag' on the constitutional question: 'In my view, the United Kingdom is disintegrating before our very eyes.' [ Irish unification would cost €152m annually to give Northern Irish civil servants pay parity, report says Opens in new window ] The biggest lesson he has learned from his time as an MP in Westminster is that large elements of British political and public opinion 'care if Scotland goes, but they don't care if we go'. 'In fact, if we left in the morning and caused no trouble, they'd be happy enough. I just don't believe that there is anything that can be done by any British government to stop that momentum,' he went on. Saying that he wanted a united Ireland even if it meant he had 'to eat grass', Mr Eastwood accepted that middle ground opinion in Northern Ireland must be convinced that they are not putting their futures at risk by voting for it. 'There is a significant number of people in the middle who are unsure, or undecided, or just curious about it. We need to know who they are, and who they might vote for. We need to know what makes them tick, and what convinces them. 'We need to speak to them relentlessly over a period of years to convince them. If they tell us that they have concerns about pensions, we need to take that concern away by having the answer,' he said. Mr Eastwood, who leads the SDLP's New Ireland Commission, added that unless they looked at 'every single thing that makes them worried or concerned and have an answer for that', they would lose. Meanwhile, the Alliance Party , which declares itself as neutral on the constitutional question will 'not count' in future, even though people who currently vote for it will be central to the outcome of any referendum held, he said. 'I think their voters are the most important people in this conversation. But I think the Alliance Party, if they continue to say they have no position on the future of this island, will not count,' he declared. Political parties 'have to have positions' on the important issues facing society: 'I don't think it's good enough, actually, to say that they are going to decide at some point in the future.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Israel has ‘no choice' but to attack Gaza City, says Netanyahu, as hostage families call strike
Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu has insisted his country had 'no choice' but to approve a plan to attack Gaza City in order to topple Hamas's remaining stronghold. 'Our goal is not to occupy Gaza but to liberate it from Hamas,' he told a news conference on Sunday night. He also outlined the creation of a new governing body for the enclave. 'We will work to establish a civilian authority that is not affiliated with Hamas or the Palestinian Authority,' he said. READ MORE Mr Netanyahu said on Monday that Israel is 'approaching the end of the campaign' against those who sought to destroy it. 'We are working to defeat the remnants of the Iranian axis and to free all our hostages,' he said. The plan to attack Gaza City will entail the forced transfer of more than 800,000 Palestinian civilians, many of whom have already been displaced multiple times over the past 22 months of fighting. The Israeli attack on Gaza City is planned to start on October 7th, leaving almost two months for the army to mobilise the required forces for the operation. The army has been authorised to call up more than 400,000 reservists, but it is not clear exactly how many extra soldiers will be required. The military says civilians will be moved to the Muwasi humanitarian zone over the next six weeks and, in parallel, Israel says it plans to significantly increase aid deliveries. It says daily lorry convoys carrying humanitarian aid will increase from 300 to 1,200, with intensified aerial drops and the setting up of additional distribution centres. Some commentators believe the plan to attack Gaza City is designed to exert pressure on Hamas to resume negotiations on a ceasefire and hostage-release deal. A Hamas delegation reportedly arrived in Cairo on Monday as efforts by international mediators to break the deadlock continue. [ What is behind Israel's plan to take control of Gaza City? Opens in new window ] Far-right finance minister Bezalel Smotrich said he no longer believes Mr Netanyahu is willing to do what it takes to win the war in Gaza, calling the security cabinet's approval of a plan to conquer Gaza City a 'half-measure'. More than 61,000 Palestinians have been killed in the war, according to the Hamas-run Gaza health ministry. The war was triggered when 1,200 people were killed and 250 were taken hostage into Gaza during a Hamas attack on southern Israel on October 7th, 2023, according to Israeli tallies. Families of the hostages have declared a one-day general strike for Sunday, the first day of Israel's working week, as part of their campaign for a ceasefire aimed at bringing back all 50 hostages, 20 of whom are believed to be alive. However, the Histadrut trade union federation announced on Monday that it would not order its members to join the strike. After talks with business leaders and relatives of hostages, Histadrut leader Arnon Bar-David argued that joining the strike would politicise the question of the hostages. 'If I knew that a strike – not just for one day but longer – would end the matter, stop the war and bring back the hostages, I would go for it with full force,' he said. 'Unfortunately, and although my heart is bursting with anger, it has no practical outcome.' [ Trump should use influence with Netanyahu to stop war in Gaza, says Taoiseach Opens in new window ] He did, however, promise to encourage employers to allow workers to attend protests and rallies without risking their employment rights. Israeli police on Monday, meanwhile, arrested a 27-year-old Jerusalem man suspected of spray-painting anti-war slogans, including 'there's a holocaust in Gaza', on a section of the Western Wall in Jerusalem's old city and at the city's main synagogue. The action was condemned by politicians from across the political spectrum.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
More than 100 former MEPs urge EU to suspend association agreement with Israel
The ongoing starvation of the civilian population in Gaza amounts to 'nothing short of a war crime', a group of more than 100 former members of the European Parliament have said. Tentative moves by the European Commission to sanction Israel for its conduct during its invasion of Gaza are 'too little, too late', the former MEPs stated. In an open letter criticising the EU's response to the war in Gaza, the large group of former politicians said concrete action needed to be taken by the EU executive arm led by Ursula von der Leyen . The letter was signed by Josep Borrell, a former Spanish MEP who was the EU's top foreign affairs envoy until late last year. His efforts to sanction Israel in that role were blocked. READ MORE In total 110 former MEPs from Spain, Ireland, France, the UK and several other countries added their names to the joint letter. [ Al Jazeera rejects claims journalist killed in Israeli airstrike in Gaza led Hamas cell Opens in new window ] The group called for the EU to suspend an association agreement that governs the bloc's relations with Israel, which includes a free-trade deal. The commission recently proposed suspending part of the agreement that allows to Israel access Horizon research funding. The decision needs the support of a weighted majority of the EU's 27 states, with two of Israel's backers, Germany and Italy, holding up the suspension. [ Germany divided over plan to limit weapons for Israel Opens in new window ] The open letter was organised by a former UK MEP, Glyn Ford of the Labour Party. Several former Irish MEPs added their names to the letter, including Emer Costello, Brian Crowley, Proinsias De Rossa and Pat the Cope Gallagher. Former Independent MEP and current Minister of State Marian Harkin is also among the signatories. A failure by EU states to agree to take action against Israel would expose their 'complicity' in its war crimes in Gaza, the letter stated. [ Why has Gazans' hunger attained the status of 'moral crisis' when Israel's genocidal slaughter did not? Opens in new window ] Israel's restriction of humanitarian aid getting into Gaza over recent weeks and months has heightened pressure on the country, as aid agencies continue to warn of spreading famine in the war-torn strip. Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu's plan to further expand military operations in Gaza has drawn more international condemnation. EU foreign ministers were to discuss the situation in Gaza during a video call on Monday, mostly focusing on upcoming talks on the Ukraine war between United States president Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin. More than 60,000 Palestinians have been killed during Israel's aerial bombardment and ground offensive in Gaza, which has destroyed much of the Palestinian territory's buildings and infracture. The Israeli invasion followed attacks by Hamas militants in southern Israel on October 7th, 2023, during which 1,200 people were killed and 250 taken hostage.
