‘Easy money is a trap': Delhi HC quashes cheating case against man
Justice Arun Monga, in his 35-page, strongly worded verdict released on Monday, termed 'easy money' as a 'trap' and warned against chasing unrealistic returns. Individuals lured by unrealistic financial returns cannot later claim to be a victim of fraud, the court said.
'Those who gamble with impractical promises must own their risks. People, lured by unrealistic returns, first willingly dive into financial traps and later cry foul, running to seek State help. An uncomfortable, but necessary reality is that if you choose to chase extraordinary gains, you must be prepared for extraordinary losses,' justice Monga said in his August 13 verdict.
He added, 'If you choose greed, you choose risk, and if you choose risk, you choose consequences. But such victims ought not to pretend that they were duped by magic when they walked willingly into the illusion. So every dreamer chasing quick riches– it is a wake-up call. Easy money is a trap. If the return sounds unbelievable, believe this instead: you are the next in line to pay the price.'
The case originated from an FIR filed by the Delhi Police in 2019 under Section 420 (cheating) of the Indian Penal Code. The three complainants alleged that the accused had promised to pay interest at 24% annually for six months on an investment of ₹1.5 crore in a company, but later failed to return both the interest and the principal amount. They also claimed the man had induced them to buy a 1.25% stake in a company for ₹43.66 lakh, which was never refunded.
Ultimately, the court quashed the case, observing that even after six years, the police had failed to file a complete chargesheet. It noted that the allegations in the FIR lacked the essential elements of the offence of cheating, stating that what was essentially a civil dispute had been disguised as a criminal case. The investigating agency's conduct, the judge said, reflected 'gross negligence' and 'lack of due diligence.'
'What is essentially a civil dispute has been camouflaged as a criminal case. No satisfactory explanation has been offered for the six-year delay, which vitiates the sanctity of the entire process and raises serious doubts about the bona fide of the prosecution,' the court maintained.
The judge, in his verdict, also emphasised the ripple effects caused by investors pumping money into unsustainable ventures, saying that the same has the likelihood of harming genuine end users and distorting market equilibrium.
'Greed is not just a personal flaw, it creates ripple effects. When investors pump money into unsustainable ventures, they inflate bubbles that harm genuine end users and distort market equilibrium. And when the bubble bursts, they expect the law to paint them as victims, absolving them of all responsibility. The allure of easy money is a dangerous illusion. Investors who ignore prudence and succumb to unrealistic promises must understand that their choices carry consequences. The law must punish fraud, but it cannot shield people from the fallout of their avarice,' the court maintained.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Mute vagabond murdered in southeast Delhi park, 2 minors among 4 held
The Delhi Police arrested an 18-year-old man, a woman, and apprehended two minors in connection with the murder of a mute vagabond at the Astha Kunj Park in southeast Delhi, officials said on Tuesday. Police said the victim stared at the group for a long time, after which the accused assaulted him with fists, kicks and a stick.(Hindustan Times/Representative Image) The body of the victim, identified as Dharam alias Gunga, a mute vagabond who lived near the ISKCON temple, was found on the morning of August 13, the police said. The three accused, identified as Dinesh alias Lalla (18) and two minors, had come to the park for food and drinks. The victim stared at the group for a long time, after which the accused assaulted him with fists, kicks and a stick, Deputy Commissioner of Police (Southeast) Hemant Tiwari said. In a related development, the police also arrested a woman identified as Rahana (44), a resident of Shriniwaspuri, who allegedly supplied cannabis to the accused. A case was registered under Section 103 (1) (murder) of the BNS at the Amar Colony Police Station. Since there was no CCTV coverage inside the park, the team analysed footage from the cameras along Raja Dhir Singh Marg near the temple. "A recording from around 12.40 am on August 13 showed three youths alighting from an auto and heading towards the park. Based on surveillance and inputs from informers, police laid a trap and apprehended the accused," the DCP stated. The police recovered blood-stained clothes, two mobile phones and a stick used in the crime. Dinesh, a resident of Banda in Uttar Pradesh, was previously involved in an attempt to murder case as a minor, the DCP added. During interrogation, the accused revealed that the victim allegedly kept staring at them, which provoked them. "When the victim failed to respond to repeated questioning, the accused and his associates assaulted him, leaving him fatally injured," the officer said. Additionally, cannabis weighing 175 grams was recovered from Rahana, leading to a separate case being registered under the NDPS Act at the Amar Colony Police Station.
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Pregnant Minor Rape Survivor Agrees To Give Birth After Moving Delhi High Court
New Delhi: A minor rape survivor who moved the Delhi High Court with a plea to terminate her 30-week pregnancy has agreed to give birth to the child, who would be given for adoption. The 14-year-old girl, who was abandoned by her parents, moved the court through her aunt. She was raped and impregnated by a cousin and is currently residing at a shelter home in the capital. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma's August 18 order observed the survivor was abandoned by both parents and the mother of the rape accused, her aunt, was the only guardian with whom she wanted to reside. "With these peculiar background circumstances, this court by way of abundant caution, deems it appropriate to hold that the child will need care and protection under the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 and CWC is directed to independently interact with the child, obtain her opinion and inform this court regarding the same before passing of a final order," the court said. The survivor and her guardian agreed on giving birth after being counselled about the opinion of the medical board, which examined her and said the termination of her pregnancy was not possible, given the medical complications. The board opined that any pre-term C-section for delivery or medical termination of pregnancy would pose higher future obstetrical implications, and if undertaken, could adversely affect her future reproductive prospects. The board's report indicated that at the present gestation period, the child would be born alive, and the doctors have informed the girl and her guardian about the implications of terminating the pregnancy. The board informed the court that the minor and her guardian were willing to continue with the pregnancy for the next four to six weeks. The court noted the minor's pregnancy would continue given the statements, and it couldn't direct the termination against their will. "Considering the above, the prayer to direct the respondents 1 and 2 (Delhi government) to medically terminate the pregnancy of the victim given the Explanation 2, Section 3(2) of the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971, will be infructuous," it said. The court then posted the matter for August 20, when the Child Welfare Committee would submit its report. The girl learnt about her pregnancy in early August when she saw a doctor. She was already 27 weeks pregnant by then. She subsequently moved the court after the doctors referred to statutory restrictions under the MTP Act, limiting such procedures to 20 weeks in ordinary cases and 24 weeks in certain categories such as rape survivors.
Hindustan Times
5 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Adobe's new Acrobat Studio places your PDFs and AI assistants in one place
Adobe is introducing a new platform that weaves together Adobe Acrobat, Adobe Express and artificial intelligence (AI) automation in a single window, the idea being to consolidate PDF documents, web pages and multiple tools into a hub. Adobe envisions Acrobat Studio, which also spawns its own subscription, as a collective that allows users to find value from creating specific workplaces where PDFs form the foundation of conversational knowledge hubs, with customisable AI Assistants to draw information, answers or recommendations alongside the company's Express creativity platform, PDF management tools, and the Firefly AI powered image and video generation options. Official image. Acrobat Studio will be priced at $24.99 per month (or ₹1,357 in India) for individuals and $29.99/month for teams (that's priced at ₹2,969 per license, in India). Adobe calls this as 'early access pricing', and it isn't clear for now if this will increase after this offer ends on October 31. This now sits alongside Acrobat Standard ($12.99 per month) and Acrobat Pro ($19.99 per month), and the exclusive functionality includes an Acrobat AI Assistant as well. Adobe says anyone who is currently subscribed to any of these plans, can upgrade. There are specific use-cases that may draw value from the Acrobat Studio subscription, with a proposition for students to piece together their notes into study guides and also able to quickly generate precise citations from their sources. Another possible use case could be relevant for travellers, who may be able to draw upon Acrobat Studio to collect location reviews, itineraries or recommendations and have AI Assistants help them plan the vacation. Or use Express tools to transform data into infographics or visual assets. 'Acrobat Studio is the place where your best work comes together, uniting the productivity of Acrobat, the creative power of Adobe Express and the value of AI to empower you to work smarter and faster. We're reinventing PDF for modern work, so whatever you need to get done, you can do that with Acrobat,' says Abhigyan Modi, senior vice president, Document Product Group at Adobe, in a briefing of which HT was a part. PDF Spaces will also allow users to also add specific websites and webpages to the collection of files and documents, for more information. Adobe says that users will have the flexibility to assign AI Assistants in PDF Spaces with specific roles, such as that of an instructor, or analyst, or entertainer, which will form the baseline personality for how they collate and present information, answer user questions and deploy reasoning to suggest further aspects worth exploring. Sharing should be easy too, the company promises, insisting entire PDF Spaces, including personalised AI Assistants, can be shared with colleagues, customers and classmates. At this time, Acrobat Studio is available only in English, worldwide. Adobe's Acrobat Studio and its focused proposition competes, in varying degrees, with Google's NotebookLM that can also behave as a virtual assistant capable of summarising, explaining, and answering questions based on uploaded documents (these can be PDFs, Docs, Slides, Microsoft 365 files, or web pages), and also includes a 'podcast-style' Audio Overview features. While Google unlocks NotebookLM with the entry spec AI Pro plan ₹1,950 per month), you'll need the top-tier AI Ultra plan ( ₹24,500 per month) to unlock higher usage limits. If the focus is on just writing and assistance with information, OpenAI's ChatGPT Canvas and Google Gemini Canvas also have areas of strength with wider document support and Google Docs sync respectively. It must be noted that the Canvas propositions from Google and OpenAI are more focused on coding tasks as well, something Adobe isn't promising.
