SC: Police can't serve notice or summon through WhatsApp or other electronic means
Pressing for electronic means of serving summons, the state submitted that the new law of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita allowed use of electronic means for court proceedings for issuance, service and execution of summons and warrant and that should be allowed to police also. But a bench of Justices M M Sundresh and N K Singh said that summons issued by a court is a judicial act, whereas a notice issued by the investigating agency is an executive act and the procedure prescribed for a judicial act cannot be read into the procedure prescribed for an executive act.
The court clarified that the issue of liberty is involved in the case of police summon as the person can be arrested for non-compliance of summon and in such cases it is appropriate that such a notice be served in person on the accused, and not through the mode of electronic communication. It accepted the submission of senior advocate Siddharth Luthra who is assisting the court as amicus curiae and told the bench that summons are to be served personally on the person, as per the regular mode of service.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
No annual fees for life
UnionBank Credit Card
Apply Now
Undo
"The protection of one's liberty is a crucial aspect of the right to life guaranteed to each and every individual, under Article 21 of the Constitution. The procedure encapsulated in Section 35(6) of the BNSS, 2023, seeks to secure this fundamental right, from encroachment by the relevant Authority, and therefore, any attempt to interpret the provision as a mere procedural one, would amount to rewriting the provision itself .
.The Legislature, in its wisdom, has specifically excluded the service of a notice under Section 35 of the BNSS from the ambit of procedures permissible through electronic communication," the bench said.
"When viewed from any lens, we are unable to convince ourselves that electronic communication is a valid mode of service of notice under Section 35 of the BNSS, since its conscious omission is a clear manifestation of the legislative intent. Introducing a procedure into Section 35 of the BNSS, that has not been specifically provided for by the legislature, would be violative of its intent," the Supreme Court bench said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
a minute ago
- Indian Express
SIM boxes, fake officials and threats: Chandigarh Police bust Rs 1,000 crore digital arrest ‘scam', arrest 10
The Chandigarh Police said Friday they have busted a sophisticated digital arrest 'scam' operated by a transnational cybercrime syndicate based in Cambodia and other Southeast Asian countries, with the arrest of 10 people across Punjab and Uttar Pradesh. Officers of the Cyber Crime Police Station arrested the suspects after lodging a First Information Report (FIR) registered on July 21 under various sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). They also said Rs 36.98 lakh has been frozen across various bank accounts linked to the suspects. They said details of the accused and the equipment they seized have been shared with the Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C) to determine their possible links with other cybercrime cases across India. The police said the alleged scam came to light after Manjeet Behl, a senior citizen and wife of late Brigadier Amarjit Singh Behl, lodged a complaint, saying she was duped of Rs 1.01 crore after being threatened on a voice call, followed by a WhatsApp video call from someone posing as a CBI officer. The caller falsely accused her of being involved in a money laundering case linked to her Aadhaar number and bank details. The fraudsters shared fake documents, including forged government notices and a fabricated bank passbook, with her. During the video call, a fake police station setup was displayed to intimidate her into transferring her life savings into accounts claimed to be for 'safe custody.' Modus operandi Investigations revealed the alleged scam was being orchestrated from Southeast Asian countries like Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, and Hong Kong. The fraudsters used devices known as SIM boxes, which can generate lakhs of IVR calls per day by converting internet-based calls into local mobile calls, thereby bypassing telecom tracking. Geetanjali Khandewal, Superintendent of Police, Cyber Crime, who headed the probe, said victims across India were targeted by people impersonating officials from the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), or courier companies like FedEx, and each SIM card plugged into these devices could make over 1,500 calls per day. The syndicate was estimated to be causing losses of nearly Rs 1,000 crore to the Indian economy every month, said the police. According to the police, Indians were lured via Facebook and Telegram with promises of work-from-home jobs. They were then recruited to operate the SIM boxes by providing internet connectivity, uninterrupted power supply, and SIM cards, with all activity monitored remotely by foreign handlers through Telegram groups. Acting on technical leads and approvals, Chandigarh Police launched a series of coordinated raids in Meerut, Ludhiana, and Amritsar. In Meerut, Parvez Chauhan was arrested with a SIM box, Wi-Fi router, and over 70 SIM cards. He admitted to earning 50 USDT per day in cryptocurrency for routing international scam calls. In Ludhiana, Vijay Kumar Shah and Krishna Shah, two men of Nepalese origin, were arrested for their fraudulent point-of-sale (PoS) operations where they activated multiple SIMs using one customer's KYC without their knowledge. These SIMs were later sold to Akash Kumar, who distributed them further. The police then arrested Suhail Akhtar, who confessed to purchasing SIMs from Kumar, and supplying them to Shubham Mehra alias Sunny. They searched a rented property in Amritsar where Mehra was operating a SIM box facility. The police seized six high-end SIM boxes (Dinstar brand), over 400 SIM cards, 11 mobile phones, laptops, routers, and modems. The police said Mehra admitted he was recruited through a Facebook ad and Telegram by foreign nationals, and was paid Rs 25,000 in cash monthly for managing the infrastructure. The chain extended to Ajit Kumar, Vipin Kumar, Saroj Kumar, and Abhishek Kumar, who were involved in sourcing and financing the illegal SIM operations. Vipin provided financial backing, while Saroj and Abhishek, both PoS agents, activated SIMs, which were later used in cyber frauds. The police said their probe also revealed a human trafficking angle. Between 2022 and 2025, nearly 3,000 Indian citizens were rescued from countries like Cambodia and Laos, where they had been lured by fake job offers and forced to operate cyber scams under duress, including the digital arrest model.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
a minute ago
- Business Standard
Himachal may 'vanish in thin air' amid ecological imbalance, warns SC
The Supreme Court has flagged the ecological imbalance in Himachal Pradesh and cautioned that the entire state may "vanish in thin air" if the situation does not change. Observing that the situation in Himachal Pradesh has gone from bad to worse, the apex court said climate change is having a "visible and alarming impact" on the state. "We want to impress upon the state government and Union of India that earning revenue is not everything. Revenue cannot be earned at the cost of environment and ecology," a bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan said. "If things proceed the way they are as on date, the day is not far when the entire state of HP may vanish in thin air from the map of the country. God forbid this doesn't happen," it said. The top court made the observations on July 28 while dealing with a petition against an order of the Himachal Pradesh High Court, which declined to entertain a plea challenging the state's June 2025 notification declaring certain areas as "green area". While refusing to interfere with the high court's order, the apex court said the obvious reason for issuing the notification was to curb construction activities in a particular area. "The situation in the state of Himachal Pradesh has gone from bad to worse. The severe ecological imbalance and other environmental conditions have led to serious natural calamities over a period of years," the bench said. It noted the nature definitely is "annoyed" with the activities that are going on in Himachal Pradesh. "It is not right to blame only nature for the disaster in Himachal Pradesh. Humans, not nature, are responsible for phenomenon such as continuous land sliding of mountains and soil, landslides on roads, collapsing of houses and buildings, subsidence of road etc.," it said. The bench said according to experts and various reports, the major causes of destruction in the state are hydropower projects, four-lane roads, deforestation, multi-storey buildings, etc. It observed that Himachal Pradesh is nestled in the lap of Himalayan mountains and it is important to seek the opinion of geologists, environmental experts and locals before any development project is undertaken there. The bench said taking advantage of the state's natural beauty, the government started constructing four-lane roads to promote it as a tourist destination. "With forests encompassing more than 66 per cent of the total land area, Himachal Pradesh is renowned for its abundant beauty and greenery. But the danger to this natural richness is growing as a result of human greed and apathy," it said. The bench said unrelenting building, tunnel and road construction, frequently done without sufficient environmental planning, has increased the area's susceptibility to natural disasters and effects of climate change. Stating that Himachal Pradesh is often referred to as the "power state" of India due to its significant hydropower potential, the bench said, "While this form of energy is renewable and low-carbon, large-scale construction of dams, reservoirs, and tunnels comes with considerable environmental costs." It said the state has been witnessing rising average temperatures, shifting snowfall patterns and an increase in the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events. "These changes threaten not only the environment but also the livelihoods of local communities dependent on farming, horticulture, and eco-tourism deforestation and forest degradation are major concerns," it said. It also flagged forest fires, encroachments, overgrazing and expansion of agricultural and urban areas as contributing factors. The bench said pace of infrastructure development in the state has intensified in recent years, driven by the twin goals of connectivity and tourism. Projects like four-lane highways, ropeways, tunnels and urban expansions often bypass environmental safeguards, it said. The apex court also said that tourism is a major source of income in Himachal Pradesh but the uncontrolled growth of tourism has strained the state's environment. "If left unchecked, the pressure from tourism could severely undermine the ecological and social fabric of the state," it said. Referring to the peculiarities in the Himalayan region, the bench said there is a need for all the Himalayan states to collate resources and expertise so as to ensure that development plans are cognizant of these challenges. "All that we want to convey today is that it is high time the state of HP pays attention to what we have observed and starts taking necessary action at the earliest in the right direction," it said. The bench said the Centre also owes an obligation to see that ecological imbalance in the state does not get further disturbed and natural calamities do not occur. "Of course much damage has been caused but there is a saying that 'something is better than nothing'," the bench observed, as it directed the apex court registry to register a writ petition in public interest in this regard. "We expect the state to file an appropriate reply explaining whether they have any action plan to meet with the issues we have discussed and what do they propose to do in future," it said. The bench also said the registry shall notify the matter before it after obtaining appropriate order from the Chief Justice of India. It posted the matter for hearing on August 25.
Hindustan Times
a minute ago
- Hindustan Times
Mob violence in Pune's Yavat over 'objectionable' WhatsApp post; youth detained
An irate mob vandalised properties and indulged in arson in Yavat in Pune's Daund tehsil on Friday afternoon over an objectionable post allegedly uploaded on social media by a youth from a different community, police officials said. People gather after two groups clashed over a social media post, in Yavat in Pune's Daund tehsil, Friday.(PTI) A motorcycle was set ablaze and a bakery was damaged, the officials said, adding teargas shells had to be lobbed to bring the situation under control amid large mobs taking to the streets to vent their ire. There is heavy police presence in the village at the moment and peace and order has been restored, these officials said. The youth, who hails from outside the village, had kept an objectionable Whatsapp post, and he has been detained, Sandip Singh Gill, Superintendent of Police (Pune Rural), told PTI. "On being alerted, we detained the youth and the process of taking action was underway. However, by then the post went viral, leading to trouble in the village already tense due to some previous incidents. The mob vandalised structures belonging to members of the opposite community hailing from outside," Gill said. Another official said residents of the village, who are from both communities, are opposed to some persons who are "non-native" and hail from outside the region. This official said the village was tense recently after the desecration of a statue of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj at a temple. Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, who was in Pune to attend an event, said a youth, who hails from outside, had put up an objectionable post about a Hindu priest raping someone, which angered residents. "To disperse the mob, police had to resort to lathi charge. The situation in Yavat is now under control and peace prevails. People from both communities are together and efforts are on to defuse tensions. Some persons keep such objectionable posts just to create tension. Strict action will be taken against them. No one has the right to post objectionable content," the CM said.
