Judge reinstates credit union agency members fired by Trump

The Hill

22-07-2025

A federal judge reinstated two Democratic appointees at the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) on Tuesday whom President Trump purported to fire.
It's the latest decision reversing Trump's firings of independent agency leaders across the federal bureaucracy.
U.S. District Judge Amir Ali warned in his 27-page ruling that accepting the administration's position would mean that Trump could also fire the Federal Reserve chair without cause.
'The overlap in powers wielded by the NCUA Board and the Federal Reserve, and their common role as financial regulators, supports the conclusion that Congress can insulate NCUA Board members from at-will removal,' Ali wrote.
Ali did not reference Trump's recent flirtations with firing Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell. But the Biden-appointed judge repeatedly suggested the government 'all but concedes' the point that they'd equally be able to fire Powell, too.
The Justice Department declined to comment. The Hill has reached out to Harper and Otsuka's legal team for comment.
Created in 1970, the NCUA is tasked with regulating and insuring credit unions. It plays a similar role to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which insures banks.
The NCUA board members once served at the pleasure of the president. But within a few years, Congress removed that language and provided they should instead serve fixed, six-year terms, with no more than two of the three members coming from the same political party.
In April, Trump purported to fire Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka, the two Democrats on NCUA's board, without explanation. Harper and Otsuka soon sued.
The administration in court did not purport to have cause, but it argued Trump has absolute authority to remove the duo at will and the courts had no authority to order their reinstatement.
The NCUA is one of a handful of agencies where Trump has attempted to fire top leadership despite their traditional independence from the White House.
The administration has a pending request with the Supreme Court to greenlight Trump's firings at the Consumer Product Safety Commission. It comes after the justices in May sided with the administration in its effort to fire officials at the National Labor Relations Board and Merit Systems Protection Board.
Other battles could soon reach the justices. On Monday, a panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit temporarily halted a lower judge's order reinstating a fired member at the Federal Trade Commission.