ONOE aims to alter basic principles of Constitution: Singhvi
New Delhi: Legal expert and Congress lawmaker Abhishek Singhvi on Tuesday emphasised that the Constitution (129th) amendment bill proposing simultaneous elections in the country would need ratification by at least half of the state legislatures, noting that the legislation aims at altering the basic principles of the Constitution.
The Rajya Sabha member, who was deposing before the joint parliamentary committee (JPC) examining the bills on one nation, one election (ONOE), made a detailed presentation on legal points and said the draft laws violate the 'will of the people' and principles of federalism.
When Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, who is also part of the 31-member JPC, asked Singhvi if simultaneous polls lead to favourable verdict to the ruling party, the latter pointed to reports that suggest favourable results.
The senior advocate told the JPC that changing the schedule for Lok Sabha and assembly elections to hold them simultaneously would amount to curtailing the mandate of the voters as some assemblies' five year-term would be reduced by a few years to sync the polls.
He emphasised that the Constitution amendment bill will need approval from at least half of the state legislatures, noting that it seeks to alter the basic principles of the Constitution. He pointed to certain provisos of Article 368(2) (which empowers Parliament to amend the Constitution) to back his argument on the need of ratification by state legislatures.
Singhvi maintained that federalism is most vital part of the basic structure and when it is interfered with or artificially curtailed, it tampers the basic structure.
The committee headed by BJP lawmaker PP Chaudhary is mandated to examine the bills on simultaneous polls — the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill — and give its report on whether they are sound enough for the purpose or need changes. The panel is likely to submit its report in monsoon session in July.
Several lawmakers, Chaudhary, Randeep Surjewala, Ghanshyam Tiwari and Sambit Patra, also asked questions to Singhvi.
BJP leader and Lok Sabha MP Bansuri Swaraj attended the meeting with a bag carrying a message about the 'loot' in the National Herald case.
Talking to reporters later, Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra said: '(Swaraj) was roaming around with some slogan. I enjoyed it. I even asked her about her bag but she just smiled…'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
21 minutes ago
- Time of India
Don't Travel to the Mountains Without These Gadgets!
Bihar's Pad Girl Talks About Marriage With Rahul Gandhi | Video From Bihar Goes Viral Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's visit to Bihar took a heartwarming and empowering turn when he met Riya Paswan — popularly known as the 'Pad Girl'. Speaking at a Mahila Samwad in Gaya, Riya credited the Congress's Shakti Abhiyan for transforming her life and inspiring her to enter politics. In a viral moment, she boldly declared that, just like Rahul Gandhi, she would never marry and instead dedicate her life to public service. Rahul, visibly impressed, encouraged her passion and confidence. This powerful exchange showcases the changing face of grassroots politics, women empowerment, and how political mentorship can spark real social change — even in India's most marginalized communities.#rahulgandhi #padgirl #riyapaswan #rahulgandhimarriage #rahulgandhimarriagevideo #rahulgandhiviralvideo #shaktiabhiyan #biharpolitics #congress #womenspolitics #mahilasamwad #gaya #biharassembly2025 #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews 1.4K views | 2 hours ago
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Raghubar slams govt for non-implementation of PESA Act
Dumka: Former chief minister Raghubar Das on Saturday criticised the state govt for being indifferent towards the implementation of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) (PESA) Act, 1996, in the state. Das said, "The tribal society has been deprived of the benefits of the Union govt funds due to the non-implementation of the PESA Act though the community comprises the major support base of JMM, which is the ruling party in the state govt coalition. Jharkhand lost the Rs 1,400crore allotted by the central finance commission in the 2024-25 financial year as the state govt failed to introduce the PESA Act during its subsequent terms. The situation persisted even after JMM promised the electorate to implement the PESA Act in its election manifesto." "The implementation of the PESA Act would ensure 'Abua Raj' in real term as it would provide the traditional self-rule system of the tribal society a legal status in the 13 districts, comprising 112 blocks, which fall under the scheduled areas. The empowerment of the traditional self-rule bodies through the PESA Act will, in turn, go a long way in preventing the ongoing conversion of the tribals, otherwise being supported by the ruling alliance at the cost of the existence of the community and its culture," he alleged, accusing JMM of betraying the tribal society. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Device Made My Power Bill Drop Overnight elecTrick - Save upto 80% on Power Bill Pre-Order Undo The former Odisha governor further said, "The backward and Dalit community members were at the receiving end as central funds to the tune of hundreds of crores of rupees could not be released to the urban and rural civic bodies for development works. Finance minister Radha Krishna Kishore, through a letter to the CM, mentioned that the condition of Dalits was worse than that of the PVTG communities." While local JMM office bearers didn't respond, spokesperson for the state Congress, part of the ruling coalition, Shyamal Kishore Singh, refuted the allegations. "The state govt was committed to implement the PESA act. State Congress in-charge K Raju presided over a meeting with the party's district presidents on Saturday on the implementation of the PESA act. The district presidents have been directed to submit the reports to the party after due consultations with common people of the respective areas falling under the fifth schedule. " The state rural development department had held a state-level consultation with different stakeholders for seeking suggestions on the issue in Ranchi a few days ago.
Hans India
32 minutes ago
- Hans India
Take action against Siddaramaiah over stampede tragedy: Shobha Karandlaje asks Cong leadership
Bengaluru: Union Minister Shobha Karandlaje on Saturday challenged the Congress leadership to initiate action against Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar over the Chinnaswamy stampede incident, which claimed 11 lives. Addressing a press conference at the BJP headquarters in Bengaluru, Union Minister of State for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises and Labour and Employment, said, "If the High Command has any capacity, I want to ask the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, are you bankrupt? Are there no leaders in Karnataka other than CM Siddaramaiah and Deputy CM Shivakumar?" "Appoint other leaders and investigate them. You talk about the country on foreign soil; don't you have the capacity to punish your own leaders when they are found guilty?" she said. The MoS said that the Congress leadership was mum as "Karnataka is its ATM". Countering the Congress' claim that the stampede incident was an accident, she asked, "If it is an accident, why didn't you open all the gates of Chinnaswamy Stadium? There was no one to control the crowd. Why are you protecting Karnataka State Cricket Association (KSCA) office bearers? What's your relation with them? What was the urgency for the KSCA to felicitate RCB? What is your relation with RCB, which is a private franchise?" Attacking Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, she stated, "You got blood on your hands, and you can't escape. This tragedy occurred due to a craze for publicity. I don't know whether someone from the state Congress will become an IPL franchise owner. Anything can happen in the state." "The parents have lost their young children in the stampede. A youth studying in my constituency died. The family is now in such a state of depression that they didn't want to bring his body to their residence in Bengaluru and took it to their native place. They clearly said they wanted no one to visit them," she recounted. "You have committed a mistake and are passing the blame on the police officers. I want to ask CM and Dy CM, why did you want to celebrate it? We can understand if an Olympic gold medallist or champion teams representing the country are felicitated. When a private franchise like the RCB wins, you think of felicitating them," she questioned. "You post about it and go to receive them at the airport. The grand steps of Vidhana Soudha were used for swearing-in ceremonies of new governments. There, you bring a private team. The PWD Department, while giving permission, stated that seating arrangements had to be made on stage for only 25 to 30 persons. But your family, children, grandchildren from CM Siddaramaiah, Minister Zameer Ahmad Khan, Minister Ramalinga Reddy-there were 300 to 350 persons," she chided. "In front of you, people stood unsafely on the terrace of the High Court; people were seen dangerously sitting on top of trees on branches. How did you issue permission?" she asked.
