logo
We put Tesla's FSD and Waymo's robotaxi to the test. One shocking mistake made the winner clear.

We put Tesla's FSD and Waymo's robotaxi to the test. One shocking mistake made the winner clear.

The robotaxi race is speeding up.
Tesla is preparing to debut its autonomous ride-hailing service in Austin next month, and Alphabet's Waymo continues to expand throughout major US cities.
Under the hood of the Tesla and Waymo robotaxis are two key pieces of technology that the companies respectively call Full Self-Driving (FSD) and the Waymo Driver.
We (Business Insider's Lloyd Lee and Alistair Barr) tested both of these AI-powered drivers in San Francisco — and the results truly surprised us.
Given the positive experiences we've had with Waymo and Tesla's FSD, we expected the results of our not-so-scientific test to come down to minute details — maybe by how many times the AI-driver would hesitate or if it would make a curious lane change for no apparent reason.
That didn't happen. Instead, the Tesla made an egregious error that handed Waymo the clear win.
Here's how it went down.
The test
Our vehicles for the test included Waymo's Jaguar I-PACE SUVs and Barr's personal 2024 Tesla Model 3.
The Waymo robotaxis are equipped with the company's fifth-generation Waymo Driver and guided by five lidar sensors, six radars, and 29 cameras.
Barr's Tesla was equipped with Hardware 4 and FSD Supervised software v13.2.8. Tesla released a minor update to the software days after this test was conducted. The vehicle has eight external cameras.
It should be noted that this is not the same software Tesla plans to use in the robotaxis set to roll out this summer. The company said it plans to release FSD Unsupervised, a self-driving system that will not require a human behind the wheel. Nevertheless, we wanted to see how far Tesla's FSD had come since its beta rollout in 2020.
We couldn't compare Tesla and Waymo as a full-package robotaxi service. Tesla has yet to launch that product, so we focused only on the driving experience.
We started at San Francisco's iconic Twin Peaks viewpoint and ended at Chase Center. Depending on the route, that's about a 4- to 7-mile ride.
We chose these destinations for two reasons. One, it would take the cars through winding roads and both suburban and city landscapes. And two, there were a few ways to get to Chase Center from Twin Peaks, including the 280 highway.
Waymo's robotaxis can't take riders on the highway yet. Tesla can.
According to Google Maps, the highway is more time-efficient. For the Tesla, we went with the route the vehicle highlighted first. It pointed out the highway on the way back to Twin Peaks.
We took a Waymo around 8:30 a.m. on a Thursday and the Tesla afterward at around 10 a.m. The traffic conditions for both rides were light to moderate and not noticeably different.
Predictions
Our prediction was that the AI drivers' skills would be nearly neck-and-neck.
But in the spirit of competition, Lee predicted Waymo would deliver a smoother experience and a smarter driver, given the high-tech sensor stack the company relies on.
Barr went with Tesla. He said he'd driven hundreds of miles on FSD with two or three relatively minor interventions so far, and given this previous experience, Barr said he'd have no problem riding in the back seat of a Tesla robotaxi.
Waymo
Throughout our ride in the Waymo, we were impressed by the AI driver's ability to be safe but assertive.
The Waymo was not shy about making yellow lights, for example, but it never made maneuvers you wouldn't want a robot driver you're entrusting your life with to make.
One small but notable moment in our ride was when the Waymo stopped behind a car at a stop sign. To the right of us was an open lane.
For whatever reason, the Waymo saw that and decided to switch lanes, as if it was tired of waiting behind the other car. We found that a bit amusing because it seemed like such a human moment.
As human drivers, we might make choices like that because we get antsy waiting behind another car, even though we're not shaving more than a few seconds, if any, off of our commute.
Barr noted that the Waymo Driver can have moments of sass or attitude. It had an urgency, giving us the feeling that it somehow really cared that we got to the Chase Center in good time.
"It's got New York cab driver energy," Barr said, stealing a line from BI editor in chief Jamie Heller, who also took a Waymo during a trip to San Francisco earlier this year.
Sandy Karp, a spokesperson for Waymo, said the company doesn't have specific details on what happened in that moment but said that the Waymo Driver "is constantly planning its next move, including the optimal route to get its rider where they're going safely and efficiently."
"This planning can involve decisions like changing lanes when deemed favorable," she said.
Ultimately, though, the best litmus test for any robotaxi is when you stop noticing that you're in a robotaxi.
Outside those small but notable moments, we recorded footage for this story and chatted in comfort without feeling like we were on the edge of our seats.
Tesla
Tesla's FSD delivered a mostly smooth driving experience, and we think it deserves some props for doing so with a smaller and cheaper tech stack, i.e., only eight cameras.
FSD knew how to signal a lane change as it approached a large stalled vehicle taking up a lot of road room, and it didn't have any sudden moments of braking. Just a few years ago, Tesla owners were reporting issues of "phantom braking." We experienced none of that on our drive.
Tesla also handled highway driving flawlessly. Sure, the weather was clear and traffic was fairly light, but, as noted earlier, Waymo does not yet offer public rides on highways. The company is still testing.
However, Tesla FSD did make a few mistakes, including one critical error.
At the end of our drive at Chase Center, we assessed how Waymo and Tesla's systems performed. We both gave Waymo a slight edge, but were also impressed with the FSD system.
On our way back to Twin Peaks, Tesla highlighted a route that would take us on the highway — a route that Waymo cannot take. We kept Tesla FSD on for this trip while we continued recording.
San Francisco is known to have a lot of brightly marked, green bike lanes for cyclists. There was one moment during the trip back when the Tesla made a right turn onto a bike lane and continued to drive on it for a few seconds before it merged into the proper lane.
Then, as we approached the last half-mile of our ride, the Tesla, for an unknown reason, ran a red light.
The incident occurred at a fairly complex intersection that resembles a slip-lane intersection, but with a traffic light. The Waymo did not approach this intersection since it took a different route to get back to Twin Peaks.
The Tesla's console screen showed how the car detected the red light and came to a dutiful stop. Then, despite the traffic light not changing, the Tesla drove ahead.
We didn't come close to hitting any cars or humans on the street — Tesla's FSD is good at spotting such risks, and the main source of traffic coming across our path had been stopped by another traffic light. However, the vehicle slowly drove through this red light, which left us both somewhat shocked at the time.
Some Tesla drivers appeared to have reported similar issues in online forums and in videos that showed the vehicle recognizing the red light but driving ahead. One YouTuber showed how the Tesla first came to a stop at a red light and then continued driving before the light changed.
It's unclear how common this issue is. Tesla hasn't publicly addressed the problem.
A spokesperson for Tesla did not respond to a request for comment.
At this point, we thought the winner was clear.
Verdict
Since Tesla's FSD made a critical error that would have landed an automatic fail during a driver's license test, we thought it was fair to give Waymo the win for this test.
The Tesla handled San Francisco's hilly and winding roads almost as flawlessly as Waymo.
We also think FSD's ability to handle routes that Waymo can't handle for now — in particular, the highway — would give Tesla a major upper hand.
In addition, when Lee tried on a different day to make the Waymo go through the same intersection where the Tesla blew the red light, the Waymo app appeared to do everything it could to avoid that intersection, even if it provided the quickest path to get to the destination, according to Google Maps.
A Waymo spokesperson did not provide a comment on what could've happened here.
Still, an error like running a red light cannot be overlooked when human lives are at stake. Consider that when Tesla rolls out its robotaxi service, a human driver will not be behind the wheel to quickly intervene if it makes an error.
For Tesla and Waymo, we expected to be on the lookout for small, almost negligible, mistakes or glitchy moments from the AI driver. We did not anticipate an error as glaring as running a red light.
Once Tesla launches its robotaxi service in more areas, we'll have to see how the pick-up and drop-off times compare.
Tesla CEO Elon Musk said that the company's generalized solution to self-driving is far superior to its competitors. The company has millions of cars already on the roads collecting massive amounts of real-world data. According to Musk, this will make FSD smarter and able to operate with only cameras.
With Tesla's robotaxi service set to launch in June with human passengers, we certainly hope so.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Fund manager who sold Tesla, just in time, says investors are overlooking these tech bargains
Fund manager who sold Tesla, just in time, says investors are overlooking these tech bargains

Yahoo

time34 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Fund manager who sold Tesla, just in time, says investors are overlooking these tech bargains

Two weeks ago, Wall Street veteran Gary Black sold his remaining Tesla shares, helping clients sidestep a selloff driven by a public fallout between Chief Executive Elon Musk and President Donald Trump. Black's unease with Tesla TSLA goes back a ways. When the managing partner of The Future Fund launched the One Global ETF FFND in August 2021, he snapped up Tesla, which quickly became the biggest position. By the second quarter of 2022, he began to trim as Musk started cutting electric-vehicle prices. Why Goldman Sachs says high-flying tech stocks may be headed for a tough stretch 'It might be another Apple or Microsoft': My wife invested $100K in one stock and it exploded 1,500%. Do we sell? U.S. debt-limit deadlock is making this favorite asset more scarce My friend, 83, wants to add me to his bank account to pay his bills. What could go wrong? One of our children has legal knowledge and lives far away, the other lacks financial savvy but lives nearby. Who should we appoint as executor? 'We didn't think that was a smart move. It turned out not to be a smart move, because they didn't get any incremental volume,' Black told MarketWatch in an interview on Monday. His Tesla haircuts continued, peppered by such worries as 'hype around unsupervised autonomy,' and when he finally exited it completely at $358 per share, valuation had gotten 'excessive.' Tesla shares need to be priced 'a lot less than they are today' for Black to repurchase. 'I don't want to call this stock uninvestable because at some price we would buy it back again, but with that level of volatility it almost makes the stock uninvestable at times,' he said, adding that Musk needs to 'keep his mouth closed and focus on the business.' Black, whose nearly 30-year career includes stints as CEO of Aegon Asset Management and Janus Capital, and his firm look after about $72 million in One Global, and the Long/Short ETF FFLS, roughly $49 million. One Global has returned 6.5% this year and 15% over three years, annualized, according to Morningstar, versus its MSCI All Country World Index benchmark returns of 7.3% and 14.3%, respectively. Black is now focused on what he sees as big tech bargains, such as Nvidia NVDA. The company's stock-picking process begins with 'ten long-term circular mega trends,' such as e-commerce, 24/7 information technology and, of course, artificial intelligence. 'We like the AI road map in front of [Nvidia] and they still can't make enough of their high-end AI chips. They continue to have extremely high demand for it, and they're still capacity constrained,' he said. Tesla, even with its recent decline, is still trading at 150 times forward earnings, while Nvidia sits at around 32 times, but is growing earnings, Black said. 'If you look at price-to-earnings relative to growth, which is how we think about the world, in a simplistic way, it's still reasonably cheap.' Meta META is also a big position. 'We like the growth we're seeing in Instagram and Facebook and WhatsApp. Again, the stock has done well, but it's still a very cheap stock,' trading at about 27 times earnings, he said. Then there's AMZN, and its vastly expanded offerings. 'You can buy prescription drugs over it now. You can buy tires, you can buy cars. It's become the go-to place if you want to buy anything,' and at around 35 times forward earnings, is now far less expensive, he said. He also flags DoorDash DASH. 'People don't have the time to make their own food anymore, so they order from the restaurants they love and [DoorDash] has gotten more and more restaurants on the platform, and as a result of that, the stock has done extremely well,' he said. Like Nvidia, DoorDash is reasonably priced, trading at 54 times forward earning, he said. His short bets in the Long/Short ETF, are about either poorly positioned companies or companies facing disruption. Those include Booking Holdings BKNG, which is in a 'very competitive business,' he said. 'We don't really see the proprietary technology to allow that to continue to gain share, so we decided that was a good short.' Fintech group Sofi Technologies SOFI is another. 'They've expanded their loans. and we just worry that they've grown too fast. and that's why it's a decent short we believe.' As the S&P 500 SPX continues to push past 6,000, Black says he's still bullish on the market overall, with expectations the Fed will likely to start cutting interest rates, though not as fast as Trump would like. 'I think what has happened because of the tariffs, the odds are you are going to have a first rate cut by September now,' he said. What else worries Black? He points to concerning 'pockets' of the market currently, such as the blockbuster Circle CRCL IPO, of which they didn't take part. 'We have stocks that are trading at very high multiples that aren't related to their earnings growth. We're always wary, especially in the growth space, that you've got speculative excess, and I think there are areas where people are just getting overly exuberant about prospects. And that's always negative,' said Black. Read: 'Big Money' turns bullish on stocks. Will that lead the S&P 500 to a 'melt up'? U.S. stocks SPX DJIA COMP are inching higher, while Treasury yields BX:TMUBMUSD10Y BX:TMUBMUSD02Y drop. Key asset performance Last 5d 1m YTD 1y S&P 500 6005.88 1.18% 2.77% 2.11% 12.03% Nasdaq Composite 19,591.24 1.81% 4.72% 1.45% 13.95% 10-year Treasury 4.456 -1.40 -1.70 -12.00 5.10 Gold 3349.9 -0.80% 2.93% 26.92% 43.53% Oil 65.56 3.50% 3.03% -8.78% -16.14% Data: MarketWatch. Treasury yields change expressed in basis points Need to Know starts early and is updated until the opening bell, but to get it delivered once to your email box. The emailed version will be sent out at about 7:30 a.m. Eastern. Trade talks between the U.S. and China continue in London on Tuesday. Tesla shares TSLA are tracking Monday's gains after more signs of a cooling feud between Musk and President Trump. J.M. Smucker stock SJM is down 7% after mixed results and a weak profit forecast from the food maker. Uber UBER said it's going to pilot self-driving cars in London. Tencent Music TME is reportedly buying China audio platform Ximalaya for $1.26 billion. The shares are rising. GameStop GME reports results after the close, and this analyst isn't that upbeat. A small-business optimism index was slightly more upbeat for May, with those expecting better business conditions at a historical high. Gold and the S&P 500 are chasing record highs at the same time. Here's why that's so rare. The White House marching orders that sparked the L.A. migrant crackdown. Mark Zuckerberg is handpicking a new 'superintelligence' AI team. Here's more evidence institutional investors are buying stocks again. This State Street risk-appetite index, based on the firm's $44 trillion of assets under custody and administration, shows 'long-term investor allocations to equities rose anew in May to levels last seen on the cusp of the Liberation Day announcement in early April,' said Dwyfor Evans, strategist at State Street Global Markets. While flows to stocks rose, investors continued to shun the dollar and U.S. Treasurys, Evans said. These were the most searched tickers on MarketWatch as of 6 a.m. Ticker Security name TSLA Tesla NVDA Nvidia GME GameStop PLTR Palantir Technologies PLUG Plug Power AAPL Apple TSM Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing AMD Advanced Micro Devices KLTO Klotho Neurosciences AMZN Amazon No joke. Comedian on why planes crash. Who you gonna call? Frustrated couple 'steal back' their own Jaguar. 'The situation is extreme': I'm 65 and leaving my estate to only one grandchild. Can the others contest my will? 'I prepaid our mom's rent for a year': My sister is a millionaire and never helps our mother. How do I cut her out of her will? I bought my mother-in-law a condo — and she took out a $30,000 car loan. Now she refuses to get a roommate. How do I make sure my son-in-law doesn't get his hands on my daughter's inheritance? My life partner is 18 years my senior. He wants to leave his $4.5 million fortune to me — not his two kids. Do we tell them? Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Tesla (TSLA) Faces Delivery Slump as Wells Fargo Sticks With $120 Price Target
Tesla (TSLA) Faces Delivery Slump as Wells Fargo Sticks With $120 Price Target

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Tesla (TSLA) Faces Delivery Slump as Wells Fargo Sticks With $120 Price Target

Tesla, Inc. (NASDAQ:) is one of the 10 AI Stocks on Wall Street's Radar. On June 10, Wells Fargo reiterated an 'Underweight' rating on the stock with a $120 price target. The firm is sticking with its underweight rating, stating that the company's Q2 deliveries are 'on track for another poor quarter.' 'Most of TSLA May delivery results are now out. Once again, global deliveries are trending meaningfully weaker, with May trending 23% lower y/y and Q2 QTD trending 21% lower y/y. All three key regions are double-digit % lower, with EU the worst.' North America, Europe, and China— Tesla's key regions— have been experiencing double-digit percentage declines, the firm noted, further revealing that the 'fundamentals of the core auto business continue to weaken.' It further said that 'order' pricing on the website appears stable over the LTM,' but 'aggressive financing promotions continue to act as price cuts.' This, coupled with lower leverage, is a risk to Q2 margins. Attention is now being diverted to Austin Robotaxi deployment on June 12, which the firm doubts 'the likely limited debut will be enough to overshadow the poor fundamentals.' The firm also pointed toward China, Tesla's second-largest market, which is 'trending 22% lower QTD.' The firm asserted how the 'competition in China is beginning to take its toll on TSLA's business,' as local OEMs like BYD (SZ:002594) and Chery 'continue to undercut TSLA on pricing.' While we acknowledge the potential of TSLA as an investment, we believe certain AI stocks offer greater upside potential and carry less downside risk. If you're looking for an extremely undervalued AI stock that also stands to benefit significantly from Trump-era tariffs and the onshoring trend, see our free report on the best short-term AI stock. READ NEXT: and Disclosure: None. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Attorney Amy Witherite: Red Flags Emerge Just as Elon Musk Plans to Put Robotaxis on Austin Streets
Attorney Amy Witherite: Red Flags Emerge Just as Elon Musk Plans to Put Robotaxis on Austin Streets

Business Wire

time2 hours ago

  • Business Wire

Attorney Amy Witherite: Red Flags Emerge Just as Elon Musk Plans to Put Robotaxis on Austin Streets

DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--A dispute between Tesla (TSLA.O) and the Reuters news organization is raising red flags just as Tesla plans to roll out Model Y robotaxis in Austin, Texas, warns attorney and safety expert Amy Witherite, founder of the Witherite Law Group. Tesla's challenging a Texas Public Records Act request by Reuters for its communications with Austin city officials. In justifying the request an attorney for Reuters wrote that Tesla's intent to deploy the unproven technology on Texas roadways makes its plans 'an issue of enormous importance to Texas and the public at large' and underscored the public's right to know. 'If there was ever a need for complete transparency it is in the largely unregulated business of autonomous cars and trucks,' said Witherite, whose law firm represents the victims of auto and truck accidents. According to the American Automobile Association's (AAA) latest survey on autonomous vehicles, only 13% of U.S. drivers would trust riding in self-driving vehicles – an increase from last year, when this number was 9%. Despite this slight increase, 6 in 10 U.S. drivers still report being afraid to ride in a self-driving vehicle. 'Currently there is no national safety performance standard for driverless vehicles,' notes Witherite. 'Regulators have generally given free rein to companies allowing them to test their technology in cities such as Austin at the expense of the public's safety. Federal regulators are also asking Tesla tough questions. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) recently sent Tesla a letter demanding additional information "to assess the ability of Tesla's system to react appropriately to reduced roadway visibility conditions." The agency opened an investigation in October into 2.4 million Tesla vehicles equipped with full self-driving (FSD) technology following four reported collisions, including a fatal one in 2023. 'If Tesla, or any other company, wants to put driverless vehicles on Austin streets they have an obligation to allow the public to be fully informed, especially since there are so many unanswered questions concerning the safety of these vehicles,' said Witherite. The Texas Attorney General's office is reviewing Tesla's confidentiality claims and will determine what if any information can be released. The Witherite Law Group specializes in vehicle accident cases and offers crucial support for individuals involved in accidents with driverless vehicles. For more information visit their website:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store