"Superstars can win me games" - KCP explains why Mitchell and Haliburton aren't superstars
Two-time NBA champion Kentavious Caldwell-Pope issued a bold statement about Cleveland Cavaliers shooting guard Donovan Mitchell and Indiana Pacers point guard Tyrese Haliburton during his recent guest appearance on Jordan McGruder's "Dawg Talk" podcast.
Advertisement
Caldwell-Pope, who was recently traded from the Orlando Magic to the Memphis Grizzlies in the Desmond Bane deal, said that while Mitchell and Haliburton are the franchise players of their respective teams, they have not yet achieved superstar status.
"No," he responded when asked if he thought Haliburton was a superstar. "I wouldn't even build a team around Donovan Mitchell either. He's a 'superstar,' but superstars can win me games. Can he do that consistently every night? Go out there and try to win me a game? Can he average 25, 8, and 8? Bron did his whole career."
KCP has played with Bron and Joker
Caldwell-Pope has played long enough in the league to know what a superstar player is. When he played for the Los Angeles Lakers, he was a teammate of LeBron James, and they won the 2020 NBA title. After L.A., KCP suited up for the Denver Nuggets and was on the same squad as Nikola Jokic. He won his second title there with the Serbian center.
Advertisement
Meanwhile, Mitchell has been an All-Star in each of the last six seasons. He's made the playoffs every year in his career but has never led any of his teams past the second round of the playoffs. On the other hand, Haliburton has made the All-NBA third team in each of the last two seasons. He's taken the Pacers to back-to-back ECF appearances, including a trip to the NBA Finals this year.
When comparing the two, KCP likes Hali's chances of reaching superstar status. In fact, Tyrese is already on his way there.
"We're talking about getting teams involved, getting players involved, like going out and when my team needs me to win, I'm gonna go get this win. I can't do that with Donovan Mitchell, and I'm 50/50 with Haliburton. Because Haliburton can average 25-8-8. But for me, he's clutch now, but consistently throughout the game. I need you to be consistent with shooting the ball, playmaking, and all that. He's getting there but still inconsistent," KCP added.
Related: "After much consideration, I am now prepared to rule" - When Utah judge ruled Michael Jordan pushed off in his final shot in '98
Hali beat Spida in the Playoffs
Coincidentally, Mitchell and Haliburton faced off in the second round of the 2025 playoffs. Despite having a home-court advantage, Donovan could not lead his Cavaliers against Tyrese's underdog Pacers.
Advertisement
After Indiana stole Game 1 in Cleveland, they repeated in Game 2 with Haliburton knocking down the game-winning basket. With two points down and time winding down, Hali hit a step-back three-pointer to give the Pacers the 120-119 win. Mitchell had 43 in Game 3 as the Cavs cut the deficit to 1-2. However, the Pacers proved to be too tough for the Cavs as they completed a "Gentleman's Sweep".
Donovan and Tyrese are some of the best players in the NBA today, and one can argue that they are already superstars in their own right. But if we consider Kenatvious' definition, he has a reason to put Hali in a better spot than Spida because Tyrese has been to back-to-back ECFs and Finals, while Donovan has never seen the postseason after the second round.
Related: T-Mac doesn't think Haliburton is a superstar: "He is a really good basketball player on a really good basketball team"
This story was originally reported by Basketball Network on Jul 4, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
29 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Sophie Cunningham leaves Fever's overtime win over Sun with a knee injury
Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham was ruled out of Sunday's game against the Connecticut Sun with a knee injury, marking the latest injury to a Fever squad that has already been decimated. The injury occurred during the second quarter of Indiana's 99-93 overtime victory when Connecticut guard Bria Hartley drove to the basket, fell and collided with Cunningham's leg on her way down. [Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2025 NFL season] Cunningham stayed down clutching her right knee in pain as the rest of the team went to the other side of the court. She was helped off the court and into the locker room, wearing a towel over her head. After Cunningham went down, the Fever battled back to win. Despite Connecticut being up by as many as 21 points, Indiana forced OT after a stellar 32-point fourth quarter. Fever guard Kelsey Mitchell finished with 38 points, tying a season high; 34 of those points came after halftime. After the game, Cunningham did not comment on the injury, but praised Mitchell for her stellar performance on X. Cunningham's sister, Lindsey, took to X after the game to point blame at the officials for the injury. "@WNBA maybe you should focus less on fining players for commenting on your poor officiating & more about hiring officials that are able to call a consistent game and protect your athletes," she wrote, with Sophie Cunningham reposting her sister's message. Cunningham has been fined twice by the league for complaints about officiating. Cunningham's injury is the latest for the Fever, who have lost most of their guards due to injury. Caitlin Clark has missed most of the season with a groin injury, while the other two point guards — Aari McDonald and veteran Sydney Colson — both suffered season-ending injuries in a loss to the Phoenix Mercury earlier this month. Colson went down with an ACL tear, while McDonald suffered a broken bone in her foot. Last week, the Fever signed veteran guard Odyssey Sims to a hardship contract to help replenish their point guard depth. Sims made her first start for Indiana on Sunday.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
Guardians notes: Parker Messick, Triston McKenzie, Tyler Naquin, Daniel Espino and more
CLEVELAND — The Cleveland Guardians need a starting pitcher for Wednesday. They didn't have to need a starter for Wednesday, but they chose to need one. They optioned Joey Cantillo to Triple-A Columbus, and tasked him with peppering the strike zone with fastballs and changeups and curveballs. He had been doing that in the big leagues, just not as consistently as he or the club would have preferred. Advertisement In his last five starts, Cantillo has issued 16 walks in 25 1/3 innings. That's a lot of self-inflicted stress. However, Cantillo has recorded a 3.55 ERA in that stretch. There's nothing wrong with that (though it makes you wonder what his ceiling is if he can nibble less). When asked why Cantillo can't simply work on his strike-throwing at the big-league level, assistant GM Matt Forman said, well, some words that would lead one to think this isn't actually about Cantillo. 'Decisions like this are tough,' Forman said. 'There are a lot of factors that go into those. We're balancing winning and development.' So, really, this could be a convenient way to get a look at someone else in the rotation. No, it won't be John Means, who tossed 38 pitches in a rehab start for Class A Lake County on Friday. Means is expected to make another rehab start this week, and could stretch out to about 50 pitches. He'll be part of the equation in September. What about Parker Messick, Cleveland's second-round pick out of Florida State in 2022? If the Guardians, say, tab Messick to start in Arizona this week, there's room to add him to the 40-man roster, since the club recently outrighted Trevor Stephan to clear a spot. Messick has posted a 3.47 ERA in 20 starts at Columbus this season, with 42 walks and 119 strikeouts in 98 2/3 innings. The Athletic's Keith Law wrote this spring that Messick 'has excellent deception and moves quickly through his delivery, which seems to help keep hitters off balance,' and that he profiled as a No. 3 starter with above-average upside. Messick has boosted his velocity the last two years and added a sinker to his repertoire. 'He's answered the call,' said Stephen Osterer, Cleveland's director of player development. Now, will he get the call? The Guardians are still weighing their options for the opportunity — one they intentionally created. Advertisement When did you last think about McKenzie, the former Robin to Shane Bieber's Batman act in Cleveland's rotation? The 28-year-old made four appearances for the Guardians at the start of the regular season before he was designated for assignment. McKenzie has spent the last four months pitching against teenagers at the Guardians' complex in Goodyear, Ariz. He finally escaped the desert, and pitched for Triple-A Columbus on Sunday. McKenzie allowed an unearned run and two walks in one inning. His fastball sat in the 93-96 mph range. He'll continue to work out of the Columbus bullpen. He can become a minor-league free agent at the end of the season. 'It's been a long road for Triston,' Osterer said. … 'In a lot of ways, it did challenge Triston, but he's come out in a pretty good spot right now. We're excited to see what he can do for the next few weeks.' The Triple-A Columbus Clippers have one month of games remaining, so the clock is ticking for DeLauter and Brito as they work back from injuries that might have cost them a 2025 big-league debut. DeLauter is a little more than three weeks removed from an operation to remove the hook of the hamate bone in his right hand. The customary timetable for a return from that procedure is six to eight weeks. He has resumed baseball activity and was trending toward a major-league promotion when he started to experience the pain that ultimately led to the surgery. Because of a variety of injuries, DeLauter has appeared in only 138 games since the Guardians selected him in the first round of the 2022 draft. 'It can wear out a player mentally, going through it again,' Osterer said, 'and especially when it's a different part of the body. … He's come a long way in the last couple years (in how to deal) with these things.' Advertisement Brito, meanwhile, is about six weeks removed from suffering a severe right hamstring strain. He has resumed swinging, throwing and doing some defensive drills. Now, he just needs to build up his running. The typical timeframe for a return to game action is eight to 12 weeks. Brito has totaled 24 games at Triple A this season, thanks to a pair of significant injuries. He was contending for the Guardians' Opening Day second base gig in spring training. Now, he's on the verge of a mostly wasted season. There might not be a minor-league bat sizzling more than the one Ralphy Velazquez has been wielding the last two months. Over the last seven weeks, he boasts a .360/.440/.691 slash line. The Guardians promoted Velazquez to Double-A Akron last week, and the first baseman's production hasn't slowed against stiffer competition. Consider his first four games at the affiliate: 1. 1-for-4 with a triple and a walk 2. 2-for-4 with a double 3. 3-for-4 with two homers, a double and a walk 4. 3-for-5 with a homer, a double and a walk Velazquez, who turned 20 in late May, is one of the youngest players at the Double-A level. (According to the Guardians' data, there are only four position players and one pitcher younger than Velazquez.) He had a slow start at Class A Lake County this season, but Cleveland's front office evaluators figured a turnaround was inevitable, given his promising underlying metrics. Velazquez leads all Cleveland prospects this season with 20 home runs. Just as Shane Bieber prepares for his first big-league outing this week since April 2, 2024, the prospect the Guardians received from the Blue Jays in exchange for Bieber last month is nearing a return to game action. Stephen, whom MLB Pipeline placed seventh on Cleveland's top prospects list, was dealing with a right shoulder impingement at the time of the trade. He threw a live bullpen on Friday and will throw another two-inning session this week. The Guardians believe he could help their big-league club as soon as next season. Advertisement Hentges last pitched on July 10, 2024, before he underwent surgery to repair the anterior capsule in his left shoulder. The goal is for him to be healthy when he arrives at spring training in February. (Well, he's technically already there, since he lives in the area and has been rehabbing at the team's facility since the procedure.) He is expected to begin a mound progression in September. Espino last appeared in a game in April 2022. Since then, he has endured a pair of shoulder surgeries, and conversation about the former top prospect has shifted from 'Did you see how hard he threw and how many strikeouts he racked up?' to 'Remember him?' Espino has been throwing at the club's Arizona complex in recent months, with some periods of recovery built into his program. He recently completed one of those de-load stretches and has resumed throwing bullpen sessions. He will not pitch at an affiliate this year. 'When we first had him and he was younger,' Osterer said, 'he was very detail-oriented and every single thing that he did had a purpose. He still has that, but he's a little bit more lenient on himself. He gives himself a little bit more grace and doesn't wear it as much. … The resilience there is just off the charts.' Imagine being told a few years ago that Naquin would be ahead of McKenzie on the organization's pitching depth chart in 2025. OK, so maybe that isn't exactly the case now that McKenzie has returned to Columbus and Naquin is a work in progress, but what a bizarre path both players have traveled. Naquin, who has switched to pitching, has reached a bit of a rough patch at Lake County. He has walked three in back-to-back outings, and he needed 35 pitches to record two outs on Sunday. Of course, every development with him comes with the caveat that, after 12 years in the professional ranks as an outfielder, he's still new to this pitching thing. And the Guardians are encouraged by the growth he's demonstrated. Osterer said Naquin's fastball is clocking in at 92-96 mph. 'He has pretty good stuff,' Osterer said. 'It's just the consistency of it. In fairness to Tyler, he hasn't done it a ton. It has been arrow up. He has gotten a lot better.' (Top photo of Parker Messick: Brett Davis / Imagn Images) Spot the pattern. Connect the terms Find the hidden link between sports terms Play today's puzzle
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Sophie Cunningham leaves Fever's overtime win over Sun with a knee injury
Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham was ruled out of Sunday's game against the Connecticut Sun with a knee injury, marking the latest injury to a Fever squad that has already been decimated. The injury occurred during the second quarter of Indiana's 99-93 overtime victory when Connecticut guard Bria Hartley drove to the basket, fell and collided with Cunningham's leg on her way down. [Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2025 NFL season] Cunningham stayed down clutching her right knee in pain as the rest of the team went to the other side of the court. She was helped off the court and into the locker room, wearing a towel over her head. Cunningham's injury is the latest for the Fever, who have lost most of their guards due to injury. Caitlin Clark has missed most of the season with a groin injury, while the other two point guards — Aari McDonald and veteran Sydney Colson — both suffered season-ending injuries in a loss to the Phoenix Mercury earlier this month. Colson went down with an ACL tear, while McDonald suffered a broken bone in her foot. Last week, the Fever signed veteran guard Odyssey Sims to a hardship contract to help replenish their point guard depth. Sims made her first start for Indiana on Sunday. After Cunningham went down, the Fever battled back to win. Despite Connecticut being up by as many as 21 points, Indiana forced OT after a stellar 32-point fourth quarter. Fever guard Kelsey Mitchell finished with 38 points, tying a season high; 34 of those points came after halftime.
