‘Soft resistance' involves using false statements to create misunderstanding about authorities, justice sec. says
Speaking to local media outlets in interviews published on Monday, the fifth anniversary of the Beijing-imposed national security law, Lam said methods of soft resistance may not always be illegal – but that did not mean they would not harm society.
He said there were three main elements of soft resistance – making false or misleading statements; expressing them irrationally and with emotional bias; and with the intention of creating misunderstanding about the Chinese and Hong Kong governments and their policies.
Lam's interview marks the first time authorities have explained what soft resistance is. Since 2021, Chinese and Hong Kong officials have cited the phrase as a threat to national security, but have not been specific about what it means.
The justice secretary said soft resistance was difficult to define, and the government would not use the label arbitrarily.
Ahead of the fifth anniversary of the Beijing-imposed national security law, high-ranking officials have given media interviews addressing 'soft resistance' in areas ranging from arts and culture to development and medicine.
The term was first used in 2021 by the then-director of China's Liaison Office in Hong Kong Luo Huining, who warned that Hong Kong must regulate 'soft resistance' in addition to cracking down on 'hard resistance.'
Last week, Chief Executive John Lee said in a press conference that soft resistance is 'real' and is 'lurking across different areas and different sectors.'
'Different views' still allowed
Speaking to HK01, Lam said citizens can have 'different views' about the government, including negative views, but such opinions must be based on 'objective facts.'
Soft resistance cannot be condoned, he told the media outlet.
'If it creates a negative impact, it would affect society's overall stability, hinder the building of consensus in society, and stand in the way of Hong Kong's collective effort of driving development,' he said in Chinese.
Just because not all soft resistance methods may be illegal, this did not mean that society could ignore them, he said.
'Not all issues in society should be addressed by legal means. [Legal means] are also not always the most effective way of handling [matters],' Lam said.
Beijing imposed a national security law in Hong Kong on June 30, 2020 following a year of pro-democracy protests and unrest over a controversial extradition bill.
It criminalised subversion, secession, collusion with foreign forces and terrorist acts, which were broadly defined to include disruption to transport and other infrastructure.
The move gave police sweeping new powers, alarming democrats, civil society groups and trade partners, as such laws have been used broadly to silence and punish dissidents in China.
However, authorities say it has restored stability and peace to the city.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
27 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
From seas to space: China's Type 815A spy ships are keeping PLA Navy informed and ready
China's Type 815A spy ships have become pivotal to People's Liberation Army naval operations and intelligence gathering, with recent incidents underscoring the vessels' crucial role in Beijing's maritime surveillance and power projection. On July 12, the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) reported the interception of the Type 815A electronic surveillance ship Tianwangxing (hull number 793) operating about 69 nautical miles (128km) off the western Philippines, within Manila's exclusive economic zone. Despite repeated radio challenges from the flagship PCG vessel Teresa Magbanua, the Tianwangxing remained unresponsive while the accompanying China Coast Guard (CCG) ship undertook manoeuvres described by the PCG as 'asserting Beijing's jurisdiction over the disputed waters'. The Chinese spy ship, accompanied by the CCG's Zhaojun-class cutter 4203 and later joined by PLA Navy Type 052D guided missile destroyer Guilin (hull number 164), was conducting what appeared to be intelligence-gathering operations during the US-Philippine Cope Thunder aerial combat exercise. The drills, carried out on July 7-18, saw America's most advanced F-35A Lightning II stealth fighters deployed to the Philippines for the first time. In April, the Japanese defence ministry also reported spotting two PLA Navy Type 815A spy ships near Japan's southwestern islands. It said Japanese naval vessels closely monitored the Yuhengxing (hull number 798) and the Kaiyangxing (hull number 796) as they made their way from the Philippine Sea to the East China Sea, the first one passing through the strategic Miyako Strait and the other sailing between Taiwan and Japan's Yonaguni Island.
RTHK
an hour ago
- RTHK
China, US to seek tariffs truce extension after talks
China, US to seek tariffs truce extension after talks Vice Premier He Lifeng called on the two sides to deepen dialogue and reduce misunderstandings. Photo: Reuters Chinese and US officials have agreed to seek an extension of their 90-day tariff truce, after the latest two-day round of talks to reach a trade deal ahead of an August 12 deadline. China's international trade representative Li Chenggang said the talks in Stockholm were "candid, in-depth, constructive", according to the Xinhua News Agency. The two countries exchanged views on major trade and economic concerns, Li said, and are due to maintain close communications. Xinhua also quoted Vice Premier He Lifeng as saying that the United States should work with China to continue to enhance consensus, reduce misunderstandings, strengthen cooperation, further deepen dialogue and consultations, and strive for more win-win outcomes. A stable, healthy and sustainable China-US economic and trade relationship serves not only the two countries' respective development goals but also contributes to global economic growth and stability, He said. US officials, meanwhile, said it was up to President Donald Trump to decide whether to extend a trade truce that expires on August 12 or potentially let tariffs shoot back up to triple-digit figures. But US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent tamped down any expectation of Trump rejecting the extension. "The meetings were very constructive," Bessent told reporters after the meetings wrapped up. "It's just that we haven't given the signoff." As Trump returned to Washington after visiting Scotland, where he inked a trade deal with the European Union, he said Bessent had just briefed him on the China talks. "He felt very good about the meeting, better than he felt yesterday," Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One. Bessent said there would likely be another meeting between the two sides in about 90 days, and the agreements on the flow of Chinese rare earths were becoming more refined after previous talks in Geneva and London. "There was good personal interaction being built up, good, mutual respect. I think we understand their agenda much better," he said. The truce between China and the United States, the world's two largest economies, has temporarily set US duties on Chinese goods at 30 percent, and Chinese levies on US ones at 10 percent. That accord, reached in Geneva in May, brought down the tariffs each side had levelled at the other after Trump embarked on his trade war. (Agencies)
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
‘Father of Shue Yan' dedicated his life to benevolent education in Hong Kong
The Chinese saying that it takes 10 years to grow a tree but 100 years to nurture a talent encapsulates the dedication required in education. This noble mission was behind Henry Hu Hung-lick forking out his savings to establish Shue Yan College, Hong Kong's first private higher education institution, more than half a century ago, with a name that resonates with that spirit – cultivating virtues of benevolence. The revered educator, who died at the age of 105 this week, will be remembered for his lifelong endeavour in transforming generations of students and reshaping the city's education landscape. Hu and his late wife, Dr Chung Chi-yung, broke new ground with Shue Yan College in the 1970s, when the city was not known for private universities or a culture of philanthropic support for centres of learning. With publicly funded degree places still confined to the crème de la crème in those days, the couple's admirable but lofty goal of liberalising higher education might have raised some eyebrows. But their pioneering venture and selfless contribution have offered life-changing opportunities for countless students over the decades. Among the prominent Shue Yan alumni is Chief Secretary Eric Chan Kwok-ki. Hu is a role model for learning. The Zhejiang-born graduate of the National University of Political Science also spoke Russian and French. He served as a diplomat in Tashkent in present-day Uzbekistan, studied law and international politics in France and took the Bar exams in Britain in 1954. A member of the Legislative Council and the now-defunct Urban Council, Hu was also known for his work as the defence counsel in a high-profile murder case in 1975. He was an example of not giving up easily. His commitment to providing four-year courses, with an emphasis on Chinese culture and the liberal arts, instead of the usual three-year course, was an obstacle to obtaining government funding. While Shue Yan gained recognition as a private post-secondary institution in 1976, it was not until 2006 that it became Hong Kong's first private university. Hu was awarded the highest honour of the Grand Bauhinia Medal in 2008 for his lifelong contributions to society; his wife received the Gold Bauhinia Star in 2000. Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu praised Hu for devoting 'substantial financial resources and personal effort to the development of Hong Kong's post-secondary education, nurturing generations of virtuous talent for Hong Kong'.
