Reviving Pak-BD ties
EDITORIAL: Relations between the two South Asian cousins, Pakistan and Bangladesh, have been improving since former prime minister Sheikh Hasina was ousted last August in a students-led mass uprising and fled to India. Foreign Secretary Amna Baloch arrived in Dhaka on Thursday for the resumption of formal talks after a 15-year-long hiatus. There have been several high-level informal exchanges, however.
Last September Bangladesh's interim leader Nobel Peace Prize laureate Muhammad Yunus met with Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on the sidelines of UN General Assembly session; and again, in December at the D-8 Summit in Cairo. The next month, i.e. January last, a six-member military delegation, led by Lt-Gen S M Kamrul Hasan, made an exceptional visit to Pakistan and called on the three armed forces chiefs and also held discussions with other high-ranking officers. Then in February Bangladeshi navy participated in a multinational maritime exercises held off the Karachi coast.
These interactions are reflective of a strong mutual desire to revitalize relations. According to media reports, while the government-to-government talks were resumed two months ago, before then a container ship carrying 50,000 tons of rice had sailed from Karachi to Chittagong for the first time since 1971. And direct private trade had already started in November last. There is a lot of room for increasing bilateral trade which at present stands around $700 million annually. Meanwhile, visa procedures have been simplified as direct flights between the two countries are expected to be resumed soon. Our Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar is also scheduled to go on a two-day visit to Bangladesh later this month. All this would have been unthinkable under Sheikh Hasina, who had no inclination to let the bygones be bygones, whether that involved citizens of her own country – in 2015, her government sent two opposition leaders to the gallows allegedly for committing war crimes during the 1971 war of secession — or relations with Pakistan which she regularly criticised. Cozying up to India, she ruled with an iron hand that finally led to her undoing and exile to India.
Some of the old issues, nevertheless, still linger on. Dhaka reportedly has been preparing to formally raise its demand for USF 4.52 billion in financial compensation from Pakistan. After Thursday's meeting with Amna Baloch Bangladesh's Foreign Secretary Jashim Uddin said his side had raised historically 'unsettled issues' with Pakistan, including a formal public apology for the events of 1971, as well as monetary compensation. None of this is likely to yield the sought outcome. However, the two sides also discussed expansion of trade and commerce as well as increasing cooperation in agriculture and other sectors. Baloch also called on Yunus who while emphasising strengthening of ties with Pakistan to boost mutual cooperation and explore trade and business potential, said 'there are certain hurdles. We have to find ways to overcome those and move forward.' Both sides can do that without prejudice to their respective positions on old and unresolved emotive issues.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
India pushes back 'foreigners' into Bangladesh, sparking human rights concerns
Police officers stand next to men they believe to be undocumented Bangladeshi nationals after they were detained during raids in Ahmedabad, India, April 26, 2025. PHOTO: REUTERS Listen to article India has started to push people it considers illegal immigrants into neighbouring Bangladesh, but human rights activists say authorities are arbitrarily throwing people out of the country. Since May, the northeastern Indian state of Assam has "pushed back" 303 people into Bangladesh out of 30,000 declared as foreigners by various tribunals over the years, a top official said this week. Such people in Assam are typically long-term residents with families and land in the state, which is home to tens of thousands of families tracing their roots to Muslim-majority Bangladesh. Activists say many of them and their families are often wrongly classified as foreigners in mainly Hindu India and are too poor to challenge tribunal judgements in higher courts. Some activists, who did not want to be named for fear of reprisal, said only Muslims had been targeted in the expulsion drive. An Assam government spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Assam, which has a 260 km (160 mile) border with Bangladesh, started sending back people last month who had been declared as foreigners by its Foreigners Tribunals. Such a move is politically popular in Assam, where Bengali language speakers with possible roots in Bangladesh compete for jobs and resources with local Assamese speakers. "There is pressure from the Supreme Court to act on the expulsion of foreigners," Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma told the state assembly on Monday. "We have pushed back 303 people. These pushbacks will be intensified. We have to be more active and proactive to save the state." He was referring to the Supreme Court asking Assam in February why it had not moved on deporting, opens new tab declared foreigners. Bangladesh's foreign affairs adviser, Touhid Hossain, did not immediately reply to an email seeking comment. Last week, he told reporters that people were being sent to his country from India and that the government was in touch with New Delhi over it. Aman Wadud, an Assam-based lawyer who routinely fights citizenship cases and is now a member of the main opposition Congress party, said the government was "arbitrarily throwing people out of the country". "There is a lot of panic on the ground - more than ever before," he said. Some brought back Sarma said no genuine Indian citizens will be expelled. But he added that up to four of the people deported were brought back to India because appeals challenging their non-Indian status were being heard in court. One of them was Khairul Islam, a 51-year-old former government school teacher who was declared a foreigner by a tribunal in 2016. He spent two years in an Assam detention centre and was released on bail in August 2020. He said police picked him up on May 23 from his home and took him to a detention centre, from where he and 31 others were rounded up by Indian border guards and loaded into a van, blindfolded and hands tied. "Then, 14 of us were put onto another truck. We were taken to a spot along the border and pushed into Bangladesh," he said. "It was terrifying. I've never experienced anything like it. It was late at night. There was a straight road, and we all started walking along it." Islam said residents of a Bangladeshi village then called the Border Guard Bangladesh, who then pushed the group of 14 into the "no man's land between the two countries". "All day we stood there in the open field under the harsh sun," he said. Later, the group was taken to a Bangladesh guards camp while Islam's wife told police in Assam that as his case was still pending in court, he should be brought back. "After a few days, I was suddenly handed back to Indian police," he said. "That's how I made my way back home. I have no idea what happened to the others who were with me, or where they are." It is not only Assam that is acting against people deemed to be living illegally in the country. Police in the western city of Ahmedabad said they have identified more than 250 people "confirmed to be Bangladeshi immigrants living illegally here". "The process to deport them is in progress," said senior police officer Ajit Rajian.
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan likely to hike defence spending but slash overall budget in 2025-26
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan will unveil its annual federal budget for the coming fiscal year later on Tuesday, seeking to kickstart growth while finding resources for an expected hike in defence expenditure following the conflict with India last month. Islamabad will also have to contend with remaining within the discipline of its International Monetary Fund programme and the uncertainty from new trade tariffs being imposed by the United States, its biggest export market. Media reports say the government is likely to present a 17.6 trillion rupee ($62.45 billion) budget for the fiscal year beginning July 1, down 6.7% from this fiscal year. It has projected a fiscal deficit of 4.8% of GDP, against a targeted 5.9% deficit in 2024-25, the reports say. Analysts said they expect an increase of around 20% in the defence budget, likely offset by cuts in development spending. Pakistan allocated 2.1 trillion Pakistani rupees($7.45 billion) for defence in the outgoing fiscal year, including $2 billion for equipment and other assets. An additional 563 billion rupees ($1.99 billion) was set aside for military pensions, which are not counted within the official defence budget. India's defence spending in its 2025–26 (April-March) fiscal year was set at $78.7 billion, a 9.5% increase from the previous year, including pensions and $21 billion earmarked for equipment. It has indicated it will step up expenditure following the May conflict with Pakistan. The government of Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has projected 4.2% economic growth in 2025-26, saying it has steadied the economy, which had looked at risk of defaulting on its debts as recently as 2023. Growth this fiscal year is likely to be 2.7%, against an initial target of 3.6% set in the budget last year. Economic Survey 2024-25: Pakistan misses growth target Pakistan's growth lags far behind the region. In 2024, South Asian countries grew by an average of 5.8% and 6.0% growth is expected in 2025, according to the Asian Development Bank. Rate cuts not enough Expansion of the economy should be aided by a sharp drop in the cost of borrowing, the government says, after a succession of interest rate cuts by the central bank. But economists warn that monetary policy alone may not be enough, with fiscal constraints and IMF-mandated reforms still weighing on investment. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb said on Monday that he wanted to avoid Pakistan's boom and bust cycles of the past. 'The macroeconomic stability that we have achieved, we want to absolutely stay the course,' he said. 'This time around we are very, very clear that we do not want to squander the opportunity.' The budget is expected to prioritize expanding the tax base, enforcing agriculture income tax laws, and reducing government subsidies to industry, to meet the terms of a $7 billion IMF bailout signed last summer. Just 1.3% of the population paid income tax in 2024, according to the tax authorities, with agriculture and the retail sector largely outside of the tax net. The IMF has urged Pakistan to widen the tax base through reforms which include taxing agriculture, retail, and real estate. Ahmad Mobeen, senior economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence, said that he expected the revenue target for 2025-26 will be missed. 'The shortfall will mostly be owing to lack of optimal implementation of announced measures as well as absence of meaningful structural reforms to widen the tax net in general,' said Mobeen.
Express Tribune
17 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Bangladesh's growing predicament
Steps taken by the interim government of Dr Mohammad Yunus like banning Awami League, removing the picture of Bangladesh founder Sheikh Mujibur Rehman from currency notes and erasing from textbooks the role of Awami League in freedom struggle reflect a paradigm shift in Dhaka's narrative about a political party which spearheaded the country's freedom movement. Around a year has passed since Dr Yunus took the reins of government following the exit of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina from power and her taking refuge in India. Finally succumbing to pressure, Dr Yunus announced the holding of general elections in April 2026. Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) which suffered Sheikh Hasina's wrath for more than 15 years initially supported the Yunus regime but then took an aggressive stance against it, urging Yunus to announce elections at the earliest. Why has BNP, a beneficiary of Sheikh Hasina's exit from power, turned against Dr Yunus? What is the future of the banned Awami League? How are the fault lines in Bangladesh related to its economy, politics, governance, military and India are deepening its predicament? Dr Yunus has recently made it clear that elections will be held in April 2026 but his opponents are not ready to trust him and allege that he is trying to prolong his rule by amplifying controversial issues like banning Awami League, giving space to Islamist political parties and groups and relying too much on China for supporting the country's economy. In order to gain some credibility for his regime, Dr Yunus in late 2024 established reform commissions aimed at bettering institutions so that meaningful general elections could be held. On February 8, 2025 Dhaka Tribune reported the formation of six reform commissions - on Constitution, Election Commission, Police Reform, Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC), Public Administration and Judiciary. The reports on the commissions were also published on the Cabinet Division's website. The reform commission about political parties held several meeting but remained inconclusive. It was a gigantic task for the Yunus regime to reform centres of power as he lamented that Bangladesh is in a quandary because of rampant corruption, nepotism as well as politicisation of bureaucracy, judiciary, education and economy. Unfortunately, the reform commissions failed to move ahead. BNP alleged that the Yunus regime was trying to gain time under the cover of reform commissions. One needs to analyse Bangladesh's growing predicament amidst the announcement of elections in April 2026 from three angles. First, the credibility of the Yunus regime is questionable because it does not have any legal or constitutional status nor does it enjoy the public mandate. The only legitimacy is has is that when Sheikh Hasina fled to India and her government collapsed, the Supreme Court of Bangladesh allowed the President to take oath from Dr Mohammad Yunus as the caretaker Chief Adviser. In order to win some legitimacy, Yunus should have gone for a public referendum, but he continued as the head of the government and pledged to hold elections after reforming institutions latest by June 2026. Later on, he advanced the election date to April 2026. Critics argue that instead of focusing on the economy, governance and reforms, Yunus has conducted 11 foreign tours during the 10 months of his rule so far. The Yunus regime supporters, like the newly formed National Citizens Party (NCP) of student leader Nahid Islam and Jamaat-i-Islami, feel concerned about the growing popular chagrin against the caretaker government. Initially, the Yunus regime tried to take advantage of the Awami League government's repression against the protesting students that resulted in the killing of more than 1,400 people. Second, Army Chief General Waker-uz-Zaman who was supportive to the Yunus regime and provided him space to run the government is now giving a different message. In his neutral and professional position, the Army Chief cannot remain oblivious to ground realities. He has also called for early elections. According to AFP, addressing officers of Bangladesh military on May 21, the Army Chief said, "Bangladesh is passing through a chaotic phase. The situation is worsening. The structure of the civil administration and law enforcement agencies has collapsed and failed to reconstitute." He called for holding general elections by December 2025 in order to pull the country from the prevailing crisis. This clearly means loss of military support to the Yunus regime and its further fragility. Third, India is closely watching the current political situation in Bangladesh. New Delhi is exerting pressure on the Yunus regime to abandon what it perceives as anti-Indian stance. A section of the Indian media and the Modi government leave no issue to criticise the Yunus regime - whether it is the banning of Awami League, reported construction of an airbase with the Chinese assistance in north Bengal's city Lal Monirhat, Dhaka's growing rapport with Pakistan or the rise of Islamist forces in Bangladesh. Dhaka criticises New Delhi on why it has allowed Sheikh Hasina to launch hostile tirade against the Yunus regime and why despite official request it has not handed her over to Bangladesh. Bangladesh also accuses India of using the 'Hindu' minority card to blame the Yunus regime. Decades of deep-rooted influence of India's RAW in Bangladesh - permeating in academia, civil society, bureaucracy, judiciary and other segments of society - is making it difficult for the Yunus regime to take an independent position. Surrounded by three sides from India and economically dependent, Bangladesh is trying to get space by reaching out to China and other countries. In order to penalise Bangladesh over its refusal to follow a pro-India stance, Delhi has imposed trade restrictions so that Dhaka capitulates. In order to deal with its growing predicament, the Yunus regime has announced general elections to be held in April 2026, but one is not sure to what extent Bangladesh will be able to ensure transparent elections within the next 10 months. The coming months will be decisive regarding the approach of the caretaker government and political parties to deal with coming elections.
