Judge nixes Biden-era rule removing medical debt from credit reports
Dive Brief:
A federal judge has vacated a rule from the Biden administration that would have removed medical debt from credit reports, in a win for the credit reporting industry.
Judge Sean Jordan, a Trump appointee, said that the rule exceeded the authority of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, an independent agency that's been carved out by cuts under the Trump administration.
The CFPB had finalized the rule in January, weeks before former President Joe Biden left office. The Biden administration estimated the regulation, which never went into effect due to legal challenges, would have removed almost $50 billion of medical debt from the credit reports of some 15 million Americans.
Dive Insight:
Two credit reporting trade associations, the Cornerstone Credit Union and the Consumer Data Industry Association, sued to overturn the CFPB's rule earlier this year. The rule would cut into revenue such groups earn from training providers on how to submit medical debt data to credit reporting agencies.
Credit reporting agencies also argued that the rule would make it hard for lenders to get an accurate picture of a consumer's financial status in making loan determinations.
The hollowed-out CFPB under Trump declined to defend its regulation in court. Though a group of clinics and individuals with medical debt stepped up as intervening defendants in the litigation, their arguments were unsuccessful in swaying Jordan that the rule should go into effect.
According to the judge, the Fair Credit Reporting Act of 1970 allows reporting agencies to include information about consumers' medical debt and lenders to consider such information when making credit decisions. The CFPB overstepped in seeking to prevent that, Jordan wrote in his Friday opinion.
The judge's decision to vacate the rule is a stumbling block for those advocating to reduce the burden of medical debt. More than 100 million Americans struggle with medical debt, which is the largest source of debt in collection across the country, the Biden administration said in January.
Roughly 1 in 12 adults have unpaid medical bills of $250 or above, according to an analysis from the Peterson Center on Healthcare and KFF last year.
The bills can weigh on patients' credit scores, suppressing financial opportunities, patient advocates say. That's despite such bills being prone to errors and often the result of one-time medical emergencies, instead of evidence of long-term financial mismanagement.
The rule was part of a larger effort from the Biden administration to crack down on medical debt. A handful of states have also tried to ease the burden of medical debt in recent years, including North Carolina and New Jersey.
'The facts are clear: Medical debt is not predictive of creditworthiness,' said Allison Sesso, the president and CEO of nonprofit Undue Medical Debt, in a statement Monday.
'This decision will hurt people's financial futures, including their ability to buy a home, care for their families, or even get a job — all because they got sick, injured or were born with a chronic condition through no fault of their own. It will also further decrease their willingness to get the care they need,' Sesso added.
The pullback of the rule comes amid a larger Trump administration push to roll back the U.S. safety net, including steep Medicaid cuts in the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' passed earlier this month. An estimated 12 million people are expected to lose health insurance as a result of the bill.
Recommended Reading
New rule wipes medical debt from consumer credit reports
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
12 minutes ago
- The Hill
Australia to reduce US beef import restrictions denounced by Trump as a ban
MELBOURNE, Australia (AP) — Australia will reduce restrictions on U.S. beef imports after U.S. President Donald Trump criticized what he described as an Australian ban on the meat, Agriculture Minister Julie Collins said. Collins said Thursday that relaxing the restrictions designed to keep Australia free of mad cow disease, also known as bovine spongiform encephalopathy or BSE, among its cattle herds would not compromise biosecurity. 'Australia stands for open and free trade — our cattle industry has significantly benefited from this,' Collins said in a statement. Australia has allowed imports of beef grown in the United States since 2019. But Australia has not allowed imports from the U.S. of beef sourced from Canada or Mexico because of the disease risk. But the U.S. has recently introduced additional movement controls that identify and trace all cattle from Mexico and Canada to their farms of origin. US cattle import controls satisfy Australian authorities Australian authorities were 'satisfied the strengthened control measures put in place by the U.S. effectively manage biosecurity risks,' Collins said. The timing of the new, reduced restrictions has not been finalized. Trump attacked Australian import restrictions on U.S. beef when he announced in April that tariffs of at least 10% would be placed on Australian imports, with steel and aluminum facing a 50% tariff. 'Australia bans — and they're wonderful people, and wonderful everything — but they ban American beef,' Trump told reporters then. 'Yet we imported $3 billion of Australian beef from them just last year alone. They won't take any of our beef. They don't want it because they don't want it to affect their farmers and, you know, I don't blame them, but we're doing the same thing right now,' Trump added. Lawmaker fears appeasing Trump endangers Australian cattle industry Opposition lawmaker David Littleproud suspected the government was endangering Australia's cattle industry to appease Trump. 'I want to see the science and it should be predicated on science. I'm suspicious of the speed at which this has been done,' Littleproud told reporters. 'We need to give confidence to the industry, but also to you (the public): this is not just about animal welfare, this is about human welfare, this is about BSE potentially coming into this country and having a human impact, so I think it's important the government's very transparent about the science and I don't think it's even beyond the question to have an independent panel review that science to give confidence to everybody,' he added. Around 70% of Australian beef is exported. Producers fear that export market would vanish overnight if diseases including mad cow or foot-and-mouth disease infected Australian cattle. Will Evans, chief executive of Cattle Australia who represents more than 52,000 grass-fed beef producers across the nation, said he was confident the agriculture department had taken a cautious approach toward U.S. imports. 'The department's undertaken a technical scientific assessment and we have to put faith in them. They've made this assessment themselves. They've said: 'We've looked at this, we've looked at the best science, this is a decision that we feel comfortable with,'' Evans told the Australian Broadcasting Corp. 'When you have a 75 billion (Australian dollar, $50 billion) industry relying on them not making this mistake, I'm sure they've been very cautious in their decision-making,' he added. US beef prices rise because of drought and a domestic cattle shortage Beef prices have been rising in the U.S. due to factors that include drought and shrinking domestic herd numbers. The average price of a pound of ground beef in the U.S. rose to $6.12 in June, up nearly 12% from a year ago, according to U.S. government data. The average price of all uncooked beef steaks rose 8% to $11.49 per pound. Australia's opposition to any U.S. tariffs will be high on the agenda when Prime Minister Anthony Albanese secures his first face-to-face meeting with Trump. Albanese and Trump were to hold a one-on-one meeting on the sidelines of a Group of Seven summit in Canada last month, but the U.S. president left early. Albanese expects the pair will meet this year, although no date has been announced. The two countries have had a bilateral free trade deal for 20 years and the U.S. has maintained a trade surplus with Australia for decades.
CNBC
14 minutes ago
- CNBC
World's largest olive oil producer warns U.S. consumers of a double whammy from Trump tariffs
Spain's Deoleo, the world's largest olive oil producer, says U.S. President Donald Trump's threat to impose 30% tariffs on imports from the European Union could translate into higher prices for U.S. consumers — as well as limited access to a superfood staple. Trump has threatened to raise tariffs on the 27-member bloc from Aug. 1, in what would mark a steep jump from the current 10% duty. The EU has long been scrambling to reach a trade deal with the U.S. and is considering its options ahead of Trump's deadline, including the prospect of countermeasures. Huge uncertainty persists over whether the U.S. and EU can strike a deal over the coming days, although a blockbuster framework agreement between the U.S. and Japan has raised hopes of a breakthrough. Deoleo, the maker of household olive oil brands such as Bertolli and Carbonell, told CNBC that the Trump administration's trade measures could have an impact on American consumers, particularly given limited U.S. production. "It is worth noting that approximately 95% of the olive oil consumed in the U.S. is imported, so such policies will affect end users," Deoleo CEO Cristóbal Valdés told CNBC by email. The Spanish company said the U.S. accounts for more than a quarter of its total revenue, making it a strategically important market. Around 40,000 acres (16,187 hectares) of olives are planted exclusively in the U.S. for olive oil production, according to the American Olive Oil Producers Association. By comparison, the EU is known to be the leading producer, consumer and exporter of olive oil, with roughly 4 million hectares (9.88 million acres) dedicated to the cultivation of olive trees across the region. Most of the world's supply of olive oil comes from the Mediterranean, with southern European countries such as Spain, Italy and Greece among the world's leading producers of the precious commodity. Spain, in particular, is the biggest olive oil producer in the EU and a global reference for prices. As part of its preparation for a higher tariffs rate, Deoleo's Valdés said the company intends to ramp up its communication, marketing and consumer engagement efforts to ensure olive oil remains an everyday staple. "Beyond institutional dialogue, we are strengthening our value proposition in the U.S. through consumer awareness campaigns about the benefits of olive oil and a renewed commitment to our brands—especially Bertolli, which today represents trust and consistency for American consumers," Valdés said. Deoleo's chief executive also said the olive oil producer would continue to keep all strategic options open, while working on logistics and supply chain improvements to respond to different market scenarios. "However, beyond tactical decisions, our main priority is to protect American consumers' access to a food product that is essential to their health. Access to olive oil should not be penalized — it should be promoted," Valdés said. As U.S. tariffs on EU goods first came into effect in early April, analysts at commodity data firm Expana warned that a reduction in U.S. olive oil imports could have "serious repercussions" for the global market. They cited market players as saying that such a shift could create a supply glut in the EU, leading to further downward price pressure and intensifying competition among producers. It's not just olive oil exporters that have been rattled by Trump's latest tariff threats, however. Irish whiskey firms, Italian cheesemakers and French wine producers are among those who have sounded the alarm over the potential impact.
Bloomberg
14 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Philippine Ambassador to the US on Trade Deal
Philippine Ambassador to the US Jose Manuel Romualdez discusses his outlook after President Trump announced a trade deal with Philippine that will impose 19% tariff on imports. He speaks with David Ingles and Yvonne Man on "Bloomberg: the China Show." (Source: Bloomberg)
