Rate rationalisation in GST welcome, but States' revenues should be protected, says Karnataka Revenue Minister Byre Gowda
Speaking to The Hindu, Mr. Gowda, who is also a member of the Group of Ministers (GoM) on rate rationalisation, said that the impact of the Centre's proposals have to be carefully assessed. A major overhaul of GST was announced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his independence day address, with a flat two rate structure of 18% and 5% proposed by the Centre.
'We are for rate rationalisation. The rate impact of the same is on the revenues of the state are of great concern. Since the Central Govt has carried out these deliberations and developed proposals outside the GST consultation forum, we are not in the knowledge of the full proposals including measures to protect State revenues, if any. We are looking forward to understand and discuss,' he said.
While the Centre, he said, had various other revenue sources, i. e. Direct taxes, customs, dividends of monopoly PSUs, dividends from RBI, etc, the States have very limited sources.
'GST is the biggest source for the states. So, any major shock in GST will fundamentally affect the fiscal health of the states. So, we would like the rate rationalisation carried out along with protections for state revenues,' he added.
Mr. Gowda added that his government had raised the consequential impact of GST on State's finances before the Finance Commission, but did not get much joy out of the response, which basically kept separate the GST and other financial issues.
'In my view, though, this is a structural issue. The GST, by moving from origin to destination principle, has fundamentally affected and altered long term revenue and fiscal trajectory of some states. Hence, it is a fiscal issue. Now, if the Finance Commission refuses to recognise this, then states like Karnataka and few others will get the wrong end of both worlds. GST council will only discuss GsT issues and will consider fiscal issues as extraneous and outside the mandate of the Council and hence not really to be debated in the Council. And, FC will refuse to discuss the fiscal impact of GST in state finances,' he said.
'With no redressal mechanism in the federal structure. I sincerely hope, for the sake of our federal unity, that these issues will be understood and adequately addressed. I hope these issues will not be brushed aside. Such a move will only harm the federal spirit,' he added.
A meeting of the GoM on rate rationalisation will be addressed by Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Wednesday (August 20, 2025).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
24 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Cheema demands ₹50,000 cr from Centre over GST losses
letterschd@ Agreeing to the proposed Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate cuts, the Bhagwant Mann-led Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government on Thursday demanded that the Centre should release ₹ 50,000 crore to Punjab to compensate the state for the loss it suffered due to the indirect tax regime. Chandigarh : Agreeing to the proposed Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate cuts, the Bhagwant Mann-led Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government on Thursday demanded that the Centre should release ₹50,000 crore to Punjab to compensate the state for the loss it suffered due to the indirect tax regime. After a meeting of the group of ministers (GoM) on the GST, Punjab finance minister Harpal Singh Cheema claimed that the GST inflicted a ₹1.11-lakh crore loss on Punjab as the Centre released only ₹60,000 crore so far. Over ₹50,000 crore and ₹8,000 crore Rural Development Fund (RDF) remain due, he said, adding the state would not have suffered such massive revenue losses had it not joined the 'One Nation-One Tax' scheme. 'With the compensation cess now scrapped, the BJP government is deliberately wrecking state economies to make them beg before the Centre,' he alleged at a press conference in Delhi. Cheema said that GST was introduced in 2017, and there have been 27 amendments in GST in the past eight years, with exemptions given to different sectors, and rates were revised 15 times. 'Since the GST was introduced, the central government has kept making one amendment after another, but never reached a conclusion. Taxpayers are being harassed continuously. The system of the country is being destroyed. Several states are continuously losing revenue due to the GST system. The central government has backed away from making up for this loss,' he claimed. Detailing the latest discussions, Cheema said: 'In Thursday's meeting on compensation cess, the central government said that the loans taken to pay states under compensation cess would be fully repaid by October. On harmful goods (sin goods), a special tax was imposed. The states suffering losses in its collection were being compensated. But now the report of the rate rationalisation committee shows that even the tax slab on sin goods is being reduced.' Raising concern over GST rate cuts, the finance minister said that in the rate rationalisation committee meeting, he demanded that the Centre clarify who will compensate for the revenue loss to states caused by reduction of GST rates.
Hindustan Times
24 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Online Gaming Bill can damage India's digital economy: K'taka IT minister
The Union government's decision to impose a blanket ban on real money gaming (RMG), with the passage of the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Bill in the parliament, has drawn sharp criticism from Karnataka IT minister Priyank Kharge, who called it a 'knee-jerk reaction' that could damage India's digital economy. Online Gaming Bill can damage India's digital economy: K'taka IT minister The online gaming sector has grown rapidly in recent years, generating close to ₹20,000 crore annually through GST and income tax. Over 2,000 gaming startups operate in the country, many of them providing coding, design, and backend services for global platforms. Industry estimates suggest that more than two lakh jobs in IT, AI design, and the creative economy are linked to this ecosystem. The sector has also attracted around ₹23,000 crore in foreign direct investment (FDI) over the past five years, said Kharge. Kharge warned that the ban threatens this entire ecosystem. 'Thousands of people will be unemployed, the gaming talent pool will shrink, and allied sectors like data centres, advertising, and cybersecurity will be hit. If the government is talking about building a $10 trillion digital economy, how does shutting down this vertical send the right signal to global investors?' he said. A senior government official had told HT that the Centre weighed the revenue from online money games against their social costs and concluded that the latter outweighed the financial gains. The official added that 45 crore players have lost ₹20,000 crore to online money games. The government is also of the view that these money games not only create a financial burden but also contribute to behavioural changes like addiction and related suicides among youth. Beyond jobs and revenue, Kharge argued that prohibition will push users to unregulated offshore platforms. Industry observers have also raised similar concerns, pointing out that platforms based in China and Eastern Europe often operate without mechanisms like KYC or tax compliance, raising risks of money laundering, data theft, and even terror financing. The minister said the industry itself has been demanding regulation, not prohibition. 'Addiction won't end by banning platforms. Instead, users will flock to offshore servers where no safeguards exist. If they lose money there, who will they complain to?' he asked. Estimates suggest that India could lose nearly ₹8 lakh crore annually to unregulated foreign operators if players migrate en masse. Government officials have acknowledged that the ban will affect the industry but maintain that companies can reorient themselves towards recreational and casual games that do not involve monetary stakes. Kharge, however, drew a comparison with India's earlier attempt to block pornography websites, saying such bans only drove users to VPNs and unregulated domains. He also criticised the timing of the Online Gaming Bill, describing it, along with other recent pieces of legislation like the the Constitution Amendment Bill, 2025, the Government of Union Territories (Amendment) Bill, 2025, and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2025, as a 'diversion' from the Election Commission's ongoing scrutiny of electoral rolls. 'It is common sense that illegal markets will threaten national security. How many URLs can you block? They will just reappear under different domains. And if servers move abroad, they go beyond India's ambit,' Kharge said. HT reached out to IT ministry officials for a comment but did not immediately receive a response.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Punjab Finance Minister Cheema criticises Centre's GST rate rationalisation, terms it ‘irresponsible'
Criticising the Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate rationalisation and terming it 'irresponsible', Punjab Finance Minister Harpal Singh Cheema has asked the Central government to immediately release compensation of ₹50,000 crore to Punjab to cover losses after GST implementation. After participating in the two-day meeting of the GST ministerial group on health and insurance, rationalising rates, and compensation cess, Mr. Cheema said that since the implementation of GST in 2017, Punjab has suffered a total financial loss of ₹1,11,045 crore. Also read: Required reforms: On reforms to the GST system He said that despite receiving approximately ₹60,000 crore as compensation from the Centre, ₹50,000 crore is still pending. The Central government had announced a 5-year compensation package to states in lieu of financial losses incurred due to GST implementation, but this compensation has now been discontinued, he said. 'While the Punjab government is not opposed to the rationalisation of GST rates, the Union government must take responsibility for the resulting financial losses to the states. The BJP-led Central government is continuously undermining the financial structure of states, which is a significant attack on the federal structure of the country. The Central government is even evading the release of funds to Punjab. Apart from GST, ₹8,000 crore of rural development funds and over ₹1,000 crore under the Prime Minister's Road Scheme are also being withheld,' he said. Hitting out at the BJP-led Union government for repeatedly making changes to the GST system without reaching a definitive solution, Mr. Cheema said this uncertainty leads to constant harassment of taxpayers and a systematic breakdown of the country's financial framework. The gambling with the tax structure would cause massive harm to the nation, he said, dismissing the Centre's promises as mere rhetoric.
