Why was Malta's ‘golden passports' scheme scrapped?
The story so far: In late April, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) struck down Malta's 'golden passports' scheme — a 2020 scheme which authorises the naturalisation of foreigners in the country, and consequently the European Union, in return for hefty financial investments in the country. Brussels had launched infringement proceedings against Malta, as it persisted with its own scheme, blocking access only to Russians and Belarusians consequent to Russia's war against Ukraine.
What are CBIs and RBIs?
Citizenship by investment (CBI), known as golden passports, and residency by investment (RBI), or golden visas, enable third country nationals to live and work in host countries in exchange for financial investments. The European Parliament and the Commission have called for both forms of mobility to be abolished in view of the inherent risks to security, such as money laundering, organised crime, tax evasion and corruption. Between 2013 and 2019, about 1,32,000 persons had obtained entry into the EU through CBI and RBI schemes, generating financial inflows of over €20 billion, as per a 2022 European Parliament Research Service report. The risks from CBI and RBI have been highlighted by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development and the Financial Action Task Force. Principal among the beneficiaries of such migration are nationals from China, Russia and West Asia.
Why is the EU against the scheme?
Within the 27-member bloc, the acquisition or loss of nationality falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of each country. That said, the historic 1992 Maastricht Treaty inaugurated common EU citizenship. That is to say, nationals of an EU state are simultaneously common EU citizens. Therefore, the matter of the grant or rejection of nationality must accord with EU law.
The European Commission contended that the attractiveness of Malta's CBI scheme did not lie in the acquisition of Maltese nationality per se, but instead in the rights that accrue from the complementary EU citizenship. The implicit assumption here being the unique appeal of the absence of internal frontiers, the right to free movement and work across the bloc, the right to vote and to be elected in local as well as European parliament elections. The Commission President Ursula von der Leyen made a pointed reference to golden passports in the 2020 State of the Union address, declaring that 'European values are not for sale.' Brussels further argued that the grant of nationality in return for investments — a commodification of citizenship — was incompatible with the principles of membership of the bloc. These are sincere cooperation, fairness and non-discrimination — codified in Article 4(3) of the 1992 Maastricht Treaty and under Article 20 of the 2009 Treaty on the Functioning of the EU.
What did the ECJ verdict state?
Upholding the Commission's claims, the court reasoned that the pillars of European citizenship are dependent on mutual trust among member states and mutual respect for national decisions. The bond of nationality of a given state is underpinned by a 'relationship of solidarity, good faith and the reciprocity of rights and duties between the state and citizens,' the court added. These principles are infringed upon once citizenship is sought to be granted as a commercial transaction in exchange for an investment. The 2020 Maltese scheme is tantamount to the commercialisation of the grant of nationality of a particular state, and by extension, of the entire bloc. This is incompatible with EU treaties.
What next?
In theory, Malta could exercise its authority to confer nationality to those who availed the CBI scheme, minus union citizenship. This would risk diminishing its appeal as a destination state.
The writer is Director, Strategic Initiatives, AgnoShin Technologies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
22 minutes ago
- Time of India
Consumption and infrastructure 2 top compounding themes in market now: Sumit Bhatnagar
Sumit Bhatnagar , Fund Manager, LIC MF , says consumption is expected to rise and can be a top compounding theme as factors that slowed it down recede. Rural consumption has revived and urban consumption should follow. Tax cuts and RBI measures on unsecured loans will help. Government pay commissions in FY27 and FY28 will inject funds. The second compounding theme is infrastructure. India needs infrastructure investment in power, ports, railways, and roads. Focus on infrastructure is expected to continue. After that RBI bazooka of repo and CRR cuts, the Indian markets were seen to be trending higher, but given the fact that the crude oil is now showing a surge in the international market, what do you make of the market and where are we headed from here? Sumit Bhatnagar: We are positive on the markets over the near term. We are seeing a very clear sign of economic revival as also a potential for corporate earning revival as well. If you look at the global environment that we are in, both the IMF and World Bank have cut their global growth estimate by 50 bps. In that kind of an environment if your economy is growing at 6.5%, it is still a pretty decent number. With the recent policy measure that you just mentioned by the RBI both on the monetary side as also the regulatory step that they had taken earlier, it provides a significant support to your economic growth outlook. If the credit growth revives and if the credit growth picks up, then there can be a small positive surprise on the RBI GDP growth estimates as well. In that kind of an environment, markets should do well from here onwards also, but that should broadly be in line with the corporate earnings expectations which we expect to be in a low double digit return, low double digit over next one or two years. In so far as crude is concerned, even at $70 crude is not a major concern for us as it is within the budgeted numbers, its impact on inflation can easily be managed. What are some of the top secular or compounding themes in the market right now? What are you liking among the sectors at the moment? Sumit Bhatnagar: The top compounding themes to my mind would be consumption now. What has happened is that over the last two years consumption has lagged, but now the factors that were impacting the consumption or leading to slowdown are slowly receding. While we all know that rural consumption has revived, urban consumption also should now revive over the next one or two years. Live Events You Might Also Like: Buy on dips if you believe in long-term India growth, 3 investment themes to bet on: Mihir Vora One is led by the tax cuts that the government has announced. Secondly, the steps that RBI has announced in so far as your unsecured loans are concerned should also help in revival of urban consumption. More importantly, in FY27, we expect central government's pay commission to come in and at the same time, one year later, maybe in FY28, some state government pay commission should come in and that should push in around Rs 2.5 lakh crore into the hands of one-and-a-half crore employees and that should provide some bit of a support to consumption. The second compounding theme is infrastructure. We think India still is very underinvested in so far as infrastructure is concerned, including power, power transmission, ports, railways, and roads. If you are planning to be a major manufacturing hub, you want to be a China plus one type of an alternative, there is no choice but to invest heavily into infrastructure. Both the central and state government's focus continues to be on that. Last year may have been an aberration. We expect focus to continue going forward. So, these two would be the key themes for me. Help us with your take on the IT pack as well. The sector has not participated much in the recent rally that we have seen, but for the past couple of days, select IT counters were buzzing. Is there merit to once again look into any of the IT counters? Can they do well? Sumit Bhatnagar: IT as a pack is in a very tricky situation. While valuations have corrected somewhat over last six months led by global uncertainty, if we do not see a revival in global growth, if uncertainty around us does not recede or US-China does not recede, we can continue to see disappointments in it, so that is one space where there is a potential of a downgrade if the global uncertainty does not recede per se. And if you talk about the overall market construct right now, Q4 FY25 earnings have been better than what the Street was estimating. On the back of this, do you believe there are any sectors that need to be relooked or revisited in terms of any rerating, derating perhaps? Sumit Bhatnagar: Broadly we expect low double digit type of earnings at a largecap level over next two years. But in terms of sectors, maybe financial, both banks and NBFCs can now surprise positively. The recent RBI measure can help banks in managing the NIMs much better with a CRR cut that they have announced. You Might Also Like: Next biggest opportunity will be thrown up by manufacturing in India: Mihir Vora Plus, frontloading of the repo rate cut should help NBFCs as well. With credit growth revival, there can be earnings surprises in both these segments. Secondly, telecoms with the possibility of a tariff hike can surprise positively on earnings. Cement, we expect to do well with the prices holding up firmly and with the volume growth of 6-7%, cement can surprise on upside in so far as earnings are concerned. Consumption over the next two-three years can surprise if demand picks up. Drivers are now getting in place for demand revival, but we need to watch out for that. What is your take on metals? We believe the government is likely to hike the safeguard duty on the steel products beyond 12% and on a month-on-month basis, we are seeing domestic steel production inching higher. What will impact the steel stocks? Will it be the demand, will it be the price, or will it be supply? Sumit Bhatnagar: Our sense is that in the entire metal space, steel is one segment that should do reasonably well. Even without your government support on anti-dumping or safeguard duties, steel volumes were still growing at a pretty healthy 8-9%. And with the government's plan to hike duty to 24%, it could only reduce the cheap Chinese imports that are coming in. So, maintain a positive view on steel, but valuations also need to be looked at in steel stocks. What is your take on emerging sectors like aviation as a subsector of defence? We have already seen a significant runup in some of these defence counters. Would you still continue to be bullish on defence and also aviation in terms of drones as a subsector of defence? Sumit Bhatnagar: So far as defence is concerned, till about a month back, it used to be a narrative sector, but after the proof given in Operation Sindoor , the narrative part is over, now they can actually offer a very attractive opportunity over a medium to long term. With the kind of proof that we have seen, we do expect some bit of an inquiries or increase in inquiries for your defence platforms as well. Earlier, we used to export support consumables, but now platforms also are a fair game but that is going to take time. So, in so far as near-term is concerned, the recent rally prices in a lot of positives and space as a whole may be a fairly priced or maybe inching towards valuations as well. You Might Also Like: ETMarkets Smart Talk: Defence stocks may face bumpy ride despite big potential, says Asit Bhandarkar In so far as drones are concerned, we have seen the importance of drones in Operation Sindoor per se and even in Russia-Ukraine war. Now drones are a very effective weapon system as well. Drones have both a defence as also your industrial application. As a space, drones can do well, but unfortunately there are not many options available to play this space.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Highest FD interest rate of 7.85% for senior citizens: This bank revises FD interest rates after RBI repo rate cut
Tenure Regular Interest Rates (%P.A.)* 7 days to 14 days 3.25% 15 days to 45 days 3.50% 46 days to 90 days 4.50% 91 days to 120 days 4.75% 121 days to 180 days 4.75% 181 days to 271 days 6.00% 272 days to < 12 months 6.25% 12 months 6.75% 12 months 1 day < 18 months 6.85% 18 months 6.85% 18 months 1 day < 24 months 7.00% 24 months < 36 months 7.00% 36 months to < 60 months 7.10% 60 months 6.75% 60 months 1 day to <= 120 months 6.75% Senior Citizen FD rates Tenure Senior Citizen** Interest Rates (%P.A.)* 7 days to 14 days 3.75% 15 days to 45 days 4.00% 46 days to 90 days 5.00% 91 days to 120 days 5.25% 121 days to 180 days 5.25% 181 days to 271 days 6.50% 272 days to < 12 months 6.75% 12 months 7.25% 12 months 1 day < 18 months 7.35% 18 months 7.35% 18 months 1 day < 24 months 7.50% 24 months < 36 months 7.50% 36 months to < 60 months 7.85% 60 months 7.50% 60 months 1 day to <= 120 months 7.50% Private sector lender YES Bank has revised its interest rates on fixed deposits (FDs) for amounts below Rs 3 crore after the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) cut the repo rate by 50 basis points in its Monetary Policy Committee's meeting on June 6, deposit and lending rates are closely tied to the repo rate-the rate at which the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) lends to commercial the revision, YES Bank offers interest rates between 3.25% and 7.10% for FD amounts less than Rs 3 crore for general citizens for tenures ranging from 7 days to 10 years, compared to 3.25% and 7.5% earlier. The bank offers the highest interest rate of 7.1% for a tenure ranging from 36 months to less than 60 senior citizens, YES Bank now offers interest rates between 3.75% and 7.85% per annum for amounts less than Rs 3 crore, compared to 3.75-8.25% highest interest rate of 7.85% per annum is offered on tenures ranging from 36 months to less than 60 months for senior citizens."Resident senior citizens earn additional interest of 0.5% for tenure less than 3 years and 0.75% p.a. for tenure of 3 years and above on fixed deposits value less than INR 5 Crore," YES Bank stated on its Senior Citizen**Interest Rates (%P.A.)*Source- Bank website
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
After easing of food inflation, the cooling effect
Retail inflation, as measured by the consumer price index, plunged to a multi-year low of 2.82 per cent in May 2025, according to the latest data from the National Statistics Office. This is, in fact, the lowest recorded inflation after February 2019. With this latest print, retail inflation has averaged just under 3 per cent in the quarter so far (April-May). This is in line with the RBI's expectations. In the Monetary Policy Committee's June meeting, the central bank had pegged inflation at 2.9 per cent in the first quarter. The decline was, in part, due to softening food inflation. The moderation in the food price index was led by vegetables (-13.7 per cent) and pulses (-8.22 per cent), even as oils, fats and fruits have registered double-digit inflation. The agricultural sector had fared well last year — it had grown by a robust 4.6 per cent — with the benefits showing in the rabi crop. Much will now depend on how the southwest monsoon unfolds. As on June 12, rainfall during the season has been 33 per cent below its long-term average. This will decide the fate of the kharif crop, the sowing for which has commenced. On the other hand, core inflation, which excludes the volatile food and fuel components, remained stable at around 4.3 per cent. Inflation, though, remains high in the personal care and effects category. In an earlier report, analysts at Nomura had noted that 'muted core inflationary pressures likely reflect lower global commodity prices, India's increased reliance on Chinese imports, weak domestic growth, and muted second-round effects through lower household inflation expectations and wage growth'. With this latest print, inflation has stayed below the RBI's target of 4 per cent for four consecutive months. In its last meeting, the RBI's Monetary Policy Committee had lowered the benchmark repo rate by 50 basis points. Since February, the MPC has cumulatively cut rates by 100 basis points, bringing down the repo rate to 5.5 per cent. Alongside, the central bank had also lowered the cash reserve ratio by 100 basis points, a move designed to aid policy transmission. At the same meeting, however, RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra also noted that 'monetary policy is left with very limited space to support growth'. As per the central bank's projections, inflation is likely to slowly edge upwards this year, averaging just about 3.7 per cent, even as some analysts expect it to be lower. The MPC is thus likely to adopt a wait-and-watch approach. Greater clarity will emerge on the monsoon over the coming weeks and months. This will have implications for food output and prices. How the trajectories of prices and growth evolve will determine further policy action.
