Labour's love lost in less than a year but will electoral reform rescue it?
Do you agree with our readers? Have your say on these MetroTalk topics and more in the comments.
Is your spiritual home sturdy? Reader comments on Farage, Corbyn and Starmer
Brian Dooley (MetroTalk, Wed) thinks Jeremy Corbyn's new political party should be the spiritual home of Labour supporters because Sir Keir Starmer has abandoned core Labour values.
If only! Starmer ran to be Labour leader on left-of-centre policies and then understandably abandoned them to win last year's general election.
Then, inexplicably, he forgot why he had won and reverted to comfort-zone, left-of-centre policies that plunged the government into a serious poll dive that shows no sign of being reversed.
Immigration control, law and order, economic growth, NHS reform… policies very popular with the electorate have all collapsed in less than a year.
Instead, out-of-touch, left-of-centre backbenchers bully the prime minister to maintain a bloated welfare state that is a magnet for migrants. No wonder Nigel Farage is so popular.
Brian, the present Labour Party is indeed your spiritual home… until it is swept away in a few years' time – something that has happened in practically every country in Europe. Chris Shepherd, London
Left-wing and centre-left vote to be split four ways?
This reader says Corbyn would have less momentum if Labour offered concession to the left-wing(Picture:)
I couldn't agree more with James Freeman (MetroTalk, Tue) that if Labour were to offer any sort of concession to the left wing of the party then Corbyn's party wouldn't have as much momentum.
To reduce the threat posed by Reform UK, we also need proportional representation (PR). Under first past the post (FPTP), there is a danger the left-wing and centre-left vote will be split between Labour, the Lib Dems, the Greens and Corbyn's party, while the right-wing vote is largely united behind Reform UK.
Reform could win an overall majority with just 30 per cent of the popular vote under FPTP – but this could not happen under PR. Alan Yearsley, Sheffield
Anti-immigrant, anti-immigration or pro-borders? Reader debates
Some politicians and pro-immigration activists call their opponents 'anti-immigrant' protesters.
Got a question about UK politics?
Send in yours and Metro's Senior Politics Reporter Craig Munro will answer it in an upcoming edition of our weekly politics newsletter. Email alrightgov@metro.co.uk or submit your question here.
Maybe the protesters are not so much opposing immigrants – maybe they are opposing the government policies that have encouraged mass immigration? So, why not call them anti-immigration protesters?
Or again, perhaps it would be more accurate to call them pro-borders protesters? Some of the pro-immigration activists carry banners calling for 'No borders, no nations'. Will Podmore, London
'Trying to nail down jelly', reader talks wealth tax
This reader says wealth tax would be 'impossible to administer' (Picture:)
Rob Slater (MetroTalk, Tue) asks why chancellor Rachel Reeves has ruled out introducing a wealth tax.
The answer is simple – it's impossible to administer, as other countries have found.
How do you put a value on works of art, fine wines, vintage cars, property or companies owned by individuals, to give just a few examples? What's to stop people who live here moving their assets to another country? How many civil servants would you need to assess values – if indeed you could?
How many court cases would be brought by those who feel their assets have been overvalued? It's like trying to nail down jelly.
The big mistake this government made was in promising not to increase those taxes that make up two-thirds of the total tax income – income tax, national insurance and VAT.
If we don't want to pay more tax then we have to expect cuts to public services. It's as simple as that. John Daniels, Redhill
Reader says Reform can't solve emigration when the party includes many ex-Tories responsible for mass migration?
In her analysis of the causes of mass immigration, Helen (MetroTalk, Tue) ignores the fact large numbers of migrants don't come from countries with war or disaster but the EU and India etc.
She glossed over the fact many who do come from problem countries go through safe countries to get here.
Helen ignored the impact on the country of over-population (in the 1970s people were urged to stop having children as the then much smaller population was considered unsustainable). She also ignored the fact not only are we becoming 'an island of strangers' – in the words of Starmer, albeit words he now regrets – but of enemies as per the under-reported conflict between Muslims and Hindus.
Helen is right about the terrible conditions driving some to emigrate but as to Reform claiming to being the solution, the party contains many ex-Tories responsible for much of the mass migration.
Reform is in favour of increasing the wealth disparity between rich and poor, probably increasing the drive for immigration. Mark, via email
At what age can you be rugby tackled to the floor for breaking the law?
This reader saysthat if they're allowed to vote, they're old enough to face consequences for stealing(Picture: Getty Images)
The other night I watched two teenagers walk out of my local superstore with a rucksack full of shopping they had not paid for.
The security guard tried to stop them but they just casually walked past him. He told me they did it all the time because they know he can't touch them.
If the government considers them old enough to vote then surely they are of the age where they can be rugby-tackled to the floor for breaking the law. Gareth, London
Reader suggests substance testing for those on benefits with mental health issues
Why doesn't the Department for Work and Pensions introduce drug and alcohol testing for those who receive benefits and claim to have mental health issues?
Very often I see people on the street smoking marijuana or with a can of beer. It's easy to see what kind of state they are in and it's very dangerous.
These individuals should be receiving medical care and food, travel and rent vouchers, not money or benefits. If they refuse, they should be disqualified and prosecuted. Val, Broxbourne
Arrow MORE: KöD's signature three-course menu for only £39.50: 10 unmissable Time Out deals
Arrow MORE: I'll sleep soundly through the next heatwave thanks to this game-changing item from Oodie
Arrow MORE: Former UFC fighter Conor McGregor loses appeal for civil rape case
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Nigel Farage hits out at 'cover-up' of alleged rape by Afghan asylum seekers as Reform UK council leader says he 'begged' for release of arrested men's immigration status
Nigel Farage today hit out at a 'cover-up' after two Afghan asylum seekers were charged in connection with the alleged rape of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. The Reform UK leader said it was 'absolutely disgraceful' that information about the men's background was not revealed to the public. It came after George Finch, the Reform leader of Warwickshire County Council, said he had been 'begging' for information about the immigration status of the alleged offenders in Nuneaton to be released. Speaking at a press conference in central London, Mr Farage said the immigration status of those who are charged with alleged offences should be routinely released. He also demanded that those who enter the UK illegally should not be 'free to roam the streets' and 'should be detained ahead of them being deported'. Mr Farage denied that releasing the names, addresses and imigration status of those charged with offences risked unrest on Britain's streets. He claimed that last summer's riots, in the wake of the Southport riots, was caused by the public not immediately being told the status of the attacker. He said this 'led to crazy conspiracy theories spreading online'. Mr Farage spoke this morning as he welomed Rupert Matthews, the police and crime commissioner for Leicestershire, to Reform. Mr Matthews has defected from the Tories to join Mr Farage's party. He has been a police and crime commissioner since 2021, and served as an MEP for the East Midlands for the Conservatives between 2017 and 2019. At the weekend, Warwickshire Police said two men were charged in connection with the alleged rape of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. Ahmad Mulakhil, 23, was arrested on July 26 and charged the next day with rape, according to the force. He appeared at Coventry Magistrates' Court on Monday and has been remanded in custody. Mohammad Kabir, 23, was arrested in Nuneaton on Thursday and charged with kidnap, strangulation and aiding and abetting rape of a girl under 13, the force added. He appeared at Coventry Magistrates' Court on Saturday and has been remanded in custody. Mulakhil and Kabir will both appear at Warwick Crown Court on August 26. Officers are appealing to anyone who was in the Cheveral Street area between 8.30pm and 9.45pm on July 22 and may have seen anything of interest to come forward by calling 101 and quoting incident number 418 of July 22. Warwickshire Police did not deny Mulakhil and Kabir are asylum seekers, as revealed by the Mail On Sunday. In a statement, the force said that once someone is charged with an offence, they follow national guidance, which 'does not include sharing ethnicity or immigration status'. The force said: 'Our neighbourhood officers work every day with local community partners. 'When something significant happens, we brief these partners and local elected officials on the circumstances of the crime, the investigation, the work being undertaken to arrest those responsible and how local people and partners can help a concerned community. 'Where relevant, sensitive information around locations, details of the crime and policing activity to catch offenders can be shared, with a warning that this is sensitive or confidential information and disclosure by those being briefed could affect future court hearings. 'We work to hold offenders to account and will always do everything in our power to present a robust case to the courts and protect the integrity of court proceedings. 'Once someone is charged with an offence, we follow national guidance. This guidance does not include sharing ethnicity or immigration status.'
South Wales Guardian
32 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Reform UK's new justice adviser calls for bolstered ‘rehabilitation' in prisons
Vanessa Frake also warned that criminals 'lose their support systems on the outside' when they are sentenced, and risk having no other choice than to 'get on that crime ladder' after a short time in prison. Nigel Farage, Reform UK's leader, has promised 'the most significant event' of his party's crime campaign later on Monday. Speaking on Times Radio, Ms Frake said: 'I read every week negative press about our prison service and drugs, mobiles, violence, suicide, self-harm, etcetera, etcetera. 'And you know, the time is now for somebody to do something about it. Successive governments have failed and failed miserably and, you know, that's why our prison service now is on its knees.' The former prison governor said: 'I'm not naive in the fact that people don't want to spend money on prisons – they'd rather it went to the NHS, to education – I'm not naive at all about that. 'But actually, if you think about the whole picture, at the moment we're warehousing prisoners and we're turning out better criminals into our society. 'I'd like to see it where we actually do some rehabilitation and make our society safer for our children, and that is going to cost money but at least somebody is listening to others.' Ms Frake, who wrote about her previous work in her book The Governor, also referred to a Government scheme which cut temporarily the proportion of sentences certain inmates must serve behind bars from 50% to 40%. 'In a prison, now they do 40% of a sentence,' she said. 'There's very little you can do with somebody who is addicted to drugs, alcohol, has mental health issues. There is very little you can do within a prison at that time. 'And when people are sentenced to short sentences, they lose their support systems on the outside. 'They lose their home if they had one, they lose family support and we let them out with nothing so their only alternative is to commit crime and get on that crime ladder, and that needs to be addressed. 'What I would like to see is much better community services, much better community and substance misuse services outside of prisons, and much better management of prisoners on the outside.' Asked whether she was willing to have a 'difficult conversation' with party leader Nigel Farage, Ms Frake replied: 'He might have his own views but he will listen far more than any other party has listened in the past.'
Times
40 minutes ago
- Times
Nigel Farage tells police to release ethnicity of suspected sex offenders
The ethnicity of suspects charged with sexual assaults and rapes should be revealed to maintain public trust, Nigel Farage has said. The Reform UK leader accused police of a 'cover up' over the identity of two men arrested over the alleged rape of a young girl. He said there was 'rising public anger' over migrant hotels, evidenced by protests he said were taking place across the country. Warwickshire police have been subject of criticism and accused of a cover up by the Reform leader of Warwickshire county council, for failing to disclose the immigration status of the two men charged with the rape of a 12-year-old girl, in Nuneaton, last month. The police force has defended its position, stating that 'we follow national guidance', which does not extend to 'sharing ethnicity or immigration status'. Farage said: 'I think particularly given there's a pretty febrile atmosphere … particularly sexual assaults and rapes, where the temperature on this debate has risen significantly. I do believe they should [disclose suspects' ethnicities].' He said the issue had escalated from being about the fairness of taxpayers funding accommodation for asylum seekers, to the 'safety of women and children'. Farage went further, saying there had been 'a cover up — a cover up that, in many ways, is reminiscent of what happened after the Southport killings last year'. He was joined by George Finch, 19, the Reform leader of Warwickshire county council. Finch said he had been 'begging' and 'screaming' for Warwickshire police to release the immigration status of the two men arrested over the rape of a young girl in Nuneaton. Small boat arrivals should no longer be put up in houses of multiple occupancy, or hotels, at the expense of the taxpayer, Finch claimed. Farage welcomed Finch's comment, adding no young unidentified men who arrive by small boats should be 'free to roam the streets'. 'They should be detained,' he said. Warwickshire police said previously: 'Once someone is charged with an offence, we follow national guidance. This guidance does not include sharing ethnicity or immigration status. 'As our investigation progresses, the victim remains at the forefront of our focus, and we will continue to work with our partners – providing updates and working alongside the people of Nuneaton.'
