Trump won't walk away from Alaska with a ceasefire — Phar Kim Beng
Without Kyiv's direct involvement, no arrangement to transform roughly one-quarter of Ukraine's eastern territories into a so-called 'safe buffer zone' can hold.
This is not a neutral security measure; it is a geopolitical carve-out that Moscow might see as a fait accompli, but which Kyiv would treat as illegitimate.
The fact that more than half a million Russian soldiers have reportedly perished and large swathes of both occupied and unoccupied territory remain mined only complicates the picture.
Russia has no strategic interest in inheriting a wasteland, and Ukraine has no incentive to formalise losses under such dangerous conditions.
The NATO factor
Adding to the difficulty, NATO's largest European powers — notably France and Germany — are not buying into the premise of a Putin-friendly peace. Their pledge to raise defence spending to 5% of GDP by 2035 signals long-term strategic resistance to Russian expansionism.
This is not 1938, and the political mood is the opposite of Munich's ill-fated appeasement. Their military build-up reflects a collective decision to fortify Europe's eastern flank, not to bargain away Ukrainian territory in the name of expediency.
This means even if Trump and Putin agree on a provisional framework, European resolve will act as a brake.
No NATO consensus will emerge behind an agreement that concedes strategic depth to Moscow without robust verification and enforcement measures.
Then there is Beijing.
T-shirts with images of Russian President Vladimir Putin and U.S. President Donald Trump are displayed for sale at a gift shop in central Moscow, Russia, August 12, 2025. — Reuters pic
China has already made clear it will not allow Russia to lose to the United States, and this is more than diplomatic rhetoric.
The statement aligns with Beijing's broader grand strategy — a multipolar order in which a weakened Russia would tilt the global balance in Washington's favour.
This strategic commitment emboldens Moscow, making it less likely to compromise in ways that would give the US or NATO a clear win.
As long as China's economic and diplomatic umbrella remains open over Russia, Putin will calculate that time is on his side.
This makes any substantive concession in Alaska highly improbable.
The most likely outcome
In reality, the best Trump can hope for is an agreement to keep talking.
The East Asian Summit in Kuala Lumpur later this year could serve as the next venue for high-level dialogue.
While the EAS is not designed to address European conflicts, it gathers the US, Russia, China, and ASEAN under one roof — creating a multipolar stage where ongoing discussions can be framed as progress without the pressure of immediate resolution.
For Trump, this would still be a face-saving result.
He could present the Alaska meeting as a breakthrough in getting adversaries to engage directly, while leaving room for further negotiations in a setting that dilutes NATO's centrality and includes Asian powers with vested interests in global stability.
Why there will be no ceasefire in Alaska
The absence of Ukraine, NATO's hardening stance, and China's strategic alignment with Russia form a triangular blockade to any rapid deal. These are not conditions that yield an enforceable ceasefire. At most, Alaska will produce another handshake moment and a promise to meet again — a symbolic gesture, not a settlement.
The war will continue, the battle lines will remain, and the mines will still be in the ground. Trump may leave Alaska with headlines, but not with peace.
* Phar Kim Beng is a professor of Asean Studies and Director of the Institute of Internationalization and Asean Studies at the International Islamic University of Malaysia.
** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Trump, Putin cite progress but no Ukraine deal at summit
ANCHORAGE, Aug 16 — Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin yesterday made no apparent breakthrough on Ukraine in a high-stakes summit, pointing to areas of agreement and rekindling a friendship but offering no news on a ceasefire. Trump, fond of calling himself a master deal-maker, rolled out the red carpet for Putin at an Alaska air base in the first time the Russian leader was allowed on Western soil since he ordered the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. After three hours of talks with top aides, Trump and Putin offered warm words but took no questions from reporters—highly unusual for the media-savvy US president. 'We had an extremely productive meeting, and many points were agreed to,' Trump said. 'There are just a very few that are left, some are not that significant, one is probably the most significant,' Trump said without elaborating. 'But we have a very good chance of getting there. We didn't get there, but we have a very good chance of getting there.' Putin also spoke in general terms of cooperation in a joint press appearance that lasted just 12 minutes. 'We hope that the understanding we have reached will... pave the way for peace in Ukraine,' Putin said. As Trump mused about a second meeting, Putin smiled and said in English: 'Next time in Moscow.' The former KGB agent quickly tried to flatter Trump, who has voiced admiration for the Russian leader in the past. Putin told Trump he agreed with him that the Ukraine war, which Putin ordered, would not have happened if Trump were president instead of Joe Biden. Trump for his part again complained of a 'hoax' that Russia intervened to help him the 2016 election—a finding backed by US intelligence. Putin warns Western allies The friendly reception was a stark contrast to Trump's berating of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky when he met him at the White House in February. But Trump said he would soon consult Zelensky as well as NATO leaders, who have voiced unease about the US leader's outreach to Putin. Putin, in his brief appearance with Trump, warned Ukraine and European countries to 'not create any obstacles' and not 'make attempts to disrupt this emerging progress through provocation or behind-the-scenes intrigues.' Trump invited Putin just a week ago and ensured there was some carefully choreographed drama for their first in-person meeting since 2019. The two leaders arrived in their respective presidential jets and descended on the tarmac of an air base, with Trump clapping as Putin appeared. US military might was on display with a B-2 stealth bomber flying overhead, as a reporter shouted audibly to Putin, 'Will you stop killing civilians?' Putin, undaunted, grinned widely as Trump took the unusual step of escorting him into 'The Beast,' the secure US presidential limousine, before a meeting in a room before a screen that said—in English only—'Pursuing Peace.' Putin smiled and joked with Russian reporters on the visit, a landmark for a leader who is facing an arrest warrant by the International Criminal Court related to the Ukraine war, which has killed tens of thousands of people. Russia presses on battlefield Russia in recent days has made battlefield gains that could strengthen Putin's hand in any ceasefire negotiations, although Ukraine announced as Putin was flying in that it had retaken several villages. Trump had insisted he would be firm with Putin, after coming under heated criticism for appearing cowed during a 2018 summit in Helsinki. While he was traveling to Alaska, the White House abruptly announced that Trump had scrapped a plan to see Putin alone and he instead held the talks with Secretary of State Marco Rubio and his roving envoy Steve Witkoff. Zelensky was not included and has refused pressure from Trump to surrender territory seized by Russia. 'It is time to end the war, and the necessary steps must be taken by Russia. We are counting on America,' Zelensky said in a social media post. Trump has said that any final agreement would come in a three-way meeting with Putin and the Ukrainian president to 'divvy up' territory. But he made no announcement of a Zelensky meeting and quickly returned to Washington after the summit. — AFP
Barnama
an hour ago
- Barnama
Putin Hopes 'Understanding' Reached With Trump At Talks In Alaska To Pave Way For Peace In Ukraine
U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin hold a press conference following their meeting to negotiate an end to the war in Ukraine, at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, in Anchorage, Alaska, U.S., August 15, 2025. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque Russian President Vladimir Putin waves as he and U.S. President Donald Trump (not pictured) hold a press conference following their meeting to negotiate an end to the war in Ukraine, at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, in Anchorage, Alaska, U.S., August 15, 2025. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque MOSCOW, Aug 16 (Bernama-Anadolu) -- Russian President Vladimir Putin said Saturday that "an understanding" was reached at a meeting with US President Donald Trump, which he hopes will pave the way for peace in Ukraine, Anadolu Ajansi (AA) reported. Putin described discussions with Trump as "constructive and useful," noting that the situation with Ukraine was one of the central issues discussed. "I would like to hope that the understanding that we've reached together will help us bring closer that goal and will pave the path towards peace in Ukraine," he said at a news conference following the talks with Trump in Alaska. bootstrap slideshow Putin said Russia has always considered, and still considers, the Ukrainian people "to be fraternal." "We have always considered the Ukrainian people, and I have said this repeatedly, to be fraternal, no matter how strange it may sound in today's conditions. We have the same roots, and everything that happens to us is a tragedy and a great pain," he said. Putin reiterated concerns about Ukraine's "turn to the West," emphasising it is associated with fundamental threats to Russia's national security. He stated that a sustainable and long-term Ukrainian settlement is impossible without addressing the root causes, that Russia's concerns must be taken into account, and that a fair balance in security across Europe and globally must be restored. "I agree with President Trump, who spoke about it today, that the security of Ukraine must undoubtedly be ensured. Of course, we are prepared to work on this," he said. The Russian president noted he perceives a genuine willingness from the current US administration and Trump to help resolve the conflict, including Trump's readiness to examine its root causes.
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Trump-Putin summit yields no deal on ending war in Ukraine
ANCHORAGE, Alaska: A highly anticipated summit between US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin on Friday yielded no agreement to resolve or pause Moscow's war in Ukraine, though both leaders described the talks as productive. During a brief appearance before the media following the nearly three-hour meeting in Alaska, the two leaders said they had made progress on unspecified issues. But they offered no details and took no questions, with the normally loquacious Trump ignoring shouted questions from reporters. "There were many, many points that we agreed on. I would say a couple of big ones that we haven't quite got there, but we've made some headway," Trump said, standing in front of a backdrop that read, "Pursuing Peace." "There's no deal until there's a deal," he added. The talks did not initially appear to have produced meaningful steps toward a ceasefire in the deadliest conflict in Europe in 80 years – or toward a subsequent meeting between Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, both goals Trump had set ahead of the summit. Putin said he expected Ukraine and its European allies to accept the results of the US-Russia negotiation constructively and not try to "disrupt the emerging progress." "I expect that today's agreements will become a reference point, not only for solving the Ukrainian problem, but will also launch the restoration of business-like, pragmatic relations between Russia and the United States," Putin said. But Putin also repeated Moscow's long-held position that what Russia claims to be the "root causes" of the conflict must be eliminated to reach a long-term peace, a sign he remains resistant to a ceasefire. As the two leaders were talking, the war raged on, with most eastern Ukrainian regions under air raid alerts. Governors of Russia's Rostov and Bryansk regions reported that some of their territories were under Ukrainian drone attacks. Zelenskyy has ruled out formally handing Moscow any territory and is also seeking a security guarantee backed by the United States. Trump said he would call Zelenskyy and Nato leaders to update them on the Alaska talks. There was no immediate reaction from Kyiv to the summit. Ukraine's opposition lawmaker Oleksiy Honcharenko said on the Telegram messaging app, "It seems Putin has bought himself more time. No ceasefire or de-escalation has been agreed upon." Czech Foreign Minister Jan Lipavsky said in a statement that he welcomed Trump's efforts but doubted Putin's interest in a deal. "If Putin were serious about negotiating peace, he would not have been attacking Ukraine all day today," he said. ROLLING OUT THE RED CARPET The anticlimactic end to the closely watched summit was in stark contrast to the pomp and circumstance with which it began. When Putin arrived at an Air Force base in Alaska, a red carpet awaited him, where Trump greeted Putin warmly as US military aircraft flew overhead. Trump hopes a truce in the 3-1/2-year-old war that Putin started will bring peace to the region as well as bolster his credentials as a global peacemaker worthy of the Nobel Peace Prize. For Putin, the summit – the first between him and a US president since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 – was already a big win, regardless of its outcome. He can portray the meeting as evidence that years of Western attempts to isolate Russia have unravelled and that Moscow is retaking its rightful place at the high table of international diplomacy. Putin is wanted by the International Criminal Court, accused of the war crime of deporting hundreds of children from Ukraine. Russia denies the allegations, and the Kremlin has dismissed the ICC warrant as null and void. Russia and the United States are not members of the court. Both Moscow and Kyiv deny targeting civilians in the war. But thousands of civilians have died in the conflict, the vast majority Ukrainian, and the war has killed or injured well over a million people from both sides. Trump has threatened sanctions on Moscow and secondary sanctions on countries that buy its oil, primarily India and China, if no moves are made to end the war in Ukraine. Thus far, however, Trump has not followed through despite having set a deadline for Putin to agree to a ceasefire earlier this month. The day before the summit, Putin held out the prospect of something Trump wants – a new nuclear arms control agreement to replace the last surviving one, which is due to expire in February. It was unclear if the issue was discussed on Friday. 'COUNTING ON AMERICA' Zelenskyy, who was not invited to Alaska, and his European allies had feared Trump might sell out Ukraine by essentially freezing the conflict and recognising – if only informally – Russian control over one-fifth of Ukraine. Trump had sought to assuage such concerns on Friday ahead of the talks, saying he would let Ukraine decide on any possible territorial concessions. "I'm not here to negotiate for Ukraine, I'm here to get them at a table," he said. Asked what would make the meeting a success, he told reporters: "I want to see a ceasefire rapidly ... I'm not going to be happy if it's not today ... I want the killing to stop." The meeting also included US Secretary of State Marco Rubio; Trump's special envoy to Russia, Steve Witkoff; Russian foreign policy aide Yury Ushakov; and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov. Trump, who said during his presidential campaign that he would end Russia's war in Ukraine within 24 hours, conceded on Thursday it had proven a tougher task than he had expected. He had said if Friday's talks went well, quickly arranging a second, three-way summit with Zelenskyy would be more important than his encounter with Putin. Trump ended his remarks on Friday by telling Putin, "I'd like to thank you very much, and we'll speak to you very soon and probably see you again very soon." "Next time in Moscow," Putin responded. Trump said he might "get a little heat on that one" but that he could "possibly see it happening." Zelenskyy said ahead of Friday's summit that the meeting should open the way for a "just peace" and three-way talks that included him, but added that Russia was continuing to wage war. "It's time to end the war, and the necessary steps must be taken by Russia. We are counting on America," Zelenskyy wrote on Telegram.
