Disinformation catalyses anti-migrant unrest in Spain
The altercations were sparked after a 68-year-old pensioner said three men of North African origin attacked him without provocation on July 9.
Two days later, the conservative-led city council organised a protest against insecurity, which quickly escalated when far-right groups joined with hostile slogans against immigrants.
That day, and for several nights, riots broke out in the streets of the southeastern city of 40,000.
Authorities have arrested 14 people, including three suspected of involvement in the attack on the retiree.
Also among those detained is the leader of the far-right "Deport Them Now" group, who allegedly called for a "hunt" of migrants on social media.
The sudden outbreak of violence took Spain by surprise but anti-migrant discourse had already been brewing, partly due to disinformation circulating on social media.
AFP's digital verification team in Spain has debunked many false claims linked to immigrants, mostly concerning public benefits they supposedly receive and alleged attacks by foreigners on Spanish customs.
For Alexandre Lopez Borrull, a professor in communication and information science at the Open University of Catalonia, disinformation in such cases is "the fuel and the spark at the same time".
The narrative "is fuelled over a long period of time" and when a specific event occurs, it can act as a spark in scenarios like the one that played out in Torre Pacheco, he said.
A video purporting to show the assault on the pensioner, along with a list of alleged attackers, quickly circulated online -- both debunked by AFP.
Elisa Brey, a sociology professor at Madrid's Complutense University, likened the phenomenon to criminals setting off wildfires.
"It's hot, there's a temperature alert, and an arsonist passes by and throws a match. That is what happens with disinformation," she said.
Aim to destabilise
Experts also emphasised the role of politicians, particularly the far-right Vox party, in fanning the flames of anti-migrant rhetoric.
Vox has long connected immigration to crime and recently proposed, echoing other EU political parties and far-right activists, that some migrants be deported as part of a broad "remigration" plan.
Foreigners make up 14 percent of Spain's population, up from only 1.6 percent in 1998.
In events like the violent protests in Torre Pacheco, malicious discourse seeps through different layers of social media before erupting into the public sphere, Brey explained.
First, it simmers at an "underlying" level on less visible platforms like Telegram, before jumping to more popular networks such as X and TikTok. Politicians then amplify the message through public statements, she said.
Vox's leader in the southeastern Murcia region, which includes Torre Pacheco, blamed the unrest on "illegal immigration", claiming that migrants had assaulted the elderly and committed sexual violence against women.
Prosecutors have opened an investigation into his comments to determine if they constitute a hate crime.
Social media was used in a way that, "in the end, it led to these events", added Marcelino Madrigal, an expert in online platforms and cybersecurity.
Madrigal also detected that parties were shifting their position on immigration with an eye on political gain at a time of speculation about early elections in Spain.
"With disinformation about immigration, the aim is to destabilise a government or a country as well as present yourself as an alternative to save us from a problem that does not exist," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Spain
5 hours ago
- Local Spain
EXPLAINED: Fresh corruption scandal hits Spain's opposition party
Another week, another major corruption scandal rocking the upper-echelons of Spanish politics. As The Local has covered in detail, ongoing corruption allegations surrounding Spanish Prime Minister Sánchez's inner-circle have in recent months left his government teetering on the edge. For many political pundits, it was a question of when rather than if the government would fall. Allegations against Sánchez's wife, brother, attorney general and two former right-hand men made his position seem untenable and opposition parties have furiously demanded his resignation and called for early elections. But now the Spanish right has been implicated in its own major corruption network. The opposition Partido Popular (PP), who were until last week making great use of the scandals as a political weapon, has found itself engulfed in their own rather embarrassing set of allegations that threatens to undo all that political momentum and, infuriatingly for them, hand Sánchez and the Spanish left a lifeline just when they thought he couldn't fight on for much longer. Cristóbal Montoro, Spain's former Finance Minister in the right-wing Rajoy government of 2011-2015 that preceded Sánchez, has been charged with creating "a network of influence" and taking kickbacks to favour gas companies that hired his law firm. He previously also served as Finance Minister in the Aznar government. Montoro is among more than 20 accused, including senior treasury officials, of receiving at least €11 million from energy companies for favourable government policy. Back in 2004 when the PP lost power to the Socialists (PSOE), Montoro left his post. He briefly became a Member of the European Parliament that same year, and in 2006 he founded a law firm, initially called Montoro y Asociados, later renamed Equipo Económico, with four former senior officials from his ministry. That firm is now at the centre of the plot. Montoro returned to national politics as an MP in 2008 and left the firm. In 2011, the PP returned to power and Montoro was once again appointed Minister of Finance. During this time, Montoro's former office and his partners allegedly influenced several senior ministerial appointments. This allegedly led to changes in legislation, centring on lowered tax commitments, to benefit gas companies that were clients of Montoro's firm, according to the court order accessed by Spanish daily El País: "In exchange for significant payments, they intervened decisively in legislative reforms [...] in accordance with the interests of their clients," it says. The investigation, which is still underway, has also found evidence that Equipo Económico charged 'commissions' from electricity and renewable energy companies to 'influence the decisions' of the government. The Guardian reports that Rajoy was told of Montoro's alleged dealings but did not take action. In the short-term, the investigations have wrong footed the current PP leader Alberto Núñez Feijóo's main political attack line by allowing Sánchez and the Spanish left to claim the Spanish right is the real party of corruption, or at the very least that their attack lines are hollow and hypocritical. Crucially, the allegations give Sánchez some breathing room as he tries to sure up support among his parliamentary partners and ensure his government lasts a full second term. Elections aren't slated in Spain until 2027. However, that both of Spain's two great partidos del estado are simultaneously caught up in serious corruption allegations does little to help long-held political disenchantment among Spanish voters. It likely boosts the far-right, too. Dissatisfaction with Spain's two main parties gives greater opportunity for far-right Vox, surging in the polls already, to portray the Spanish system as broken and in need of something new.
Local Spain
2 days ago
- Local Spain
Disinformation catalyses anti-migrant unrest in Spain
Last weekend's unrest in the southeastern town of Torre Pacheco pitted far-right groups against immigrant residents, mainly of Moroccan origin, but a heavy police presence prevented serious confrontations. The altercations were sparked after a 68-year-old pensioner said three men of North African origin attacked him without provocation on July 9. Two days later, the conservative-led city council organised a protest against insecurity, which quickly escalated when far-right groups joined with hostile slogans against immigrants. That day, and for several nights, riots broke out in the streets of the southeastern city of 40,000. Authorities have arrested 14 people, including three suspected of involvement in the attack on the retiree. Also among those detained is the leader of the far-right "Deport Them Now" group, who allegedly called for a "hunt" of migrants on social media. The sudden outbreak of violence took Spain by surprise but anti-migrant discourse had already been brewing, partly due to disinformation circulating on social media. AFP's digital verification team in Spain has debunked many false claims linked to immigrants, mostly concerning public benefits they supposedly receive and alleged attacks by foreigners on Spanish customs. For Alexandre Lopez Borrull, a professor in communication and information science at the Open University of Catalonia, disinformation in such cases is "the fuel and the spark at the same time". The narrative "is fuelled over a long period of time" and when a specific event occurs, it can act as a spark in scenarios like the one that played out in Torre Pacheco, he said. A video purporting to show the assault on the pensioner, along with a list of alleged attackers, quickly circulated online -- both debunked by AFP. Elisa Brey, a sociology professor at Madrid's Complutense University, likened the phenomenon to criminals setting off wildfires. "It's hot, there's a temperature alert, and an arsonist passes by and throws a match. That is what happens with disinformation," she said. Aim to destabilise Experts also emphasised the role of politicians, particularly the far-right Vox party, in fanning the flames of anti-migrant rhetoric. Vox has long connected immigration to crime and recently proposed, echoing other EU political parties and far-right activists, that some migrants be deported as part of a broad "remigration" plan. Foreigners make up 14 percent of Spain's population, up from only 1.6 percent in 1998. In events like the violent protests in Torre Pacheco, malicious discourse seeps through different layers of social media before erupting into the public sphere, Brey explained. First, it simmers at an "underlying" level on less visible platforms like Telegram, before jumping to more popular networks such as X and TikTok. Politicians then amplify the message through public statements, she said. Vox's leader in the southeastern Murcia region, which includes Torre Pacheco, blamed the unrest on "illegal immigration", claiming that migrants had assaulted the elderly and committed sexual violence against women. Prosecutors have opened an investigation into his comments to determine if they constitute a hate crime. Social media was used in a way that, "in the end, it led to these events", added Marcelino Madrigal, an expert in online platforms and cybersecurity. Madrigal also detected that parties were shifting their position on immigration with an eye on political gain at a time of speculation about early elections in Spain. "With disinformation about immigration, the aim is to destabilise a government or a country as well as present yourself as an alternative to save us from a problem that does not exist," he said.
Local Spain
4 days ago
- Local Spain
'Franco did it': Five quirky ways the dictator shaped modern Spain
With the 50th anniversary of Franco's death this year, there has unsurprisingly been quite a bit of talk about the dictator's legacy and his impact on Spain. Much of it, of course, is critical. However, some Spaniards, especially younger males, view the dictatorship with increasingly rose-tinted glasses and give examples of the supposed positives Franco did for the country. Often these are untrue, such as the widely-shared claim that Franco created the Spanish social security system, that he made Sunday a rest day for workers or that he set up the country's pension system. However, despite that, to say that the man who ruled Spain for decades didn't have a huge impact on the country would also be absurd. Despite the fact there's a tendency among some foreigners - including foreign correspondents and historians - to see Franco in absolutely everything, it's fair to say that in some specific ways, the dictator's legacy does live on to this day. Everything happens later in the day because of Franco Spain is in the wrong time zone. The country is geographically in line with the UK and Portugal. It makes sense, then, that Spain was in the Greenwich Mean Time (GMT) zone until around 75 years ago. But that changed during the Second World War. With the country ravaged by its own recent Civil War - in which Franco's victory was heavily supported by Hitler - Franco felt obliged to make a gesture of some sort. Although ultimately remaining neutral in the war, he decided to show his support for Hitler by agreeing to put Spain's clocks forward by an hour in an act of solidarity with Nazi Germany. Spain has remained in the Central European Time zone ever since, in line with countries as far east as Poland. But Franco's decision all those years ago isn't just a quirk of Spanish history, or testament to the extent to which the legacy of that period still looms over Spanish society. It was also a decision that has had a lasting impact on Spanish culture and society that underpins everything from Spaniards' sleep cycles and meal times to the country's birth rates and economic growth. There have been calls to make the switch back to GMT because many believe the time zone quirk is affecting Spaniard's productivity and quality of life. In 2013, a Spanish national commission concluded that Spaniards sleep almost an hour less than the European average, and that this led to increased stress, concentration problems, both at school and work, and workplace accidents. Franco introduced Spain's divisive mass tourism model Spain received 94 million tourists in 2024 and even its long-held status as de facto holiday destination for much of northern Europe can be traced back to Franco. After decades of international isolation following the Civil War, cash-strapped Francoist Spain completely changed its strategy in the late 50s and early 60s. The dictatorship liberalised the economy and invested heavily in promoting tourism abroad as a means of whitewashing the regime, turning its back on the Catholic, traditionalist sector of society which shunned the idea of free-thinking northern European tourists gracing Spain's beaches in bikinis. The regime opened its borders without checks or visa requirements, the peseta was deliberately devalued to make it cheaper for foreigners to spend their holidays in Spain, and legislation fixed the price hotels and restaurants could charge in order to keep them low, all factors that planted the seeds for the 'anything goes' tourism model. In fact, two of the popular tourism slogans of the time were Pase sin llamar ('Come in without knocking') and 'Spain is different', written in English. From 1960 to 1970, the number of international tourists quadrupled from 6.1 million to 24.1 million. It was during this time that Spain's coastal building bonanza kicked off and, decades later, the Spanish costas are still the first choice destination of tourists across the continent. Players use a hyper-realistic replica of dictator Francisco Franco's head as a football during an artistic and political performance titled "La Copa del Generalísimo". (Photo by Josep LAGO / AFP) Franco is largely responsible for 'Empty Spain' Franco is also arguably responsible for the mass migration of Spaniards from rural Spain into big cities, setting the foundations for Empty Spain and the depopulation problems it has caused in more recent years. From the late-1950s, millions in Spain left their pueblos to live in cities in search of transfer of rural populations to industrial centres such as Catalonia, the Basque Country and Madrid led to major regional imbalances, many of which live on today. When we think of the concept of 'Empty Spain', we think of more recent migrant flows and younger Spaniards forced to provincial capitals in search of work, but according to data from INE, in the 1960s alone more than three million Spaniards left the countryside for the city. The economic boom Franco hoped for required a large workforce, which came from rural areas. To compound the trend, agricultural production was mechanised around this time which meant that there was also a surplus of labour in the countryside, forcing more people into the cities in search of work. Spaniards' obsession with home ownership started under Franco This migration from the Spanish countryside also had another effect: it made Spain into a nation of homeowners. Spain has historically had among the highest property ownership rates in Europe. The Spain of the 1930s, 1940s and 1950s was a country of tenants. Until the 1960s, half of all housing in the country was rented. Incredibly, in 1950 only one in twenty people in Madrid or Barcelona owned their own homes, but by 2007 the Ministry of Housing estimated that 87 percent of Spanish households owned at least one home. José Luis Arrese, the first Housing Minister in Spanish history, told the Francoist Parliament in the 1950s that 'We want a society of owners, not proletarians.' With the great migration ongoing, estimates suggest that around 12 million Spaniards (roughly 40 percent of the population at the time) moved house between 1951 and 1975. The Franco regime discouraged renting a 1954 limited rent law enabled the construction of millions of subsidised homes. Then the real construction boom broke out: between 1961 and 1975, four million flats were built, often in the classic Spanish apartment block style. To top it all off, the Banco Hipotecario de España was created to compensate private banks granting mortgages to the working classes flowing into Spanish cities. Spaniards' poor English is partly attributable to Francoist policies Something that many foreigners notice in Spain is the relatively low levels of English, especially compared to other European countries. Franco arguably played a hand in this too and it comes down to films. Another quirk (or annoyance, depending on your opinion) of Spain is that the vast majority of films in both cinemas and on TV are dubbed into Spanish. During the early stages of the Franco dictatorship, it was compulsory for all films to be dubbed into Spanish. The Language Defence Law, introduced in 1941, was used to strengthen Spanish nationalism by promoting Castilian Spanish through a mass cultural mode like cinema. As such, Spaniards didn't and many to this day don't regularly hear English. In Spain just 4 percent of Spaniards who go to the cinema choose to watch the original version with subtitles. Figures from the Federation of Spanish Cinemas (FECE) from 2015 show how out of the roughly 3,500 large screen cinemas in Spain, barely 200 of them showed international films in their original language. Compare this with neighbouring Portugal, a country with one of the highest levels of English on the continent, where the post-WWII Portugal of dictator Salazar went the other way and in order to guarantee what was "authentically Portuguese", a 1948 law banned Portuguese cinema from being dubbed.
