FM to face questions over winter fuel payment recovery from better-off pensioners
On Wednesday, the Scottish Government set out plans for a slightly more generous winter fuel payment, with some households receiving up to £5 more than other areas of the UK.
The benefit will be made available to all Scottish pensioners with an income below £35,000.
However, Scottish ministers said they are in discussion with the UK Government to recover payments from pensioners with income over £35,000 a year through the tax system – matching the UK government system.
Speaking to STV News on Wednesday, social justice secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said ending the universal aspect of the benefit would ensure the payments were helping those with the greatest need.
The First Minister is likely to face scrutiny for the decision on Thursday.
Tory MSP Maurice Golden is also set to challenge the First Minister to respond to reports that up to 100 truckloads of Scotland's waste will be moved each day to England as a result of the landfill ban on biodegradable waste.
The Scottish Tories have been critical of the reports, calling on the SNP to 'get a grip of this situation' before the ban comes into force in December.
The First Minister will also be asked about the Government's most recent position on University funding.
Labour MSP Pam Duncan-Glancy is preparing to ask the First Minister about his Government's up-to-date position on funding Scotland's universities.
The question comes less than 24 hours after MSPs were told Scotland's colleges have been left in a 'fragile' state following years of underinvestment.
Angela Cox, chair of the Colleges Principals Group at Colleges Scotland, told Holyrood's Education Committee on Wednesday that the further education sector was 'hanging on by our fingernails'.
FMQs will be streamed live from Holyrood at noon on Thursday.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
26 minutes ago
- Spectator
Ian Blackford refuses to rule out Holyrood bid
Well, well, well. After Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes announced she was stepping down at next year's Scottish parliament election, speculation about who could stand for her Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch constituency has been rife. Some have suggested that Ian Blackford, the former SNP MP for Ross, Skye and Lochaber and onetime Westminster group leader, could make a return to frontline politics by standing for an area he represented down south for almost a decade. So will he make the leap? When quizzed on Spectator TV about whether he would stand at next year's Holyrood election, Blackford did not rule it out – however he remarked: 'It would be a big push for me to get myself there.' How interesting… The investment banker-turned-politician went on: I didn't put myself forward for vetting to be an SNP candidate. It wasn't in my mind to stand for the Scottish parliament. What I've done is I've sought to be respectful to those that have asked me from the constituency over the course of the last few days. I've reflected on some of the some of the things which are going on. I am deeply concerned about the economy. When the UK cannot increase its debt level, the Chancellor will increase tax levels again in the budget this year. But we are not far away from a financial crisis. How do we create the economic growth that will make a difference for, for all of us in these islands and certainly for Scotland as well? I would like to find a way that I can still have an influence in that debate. And I don't believe that I have to be in the Scottish parliament to do that but I will carefully reflect on what people have asked me to do. The speculation began almost immediately after Forbes made her announcement. The Deputy FM was widely expected to run for the party leadership, whenever the next contest will take place, and her impending departure has raised the question of who might succeed First Minister John Swinney when the time comes. One nationalist told Lucy Dunn that: '[Blackford] is the dark horse here. Does he suddenly then become an outsider that could be the next leader, potentially, especially if you're looking at a caretaker regime that's basically saying the new kids on the block aren't ready to take the reins yet?' As an investment banker, Blackford could be a perfect fit to take on the role of economy secretary when Forbes steps aside – if, of course, the Nats hold onto her seat. But whether Forbes is as keen about the possibility of a Blackford return is a different story. On whether she would back a Blackford bounce-back, she told an Edinburgh Fringe audience: 'I am taking those headlines with a huge dose of salt. I did have a chat with him a few days ago and that wasn't in the conversation.' Would she vote for him? 'I will wait and see what the options are,' she replied. Not quite a full-throated endorsement, eh?
STV News
26 minutes ago
- STV News
Scottish water bosses to get £400k pay rise amid customer price hike
Scottish Water bosses have received £400,000 in pay rises despite hiking prices by nearly 10% for customers. The total cost of senior executive salaries rose to almost £1.4m in 2025, up from just more than £1.1m the year before, the body's annual report released on Wednesday shows. The chief executive Alex Plant's salary has gone up by £50,000 and now sits at £295,000. His total pay packet, including pension contributions, totals £523,000. Scottish Labour has said the 'eye-watering' salary increases will 'stick in the craw' for people across the country who are paying higher water bills this year. 'People across Scotland are struggling to make ends meet, yet the wages of bosses at Scottish Water are eye-watering and continue to rise,' Labour deputy leader Dame Jackie Baillie said. Baillie said water bosses are picking up 'hefty incentive bonuses totalling more than £230,000' at the expense of Scottish taxpayers. From April, the average household bill increased by £44 per year. That's on top of a 8.8% rise the year before. Scottish Water said more investment was needed as current infrastructure is put under 'significant pressure' by more extreme weather conditions, such as more periods of drought and intense rainfall. The Scottish Lib Dems said this year's pay rises are the third highest on record, despite water bills going up sharply and 24,398 sewage dumps last year. 'The SNP government is rewarding their water company for failure,' Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP said. 'Scottish Water are paying out enormous bonuses to bosses who are presiding over filthy sewage dumps and hitting customers with bigger bills.' Chief operating officer Peter Farrer saw his salary fall by around £20,000 but his overall package increased to £312,000. Chief financial officer Alan Dingwall, who joined the firm last year, was paid a salary of £175,000 and a total package of £293,000. But the body's annual report also shows a record performance in the past year in customer satisfaction – which hit 94% – as well as other positive results in leak reduction and the halving of serious pollution, leading Mr Plant to describe the past 12 months as 'our strongest year ever'. A spokesman for the utility company said: 'Scottish Water is one of the largest and best-performing utilities in the UK, but executive pay is significantly lower than in similarly sized private companies, where we need to compete for talent. 'Across the business, the biggest percentage pay rises have been given to the lowest-paid workers, narrowing the gap between the chief executive's pay and median employee earnings, which is already much smaller than the pay ratios in other companies of our scale. 'Total remuneration also includes pension contributions and variable pay related to performance, which is only paid when the business delivers strong results, as it did last year, with 94% customer satisfaction. 'Every Scottish Water employee is eligible for an annual outperformance payment.' The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Guardian
27 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Government is a living organism, not a machine
Martin Kettle is right to call for leaders who can operate the machinery of government (Opinion, 7 August). However, it should be made clear that the machinery of government – in which I work as a senior civil servant – is not a 'machine', as many current leaders assume. In his 2024 book On Leadership, Tony Blair says leaders often make the mistake of believing that the machinery of government is 'like an instrument in their hands' that they can learn how to use. It is not an instrument, he points out, but 'a living organism [with] a mind and a temperament'. This common misunderstanding of the nature of the system underpins the government's consistent inability to deliver. Anne Owers' independent prison capacity review is just the latest example. Machines can be mastered with manuals, precise plans and predictable cause-and-effect levers, but living organisms behave differently. As anyone who has raised a toddler or a teenager can attest: predictability and cause-and-effect do not apply. Linear approaches suitable for the 'machine', such as plans and targets, are ineffective, serving only to increase bureaucracy. Meanwhile, all remains quiet on the delivery front. Owers' review evidences this, describing the prisons-capacity response as bureaucratic and repetitive, with too much discussion and too little action. Treating the machinery of government like a complex organism, rather than a machine, is the only way it will be effectively deployed. The UK government's own guidance on 'systems thinking for civil servants', as well as research by the Institute for Government, acknowledges this, with the latter noting that the machinery of government cannot be 'controlled through plans and 'levers''. Yet time and again, leaders fall back on the same familiar levers, expecting different results. They deploy tools suitable for the 'machine', including endless plans and committees. Bureaucracy begets bureaucracy, while delivery is missing in action. Breaking this cycle will remain unsuccessful for as long as leaders continue to treat government as a 'machine'.Name and address supplied Martin Kettle correctly identifies the stranglehold that Treasury orthodoxy has on government, but does not go far enough in identifying the source. Supply-side theory claims that growth comes when entrepreneurs are given incentives such as tax breaks or subsidies. Private businesses will employ people and the wealth they create, the taxes they pay, will allow government to improve public services. Forty years of failure has not dented faith in this flawed doctrine. Perhaps because those who administer the policies do not suffer the effects. Instead of giving money to rich businessmen, much of which finds its way into tax havens, why not try using it productively through existing channels? Public spending is not a dirty word. Creating a safe, healthy and prosperous society is the essence of government. Local authorities, especially in poor areas, are desperate for funds to keep their communities in a half-decent state: give them money to rebuild and repair, perhaps with encouragement to source locally. Bring in a local income tax instead of rates. Reverse the increase in employer's national insurance contributions, which is a tax on jobs. When demand increases, supply will follow. In this way the economy will grow organically, sustainably and all around the DaviesNewton-le-Willows, Merseyside Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
