
Activist had flagged flaw in Mumbra stn curvature 4 months ago: ‘In accordance with standard practices', Railways had responded
On Monday morning, four people lost their lives and seven others were injured after passengers fell off two moving local trains near Mumbra railway station in Thane.
According to officials, the incident occurred when Kasara-bound train, which started from Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus, experienced a sudden jerk while navigating a sharp curve between Diva and Mumbra stations, causing commuters standing at the doors of the two trains to collide and fall off.
Notably, exactly four months ago, activist Ananda Maruti Patil from Diva had warned Central Railways about the potential for such a tragedy, urging immediate action. His concerns, however, went unaddressed—culminating in the very disaster he had tried to prevent.
On February 20 , Patil, a 50-year-old resident of Diva, wrote to the Railway Minister and the General Manager of Central Railways, raising serious concerns about passenger safety on the Kalwa–Mumbra–Diva stretch. Patil said he was compelled to take this step following repeated accidents and mounting complaints from fellow commuters about the dangers along this corridor.
'Beyond Kalwa station, particularly around the Parsik tunnel, and on both the Up and Down lines near Mumbra station, as well as along the curved stretches leading to Diva, train coaches tend to tilt while in motion,' Patil wrote in the letter.
'During peak hours, due to extreme overcrowding, train compartments are heavily packed. As a result, when trains tilt, passengers standing near the doors lose balance due to the pressure of the crowd and are thrown out of the train. Several commuters have suffered serious injuries, and tragically, some have lost their lives. These incidents are happening repeatedly, creating a serious threat to passenger safety. I urge you to take immediate and appropriate action in this regard and inform me in writing about the steps taken,' Patil had said in his letter.
A month later, Patil received a response from the Railways acknowledging the presence of curves along the stretch, stating that the track design, including the curvature, was in accordance with standard practices outlined in the Railway Manual.
'The major track portion between Kalwa–Mumbra–Diva is on a curvature. As per standard practice given in the Railway Manual, CANT (the raising of the outer rail on a curve) is provided in curve to facilitate the safe and smooth riding on the curve. While providing CANT, normally the outer rail is kept higher than the inner rail. Hence, the train leans towards the inner track while travelling over the curve. The technical survey has also been done for the same,' the Railways said in its reply dated March 18.
Patil said the Railways failed to act after his formal complaint.
'The root cause of repeated accidents on the Mumbra–Kalwa–Diva route is the uncontrolled overcrowding and the tilting of coaches on curved sections of the track. I had officially raised this issue with the Ministry of Railways. While the authorities acknowledged the technical aspects, no concrete safety measures have been implemented. This continued endangerment of passengers' lives must stop. Mumbai-bound trains should begin from Diva station to reduce the load,' said Patil.
Interestingly, the Railways has addressed similar safety concerns in the past. In March 2024, after multiple incidents of passengers falling from trains between Sion and Kurla stations, the Railways undertook 'track slewing'—a process involving the lateral shifting of tracks to increase the distance between them. This is done to reduce the risk of passengers standing at doorways colliding when trains pass each other at close proximity. The intervention was prompted by reports from the Railway Protection Force (RPF) highlighting repeated accidents in that section.
Patil said a similar timely intervention on the Mumbra–Diva stretch could have saved the four lives lost in Monday's tragedy.
'It's heartbreaking to see how people from far-off places travel to Mumbai in such inhuman conditions. The congestion on platforms and inside trains reduces commuters to mere cattle. This dehumanisation of working-class passengers must end,' said the activist.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NDTV
6 hours ago
- NDTV
Ashwini Vaishnaw Suspends 4 after After Dilapidated Train Sent To Pick Soldiers
New Delhi: Four railway officials have been suspended after a dilapidated train was allotted to carry Border Security Force personnel to Jammu and Kashmir for security duty during the Amarnath Yatra. Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw, who took action after the complaint, has also ordered a probe into the matter. A new train has been arranged for the BSF personnel and the minister has directed that there should be no repeat of such an incident in future. The special train will now be run from Agartala for the BSF personnel, in which their convenience will be taken care of, the minister has said. The officers who have been suspended with immediate effect include the Officer of Coaching Depot and three senior Section Engineers of Alipurduar Division. The controversy started after a video of the earlier train, allegedly made by the jawans, was widely circulated on social media. The video showed the dilapidated condition of the structure, including doors, windows, roof and electrical equipment. There were piles of dirt and garbage in the compartments. Immediately after the video went viral, the Railways clarified that the compartments were to be sent for overhauling and were mistakenly attached to the BSF special train. After the uproar on social media, NW Frontier Railway clarified on X that the allegation that such a coach was provided to BSF for travel is wrong. It said coaches are made available for travel only after necessary maintenance, repair and cleaning. The train seen in the video was being sent for repairs and was not meant for the travel of BSF forces, the Railways said. BSF sources in Delhi said the train for Jammu was to start from Tripura's Udaipur Monday and was to ferry a whole battalion -- about 13 companies -- of troops. These soldiers are to be deployed for the Amarnath Yatra and were to reach by June 12. But now due to the change in trains, the soldiers will not be able to reach Jammu in time. Amarnath Yatra is to start from July 3.


Indian Express
13 hours ago
- Indian Express
From July, no Tatkal railway ticket booking without Aadhaar authentication
In order to prevent the malpractices by agents and ensure that common people receive the benefit of Tatkal ticket scheme, the Ministry of Railways has modified the scheme. From July, only those users who have authenticated their account using Aadhaar will be able to book tatkal tickets. 'With effect from 01.07.2025, tickets under tatkal scheme can be booked through the website of Indian Railways Catering and Tourism Corporation (IRCTC)/its app only by Aadhaar authenticated users. Subsequently, Aadhaar-based OTP authentication shall also be made compulsory for the tatkal booking from 15.07.2025,' reads the circular issued by the Railway Ministry on June 10. Along with the online ticket booking system, the new rule will be applied on counter tickets as well. 'Tatkal tickets shall be available for booking through computerised PRS (passenger reservation system) counters of Indian Railways/authorised agents only after authentication of a system generated OTP which shall be sent through the system on the mobile number furnished by the user at the time of booking. This shall also be implemented by 15.07.2025,' said the circular further. According to the new rule, the authorised ticketing agents of the Indian Railways shall not be allowed to book tatkal tickets during the first 30 minutes of opening of booking for AC as well as non-AC travel classes. It means the agents will not be allowed to book tatkal tickets from 10 am to 10.30 am for air-conditioned classes and from 11 am to 11.30 am for non-air conditioned classes. The Centre for Railway Information Systems (CRIS), the technological wing of the Indian Railways, and IRCTC have been asked to make necessary modification in the system accordingly under intimation to all zonal railways. According to the data available with the Ministry of Railways, every day, around 2,25,000 passengers book Tatkal tickets through the online platform of the Indian Railways. An analysis of the online Tatkal ticket booking pattern from May 24 to June 2 by the Railways shows that on an average 5,615 out of 1,08,000 AC class tickets were booked in the first minute after the window opened. A total of 22,827 tickets were booked in the second minute. In the AC class, an average of 67,159 tickets or 62.5 per cent of Tatkal tickets daily were booked online within the first 10 minutes of the window opening. The remaining 37.5 per cent tickets were booked between 10 minutes till chart preparation, out of which 3.01 per cent of Tatkal tickets were booked after 10 hours of the window opening. In the non-AC category, from May 24 to June 2, an average of 1,18,567 tickets were booked online daily. Of these, 4,724 tickets — about 4 per cent — were booked within the first minute, while 20,786 tickets — about 17.5 per cent — were booked in the second minute. Approximately 66.4 percent of tickets were sold within the first 10 minutes after the window opened and the rest of the tickets were booked after that. A senior official of the Ministry of Railways said that the proposal for the e-Aadhaar authentication system is part of the campaign against the use of automated tools to book tickets online. Dheeraj Mishra is a Principal correspondent with The Indian Express, Business Bureau. He covers India's two key ministries- Ministry of Railways and Ministry of Road Transport & Highways. He frequently uses the Right to Information (RTI) Act for his stories, which have resulted in many impactful reports. ... Read More


Time of India
20 hours ago
- Time of India
Thane tragedy: ‘CCTV cameras' view blocked by trains, those injured too can't tell how they fell'
MUMBAI: Central Railway on Tuesday set up a five-member committee of senior officials to investigate the sequence of events leading to the Mumbra tragedy. The probe panel includes the senior divisional security commissioner, senior divisional mechanical engineer, senior divisional electrical engineer, senior divisional engineer, and the senior divisional operations manager. CR's chief public relations officer Swapnil Nila said, "There is no fixed deadline, but the committee has been asked to submit its findings at the earliest." A senior RPF official said, "We have reviewed CCTV footage from the platform, but it doesn't offer much insight as the view was blocked by the trains themselves." Adding to the mystery, officials said even the injured commuters have been unable to provide clear accounts of how they fell. "There is talk of passengers being flung and colliding with the opposite train, but nothing is confirmed yet," an official said. The incident occurred at the Diva end near Mumbra railway station. Preliminary observations suggest the incident occurred when two fast locals-a Kasara-CSMT train and a CSMT-Karjat one-crossed each other ahead of the curve. It is suspected that shoulder bags or luggage brushing against passengers could have destabilised those on the edge. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Deze plug-in SUV is écht compleet. Ontdek het zelf. Meer informatie Undo CR has not imposed any additional speed restrictions on the stretch following the accident. Of the 13 commuters involved in the mishap, 11 were aboard the Kasara-CSMT fast local, while two were on the CSMT-Karjat train. Of the deceased, Vicky Mukhyadal and Mayur Shah were in the CSMT-Karjat train, while Ketan Saroj and Rahul Gupta were travelling on the Kasara-CSMT local. An official said scratch marks were found on the exterior of the Kasara-CSMT train's last coach. "It appears that a passenger's bag may have grazed the coach of the opposite train, which may have triggered the incident," the official said. Meanwhile, the local staff from Mumbra railway station who attended to the mishap victims are likely to be called in for questioning. The railway police, guided by the assistant commissioner of police, railways, CSMT, on Tuesday inspected the spot where the victims were found following the mishap to look for clues. -Inputs by Manoj Badgeri