We need to talk about AI's staggering ecological impact
artificial intelligence (AI)
,
climate change
, war, economic turmoil and the concentration of power and wealth in ever-fewer hands. For the first time since the Second World war, higher education is not delivering the pay premium and secure employment it once did.
Because of advances in technology, the friendly receptionist is gradually being replaced by a screen, chatbot and intelligent security system. Bookkeeping can be done easily by an app that links to your bank account. The data entry clerk may be a vanishing tribe. AI can design a website, a marketing strategy and a business plan in seconds, for free or very little cost. It can generate legal documents, intricate engineering designs and write code. It will revolutionise healthcare and education and open up many new ways to access knowledge and solve intractable problems.
The technology could also
eliminate half of all entry-level white-collar roles
within five years, according to Dario Amodei, chief executive of Anthropic. However, many of the 'green' skills that the
energy transition
requires will still be in demand. Jobs that require on-the-spot problem-solving skills, along with caring roles and strategic and creative thinking, are probably the most secure for the moment.
When asked on a podcast recently what careers young people should train in, the so-called godfather of AI
Geoffrey Hinton
answered emphatically: plumbing. Robots can't (yet) navigate awkward spaces like attics or conduct manual tasks that require high levels of skill and dexterity. There's probably an AI chatbot capable of diagnosing your plumbing problem, but only an actual plumber can fix it.
READ MORE
AI will have social, psychological, ethical, organisational and ecological impacts that are difficult to fully predict. And that is the most benign version of what might happen. Many leading AI developers are now concerned about the potential for AI to do serious harm, with lethal autonomous weapons just one of the grim possibilities, alongside concerns about privacy, manipulation and algorithmic bias.
[
Why 'godfather' of AI Geoffrey Hinton quit Google to speak out about risks
Opens in new window
]
One of the impacts of AI that is too little discussed is the ecological one. It has what has been described by environmental news website
earth.org
as having a 'a staggering carbon footprint'.
OpenAI
researchers have estimated that since 2012, the amount of power required to train AI models, which often have billions of parameters, has
doubled every 3.4 months
.
A ChatGPT query
is estimated to consume
about five times more electricity than a simple web search.
The
International Energy Agency
estimates that the aggregate energy demand and climate impact of data centres alone will match that of Japan by 2026.
While the tech companies argue that digital technologies can lead to efficiency gains (for example, 'smart buildings' and 'smart grids'), these gains can be offset by increased demand for digital services and devices, leading to a net increase in energy consumption, material use and emissions. And while renewable energy sources can displace fossil fuels, there is simply not enough land, water and raw materials to meet the ever-growing demand for data centres and digital services.
In Ireland, data centres are already consuming 50 per cent of the electricity in the Dublin region and
over 20 per cent nationally
, requiring higher levels of fossil energy to balance the grid. The Cambridge Minderoo Centre has warned of a potential 25-fold increase in global tech sector energy use by 2040 due to AI, which will put net-zero goals in jeopardy.
[
Data centres and other large users of electricity to be allowed to build and operate own lines to power plants
Opens in new window
]
At some point we will have to decide whether the profits of the tech sector's investors and shareholders are more important than the future of humanity and this fragile planet.
By the time we start asking the right questions about AI, it will already be too late: the genie is well and truly out of the bottle. The data centre boom, with all its energy and water demands, will already have happened. Our data will have been fed into the AI systems and used to target us with bespoke advertising and even political content. AI tools have already been dropped into typical computer software and applications without any of us asking for it. If the strategy of the tech sector is to make us dependent on chatbots and AI so that it can start charging for their use, they have probably already succeeded.
Sadhbh O'Neill is a climate and environmental researcher
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
17 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Would-be homebuyers urged not to hold off in expectation of lower mortgage rates
Borrowers and would-be homebuyers should be wary of making financial decisions 'based on the hope that European Central Bank (ECB) rates will drop further or indefinitely'. That's according to Trevor Grant , chairman and co-founder of Irish Mortgage Advisors. Mr Grant was speaking after the Central Bank published its latest monthly data on interest rates in Wednesday, showing Ireland remained one of the more expensive jurisdictions in the euro zone for mortgages . The regulator's latest monthly data indicated that the weighted average interest rate on new mortgages here fell marginally to 3.6 per cent in June. READ MORE This was down one basis point from 3.61 in May and 51 basis points lower in annual terms. The equivalent euro zone average was 3.29 per cent, the Central Bank said, making Ireland the seventh most expensive jurisdiction in the bloc. The latest figures come after last month's decision by the ECB to pause a recent run of interest rate cuts. Analysts now anticipate that there might be just one more cut this year, in December. 'This significant shift in ECB policy could not only mark the end of its rate cutting cycle, it could also herald that ECB rate hikes might be on the cards in late 2026, particularly if inflation starts to edge upwards in the EU again,' Mr Grant said. 'So mortgage borrowers and would-be house buyers should be mindful that the pace of further mortgage rate cuts is likely to slow or even come to an end,' he said. 'Borrowers should therefore avoid making large financial decisions based on the hope that ECB rates will drop further or indefinitely.' He said there were many reasons why Ireland remains one of the more expensive euro zone countries for mortgages. 'For example, Irish lenders are required to hold more capital than many of their European peers,' he said. 'Also, when a borrower defaults on a mortgage, Irish lenders have stated that they often find it more difficult than other European lenders to take control of and sell off the assets that were pledged as collateral to secure the mortgage,' he said. 'Notwithstanding all this, there is still room for improvement and slowly competition is bringing rates down.' Rachel McGovern , deputy chief executive at industry group Brokers Ireland , said while more competition is entering the mortgage market the benefit may become more evident later in the year. The Central Bank figures also show that Irish consumers had €166 billion in savings with Irish banks as of last month. Of that, over 85 per cent – or over €142 billion – is held in overnight deposit accounts which are attracting a meagre 0.13 per cent in interest on average. Retail banks here have been criticised for failing to increase their deposit rates in line with ECB levels while reporting big annual profits. The figures also show that an increasing number of new mortgage holders are opting for fixed rates, which now constitute 85 per cent of all new mortgage contracts. 'Mortgage borrowers are seeking security,' Ms McGovern said. 'With property prices continuing to increase, they are taking on ever higher levels of debt.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Electric vehicles account for one in five new cars licensed in July
Electric vehicles accounted for 20 per cent of the rising number of cars licensed in July, the Central Statistics Office said. July is an important month in the motor industry calendar as 252-registered cars come on to the market for the first time. The number of new private cars licensed in July 2025 was 8 per cent higher compared to 2024, according to the CSO, at 19,923. Of that, almost 4,000 were electric vehicles, a rise of 64 per cent year on year. EVs accounted for almost 20 per cent of the new cars licensed during the month, with plug-in hybrid vehicles at 15 per cent. Petrol cars remain the most popular, at 5,030, but that figure is 13 per cent year lower than at the same time last year, while diesel also showed a decline to 3,242, or a 22 per cent fall-off. READ MORE The combined share of petrol and diesel cars has fallen to 44 per cent compared to 56 per cent in 2024 over the seven months. Electric vehicles have continued to grow in popularity despite concerns over charging infrastructure. The share of EVs among new private cars licensed between January and July 2025 was 17 per cent, up from 14 per cent in 2024. Plug in hybrids have also become increasingly popular rising from 9 per cent over the same period in 2024 to 15 per cent, and up 56 per cent in the month. 'In the first seven months of 2025, there was a rise of 34 per cent in new private electric cars licensed when compared with the same period in 2024,' said Damien Lenihan, a statistician in the transport section of the CSO. 'There were 26,454 new petrol cars licensed compared with 30,911 in the same period of 2024, a fall of 14 per cent. Comparing the first seven months of 2025 with 2024, the number of new diesel cars licensed decreased by 23 per cent.' Toyota was the most popular make of new private vehicle last month, followed by Volkswagen, Hyundai, Škoda and Kia. The Volkswagen ID4 topped the list of popular cars, with Hyundai's lower cost Inster in second place. The number of used imported cars licensed also rose, increasing by 17 per cent compared to July 2024, to 6,640.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gallagher quit Nutribrand after firm decided to change chairman, says presidential hopeful Sheridan
Former presidential candidate Seán Gallagher resigned from his role at Nutribrand after it decided to replace him as chairman, the company's chief executive, Gareth Sheridan , has said. Mr Sheridan, who announced his own bid for the presidency over the weekend, said the company was 'surprised' when Mr Gallagher raised the issue of a basketball corporate box in his January 2022 resignation letter. The 35-year-old pharma businessman from Terenure in Dublin intends to run as an independent candidate, seeking a nomination from local authorities to get on the ballot paper. Mr Sheridan cofounded US-based Nutribrand in 2012, which utilises technology to prevent the abuse of patch medications such as fentanyl. READ MORE Mr Gallagher, another Irish businessman who came second in the presidential race of 2011, became chairman of Nutribrand in 2018. However, according to Mr Sheridan, Mr Gallagher resigned from the role in January 2022 when communications broke down over a change in corporate structure. A spokesman for Mr Sheridan said Mr Gallagher's resignation came shortly after the company decided his role should be filled by 'someone with US capital markets experience'. It was decided that Serguei Melnik, a cofounder of Nutribrand, would be appointed chairman and that Mr Gallagher would 'voluntarily vacate' the role and remain as director on the same remuneration package. 'Communication broke down at this point,' the spokesman said, and Mr Gallagher submitted a resignation in January 2022. The spokesman said the company was 'surprised' when Mr Gallagher referenced a corporate box in his resignation letter. In 2020 the company paid $180,000 for a corporate box from basketball team Orlando Magic at the Amway Arena Stadium in Florida, for a renewable one-year period. The company described it as a 'good fit' because 'it is the NBA's most prominent team in the fight against the misuse of opioids'. Nutribrand retains this corporate box and has extended its contract, the spokesman said. Also declared as presidential contenders are former MEP Mairead McGuinness, selected as Fine Gael's candidate, and Independent TD for Galway West Catherine Connolly, who has support from Oireachtas members. No other parties have announced candidates as yet.
