How Live Aid ruined pop music
So, we exported Marxism to Ethiopia and it starved to death – and now we had the temerity to add Spandau Ballet, Phil Collins and Nik Kershaw on top
I was 17, and though I couldn't articulate why, I felt that there was something wrong about the whole affair. 'Crowds, properly worked up by skillful demagogues, are ready to believe anything,' H.L. Mencken wrote in 1918, and I felt in my bones that Bob Geldof, however well-intentioned, was rousing a rabble and flattening their thoughts.
Modern mass-produced western pop music, for me, just doesn't belong outdoors. It is a wonderful thing – but it is unnatural, synthetic, and contrived. It is best enjoyed alone at home or in small interior venues. Enormous rallies exalt it beyond its range, or rather they alter it into a mass Bacchic rite.
I could feel a strange cultural gear shifting, even though I couldn't put it into words. For me, Live Aid felt like the end of something, or a transformation of something beyond its natural limits. A study of Spotify data in 2018 reported that our musical taste is locked in when we are young teens – 14 for men, 13 for women. It follows that the first changes in music that happen after that age are going to be particularly jarring for us. To an ordinary disinterested observer, the differences between the charts of 1982 and 1985 will seem very minor. But to me, at that crucial age, it was very apparent that something had dropped off, and Live Aid put the tin hat on that.
The pop scene of 82 was playful, varied and – however flat footed – innovative. Soft Cell, ABC, Yazoo, The Associates, The Teardrop Explodes, Shalamar, Dexy's; they were all very different. Live Aid was a massive top-down corporate flattening-out of all that. It was the return of superannuated rock gods and the establishment of a gaggle of newer, much dumber concerns – Madonna, U2 and Paul Young. Pop was never exactly Mensa, no, but the brains it did have evaporated that day, and they never really came back.
My little new wave bubble was well and truly burst. It had run off the fumes of Bowie's 1977 albums Low and Heroes, and in a strange way this came full circle with Bowie's set at Live Aid. The song 'Heroes' was reborn that day – the edge and the angst of it sawn away as it became a self-glorifying stadium rock anthem.
There were other oddities and infelicities in the line-up. The inclusion of Adam Ant, who hadn't had a sniff of a hit for years, just seemed peculiar in 1985. Bryan Ferry, with a back catalogue of huge singalong smashes, decided instead to plug noodling non-single tracks from his latest album. And there were frequent crass juxtapositions, the most 'powerful' being the playing of the twee, maudlin synth whinge 'Drive' by The Cars over footage of dying Ethiopian children. Pop music, a marvellous bauble, was simply not equipped for these emotions or situations.
The other thing which gave me the abdabs was the idea that pop stars were now moral exemplars. From that day on we were supposed to revere these people. Cue the pompous windbaggery of Sting, Bono, etc. jetting around the planet combining their grotty little ditties with geo-politics and trite zero-sum economics platitudes – 'they have nothing because we have everything'. Because the troubles of the world were somehow all our fault.
In a way, they were. The Ethiopian famine certainly was, but not in the way Live Aid blithely assumed. It was the direct result of the deadliest of western exports, Marxism. The Derg regime of Ethiopia, the Red Terror, the forced farm collectivisation and land 'reforms'. The Marxist government of the dictator Mengistu is estimated to be responsible for the deaths of two million Ethiopians in the famine. But don't worry. Mengistu is living in luxury in exile in Harare, today.
So, we exported Marxism to Ethiopia and it starved to death – and now we had the temerity to add Spandau Ballet, Phil Collins and Nik Kershaw on top. Worse, we had idiot westerners like the Style Council advocating for the same ideology, from the safe distance of Woking, enjoying all the freedoms and plenty of western capitalism, and knowing full well that their puerile political bluff would never be called.
So I won't be joining in the Live Aid anniversary celebrations today. It makes me feel quite queasy, even 40 years on.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
14 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Phil Collins' reason for hospitalization is revealed after viral rumors say he was in hospice
Phil Collins is not in hospice, despite rumors swirling the internet. The 74-year-old retired Genesis drummer and singer is in the hospital for knee surgery, a rep for the musician told TMZ. The outlet wrote, further citing the rep, that Collins is 'nowhere near death'. Concerned fans took to social media earlier this week to express fear over the worst case scenario. The former entertainer put away stopped playing drums in 2022 due to physical limitations, and in February said he no longer wants to make music. 'I keep thinking I should go downstairs to the studio and see what happens,' the Grammy winner told MOJO magazine, adding, 'But I'm not hungry for it anymore. The thing is, I've been sick, I mean very sick...' The Rock and Roll Hall of Famer, suffers from type 2 diabetes and complications from a spine injury he incurred nearly 20 years ago. 'My vertebrae have been crushing my spinal cord because of the position I drum in. It comes from years of playing,' he told Daily Mail in 2009. 'I can't even hold the sticks properly without it being painful. I even used to tape the sticks to my hands to get through,' he said at the time, adding cheekily, 'Don't worry, I can still sing.' The MOJO interview was part of a larger story that served as a retrospective for all the eras of Genesis. The actor, who is the father of Emily in Paris star Lily Collins, got his start in show business as the Artful Dodger in Oliver on London's West End in 1964. During that time, the young actor, who had been drumming since the age of five, got to know the orchestra leader and the drummer, which inspired him to become a professional percussionist, according to Drumeo. Collins auditioned for Genesis and joined the group in 1970 at age 19, replacing John Mayhew on drums. He became the frontman for the group when Peter Gabriel left to pursue a solo career in August 1975. The group released eight albums together, collecting numerous awards before Collins exited to pursue a solo career in 1996. During that time he won eight Grammy awards, six Brit Awards, four Billboard Music Awards, three American Music Awards, two Golden Globes and an Oscar. Phil's health update comes days after he paid tribute to Ozzy Osbourne following his death on Tuesday at age 76. He shared a throwback photo of the two music artists embracing with smiles on their faces. The caption simply read, 'In happier times, love always PC x.'
Times
3 days ago
- Times
Why Moby is working with a Russian teen — Music brings us together
Over a four-decade career in which he took ambient music and sampling to the mainstream, at one point seemingly soundtracking every advert on television, Moby has worked with the bona fide greats. 'Ridiculously well-known people, like Ozzy Osbourne, Britney Spears and Michael Jackson,' the DJ, producer, songwriter and professional vegan says — and that's without mentioning his friend David Bowie. Next up? Dmitry Volynkin. Dmitry who? Also known as Øneheart, the Russian producer has just turned 19, and already has a song, Snowfall, with 970 million Spotify streams — making it perhaps the most successful ambient track to date. The kid was born seven years after the release of Moby's behemoth album, Play. Moby is 59. They are an unlikely pairing, yet this week are releasing a single, Lagrange Point — a gorgeous swell of synth that also features a musician called Leadwave, aka Volynkin's dad. To find out how this happened I jump on a Zoom call with Moby and Volynkin. It is audio only: Moby says that, after he watched the first series of the tech thriller Mr Robot (2015), he disabled his cameras and I don't think he's joking. • Moby: 'I read The Sunday Times and wake up 15 times a night' 'It is nice meet you,' Volynkin says to Moby. 'Nice to meet you too,' Moby replies. Hang on — you have made a song together, but not met? 'No, but there are thousands of miles between us, not to mention 10 time zones,' says Moby, who lives in Los Angeles, while Volynkin is in Moscow. 'So there has just been a lot of file sharing.' Against the backdrop of the war in Ukraine and tensions between Trump and Putin, it is a tricky time for a Russian to collaborate with an American. Russian artists such as the opera star Anna Netrebko have been banned from performing in the US, while its musicians have been excluded from the Eurovision Song Contest. Russian artists who oppose the war have been exiled by Putin, while Spotify has removed pro-war Russian artists from its platform. Moby is happy to explain why he is reaching out across the divide. 'I don't want to be in any way glib or dismissive,' he begins, 'but politics are not people. I have toured for years, going from Lebanon to Israel, and guess what? The people generally do the same thing. They're having meals, going to work and sleeping and stressing about their health. They don't have the time to hate. Geopolitical divisions in no way reflect the reality of most lives. 'And for the most part, politicians just make things worse. In terms of AI, looking at the current state of politics, I almost feel we'd be better off with robot politicians, especially in the United States. So Americans are not Trump, Russians are not Putin, Israelis are not Netanyahu. Politicians are not people — they are pernicious, corrupting anomalies, and music reminds people globally that we are not reflected by them.' Volynkin, understandably, is rather less vocal. After all, he lives in a country at war. 'Well, there are always some problems,' he says. 'But I prefer to think we are just all here for the music. Since I started growing a fanbase, I've been getting hate when people realise where I am from and that's really a hard topic for me to discuss. Politics is for politicians. I'm just making music.' • The best albums of 2025 so far Lagrange Point, which also features the Russian ambient artists Dean Korso and Reidenshi, came about when Volynkin and his father were fiddling about on tracks, the old man sharing his Moby vinyl collection. His son asked: 'What if we reached out to Moby?' That, in itself, is not so strange, but why did Moby say yes? 'I was in LA and the [radio] station KCRW was playing Snowfall,' he says. 'It took me aback. Where are the drums? Where are the vocals? But, clearly, it's a beautiful piece of music, and afterwards the DJ talked about the phenomenon, and how it found this bafflingly huge audience. It's probably the only time in the history of KCRW that they have played quiet, ambient music at two in the afternoon.' Yet as lush as Snowfall is, it is pretty weird, I say, that it has reached such a global audience. That number of streams is Lady Gaga and Beyoncé territory, not that of some Russian teenager. 'But it's the idea of music as refuge,' Moby says. 'We live in a world with a constant onslaught of demanding data and information, two-minute-long songs as loud as they can be. It's almost like if you want to get people's attention, you should do the opposite. Instead of shoving it down throats, be quiet instead. Humans are stressed and scared, and need that moment of calm.' Moby says the real boon of Snowfall is that it is a hit that no algorithm could have predicted. 'Look, AI is pretty good at convention,' he says. 'At looking at pop music and deconstructing it. But the history of music is full of counterintuitive surprise and if, a couple of years ago, you'd given a prompt to some magical AI songwriting platform and said, 'OK, generate a piece of music that, in the current musical climate, is going to generate a billion streams' — well, it would not have created a delicate piece of ambient music. AI is good at taking one plus one and getting two, whereas humans take one plus one and get 15 million. The end result is so much more than the sum of its parts.' • Read more music reviews, interviews and guides on what to listen to next Volynkin was born in the small town of Kirsanov and remembers, at just six, listening to Russian rock music with his father. Then he discovered electronic music and installed software to make it on his grandfather's computer. 'I was experimenting, starting from dubstep and house,' he says. He uses ChatGPT to help him to write Instagram posts, but when it comes to music, he stays away from the available tools. 'We've all heard of this AI band, the Velvet Sundown,' he says, 'who are growing really fast. It sounds horrible.' And how much of Volynkin's mother country seeps into his gorgeous, highly emotive soundscapes? 'In Russia, there are a lot of people who make sad songs,' he says, adding that he wants to focus on beauty. Assuming the Moby single brings Volynkin an even larger audience, who would he pick to collaborate with next? 'Charli XCX,' he says. 'I fell in love with Brat and her discography is amazing.' I wouldn't rule it out.
The Guardian
3 days ago
- The Guardian
Khruangbin, again? I quit Spotify for a month to escape samey algorithms – this is what I learned
If you use music to set or fix your mood, Spotify is a tantalising tool. Feeling sad? Cry to your personalised 'Depress Sesh Mix'. In a romantic crisis? Stew in your own 'Situationship Mix'. As I write this, I'm listening to Spotify's Daylist, a mix that refreshes every few hours based on my own listening habits. Today's vibe is 'funky beats roller skating tuesday early morning mix'. At 120bpm, the algorithm knows I need some energetic house to roll from my bed to my desk. The problem with this listening experience isn't just the creepy AI-driven intimacy of it all, more that the same songs are recycled in a predictable loop. Spotify's algorithm has anaesthetised artists I once enjoyed. Every time I hear the slippery psychedelic bass of Khruangbin slinking into one of my playlists, or flow in seamlessly from another artist's radio, I violently hit skip. A decade ago, Spotify favoured human-curated playlists made by artists, celebrities and music aficionados. But in 2021 the streaming company pivoted towards machine learning, feeding 'nearly half a trillion events' into computer models every day. Now, user data – chiefly our listening history, interactions with Spotify's user interface and the time of day – is packaged into a mixtape for every micro-occasion. Advocates argue this is a chance to democratise music promotion, neatly matching artists with their audiences. Critics suggest this ultra-subjective experience limits musical discovery to the already familiar – and the less it's challenged, the more my music taste narrows. So as a test, I quit Spotify for a month, to bring some soul back into the way I find music. First, I consulted people who had never used streaming services, like my dad, who grew up in 1970s London in the heyday of punk and glam rock. Hunched in a booth in his local record shop, he would listen to a sample and take a punt on what vinyl to buy. Some albums apparently missed the mark, and others, like Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon, transported him to a different universe. He insisted I start with my favourite artists and listen to every album front to back, as if reading a story. Sign up for the fun stuff with our rundown of must-reads, pop culture and tips for the weekend, every Saturday morning Inspired, I bought a $30 record player in an op-shop and hunted for vinyls. Late to the record renaissance, it was slim pickings – Australian pub classics, Christian country or Christmas hits. But when a friend pointed out my new turntable was missing a needle, it became a dusty but decorative addition to my living room. My 20-year-old neighbour had another suggestion: a diamante-encrusted iPod, which she produced in a ziplock bag like a hallowed artefact. Found for $200 on Facebook Marketplace, plugging in wired earplugs and hitting shuffle was a nostalgic throwback. But this romance was short-lived: the iPod was incompatible with my Bluetooth speaker and demanded hours of admin to upload music. The biggest challenge came when driving my old silver Subaru, as I was stranded with only a single CD, a flimsy aux cord and my thoughts. Stuck with silence, I wondered what the new grinding noise was – until I discovered my local community broadcaster, Vox FM 106.9. More than 5 million Australians listen to community radio every week, for 17 hours on average – and now, I can see why. The station prides itself on 'real music' and even has the tagline 'You never know what you like until you try it'. Just what I needed! And it's true, I had forgotten how good it feels to wind down the windows and blast Push the Button by the Sugababes, and then to roll them up again when a classical German song, a mystery even to Shazam, comes on. Sign up to Saved for Later Catch up on the fun stuff with Guardian Australia's culture and lifestyle rundown of pop culture, trends and tips after newsletter promotion I contacted Justin Moon, who runs a popular underground radio station and record shop in Newcastle. He sources music from record fairs, friends and Bandcamp – distributing interesting sounds as a conduit, or Hermes figure, to lay (or lazy) people like me. Moon is noticing that his customers are searching for a more 'active' listening experience. 'It's not this kind of passive wash-over-you rubbish that you make your two-minute noodles to and forget all about 10 seconds later,' he says. Music – like film, TV, and food – is now served to us effortlessly, instantly. But this has caused the way we consume music to be more siloed. Spending a month hunting for new music myself, rather than relying on an algorithm, made me feel more connected to my parents, friends, radio presenters and even complete strangers. Their recommendations – whether to my taste or not – came with a part of themselves, a memory or a shared interest. After my month's Spotify hiatus, my algorithm hasn't been cleansed. Over the course of writing this piece, my daylist has evolved into 'french indietronica swimming pool tuesday afternoon', whatever that means. There are two Khruangbin songs on there. It's safe to say I would rather play roulette with the radio.
