Turkey opens Spotify probe after 'provocative playlist' complaint
In a statement released on Friday, the competition authority said it had opened an investigation into "various allegations that the strategies and policies implemented by Spotify... in Turkey has caused anti-competitive effects in the music industry".
It said the probe would seek to establish whether Spotify gave more visibility to some artists and engaged in unfair practices in the distribution of royalties, thereby violating the competition law.
The investigation was announced the same day as deputy culture minister Batuhan Mumcu called for legal action against Spotify in a post on X, citing its "refusal" to respond to requests to remove playlists with names deemed offensive.
"Spotify persistently refuses to take the necessary steps despite all our previous warnings," he wrote.
"Content that targets our religious and national values and insults the beliefs of our society has not been corrected," he added, saying Turkey had been "closely monitoring content on Spotify for a long time".
'Targeting... sacred values'
He pointed to content published "under the guise of 'playlists'.. that disregards our religious sensitivities toward our Prophet Mohammed, deliberately and unacceptably targeting the beliefs, sacred values, and spiritual world of our people".
He also singled out playlists allegedly targeting Emine Erdogan, wife of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, which were "insidiously provocative and morally unacceptable".
"This irresponsibility and lack of oversight, which disregards the sensitivities of our society, has now become a legal matter.. I call on our competent institutions to take action," he wrote.
Attached to his post was an animated graphic showing a string of playlists with names referencing either Erdogan's wife or the life of the Prophet Mohammed.
In a statement, Spotify, which launched in Turkey in 2013, said its operations complied with "all applicable laws" but it would cooperate with the investigation although it lacked "details on the inspection's scope or focus".
"We are cooperating with the investigation, are actively seeking to understand it, and will work toward a swift, constructive resolution with the Turkish Competition Authority," the statement said, without making any mention of the playlist allegations.
It said in 2024, it had paid "over 2 billion Turkish lira ($25 million) to the local music industry" with its service playing a "pivotal (role) in growing Turkish artists' royalties globally".
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
05-08-2025
- France 24
US envoy Witkoff to visit Moscow on Wednesday
The source did not specify if the meetings will include Russian President Vladimir Putin, whom Witkoff has met with several times previously. Trump has given Russia until Friday to halt its offensive in Ukraine or face new penalties. The White House has not outlined specific actions it plans to take on Friday, but Trump has previously threatened to impose "secondary tariffs" targeting Russia's remaining trade partners, such as China and India. The move would aim to stifle Russian exports, but would risk significant international disruption. Despite pressure from Washington, Russia has continued its onslaught against its pro-Western neighbor. Three rounds of peace talks in Istanbul have failed to make headway on a possible ceasefire, with the two sides appearing as far apart as ever. Moscow has demanded that Ukraine cede more territory and renounce Western support. Kyiv is calling for an immediate ceasefire, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky last week urged his allies to push for "regime change" in Moscow. In recent weeks, Trump has increasingly voiced frustration with Putin over Moscow's unrelenting offensive. When reporters asked Trump on Monday what Witkoff's message would be to Moscow, and if there was anything Russia could do to avoid the sanctions, Trump replied: "Yeah, get a deal where people stop getting killed." Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Monday it considered the talks with Witkoff to be "important, substantial and helpful" and valued US efforts to end the conflict. Putin, who has consistently rejected calls for a ceasefire, said Friday that he wants peace but that his demands for ending his nearly three-and-a-half-year offensive were unchanged. Russia has frequently called on Ukraine to effectively cede control of four regions Moscow claims to have annexed, a demand Kyiv has called unacceptable. Putin also wants Ukraine to drop its ambitions to join NATO. The visit comes after Trump said that two nuclear submarines he deployed following an online row with former Russian president Dmitry Medvedev were now "in the region." Trump has not said whether he meant nuclear-powered or nuclear-armed submarines. He also did not elaborate on the exact deployment locations, which are kept secret by the US military. Russia, in its first comments on the deployment, urged "caution" Monday. "Russia is very attentive to the topic of nuclear non-proliferation. And we believe that everyone should be very, very cautious with nuclear rhetoric," the Kremlin's Peskov said.
France 24
01-08-2025
- France 24
Turkey government 'manufactures' enemies, opposition tells AFP
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's AKP party "politically named the new enemy on March 19 -- (and) the new enemy is the CHP," said Burhanettin Bulut, a deputy leader of the Republican People's Party (CHP). Bulut, in charge of the party's public relations and media, said Erdogan was threatening the country's democratic foundations through his government's campaign of arrests and lawsuits. Turkish authorities have detained a string of elected officials on charges ranging from graft to terror-related offences, including, on March 19, Istanbul's powerful mayor Ekrem Imamoglu -- Erdogan's main rival. "This government keeps itself alive by constantly defining an enemy," Bulut told AFP in an interview at the party's headquarters in the capital Ankara. The government "sustains its political strategy through polarisation -- manufacturing a foe and launching relentless perception campaigns in a bid to consolidate its voter base", he said. A year after Erdogan's allies suffered heavy losses in local elections, Imamoglu's detention triggered the country's largest street protests in over a decade. "This isn't just about the CHP," Bulut added. "From the grocery store clerk to the apprentice, from businesspeople to artists and journalists -- people across this country are afraid." 'Dynamite' for republic Since Imamoglu's arrest, Turkish authorities have detained 16 CHP mayors, including ones in key districts of Istanbul, and replaced elected officials in at least three municipalities with government-appointed trustees. Among those detained is the acting mayor of Istanbul's Buyukcekmece district, a party source told AFP. CHP leader Ozgur Ozel, re-elected at an emergency party congress a month after Imamoglu was jailed, has come under mounting legal pressure meanwhile. He faces lawsuits on alleged offences including "insulting the president" and vote-buying at a party congress. Media reports have suggested efforts were under way to lift Ozel's parliamentary immunity so he could face prison. Bulut alleged the crackdown "creates a smokescreen for the real issues facing society -- poverty, injustice, the erosion of democracy and individual rights -- that are pushed out of the public agenda". Arresting Ozel, he said, would be "like planting dynamite under the foundations of the Republic" -- but he played down concerns for its impact on the CHP, which he said was "not a leader-centred party". He dismissed government claims of a crisis in the CHP as "political theatre". "It's a founding party, with a deep-rooted history, led by some of the most important figures in Turkish political life — starting with Mustafa Kemal Ataturk," founder of the modern Turkish republic, he said. "That's why interfering with the leadership of this party is not something that can be done easily." Turkish democracy and justice The government's crackdown started with a key arrest seven months after the March 2024 local elections. Authorities detained the CHP mayor of Istanbul's working-class district of Esenyurt, Ahmet Ozer, accusing him of membership of the banned Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK). They have since removed CHP mayors in three districts in Ovacik in the east as well as in Esenyurt and Sisli and replaced them with trustees. The government has insisted the arrests have judicial legitimacy but critics say they are aimed at neutralising dissent in big cities where the opposition won in the elections. The government recently claimed a historic breakthrough by overseeing the disarmament of the PKK, ending its decades-long campaign of attacks. In that context, Bulut argued: "You can't claim to support democracy and justice while appointing trustees at the same time. "If you're serious about democracy, then local consensus must be part of the process." Despite pressure and fear tactics, he insisted the CHP would "be the clear winner" in the next election, expected by 2028.
Euronews
31-07-2025
- Euronews
Explained: What's the ‘Panama Playlists' leak and what does it expose?
You've all presumably heard about the Panama Papers, the 11.5 million leaked documents detailing financial information on offshore entities that were published in 2016. Eight years later, we have the Panama Playlists – and while the fallout of these new leaked documents may be significantly less damaging to high-profile figures, the repercussions will be felt. Well, heard. The new site, Panama Playlists, quietly went live yesterday and exposes the Spotify accounts of various prominent figures – including US Vice President JD Vance, Attorney General Pam Bondi and White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt. The website is run by an anonymous sleuth who claims they have been 'scraping' accounts of celebrities, politicians and journalists since the summer of 2024. Deep throat – or should that be deep ear? - said their team has access to 'playlists, live listening feed, everything. I know what songs they played, when, and how many times.' 'I found the real Spotify accounts of celebrities, politicians, and journalists,' the site claims. 'Many use their real names. With a little sleuthing, I could say with near-certainty: yep, this is them.' So, what are the bombshell revelations? For one, JD Vance is into boybands – with One Direction's 'What Makes You Beautiful' and Backstreet Boys 'I Want It That Way' featuring prominently on his playlists. Fine bops, undermined by Justin Bieber's 'One Time' on his oft-listened 'Making Dinner' playlist - but somewhat redeemed by the presence of 2000s indie darlings Death Cab For Cutie and their track 'You Are A Tourist'. The puns write themselves for that last entry. Pam Bondi seems to have an affinity for 2000s hits, like Nelly's 'Hot In Herre' and Black Eyed Peas' 'I Gotta Feeling', as well as Adele – with the inclusion of the British singer's hit 'Hello'. As for Karoline Leavitt, her 'Baby Shower' playlist features Shaboozey's hit song 'A Bar Song (Tipsy)', Beyoncé's 'Run The World (Girls)', Aretha Franklin's 'Respect', as well as Corinne Bailey Rae's stellar track 'Put Your Records On'. For our money, this is the superior playlist. However, the presence of Cyndi Lauper's 'Girls Just Want To Have Fun' makes us think that they may also want reproductive rights as well... Leavitt previously said on a podcast: '(Abortion) is not about women's reproductive rights, it is not about women's health. It is about life and protecting that period. And as a woman, it is the most amazing thing that we can do to reproduce. That's why we're here. That's why, you know, God made men and women.' Make of that what you will. Back to the playlist leaks... The sleuth told the New York Post: 'I gained confidence in each person by looking at lots of signals. An example is Pam Bondi. Her longtime partner is John Wakefield, and her profile has an old playlist called 'john' and an old shared playlist with a user named 'John Wakefield,' so that gives me a lot of confidence it is her account.' The sleuth added: 'Karoline Leavitt's profile has a playlist called 'Baby Shower,' and she had a baby a month after the playlist was made.' The mysterious sleuth did emphasize that they only collected publicly available information – in case anyone felt that privacy laws had been violated. Outside of Washington, several other prominent figures are mentioned in the 'Panama Playlists,' such as late-night host Seth Meyers, Meta Chief AI Officer Alexandr Wang, and OpenAI CEO Sam Altman. According to the site, Altman's 'My Shazam Tracks' playlist includes David Guetta and OneRepublic's 'I Don't Wanna Wait', Dixon Dallas' 'Good Lookin'' and Nicki Minaj's 'Fly'. We're less keen on this one. You can check out the full Panama Playlists leaks here. Beyond the listening habits of the wealthy and powerful, what do the Panama Playlists reveal? Well, not a great deal – apart from serving as a valuable reminder that should you wish to keep your online data private, keep in mind that Spotify playlists are public by default. If you don't want your bops to be leaked, try manually turning off the public settings on Spotify. You never know who's listening in... Oh, and do check out the New York Times privacy and technology reporter Kashmir Hill's 'Writing Music' playlist, featuring Mogwai, Aphex Twin and Nils Frahm. She's the real winner here, with some jams in there, madam!
