End of tax loophole for Shein starting to have impact, say SA retailers
Last November South Africa's tax authority ended the practice known as de minimis, which allowed companies to drop-ship packages valued at less than R500 from suppliers in China to consumers in South Africa, paying a flat rate of 20% in lieu of customs duties and no VAT of 15%.
Other markets including the US, UK and EU are also closing or planning to close loopholes that have given low-cost online platforms such as Shein and Temu, owned by PDD Holdings', pricing advantages.
'There's nothing punitive about them. It's just levelling the playing field so everybody trading in South Africa and importing products pays the same duties,' TFG CEO Anthony Thunström told Reuters in an interview after the company's earnings release.
Thunström and Mr Price CEO Mark Blair said it was difficult to get official data to quantify the exact impact on the fast-fashion giants. 'But our understanding is that the closure of that loophole has significantly slowed down some of the international pure play online into South Africa,' Thunström said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
a day ago
- Mail & Guardian
Made in China 2.0: Innovation, influence and geopolitics
Made in China' no longer means cheap plastic knockoffs. By 2014 Xiaomi, with its sleek smartphones, was seen as the 'Apple of China'. Photo: File Not long ago, the words 'Made in China' conjured up images of flimsy plastic toys, dodgy electronics and counterfeit designer handbags. For much of the world, it was shorthand for cheap, low-quality goods that generally labelled China as the factory floor of the world, not its innovation lab. Today however, that label appears on drones filming Hollywood blockbusters, smartphones that are increasingly competing with the iPhone and electric vehicles rolling on roads globally. Even the apps we scroll, from Shein to Temu to TikTok, are Chinese creations that have woven themselves into the fabric of everyday life around the world. Somehow, between counterfeit products and next-generation gadgets, China stopped copying the future and started building it. The result? As China's products advanced and improved, so did perception. Not only of Chinese goods but of China itself. China's rise from mass producer to global tech giant did not happen overnight. In the 1990s and 2000s, the country was viewed as a producer of inferior knockoff products, which were mass produced in unregulated sweatshops. The perspective was largely driven by ' Although this market thrived in China and globally, foreign firms were frustrated by intellectual property theft. Chinese authorities, too, were concerned about the effect of the Shanzhai phenomenon, fearing that the country's global reputation would be permanently tarnished. But, by the 2010s, a subtle revolution was starting. Chinese firms began investing heavily in research and development of innovative industries, shifting from the typical low-end manufacturing to high-value tech industries. In 2013, Time magazine ran an article titled reflecting global scepticism. The author, Michael Schuman, argued that 'The country can no longer rely on just making lots of stuff; China has to invent things, design them, brand them and market them. Instead of following the leaders of global industry, China has to produce leaders of its own.' Schuman goes on to add, 'Few emerging nations in modern times have made the leap from assembler to inventor, copycat to innovator.' China did exactly that. By 2014, Xiaomi was commanding headlines as the 'Apple of China', delivering sleek smartphones at a fraction of the cost of its Western counterparts. In 2015, Beijing launched the 'Made in China 2025' initiative aimed at securing the country's position as a global powerhouse in high-value technology, as well as heavily investing in domestic companies, allowing them to compete both locally and globally. Consumer drone company DJI, which makes drones used in Hollywood blockbusters like Shogun and Dune: Part Two , emerged as a global leader in cutting-edge hardware. Today, Huawei smartphones can compete toe-to-toe with Apple on camera benchmark and network performance tests. BYD and Geely are And, perhaps most significantly, ByteDance's TikTok has revolutionised social media engagement with a powerful recommendation algorithm that Western platforms are struggling to recreate. Dominance in other fields, such as high-speed rail, 5G and solar technology infrastructure, shows that China is no longer catching up. It is setting the pace. The evolution, however, has not come without geopolitical tensions. As Chinese products become increasingly used and trusted by consumers globally, they generate soft power for their nation that very few governments can match. One does not need to subscribe to Beijing's ideology to rely on its ever innovative and reliable technology and that directly translates to influence. The rise of China in these industries means different things to different people. In the In the West, however, a strange contradiction unfolds. Citizens continue to embrace platforms like Shein and TikTok, while policymakers are increasingly hostile because of dependency and national security concerns. In some cases, fearing the ideological influence of China through these platforms, Western governments have responded accordingly. Concerns over possible espionage in Huawei's 5G hardware led several states, including the US, to This tension highlights a crucial reality that is happening in front of us — China's technological ascent is no longer just a commercial success story; it is a geopolitical one. As perceptions of China evolve, so will the strategies of nations. The next frontier of geopolitics will not be decided in summits or trade sanctions. It is happening in cyber ecosystems, in the global showrooms of app stores and online platforms. The more the world relies on Chinese tech, the more China's sphere of influence expands. The West may fear ideological influence and data breaches. The Global South may welcome the chance for connectivity and participation. But what is undeniable either way is a perception shift has taken root. Global consumers today, knowingly or not, are casting votes of confidence in China's technological future, and in doing so, are helping shape the map of global influence as we know it. Orefile Babeile is a second-year master's student of international relations at North-West University.
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Chinese warehouse workers welcome Trump's extended tariff truce
Employees in China's export hubs are cautiously optimistic as US President Donald Trump prolongs a fragile truce on tariffs with Beijing. Labourer Shuai Hang went a week without work earlier this year when sky-high US tariffs on Chinese goods overwhelmed the warehouse he works at and slowed the company's US-bound parcels to a trickle. But on Tuesday, after US President Donald Trump announced a truce on those duties would be extended, the depot in southern China's manufacturing hub Guangzhou was alive with noise as workers stuffed trucks with packages of clothes and kitchenware. Many are destined for the doorsteps of US customers of Chinese-founded online shopping giant Temu. Tariffs hit workers' wages and job stability 'Tariffs impact our daily lives,' said 31-year-old Shuai, whose monthly pay of more than 10,000 yuan ($1,400) had dropped by a third previously. 'If tariffs are slightly lower, then there are more outgoing shipments, and then we have higher wages,' he said. Trump's tariff policies since taking office have upended global trade and set off a blistering tit-for-tat with Beijing — but in May the two major economies agreed to a fragile truce, with each temporarily lowering levies on the other's goods. That agreement was extended to November by Trump on Monday, hours before it expired. Deliveries plunge during peak tariff periods At the height of the tariffs, said Shuai, who has been loading parcels for Guangzhou-based logistics company Weijiang International for a year, 'there was not a single truck' for him to fill, so he couldn't work. ALSO READ: US tariffs: Here's why talks over trade deal have been 'complex' Overall deliveries dropped by about 20 percent in May, according to Weijiang's founder Xiong Wei, with the US market making up around a quarter of their cross-border business. But business has recovered since July, he said. Xiong said he hadn't lost sleep over the looming expiration of the 90-day tariff truce this week, as he had expected it would be renewed. 'We might have been worried in May, but now we are indifferent,' said Xiong. 'We are used to it'. 'Cards reshuffled' These days the warehouse is sending out 100 tonnes of packages every 24 hours, with up to 70 trucks making trips. On Tuesday industrial fans whirred as sweat-slicked workers methodically scanned yellow, black and sage green bundles into lorries. Xiong's company has recently invested in its own warehouse in Chicago. ALSO READ: Lesufi says US tariffs due to SA's Palestine stance, backs China to prop up Gauteng In many ways the uncertainty provided opportunity for smaller logistics companies like theirs, said manager Chen Weiyan, as they have taken the chance to expand their market. 'The cards have been reshuffled,' he said. Temu link boosts cross-border flows Around 30 percent of the parcels moved by Weijiang International end up in a different warehouse, this one owned by Temu-parent PDD, where they are unloaded, repacked and readied for a flight across the ocean. While the truce is welcome, Shuai, who packs three to four tonnes in a truck daily, said he still pays close attention to tariff news. 'For those of us who have travelled over 1,000 kilometres to work here, we definitely don't want frequent breaks. We all want to earn more money,' said the native of neighbouring Guizhou province. 'Folks in America need our goods' Working at the warehouse was less tiring than labouring at a construction site, and earning money had become more difficult in the past two years, he said. Chen, the manager, was bullish. 'We will not give up this market,' he said. 'Folks in America need our goods'. NOW READ: SA and China can 'do much to cooperate in film making'
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
Call for ministerial accountability over 8,000 jobs lost to customs 'loophole'
The LSF report found that Shein and Temu generated R7.3 billion in sales over the period, capturing 3.6% of South Africa's R-CTFL retail market and a staggering 37% of its online sales. Actions SA says it has formally requested the urgent appearance of the Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau, the Minister of Finance, Enoch Godongwana, and the SARS Commissioner, Edward Kieswetter, before Parliament. This comes after a new report by the Localisation Support Fund (LSF), which looked at the effect of offshore e-commerce retailers on South Africa's clothing, textile, footwear, and leather (R-CTFL) industry, found that fast-growing Chinese online retailers Shein and Temu may have cost the country more than 8,000 potential jobs over the past four years. "Between 2020 and 2024, Shein and Temu made use of the 'de minimis' rule, which allowed parcels valued under R500 to enter the country with a flat 20% customs duty and no VAT," the party said. "These companies deliberately broke up large orders into multiple low-value parcels to benefit from this rule, while local retailers and importers were paying up to 45% duty and 15% VAT on similar goods. For four years, the government allowed this practice to continue while local manufacturers and retailers bore the consequences".
