Supreme Court reserves interim orders in waqf case
The Supreme Court on Thursday (May 22, 2025) reserved its interim orders on three issues, including the power to denotify properties declared as 'waqf by courts, waqf-by-user or waqf by deed' after hearing a clutch of pleas challenging the validity of the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025.
Follow the highlights on Waqf (Amendment) Act hearing on May 22, 2025
Before reserving the interim orders, a Bench comprising Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justice Augustine George Masih heard senior advocates Kapil Sibal, Rajeev Dhavan and Abhishek Singhvi on behalf of those opposed to the amended waqf law and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Centre, for about three consecutive days.
The Centre strongly defended the Act, saying waqf by its very nature is a 'secular concept' and can't be stayed given the 'presumption of constitutionality' in its favour.
Mr. Sibal, leading the petitioners, described the law as a "complete departure from historical legal and constitutional principles" and a means to "capture waqf through a non-judicial process".
Also Read | Will the Waqf law usher in transparency?
"This is a case about the systematic capture of waqf properties. The government cannot dictate what issues can be raised," Mr. Sibal said.
The petitioners at the present stage sought interim orders on three key issues.
One of the issues related to the power to denotify properties declared as waqf by courts, waqf-by-user or waqf by deed.
The second issue was over the composition of State waqf boards and the Central Waqf Council, where they contend only Muslims should operate except ex-officio members whereas the last one is over the provision stipulating a waqf property won't be treated as a waqf when the collector conducts an inquiry to ascertain if the property is government land.
On April 25, the Union Ministry of Minority Affairs filed a preliminary 1,332-page affidavit defending the amended Waqf Act of 2025 and opposed any "blanket stay" by the court on a "law having presumption of constitutionality passed by Parliament".
The Centre notified the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 last month after it got President Droupadi Murmu's assent on April 5.
The bill was cleared by Lok Sabha with the support of 288 members while 232 MPs were against it. The Rajya Sabha saw 128 members voting in its favour and 95 against it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
33 minutes ago
- Hans India
AP partners with WEF for energy centre in Amaravati
Vijayawada: In a significant move to establish Andhra Pradesh as a global hub for innovation and sustainable development, the state government partnered with the World Economic Forum (WEF) to launch 'WEF-AP Centre for Energy and Cyber Resilience' in Amaravati. This initiative aligns with the government's ambitious 'Swarna Andhra Vision 2047'. A Government Order issued on Thursday formalized the establishment of this centre, which will operate under the WEF's global Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution (C4IR) Network. Notably, it will be India's first thematic C4IR centre and will focus on two critical areas: energy transition and green industries in collaboration with WEF's Centre for Energy and Materials (CENMAT) and AI-led digital transformation and cyber security, in partnership with WEF's Centre for Cyber Security. This initiative stems from high-level meetings with the WEF in Davos and is poised to position Amaravati as India's leading center for green energy, sustainability, and cyber security. The project is being spearheaded by Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu and IT Minister Nara Lokesh, with the overarching goal of enhancing AP's international profile and attracting significant investments in clean energy, Artificial Intelligence, and digital infrastructure. The centre's key objectives include elevating AP's global standing, fostering international partnerships, supporting the growth of green industries, enhancing cyber security capabilities, and running pilot projects in clean energy, smart grids, and the application of AI in sectors such as agriculture and governance. Furthermore, it aims at upskilling the workforce in cyber security and emerging technologies and connecting the state with prominent global platforms like the WEF's annual meeting at Davos. The state government has allocated Rs 36 crore to support the Centre's operations for three years. It will initially function from Vijayawada or Amaravati and will be governed by a high-level committee chaired by IT Minister Nara Lokesh.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Karnataka CM seeks higher share in central tax pool
Karnataka chief minister Siddaramaiah on Friday pushed for a more equitable tax devolution system while urging the 16th Finance Commission to rectify what he described as a persistent imbalance in fiscal transfers from the Centre to states. 'Karnataka's fiscal strength fuels national growth. It is time to ensure that growth is not penalised but rewarded. We urge the commission to adopt a balanced, forward-looking approach to devolution,' Siddaramaiah said during a meeting with commission chairman Arvind Panagariya and members in New Delhi to present Karnataka's views through an additional memorandum. Highlighting Karnataka's contribution to the national economy, the chief minister pointed out that the state accounts for nearly 8.7% of India's GDP, despite representing only 5% of the country's population. It also ranks second in GST collections. 'For every rupee Karnataka contributes to Union taxes, it receives only 15 paise in return,' he pointed out. Citing the reduction in the state's share of tax devolution by the 15th Finance Commission — from 4.713% to 3.647%, the CM said that it resulted in a cumulative loss of over ₹80,000 crore. Karnataka's per capita devolution, he added, has fallen from 95% of the national average during the 14th Finance Commission to just 73% under the 15th, even as the state's GDP contribution rose. The 16th Finance Commission, established in December 2023, is tasked with recommending tax revenue distribution between the central government and states for 2026-31. The commission is currently conducting consultations and must submit its recommendations by October 31, 2025. Siddaramaiah was joined by economic advisor Basavaraja Rayareddy, the chief secretary, and senior officers from the finance department and the chief minister's office. In its main memorandum, Karnataka proposed increasing the states' share in vertical tax devolution to at least 50% and capping cesses and surcharges at 5%. It also recommended that Union non-tax revenues be included in the divisible pool. For horizontal devolution among states, Karnataka argued that high-performing states should retain about 60% of their contribution, with the remaining 40% directed toward less-developed states. The state also advocated reducing the weight assigned to the income-distance criterion — a metric used to determine fiscal capacity gaps — and shifting focus towards measuring each state's economic contribution. 'Equity must be implemented in a time-bound and outcome-oriented manner, without disadvantaging states that demonstrate strong economic performance and sound fiscal management,' Siddaramaiah said. The additional memorandum focused on three key areas — disparities in per capita devolution, flaws in the design of Revenue Deficit Grants, and the unpredictability of State-Specific Grants. The CM questioned the effectiveness of Revenue Deficit Grants, pointing out that 'persistent deficits in beneficiary states' raise doubts about their impact. He called for these grants to be distributed using the horizontal devolution formula instead. He also criticised the current assumptions used in determining these grants. 'Unfortunately, these assessments tend to place welfare policies on a lower pedestal compared to salaries, pensions, and administrative expenses,' he said. Referring to the state's welfare programs, Siddaramaiah said, 'Our government has been guided by Gandhiji's philosophy of Sarvodaya, emphasising welfare for all. These initiatives stimulate local demand and drive inclusive growth.' In place of discretionary grants, Karnataka proposed a formula-based allocation of 0.3% of Gross Union Receipts. However, if special grants are retained, the state reiterated its demand for support for Bengaluru and other critical projects. Seeking backing for ₹1.15 lakh crore in investments to upgrade Bengaluru's infrastructure, the CM said the capital city plays a central role in the state's economy. He also emphasized the need to address the regional imbalances in Kalyana Karnataka and Malnad, which continue to face poor infrastructure and low income levels. Concluding the presentation, Siddaramaiah asserted that equity and growth must go hand in hand. 'A strong Karnataka — supported by fair fiscal devolution — is essential for a strong India,' he told the commission.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Political battle over Tamil Nadu history escalates, Stalin says truth about Keezhadi excavation ‘doesn't suit BJP-RSS script'
Amid the row over the excavations in Tamil Nadu's Keezhadi, Chief Minister M K Stalin on Thursday called the Centre's demand for 'more proof' regarding the antiquity of the site an attempt to suppress scientifically established truths about Tamil civilisation. 'Even when confronted with carbon-dated artefacts and accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS) reports from international laboratories on the Keezhadi excavations, they continue to demand more proof…,' Stalin said. 'On the contrary, despite strong opposition from respected historians and archaeologists, the BJP continues to promote the mythical Saraswati civilisation. They do so without credible evidence, while dismissing the rigorously proven antiquity of Tamil culture,' he alleged. He said the BJP-RSS 'ecosystem recoils' when it comes to the Keezhadi and the 'enduring truth of Tamil heritage'. 'Not because evidence is lacking, but because the truth does not serve their script. We fought for centuries to unearth our history. They fight every day to erase it. The world is watching. So is time,' the Chief Minister said. His remarks come days after Union Minister for Culture and Tourism Gajendra Singh Shekhawat reaffirmed the Centre's stance on the issue. Shekhawat, addressing questions on the Archaeological Survey of India's decision to return archaeologist K Amarnath Ramakrishna's 982-page report on Keezhadi, said: 'The reports you are talking about have not been scientific. I am aware of the findings that you are mentioning. They are not yet technically well-supported and established. A lot of things are to be done.' 'Let them come with more results, more data, more evidence, more proof. Only one finding cannot seize the discourse, because people are trying to increase regional sentiments using this. That is not fair. We have to be very, very cautious on these things. Let the research be completed on all the parameters. Then we will take a call on this,' he said. When pressed about the BJP's alleged reluctance to accept Tamil antiquity, Shekhawat said, 'Prime Minister Narendra Modi has said that Tamil Nadu is the most ancient language and that Tamil civilisation is thousands of years old. Let it be decided by the archaeologists based on the facts and technical things.' Responding to this, Tamil Nadu Finance and Archaeology Minister Thangam Thennarasu had questioned the Centre's inconsistent approach. 'First, they said there was nothing in Keezhadi. Then the archaeologist excavating Keezhadi was transferred. Later, they refused to allocate funds for excavations at that site. Finally, they put the report on the back burner for two years. Now, they claim that the evidence is insufficient,' Thennarasu said. Ramakrishna's abrupt transfer to Assam in 2017 halted ASI's direct involvement at the site. Excavations resumed only after the Madras High Court allowed the Tamil Nadu Department of Archaeology to take over, leading to the unearthing of more than 13,000 artefacts. On Thursday, the DMK's students wing, led by secretary R Rajiv Gandhi, announced a major protest to be held in Madurai on June 18. The party wing condemned the 'anti-Tamil BJP regime' for 'refusing to accept the Keezhadi archaeological findings despite it being established scientifically'. The Keeladi excavations have long been a lightning rod for political and academic discourse. Initiated in 2014 and led by archaeologist Ramakrishna under the ASI, the site revealed remnants of an advanced urban civilisation — brick structures, industrial furnaces, drainage systems, graffiti-marked pottery, and terracotta artefacts. Ramakrishna submitted his final report in January 2023, concluding that the site dated back to between the 8th and 3rd century BCE, based on stratigraphic analysis and AMS-dated artefacts. However, more than two years later, in May 2025, the ASI's Exploration and Excavation division returned the report and asked Ramakrishna to revise it based on comments from two unnamed experts. The ASI's letter argued that the proposed dating was 'very early' and suggested the earliest period should be revised to 'at the maximum, somewhere in pre-300 BCE'. Ramakrishna, in a formal written reply, defended the scientific basis of his chronology and rejected the demand to rework the sequence.
