Great Nicobar's development: Strategic gain or loss of balance?
The remote, stunningly beautiful and little understood Great Nicobar Island has been the focus of news reports in recent months, two decades after it made headlines when the 2004 tsunami devastated lives and altered its coastline. This time, it's a man-made wave of development that is drawing attention: specifically, plans under the Great Nicobar Island Development Project, which has an outlay of
₹
81,000 crore and was launched in 2021.
Infra work is proceeding apace on a trans-shipment port, an international airport, power plants, tourism facilities and a township where hundreds of thousands of people are expected to settle. The project's blueprint covers 160-sq-km, including 130-sq-km of tropical rain- forest land that is home to people whose lives are intricately linked to its numerous species of plant and animal life. Environmentalists,
climate activists
and even novelist Amitav Ghosh have described it as 'ecocide.'
India's biodiversity is like a wondrous quilt of beauty and Great Nicobar is one of our few untouched hot-spots. It holds a range of micro-habitats, from beaches, mangroves and coastal forests to rivers, lagoons and rainforests that host an invaluable variety of mammals, birds, reptiles, crustaceans, amphibians, insects and plants—some found nowhere else in the world.
This treasure trove is at risk. The isle's Galathea Bay Wildlife Sanctuary, one of the few nesting sites for the vulnerable and endemic Nicobar megapode as well as the Giant Leatherback Sea turtle, was de-notified in January 2021 to ease the port's construction.
Apart from causing irreversible ecological harm, our brick-and-mortar intrusion is likely to devastate traditional lifestyles and ancestral lands. Forest-dwelling and semi-nomadic, the Shompen are a 'particularly vulnerable tribal group" of 229 individuals, according to India's 2011 census. It's a population small enough to be wiped out by the flu, and, as they are among the world's last people with almost no contact with the outside world, their immunity may prove unable to withstand an influx of outsiders.
Great Nicobar is also home of the Nicobarese, a settled tribe that mostly practises horticulture. For decades, India has respected and protected the rights of isolated indigenous people to their land and way of life, with contact made on their terms. Not very long ago, an American social media influencer who tried to film the Sentinelese on North Sentinel Island was arrested. Yet, '
development
' seems to license much worse.
The archipelago's strategic value for trade and defence, given its Bay of Bengal location, is undeniable. The isles are within close reach of major Indian and East Asian ports, and could support the Quad's aim of a free and open Indo-Pacific.
But Great Nicobar isn't just real estate; it is a fragile ecosystem that's prone to low-intensity quakes. The 2004 tsunami's impact is yet to be fully understood, though researchers found that it tilted the archipelago, leaving some dry parts submerged. Is pouring tonnes of concrete and steel into such a sensitive zone a good idea?
These lands are not just inhabited by folks who deserve the liberty to live how they like, undisturbed if they so choose, they offer us a unique chance to expand the frontiers of knowledge if we go about it delicately.
While the country does need to develop, we must not place the details of our development path beyond the scrutiny of reason. Steamrollers 2,500km away from New Delhi signal a loss of balance. Our geo-strategic aims can be met at far lower cost.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
How tribal cuisines benefitted after replacing millets with maize
Maize and monsoons go together. There are few better things to eat than a bhutta roasted on a coal fire, slathered with salt, butter and chilli powder and eaten as you take shelter from the rain or the waves on Mumbai's seafront, which add extra salt to the of us don't eat much maize otherwise. In the winter, hearty makki ki rotis are enjoyed with sarson ka saag , while popcorn is a reliable pleasure on increasingly rare visits to cinema halls. But maize is an important crop for many tribal communities who live in the scrub forests and hills of central India, similar to the arid lands of Mexico where maize was first recent books, both from organisations working with tribal communities, document this use. In Desi Maize Flavor , Julie Jain, working with the Udaipur-based organisation Banyan Roots, collects tribal recipes like raab and ghugri , porridges made with fine and coarsely broken maize respectively, and paniye , maize bread cooked between leaves of the palash (flameof-the-forest) shows how maize was adapted to traditional Rajasthani recipes, like theple and daal baati , and how it can be used in even more recipes from across India, like uttappam, dosas and even gulab jamuns . The book valuably documents the diversity of maize grown in India, with deep red, glossy black and pearly white grains. All these, with their many tastes and benefits, are being edged out by the new, super-sweet yellow corn seeds. It is the same loss we have seen with rice, repeated with a grain that isn't even most likely spread through the world with the Spanish conquerors of Mexico, who took it back to Europe and possibly across the Pacific to the Philippines. American missionaries also became enthusiastic promoters of their native grain. We know from reports of the Agri-Horticultural Societies of British India that seeds were widely disseminated — and that maize succeeded by replacing millets. They were similar to grow, but millets had small grains that were easily eaten by birds, or were prone to shattering from the ears, making them harder to harvest. Maize grains were larger, so at less risk from birds and stayed on the plant till they were Bhatt's Silent Cuisines , which documents the food culture of Gujarat's Adivasi communities, doesn't mention the origins of maize, but the grain is everywhere in the recipes. It is made into flatbreads, dumplings, porridges and broken grains cooked with leafy greens. It is easy to see that these might have been made with millets earlier. Not acknowledging the change caused by this American grain is a rare shortfall in an otherwise really admirable and beautifully produced also suggests a certain way of thinking about tribal communities by the organisations that work with them, like the Gujarat-based Disha which helped Bhatt with her research. These organisations repeatedly extol the ancient, traditional wisdom of tribal communities, which may be good marketing, but overlooks instances when these communities have happily adopted new products, like maize. Tribal communities are as open to useful innovations as anyone else and this doesn't diminish the value of what they can see this with the one problem that followed the worldwide spread of maize — a disease called pellagra, caused by deficiency of Vitamin B3, which maize does not have in a form our bodies can easily assimilate. Mexicans devised a way to process maize to unlock its nutritional profile, but this knowledge did not travel with way to avoid pellagra was to eat a diverse diet, rich in products like pulses and this was what the tribal communities documented by Bhatt did. As a result, pellagra was never such an issue among them, as it was with groups in Europe. The real value of the tribal cuisine that Bhatt documents is its diversity, with maize as much as with all the other ingredients it uses.
Indian Express
2 days ago
- Indian Express
MIT taught her well. That is why Megha Vemuri could speak for others
Like many students around the United States, those studying at the prestigious Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) are proud bearers of the American tradition of the class ring. Redesigned every year, these signet-style rings bear the insignia of the school: At MIT, it is a beaver, nicknamed the 'the brass rat', that is engraved on the flat top, with one side of the bezel featuring a rendition of the Boston skyline and the other side, a view of the Cambridge — specifically the university campus — skyline. Before they graduate, MIT students wear the ring in a way that the beaver and the Boston side of the bezel face them. At their commencement, the new graduates are asked to 'flip the brass rat' — with the beaver now facing away from them, symbolising their entry into the wider world, and the campus skyline, which now faces the students, reminding them of the legacy, and its accompanying responsibilities, that they bear. At the commencement ceremony for the Class of 2025 on Thursday, yet another cohort of MIT students flipped the brass rat and prepared to step into the rest of their lives, carrying with them both knowledge and a sense of their history, forever intertwined with the history of their alma mater, that binds them as a community. In the now-viral speech delivered by Megha Vemuri, the president of the Class of 2025, she refers to this precious load when she speaks to her fellow graduates about the 'privilege of access…to a place like this (MIT)' and the 'immeasurable responsibility' they enter the world with. Remove the references to the ongoing destruction of Gaza, the suffering of the Palestinians and the silence or complicity of institutions like the one she is graduating from, Vemuri's address is no different from those delivered at commencement and graduation ceremonies at other schools, across the US and in other countries, at other times. In their four years of undergraduate studies, MIT's students, like students elsewhere, have only been learning about and preparing for their responsibilities in the world beyond the campus walls. They must now, Vemuri says, actually take on the burden. The uproar that has followed Vemuri's speech, with MIT barring her from her graduation ceremony the next day and commentators and pundits decrying her attempt to 'hijack' the event to make it about her 'personal beliefs', follow the same absurd script that has played out in university campuses across the US for almost 20 months now. A student exercised her right to free speech — without calling for violence or hate against any community — in order to point to a great injustice in the world where she and her fellow students are expected to play their roles. That was all. In her speech, Vemuri notes, 'As scientists, engineers, academics and leaders, we have a commitment to support life.' The university's actions, and the many instances of social media denunciation of her words, then beg the question: Are MIT's students expected to demonstrate this commitment only to certain kinds of lives? If yes, then who are the people that are to be excluded from this world of responsibility that Vemuri and her cohort enter? That Vemuri understands the double standards that prop up such a view of the world is clear when she notes, 'While we graduate and move on with our lives, there are no universities left in Gaza.' Vemuri is not alone in showing a wider regard, a greater range for her compassion, than appears to be allowed to students, and she's not the first to be penalised for it. In Trump's America, foreign students have already been put on notice, their visas — their futures — threatened for the slightest straying from the strict lines drawn by the powers-that-be. Vemuri, of course, doesn't have to worry about a visa, being an American citizen, but she might, as several have pointed out, have some cause for concern when it comes to her prospects. Is an independent-minded, outspoken person — a brown-skinned woman, no less — considered good employee material in the US today? Open espousal of the Palestinian cause has reportedly already led to several firings, including at major companies like Microsoft and Google. In any case, in an America where democratic norms are under assault from an administration that brooks no dissent, it is scary to be any kind of minority, and not just one that's on a visa. But that is the remarkable thing about Vemuri: She said what she wanted to say right when she lost whatever protection life as a student offered. Politically active students always tend to be condescended to, told that they don't know how the real world works, but Vemuri, at least, appears to be more than prepared for it. With or without the brass rat.
Indian Express
3 days ago
- Indian Express
Unsung heroes: Meet Ranganath, a BMTC driver who has rescued over 4000 snakes in 30 years
In 1996, amidst the lush forests of Karnataka's Malnad region in Shivamogga district, a young Ranganath K joined 35 classmates from his government school for a reptile conservation trek. What began as an educational outing transformed into a lifelong mission for Ranganath, now 44, a Bengaluru Metropolitan Transport Corporation (BMTC) bus driver and dedicated snake rescuer. Over the past three decades, he has saved 4,552 venomous and non-venomous reptiles, earning him widespread admiration. On May 19, 2025, Ranganath made his first international flight to Malaysia to receive his second honorary doctorate from American Wisdom Peace University, a testament to his extraordinary contributions. Born into a farming family, Ranganath, the eldest among three children, was enrolled in a government school while his siblings attended private institutions. Ranganath was tasked with household chores like working in the fields and tending cattle. His life pivoted in 1996, while he was in Class 9, when an American family visited Sagara, Shivamogga, to research the region's evergreen forests and engage local people in reptile conservation. Ranganath and his classmates volunteered for the trek. 'I was terrified of everything — any animal would send me running,' he recalls. 'But that trek changed me. The Americans taught us about reptile conservation, snake identification, and safe handling, sparking a passion I didn't know I had,' Ranganath says. This experience ignited a lifelong commitment to rescuing reptiles. After completing his SSLC (Class 10), Ranganath pursued a pre-university course at Sacred Heart PU College in Shivamogga, followed by a two-year industrial training programme at Sri Jagadguru Panchacharya Industrial Institute. During this time, he donated blood 33 times, once skipping an exam to save a woman's life. Fearing his family's disapproval, he fled to Bengaluru with Rs 1,000 and 20 kg of rice from his father, seeking a fresh start. In Bengaluru, Ranganath took up menial jobs—cleaning public toilets, clearing drains, and collecting garbage—to survive. He married in 2008, welcomed his first son in 2010, and secured a job as a BMTC driver in 2011. Stationed at Depot 32 in the North West zone, he operates the 242JA bus route between Ganakal and Shivajinagar, covering over 8 lakh kilometers in 14 years. Known affectionately as 'Ranganna' by passengers, he's a kind yet firm figure, reprimanding students for unsafe behaviour like standing on the bus footboard or disrespecting women. 'From corporators to MLAs, I've driven them all,' he says with pride. Ranganath never rescues snakes during his driving shifts, reserving such efforts for nighttime calls. He recounts a harrowing incident: 'A water snake had entered a cattle shed. As I tried to catch it, it slipped onto a cow. I grabbed it just before it could bite the animal, but it struck my hand. Thankfully, it was non-venomous.' Such risky rescues are routine for him. A three-month hiatus from snake rescuing, prompted by his family's superstitious concerns, led to financial strain and scarcity at home. 'We even ran out of rice,' he says. 'I realised then that this work is my calling, a divine blessing,' says Ranganath. He charges nothing for rescues, though some offer small sums for fuel. Trained in traditional medicine, he also mentors his second son, a Class 8 student, in these practices back in Sagara. His advice for encountering a reptile? 'Stay calm and still. Snakes are shy—they only react to movement or vibrations. Just wait, and they'll retreat.' His life's philosophy is equally straightforward: 'I want to earn people's love, not money. I want to be remembered for my service and character long after I'm gone.' Ranganath's dedication has earned him accolades, including the Kannada Seva Ratna Award, the Kannada Rajyotsava Award, and an honorary doctorate from Asia International Culture Research University for his expertise in reptile conservation. Sanath Prasad is a senior sub-editor and reporter with the Bengaluru bureau of Indian Express. He covers education, transport, infrastructure and trends and issues integral to Bengaluru. He holds more than two years of reporting experience in Karnataka. His major works include the impact of Hijab ban on Muslim girls in Karnataka, tracing the lives of the victims of Kerala cannibalism, exploring the trends in dairy market of Karnataka in the aftermath of Amul-Nandini controversy, and Karnataka State Elections among others. If he is not writing, he keeps himself engaged with badminton, swimming, and loves exploring. ... Read More
