logo
Denise Charlton: Child poverty must not be our shameful legacy

Denise Charlton: Child poverty must not be our shameful legacy

Irish Examiner2 days ago

We remain at risk of being the first generation in modern times to hand over a poorer society to our children. This forecast of shame should be a national call to action so we can finally break the cycle of poverty and disadvantage.
The findings in the 2025 Child Poverty Monitor by the Children's Rights Alliance add to the growing body of evidence and research showing that more and more children and their families are faced with impossible decisions of heating their home or getting a dinner together that night or buying a warmer coat for winter.
We know too, that there are an increasing number of families whose daily reality is even starker in that they do not have a place to call home. In the three years since the Alliance first partnered with Community Foundation Ireland to produce the original monitor, the number of children in emergency accommodation has increased by 1,747 to 4,775.
These findings follow the Poverty Income Inequality and Living Standards report by the Economic and Social Research Institute, released last September, which shows that 230,000 children are in material deprivation. As startling as the numbers may be, they do not tell the full story — the sleepless nights of worry and fear, wondering where the next meal will come from.
What makes the current cost-of-living and poverty crisis even more shameful is that it is escalating at a time when, on paper, we as a country are enjoying a period of wealth.
The impact of the crisis is felt in every community. We know from our partnerships with researchers and 5,000 voluntary, community, and charitable workers that those communities already facing disadvantage are at the highest risk. These include lone parents, people with disabilities, people living with addiction, Travellers, and those fleeing war and persecution.
However, in 2025, even those with jobs are at risk. Many families are just one pay cheque away from being pulled into debt, deprivation, or poverty.
The Child Poverty Monitor, ESRI research, and experience of our partners on the ground not only provide evidence but also provide solutions and recommendations. Successive Governments have only partially met those calls to action.
The roll-out of hot school meals to every pupil, pilot programmes to combat holiday hunger, and increases in welfare payments are welcome. Yet they fall short of the more systemic change called for and needed.
It is now two years since the ESRI, supported by campaigners, proposed a second-tier targeted child benefit payment, which was warmly welcomed by Government and Opposition alike but has not yet materialised.
Targeted support does deliver help to those who need it most. Groundbreaking work, such as that which the Community Foundation has been doing with the National College of Ireland, has shown that early education and care intervention and prevention programmes are proven to work.
Focused initially in Dublin 1, and running also in communities like Knocknaheeney, programmes like ABC, which produce wrap-around supports for families, are having a real impact. Trained experts work with families to identify risks to a child's development and move to prevent them, while those children who need greater support are given safe spaces to assist their growth and development.
The Government has supported this pioneering work with roll-out to other parts of the country. However, what has been achieved is small compared to what could be done by using portions of the tax billions from the Apple case to invest in childcare, schools, community and youth centres, and other social infrastructure, which would benefit not just children but people of all ages.
To those who follow political cycles, it will come as no surprise that right now, from the most expensive glass-fronted offices in our cities' docklands to community centres on the ground combatting addiction, poverty, and inequality, people are busy writing.
Denise Charlton: 'In Budget 2026, the Government must reflect on whether the moment for establishing think-tanks, special units or appointing tsars has passed. Surely now, the urgent need for systemic reforms and policies - for which independent research and evidence already exists - has replaced them.'
Whether you are an industrialist, financier lobbyist, advocate, campaigner, or community worker, you will know that now is the time to get your demands into Government through a pre-budget submission.
Many of our community partners are finalising their calls and finessing elevator pitches ready for when they bump into the local minister for a few seconds — to make the case for support.
In an increasingly uncertain world, there is no guarantee that our national wealth will continue. The opportunity to do something meaningful that will deliver long-term benefits for children, families, and communities could be slipping by with each passing budget.
In Budget 2026, the Government must reflect on whether the moment for establishing think-tanks, special units or appointing tsars has passed. Surely now, the urgent need for systemic reforms and policies — for which independent research and evidence already exists — has replaced them.
Denise Charlton is chief executive of Community Foundation Ireland, a philanthropic hub whose donors and supporters have provided over €160m to communities since 2000 to support an equality mission.
Read More
Child poverty and housing shortage are destroying the social contract

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Leisure centre in Larne set alight by rioters as violence extends beyond Ballymena
Leisure centre in Larne set alight by rioters as violence extends beyond Ballymena

The Journal

time9 hours ago

  • The Journal

Leisure centre in Larne set alight by rioters as violence extends beyond Ballymena

LAST UPDATE | 20 mins ago A LEISURE CENTRE in Larne in Northern Ireland has been set on fire by rioters as violence seen in Ballymena over the last two nights spreads to other areas. Footage shared online shows masked individuals smashing windows and setting fires outside Larne Leisure Centre. The fire has since been brought under control, according to the local fire service. Alliance MLA Danny Donnelly said: 'Larne does not need this.' Police have been deployed for a third night in a row in Ballymena. The Belfast Telegraph has reported that police are also at the scene of disorder in Coleraine , where footage online has shown bins set alight near a train track. Larne leisure centre has been attacked by masked thugs. Windows smashed and fires lit nearby. Larne does not need this. — Danny Donnelly MLA (@DannyDonnelly1) June 11, 2025 Ulster Unionist Party MLA John Stewart described the events in Larne as 'despicable and disgraceful' 'The violence, vandalism, and intimidation seen this evening have absolutely no place in our society,' Stewart said. Advertisement He said the leisure centre is a 'vital community asset at the very heart of Larne' and that 'to see it targeted in such a senseless and deliberate manner is both truly shocking and deeply saddening'. Riot police have been deployed to different parts of Antrim, including in Larne (pictured) this evening. Alamy Alamy The Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) has deployed riot police in Ballymena for the third consecutive night as a significant crowd gathered around the Clonavon Terrace area. Demonstrators who gathered on Bridge Street near the residential area were told to disperse shortly before 9pm after a firework was thrown at officers. Petrol bombs and fireworks, as well as other projectiles, have been thrown at police this evening. Earlier today, the PSNI requested assistance from police forces in Britain following the violence in Ballymena over the last two nights. The PSNI said 17 officers were injured, and six people were arrested last night, after violent disorder erupted for a second night in a row. Multiple cars and properties were set on fire while rioters hurled petrol bombs, fireworks and masonry at police officers. Riot police block a road close to Clonavon Terrace in Ballymena this evening Jonathan McCambridge / PA Jonathan McCambridge / PA / PA Alongside the injuring of police officers, much of the violence has been targeted at homes that rioters believe to belong to people from eastern European countries. Related Reads PSNI seeks reinforcements from Britain as Starmer condemns 'mindless' Ballymena violence I went to talk to people in Ballymena, and was told to make myself 'scarce' or there'd be trouble On Monday, two teenage boys appeared in court charged with the sexual assault of a young teenage girl. The two teenagers spoke through a Romanian translator. The Journal has documented some of the damage done by rioters in Ballymena, including to the home of a Bulgarian man who was targeted, a neighbouring home where the window of a child's bedroom was smashed in, and a home belonging to Filipinos who had to leave because of the extensive damage. On Clonavon Terrace, where four homes were burnt on Monday night, a Romanian teenager told The Journal that the rioters claim to be fighting for the victim of the alleged sexual assault but they're 'just destroying their own town'. 'Where is the justice for this poor girl? This isn't justice for her, this is just racism destroying where we live,' the teenager said. A pram and wheelchair outside the smashed window of a child's bedroom in Ballymena Diarmuid Pepper / The Journal Diarmuid Pepper / The Journal / The Journal Additional reporting by Press Association Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Irish Examiner view: What kind of future are we building?
Irish Examiner view: What kind of future are we building?

Irish Examiner

timea day ago

  • Irish Examiner

Irish Examiner view: What kind of future are we building?

It has long been a cliché to seize upon a particular headline or story as illustrating the seriousness of a society's challenges, the personification of its problems. However, this week offered us a true indictment of our country. The Child Poverty Monitor report for 2025 was launched yesterday by the Children's Rights Alliance, and shows that the consistent poverty rate among children is higher than in any other age group. It also found that the rate also rose significantly last year. The term 'significantly' is appropriate. CEO Tanya Ward said: 'What is deeply concerning is the number of children in consistent poverty, who are living in these conditions perpetually, which rose by a staggering 45,107 in 2024 to 102,977. 'These are children for whom a decent standard of living and aspirations of a better future diminish day by day.' Notwithstanding the untruths promoted by the far right and other bad actors, Ireland is a wealthy country with huge resources. The fact that over 100,000 Irish children are in consistent poverty should be a matter of profound shame for all of us. It is a betrayal of the principles of any civilised democracy that such a situation can develop. As Ms Ward pointed out, not only are those children in the grip of poverty now, their chances of a better future are compromised by the conditions and circumstances we have allowed to become a toxic web this country. The housing and accommodation crisis is clearly one of the dominant strands in that web, which made another announcement yesterday particularly timely. Housing minister James Browne brought proposals to Cabinet for an overhaul of rent pressure zones, which will now apply across the entire country. This move is part of an overall Government plan to attract international investment to kickstart the building of apartments. Facilitating property investment by overseas operators is not a move likely to win favour with many people struggling to find homes, but all options must be considered in a crisis of this scale. That is no exaggeration when over 100,000 children are in poverty, and when the prospect of intergenerational poverty is very real for many of them. Trump's vain display of power Senator Tom Clonan made a telling comparison online yesterday when considering the situation in Los Angeles, where US president Donald Trump has mobilised thousands of National Guard troops. They have been sent to the city in response to the reaction of locals to a series of crackdowns on and arrests in immigrant communities, which included the arrest of a union leader acting as an observer. The National Guard presence has now been augmented by the mobilisation of hundreds of US Marines, a rare instance of US army personnel being deployed on home soil. Nothing says loss of civil control and order quite like sending in the army, no matter the location. As Mr Clonan noted on social media, in a nod to our own recent history, it is 'never a good idea to deploy marines/paratroopers into civilian environment — we learned at considerable cost in Ireland that 'police primacy' is only solution to public disorder'. Whether Trump is genuinely interested in quelling public disorder or has another agenda altogether is another matter entirely. The governor of California is Gavin Newsom, one of the (increasingly numerous) potential Democratic Party candidates who may run for president in 2028. Is Trump trying to blacken Newsom's reputation ahead of that campaign or does he have even baser reasons? We have seen over the decades that military adventures are a tried-and-trusted ploy of US presidents seeking to distract voters from other issues — though such adventures tend to occur abroad rather than at home. Trump has had a well-publicised spat in recent days with X owner Elon Musk —his billionaire backer and one-time sidekick — with the two exchanging various insults online. Sending armed troops to the second-largest city in the US is the kind of expression of raw power that might be expected of someone fond of expressions of raw power. That may be Trump's motivation, but for many others it looks like another marker of US decline — with the end of that decline not yet in sight. Fact or fiction The death of novelist Frederick Forsyth was announced this week. He was 86. A successful journalist in the 60s, he was broke when he hit upon an idea for a thriller, writing The Day of the Jackal in 35 days. The book became a runaway success and Forsyth went on to write a series of thrillers including The Odessa File and The Dogs of War — they sold in their millions and many were also made into successful films. He spent several years living in Wicklow during the 70s, availing of the Irish tax exemption for artists and writers which had been introduced by Charles Haughey. He would later claim that when he told Haughey of his desire to leave Ireland and return to Britain, he was offered a seat in the Seanad — though it might be as well to file that yarn with his claim to have spied for M16 while working as a journalist. In later years, he advocated for Brexit and doubted climate change, but was always honest about his motives. 'I am slightly mercenary,' he said once. 'I write for money.' Read More Irish Examiner view: We need to eradicate TB for good

Could AI end grind schools?
Could AI end grind schools?

Irish Examiner

timea day ago

  • Irish Examiner

Could AI end grind schools?

With ASTI's rejection of proposals for Leaving Certificate reforms, there is now a realistic possibility that Ireland will be one of the first countries to witness industrial action over the use of artificial intelligence in education. Even if this impasse is eventually resolved, this foregrounds the genuine need for a discussion of what role we want AI to play in our education system. At the moment, this debate in education is polarised and it's the worst type of polarised debate – one where both sides are correct. On one side, many teachers, rightly, are concerned about the potential for students to cheat with AI and the completely impossible responsibility placed on them to detect this. On the other, supporters of the reforms, also quite rightly, can point to the benefits of project-based assessment and how experience of using AI will be an increasingly valuable life-skill. Between the hype and the handwringing, there's a very basic truth about AI in education: it's not the Messiah, but it's also not simply a very naughty bot. For a real discussion of AI in education, we need three ingredients: the first is an honest examination of the problems we have in our education system; the second is an informed discussion about what AI can and can't do; and the third is the real involvement of teachers and students. This should all start from a principle of 'Responsible AI'. In academia, it's difficult to move without some conference, grant proposal or job-ad mentioning 'Responsible AI'. Though this has diluted the meaning of quite a complex idea, there's a straightforward way to think about it: AI should solve problems we actually have and not problems that Big Tech, or AI itself, thinks we might have. Grind schools So, let's start with a glaring problem in our education system in Ireland: grind schools. These schools dominate our education system, both financially and mentally. Financially, this "shadow education" was estimated by the ESRI at €60m. Mentally, our discourse is dominated by their notes, study tips and predictions (though I've yet to see an audit on these predictions). This is all the more flagrant during exam season. There are several problems with these schools and there's a need for increased regulation, especially in the online space: one online school was recently caught peddling outdated material as a predicted paper and editing their own reviews. The education gap Beyond this, however, we have to ask if we really want an education system where a school, The Institute of Education, can sell for close to €130m? This is in a context where other schools are faced with a need to employ unqualified teachers (13,540 at post-primary and primary level). Indeed, the shortage of teaching staff between advantaged and disadvantaged schools in Ireland is one of the biggest in OECD countries. This is a social and a political problem, which needs to be addressed at a structural level. However, AI can make a contribution here: by making some tasks more efficient for teachers and by spreading educational resources to all students. Teachers and AI Three months ago, I launched a free essay corrector for the Leaving Certificate. We now have 1500 teachers and 3000 Leaving Cert students on the platform. As an academic, I've seen how disastrous AI can be in the classroom when let loose. Yet that doesn't mean we can't find a place for AI; when built with teachers, it can help improve education, especially in under-resourced schools. In the last three months, I've been in contact with well-over 100 teachers. These conversations, almost universally, featured two emotions: confusion and enthusiasm. Confusion at the current status of AI in schools; uncertainty as to how they were expected to deal with AI; and stress at the fact that this seemed to be all down to the individual teacher to determine when, how and why AI should be used. Quite rightly, these concerns are part of the basis for ASTI's rejection of the Leaving Certificate reforms. But what has stood out more than the confusion is the genuine enthusiasm from teachers to build responsible AI for their classrooms. What the debate around the Leaving Cert reforms on AI might mask is the real interest from teachers in these tools. From the newly qualified to those with 30+ years under the belt, I now get emails every day which show a real curiosity to learn more about this technology and an investment in making it better. Dr Cillian O Fathaigh: 'AI should solve problems we actually have and not problems that Big Tech, or AI itself, thinks we might have.' Importantly, this makes the real role of AI in education clear: it is a tool. It's a very powerful tool, but it is not a replacement for the inspiration and personal connection of teachers. It won't solve all the structural problems of education inequality, but it can help make teachers' and students' lives better. This enthusiasm points to a need for our discussion around AI and the Leaving Cert reforms to go beyond settings limits and rules. We also need to find ways for teachers and students to positively engage with AI and to be involved in actively shaping these tools. Responsible AI, in the end, won't build itself. Dr Cillian Ó Fathaigh is is an Assistant Professor in Philosophy at the Jagiellonian University Kraków and a Visiting Research Fellow at King's College London. He currently leads a survey of AI teaching across 7 European universities. In March, he co-created a Leaving Cert essay corrector and AI exam coach. Read More Ireland's data centres now consume more than a fifth of national electricity

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store