Tesla resale prices tumbling. These popular cars hold their value better
For that reason, we turned to experts from Kelley Blue Book/Autotrader and CarGurus for advice about making one of life's biggest purchases – whether it be new or used.
"I encourage people not to think of cars as assets because they are not an appreciating thing," said Sean Tucker, lead editor with Kelley Blue Book and Autotrader. "But it is still a major investment, and so there's a reason you don't want to buy the one that has lost 41% of its value in two years."
That vehicle, according to Kelley Blue Book data, is the 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range.
"Our industry has never seen anything like what's happened to Tesla over the last year," Tucker said. As CEO Elon Musk worked with President Donald Trump's administration, Tesla saw the lowest Q1 results in three years.
"We just don't have a frame of reference for what happens to the value of a car when people start protesting outside the dealerships that sell it," Tucker said.
Tesla's Cybertruck stands alone
Regardless of which data you review, the 2024 Cybertruck Cyberbeast 4WD has seen a notable drop:
◾ CarGurus provided an average monthly list price (aka the asking price) for the 2024 model year on its website. Below, see how the gray line trends down as the list price fell from $152,571 in May 2024 to $83,062 in May 2025, a 45.6% decrease.
◾ Kelley Blue Book (KBB), an auto valuation company, provided different metrics: two data points, the average manufacture's suggested retail price (MSRP) compared with KBB fair price today (orange line). "The fair price takes into account recent transactions within 50 miles of you within the last week and is constantly updated by what people are currently paying where you live," Tucker said. Based on the national average KBB provided to USA TODAY, a Cybertruck purchased new in May 2024 would fetch about $30,000 less one year later, a 29.4% decrease.
Kevin Roberts, director of economic and market intelligence at CarGurus, cautions that the Cybertruck decline needs some context: "While Cybertruck's prices in general look stark, there are a couple of things to keep in mind. When they first were offered in November 2023, it was a really limited volume. That limited supply leads to a lot of consumer interest. And then now we've seen supply is much more normalized. In fact, you're hearing that they have too much inventory in the new side, which puts downward pressure on the price."
Can't see our graphics? Click here.
How popular car models depreciate over time
Kelley Blue Book provided us with the same data points: the average MSRP compared with KBB fair price today for a number of popular 2023 models. Here's what we found:
Trucks
"Toyota is known for its high-end, predictable quality. They just keep their value better," Tucker said. Also, high resale value might be why you want to buy a Tacoma, Tucker said.
For the F-150, Tucker notes the EV Lightning model had an even larger decrease.
"Ford did everything it could to make those trucks functionally identical," Tucker said. "With new technology, a new market, there's always a threat that we don't face with gas-powered cars, which is that the technology could change drastically in the next few years."
Midsize and crossover SUVs
The popular Jeep Grand Cherokee saw a 31.3% decline over the past two years. "I think generally I would rather own a 3-year old Subaru than a 3-year old Jeep," Tucker said. "Jeep is a Stellantis brand, and they have kind of struggled with their long-term quality. I think it's improving, but that has been the perception for a long time."
The real standout in the midsize/crossover category is the Hyundai Palisade and its 10-year powertrain warranty, Tucker said. "If you own a 2-year-old palisade, you have eight years left of warranty protection, which is just not the case with either of the other cars in there."
Compact SUVs
The 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range saw a 41.1% drop when comparing the KKB fair price in 2023 with the average MSRP. "That comes down to what's happened to Tesla over the past year or even really the past six months," Tucker said.
Sedans
The Honda Accord dropped by 17.8%, or roughly $5,500. "Honda, very similar to Toyota, has that strong reliability reputation. These things last forever, and it shows up when it comes time to resell it," Tucker said.
Vehicles that saw the biggest and smallest changes in used listing prices
CarGurus looked at used 2024 models listed on its site from May 2024 through May 2025. From all vehicles available, it chose the five vehicles that declined the most in listing price and the five that declined the least. What they found:
The five models from CarGuru's data with the biggest drop in list price from May 2024 to May 2025:
Tesla Cybertruck: Down $69,509, 45.6% ($152,571 - $83,062)
Down $69,509, 45.6% ($152,571 - $83,062) Ford F-150: Down $34,833, 37.7% ($92,502 - $57,669)
Down $34,833, 37.7% ($92,502 - $57,669) RAM 1500: Down $16,279, 25.6% ($63,592 - $47,314)
Down $16,279, 25.6% ($63,592 - $47,314) Range Rover : Down $43,293, 24.7% ($175,187 - $131,894)
: Down $43,293, 24.7% ($175,187 - $131,894) Jeep Wrangler: Down $15,451, 24.2% ($63,940 - $48,488)
Cybertruck: When looking at the decline in Tesla's Cybertruck price, the difference can be jaw-dropping. The Cybertruck saw a 45.6%, $69,509, price drop from May 2024 to May 2025. Roberts believes the initial price of the Cybertruck was probably artificially high. "There's even people I think at time were trying to flip them," Roberts said. "That drove the average list price higher than what the market would have been."
Ford F-150, Jeep Wrangler: These models fell victim to an oversupply in the new market because of the 2021-2022 microchip shortage, Roberts said. "2024 is where we really started to see new inventory levels start to recover. And for certain brands, they got way too much inventory. With potential incentives on the new side, that puts more downward pressure on the used side price."
Land Rover, Range Rover: "Known for its luxury styling and features, but typical of many premium brands, is likely experiencing steeper early price depreciation," Roberts said.
Ram 1500: "This represents the final year of the previous generation," Roberts said, "with the all-new 2025 model likely effecting used pricing dynamics."
The five models from CarGuru's data that declined the least or are up from May 2024 to May 2025:
Subaru Crosstrek: Down $36, 0.1% ($29,690 - $29,654)
Down $36, 0.1% ($29,690 - $29,654) Subaru Forester: Down $91, 0.3% ($33,693 - $33,602)
Down $91, 0.3% ($33,693 - $33,602) Porsche Cayenne : Down $1,082, 1.1% ($102,637 - $101,555)
Down $1,082, 1.1% ($102,637 - $101,555) Toyota RAV4 Hybrid: Down $596, 1.6% ($37,698 - $37,102)
Down $596, 1.6% ($37,698 - $37,102) Porsche Macan: Down $1,342, 1.9% ($70,006 - $68,664)
Subaru: "Subaru is in a situation where they have a lot tighter inventory, particularly for some of those kind of popular CUVs," Roberts said. "That leads to a situation where, hey, maybe you want a certain model, you might have an easier time on the used market, which helps to kind of prop up those prices."
Porsche: "Luxury can be different," Roberts said. "You see a couple Porsches on the lis;, there's a limited supply in the marketplace and a lot of demand. That can lead to prices actually moving up on some of the used units."
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid: "Much like the Subarus, the RAV4 continues to face some of the tightest supply in the market," Roberts said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tesla Cybertruck Sales Fall Well Short of Hype
Tesla (TSLA, Financials) has sold just over 52,000 Cybertrucks in the U.S., far below the more than 1 million reservations it touted before launch, Cox Automotive said. Warning! GuruFocus has detected 8 Warning Signs with BKH. The futuristic design turned heads but left many truck buyers cold. Specs fell short of Tesla's promises and of rivals' gas-powered pickups, while eight recalls in a year dented confidence. Analysts say high sides, awkward loading and limited towing and battery range make the Cybertruck less functional than traditional trucks. This article first appeared on GuruFocus.
CNBC
3 hours ago
- CNBC
Why Tesla Cybertruck sales are falling short of expectations
Sales of Tesla's flashy Cybertruck are a fraction of the more than a million reservations the company had a month before deliveries began rolling out in November 2023. So far, U.S. sales total just over 52,000 units, according to Cox Automotive. "It's a really remarkable vehicle," said Sean Tucker, Executive Editor for Cox Automotive. "I quite like the design, but then I tend to quite like anything that stands out. And it certainly stands out." The Cybertruck's futuristic design certainly caught attention, but had limited appeal, especially with truck buyers. The truck's specifications also fell short of those Tesla advertised early on, and in some cases fell short of those offered by leading fuel-burning pickups. There have also been many quality and production problems as the company has issued eight voluntary recalls in little more than a year. With all those factors, plus a less-than-advertised towing and payload capacity and the disappointing battery range, many truck buyers have stayed on the sidelines. "I think the problem they ran into with that design: it's not as functional as it should be," Tucker said. "Some of the design decisions that truck makers tend to make, they've made because of many, many years of people using trucks and determining what's the best way for them to work." The sides of the Cybertruck bed are high, and the vehicle has a pyramidal shape. That makes it tough to load. "Trucks have been the same for a very long time," said Tesla CEO Elon Musk when the truck was unveiled in 2019. "Like 100 years. Trucks have been basically the same. We want to try something different." But what it created was more likely to appeal to an EV enthusiast thinking about a pickup — or a novelty vehicle — than most of the buyers who buy pickups. "Electric pickup trucks are a natural place for automakers, particularly American automakers," said Stephanie Brinley, Associate Director, AutoIntelligence for S&P Global Mobility. "It's also a tougher market in terms of its use case, in terms of the sense of conservatism that the buyer has." Truck buyers have "come a long way" over the last several years, in terms of their openness to and familiarity technology and other innovations in pickups, she added. But truck buyers still tend to favor the tried and true. Brand loyalty in the segment runs somewhere around 70-80%, said RAM CEO Tim Kuniskis in a recent interview with CNBC. A large share of truck buyers rely on their vehicles for work. Even off-roaders and recreational buyers want trucks that will meet their standards for towing, payload, and overall performance. "I think that those buyers also want a little bit more proof, a little bit more proof that it's going to do everything they need to do," Brinley said. Watch the video to learn more.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Tesla owners gut-punched after receiving unexpected notice from insurance company: 'Mind you, zero accidents in my life'
Tesla's reduced production of its Cybertruck is having a ripple effect on owners, some of whom say insurance companies are now canceling policies for the vehicle. What's happening? Once one of the world's most-hyped vehicles, sales and production numbers for Tesla's Cybertruck have fallen sharply. In the second quarter of this year, the company sold just 4,306 Cybertrucks, a drop of more than 50% over the same period in 2024. Now, Torque News reported, some insurance companies are using those numbers to cancel their coverage of the all-electric truck. One Illinois resident wrote in a Cybertruck owners' Facebook group that his Cybertruck would need to be removed from his policy. He shared a letter written by Hanover Insurance, which said the company is "unable to adequately rate and underwrite the vehicle" because of its limited production and that "its design represents a unique challenge, as it poses an extraordinary expense for repair or replacement under comprehensive or collision coverage." The only way his overall policy could avoid cancellation, the company wrote, was to remove the Cybertruck from it. "Mind you," he wrote, "zero accidents in my life." Why are Cybertruck issues concerning? This development is the latest piece of troubling news surrounding the Cybertruck — and, really, Tesla's overall sales this year. As Torque News noted, the company already has the capacity to produce 130,000 Cybertrucks per year, and CEO Elon Musk previously suggested Tesla would make up to 250,000 of the vehicles each year. But based on its second-quarter numbers, the company would be on pace to produce fewer than 20,000 Cybertrucks annually. In that quarter, Cybertruck sales were not only beaten by those of the Ford F-150 Lightning but also by the Hummer EV. And the problem wasn't limited to the Cybertruck, as Tesla's overall sales fell 12.6% from the previous year. Are you planning to buy a new car in the next two to three years? No way Maybe Probably Definitely Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. As the biggest electric-vehicle company, any negative development for Tesla could potentially make people think twice before switching to an EV, which could keep more high-polluting, dirty energy-burning cars on the road instead. What can I do about this? On the Facebook group, some other Cybertruck owners said they also received cancellation notices from Hanover Insurance but had success finding policies with other companies, namely Farmers Insurance. But no matter what make or model it is, switching from a gas-powered vehicle to an EV is one of the best choices you can make for our environment. And with the $7,500 federal EV tax credit ending Sept. 30, thanks to the passage of the "Big Beautiful Bill," now may be the perfect time to make that switch. Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
