Air India report: fuel switches cut off before plane crash
Amid confusion on the flight deck, the pilots reopened the fuel to restart the engines but it was too late. Deprived of power, the Boeing 787 Dreamliner sank to the ground 30 seconds after taking off from Ahmedabad for London on June 12, the preliminary report by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau said.
The fuel switches, which toggle between 'run' and 'cutoff', are used for the engine start and stop in every flight. They are positioned on the console between the pilots and are impossible to manipulate accidentally because they are guarded and require deliberate actions to move.
The aircraft took off normally but 'immediately thereafter, the engine one and engine two fuel cutoff switches transitioned from run to cutoff position one after another, with a time gap of 01 seconds,' the report said.
The co-pilot, Clive Kunder, was flying the aircraft with Captain Sumeet Sabharwal monitoring. 'In the cockpit voice recording, one of the pilots is heard asking the other why he cut off. The other pilot responded that he did not do so,' the report said.
AMIT DAVE/REUTERS
The report did not identify which remarks were made by the captain and which by the first officer, nor which pilot transmitted, 'mayday, mayday, mayday, losing thrust' just before the crash.
The preliminary report also does not say how the switch could have flipped to the cutoff position.
The switches were moved back to the normal position, starting the relighting sequence, but one of the engines failed to restart, ensuring the aircraft's doom, the report showed.
The fuel supply switches are only used in flight in an emergency to shut down an engine that is failing. 'These are sacred switches. We would never touch one of these in flight unless there was some very serious reason,' Ben Watts, a Boeing 737 pilot and instructor, said on a podcast after word of the engine shutdown leaked this week.
The report in effect exonerated Boeing after fears there may have been a flaw in the 787, the flagship product of the troubled US planemaker. Air India flight 171 was the first loss of one of its Dreamliners, which have been in service since 2011.
The investigation, which continues, has not yet found any significant faults with the aircraft.
John Cox, a US aviation safety expert, said a pilot would not be able to accidentally move the fuel switches that feed the engines. 'You can't bump them and they move,' he said.
The report states: 'At this stage of investigation, there are no recommended actions to B787-8 and/or GE GEnx-1B engine operators and manufacturers, suggesting that no significant fault has been found with the plane or its engines.'
There were 242 people on board, including 53 British citizens, 169 Indian citizens, seven Portuguese, one Canadian and 12 crew on board. Only one passenger survived, the British citizen Vishwash Kumar Ramesh. A total of 260 died in the incident, according to industry reports.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
The Midults: My girlfriend is always undermining me
Dear A&E, I've been with my girlfriend for two years and we've always got on really well as a couple in social situations, backing each other up and taking one another's side. Lately, though, I've found her starting to undermine me in little ways when we're out with friends – disputing my account of things that happened; contradicting me on little details; always needing to have the last word. I'm not naturally argumentative but it's starting to really bother me. She's really lovely and cosy in private. Should I talk to her, and what should I say? – Downcast Dear Downcast, Some happy, lifelong marriages involve one partner loudly and aggressively criticising the other in public. 'That story is so boring,' she squawks. 'Are you still talking??' he sneers. For many of us – as observers – this is both baffling and extremely unpleasant to be around but, hey, the heart wants what the heart wants and it's a dynamic that works for them. It is not, however, a dynamic that is working for you. At the moment it only bothers you but who's to say that, further down the line, it won't distress you. If you do not like this dynamic then you should address it as it is unlikely to go away by itself. Unfortunately, these things, left unchecked, will have a habit of either bedding in or intensifying and that has the potential to make you very unhappy. Unhappy people who actively avoid confrontation risk withdrawing, proving their point – or demonstrating their hurt – through action (or inaction), which could start to meaningfully alienate you from each other. Scary, right? If you bring this up, you might start a huge row or hear something you don't want to hear. It's only when you begin to understand what's happening, you can work out what to do. At the moment you are a bit hurt and a bit baffled – understandable but rendering you powerless. It is often at this stage of the relationship that you need to find courage. It is important to feel able to talk to the person you are with about what is going in between you. We know that sounds as though we're stating the bleeding obvious but it can feel frightening. Or exhausting. And lots of us duck it where possible. Be brave, Downcast. It will give the relationship the best chance of growing or, failing that, it will give you the best chance of growing. Right at the beginning of love affairs, we tend to find it sweet when our new and adored person gets things wrong. Or we don't even see it. Later, we may start to find it annoying but, hopefully, we make a decision – based on the bigger scheme of things – to right-size our responses; to look beyond. This is not denial. It is love. There is a chance that she may not know she is behaving in this way; that she had some kind of combative/judgmental elements to her early life. A fighty or one-upmanship-y childhood. Even a puritanical education may have nudged her towards becoming a kind of fact-checker. It doesn't really matter if an amusing anecdote is 'right', does it? The listener doesn't care whether it was Whitstable or Brixham; whether it was raining or snowing. How much does it matter to her that she is right? Would she rather be right or happy? You have various courses of action open to you. You could tell her that it is deeply uncomfortable for everyone when she does this – but that is actively shaming and makes it about the audience rather than your connection. 'Everyone thinks so…' is always a bastard thing to say unless it's around a compliment. You could try a bit of a shock approach and respond in the moment, in public, by saying something like 'I find it very difficult when you talk to me like that.' However, seeing as you have established, in your letter, that this is a kind of performative feistiness that rises in her only when you are among other people, that could cause trouble. We would think that a quiet moment, when you are alone and all is calm, might be a productive time to say something like, 'When you criticise me in public – which I feel is happening more often – what are you trying to tell me? I find it difficult, in the moment but, if there is something you need me to know, I would really like to hear it now. I don't love those public moments, which hurt my feelings, but I do love you and I'd like to understand why it happens and also look at my part in it.' What a man, Downcast! We obviously have no idea how this will go. But for both your own personal development and the future of this romance, it feels crucial that you are able to have the conversation.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Survivors share experiences of Jesus Army cult for BBC series
A small Christian commune that aspired to create heaven on Earth grew to become a cult in which sexual and physical abuse was perpetuated in plain Jesus Army church recruited thousands of people to live in close-knit, puritanical communities in Northamptonshire, London and the of the UK's most abusive cults, it is now the subject of a new BBC documentary and trace the story from its hippy origins as the Jesus Fellowship, through the high-profile launch of the Jesus Army in the late 1980s, to its shocking collapse in the 2000s when the truth about life inside the church started to survivors have been sharing their experiences. 'It was just horrible' For John Everett, it started as a dream of community life."I always had these yearnings for a lifestyle that was different to the materialistic lifestyle," he explains."This feeling that striving for wealth didn't equate to happiness, and I didn't feel attached to material property in the way that a lot of my friends seemed to be."In 1976, aged 18, John was told that in the village of Bugbrooke, near Northampton, a Christian preacher called Noel Stanton had created a "communal lifestyle" that had attracted hundreds of young saving some money, John travelled from his home in Kent to experience it for himself and soon saw the attraction."I remember a guy called Andy out in the garden. He was doing some weeding and I remember him singing away to himself while he was doing it. "And so that was the first thing that really struck me, just how happy everybody looked. I could feel myself melting."For that life, though, sacrifices needed to be made because "any kind of entertainment was wrong," John says."So no more cinema, no more television. And from now on, I would have to stop listening to any music." Details of help and support with child sexual abuse and sexual abuse or violence are available in the UK at BBC Action Line But after some time he began to have doubts, including how children were says children were disciplined with birch sticks, which "was meant to be a loving form of correction".John says: "A young child was taken away from the dining room table to be disciplined, and we could all hear."His screams as he was hit, and on that occasion, he was hit at least six times and it was just horrible. It was... humiliating for the child. It was humiliating for everybody. Horrible."John began documenting what he had seen and heard during his time in the Jesus eventually left but was branded a "traitor" and no-one from the group was allowed to contact him. 'You're told you are sinful as a woman' The Jesus Army's headquarters was at New Creation Hall, the Grade II-listed farmhouse in Bugbrooke where Noel Stanton began visiting it with her family as a child before they moved to the village permanently in 1986, "a couple of doors down" from Stanton."You could feel his influence, actually," she says. "He didn't need to be there."Many teenagers, including her older brother, were separated from their families and housed was all part of Stanton's belief that the family of God was more important than one's biological family. Philippa says when she was 12 and 13, she became aware that a friend of about the same age was being sexually says: "You're constantly being told that you are sinful as a woman. That you're distracting men from God."You're called a Jezebel. You're belittled at every opportunity by Noel. So who's gonna believe that, you know, a man, an elder, has done those things to somebody?"But eventually, while still a teenager, she testified in court against an elder who became the first member of the group to be convicted of sexually assaulting a young said she was shunned by the leadership and fled the group before eventually founding the Jesus Fellowship Survivors the Jesus Army disbanded following Stanton's death in 2009, allegations against him of numerous sexual assaults on boys Jesus Fellowship Church ultimately disbanded in 2019 following a series of historical cases of sexual abuse. A report by the Jesus Fellowship Community Trust (JFCT), a group tasked with winding up the church's affairs, found one in six children involved with it was estimated to have been sexually abused by the is still thought that some of those accused, including 162 former leaders, may have taken up roles in different churches and Northamptonshire Police is liaising with relevant local authorities to see if any safeguarding action is required. the JFCT said it was sorry for 'the severely detrimental impact' on people's lives, and hoped the conclusion of the redress scheme would 'provide an opportunity to look to the future' for all those affected during a 50-year date, about 12 former members of the Jesus Fellowship Church have been convicted for indecent assaults and other offences. Inside the Cult of the Jesus Army is available on BBC one and two of the podcast, In Detail: The Jesus Army Cult are on BBC Sounds. Follow Northamptonshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Croydon Council tackles anti-social behaviour with outdoor gyms
More outdoor gyms are to be introduced by Croydon Council in a bid to tackle anti-social council is also seeking to introduce more dog-walking zones and to deter cut-through riding on affected most by drug use and other issues, such as Upper Norwood Recreation Ground, will be is despite the financial pressures on the council, which has declared bankruptcy three times since 2020 and asked for a government bailout in February. Scott Roche, Croydon cabinet minister for streets and environment, said: "If a park gym is being used properly, you're not going to have people smoking weed there."We think outdoor gyms are a more strategic and inclusive use for a park. They're cheaper to introduce than new playgrounds, and they help tackle anti-social behaviour."However, he admits that change is slower than he would like, and says money is the greatest currently has 10 outdoor gyms, spread across the borough's 127 parks and green spaces. The news comes as Mr Roche and mayor Jason Perry opened a newly resurfaced path in Norbury area remains affected by e-bike misuse and rough sleeping, and speed bumps have been promised to deter cut-through Mr Roche said "we are restricted because it is a public space".Jenni Rodgers, leader of Friends of Norbury Park, said the path marked progress, but that the park still "needs something here that people want to see".A flood alleviation scheme for the area, which would protect 340 homes from flooding and boost biodiversity, has stalled since the pandemic.
