Carolyn Hax: At yo-yo's end with supporting friend through cyclic breakups
Dear Carolyn: I am probably at this point overinvested here, but my really good friend has been in a terrible relationship for eight years now: They break up, friend dumps on me, there's a few good months, they get back together, friend distances from friends, they break up again, etc.
They just broke up again. I am dreading the process but feel like not being there would be problematic for my social life. I am just done with the drama and feel like saying so.
Anyway, can you help me understand why otherwise great people do this yo-yo thing?
— Yo-yo's Friend
Yo-yo's Friend: Not fixing a near-decade problem mystifies me, too, so I'm not sure I can help you understand. You would think they'd tire of it. Or maybe we're both missing the point — maybe they include the on-and-off as part of the whole.
It must satisfy a need for both of them, or else they'd stay apart one of these times. An unhealthy need, or else they'd stay together. So — two unhealthy needs they use each other to avoid fixing. How's that.
As for what to say to your friend this time, now that you're 'done with the drama' and possibly a little salty, I think eight years of getting dumped on gives you standing to speak your mind.
You wrote a fine start: 'I am probably at this point overinvested, but you have been in an unstable relationship for eight years now. You break up, dump on me, have a few good months, get back together, distance yourself from friends, break up again, etc.'
Then maybe just: 'I don't know what to say anymore. But acting like this is normal or okay doesn't seem like the right call. Is there anything else I can do here?'
Like I said, though — this may be their normal. They may be life partners, in their yo-yo way. As designated friend, it might help you to see it this way: to assume there is no 'process' to 'dread' because there is no off or on, it is all of a piece, and to divest from the drama and expect nothing besides seeing your friend when your friend is available.
And don't try to fix anything — just be 'sorry to hear that.'
Dear Carolyn: I live in the East and work full time even though I am past retirement age; I like to work, I'm good at my job and it gives me something to do. I have lots of friends and plan lunches and classes weekly.
Some of my grandchildren live in the West, and I feel guilty that I don't move there to take care of them, especially 9-year-old twins. Both parents work round-the-clock, and they rely on the older kids to take care of the twins.
I don't want to move where they live. However, I feel like I'm being selfish, and they could really use my help; they need someone to pick up the kids from school, prepare dinner, help with homework — a housekeeper. Should that be my job?
— Grandparent
Grandparent: 'Should' you, no, not if you don't want to and you're deeply rooted.
It's alarming that older kids are being pressed into parent duty for youngers, if they're more than just helping out. But it doesn't make sense to me that your cross-country relocation, maybe effectively for good, is the only solution for at most a six- or seven-year problem.
Can you afford to help them hire steady after-school child care? Then you stay above your social safety net, which is so important, and they get responsible relief.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
a minute ago
- CBS News
In Brooklyn, community-based doulas work to change Black maternal health outcomes
Data shows that Black women are dying during childbirth at alarming rates, and the crisis is especially urgent in Brooklyn, which has the city's largest Black population. A local organization is stepping up with specialized support to change those outcomes. The joy is real, and so are the flickers of fear on a new parent's face. As Ana Nunez and Cristian Avila watched over their newborn son, Lyon, they reflected on the mix of hope and worry that shaped their path to parenthood. "Sometimes you hear a lot of horror stories about being a Black woman giving birth," Nunez said. "So I wanted to feel heard, I wanted to feel included. So I let my doctor know I was interested in doula service and that's how I was connected." Those fears were addressed by their doula, Reshonah Williams, who worked with them from the third trimester through several weeks postpartum. "We worked on comfort measures to help ease the condition of natural labor," Williams said. "Because the hospitals automatically come up with the idea of, you know, 'You can have an epidural if you want, you should have an epidural.' And we're like, 'Mom says she wants to do this.'" New mom Raven Lopez also found support through a doula after giving birth to her colicky baby girl. "She helped breastfeeding, you know, sometimes babies won't latch," Lopez said. "She helped me, to show me, how to make the milk flow. You know, it was hard for me to pick up the baby. She showed me how to pick up the baby." The crying, she said, was often quickly soothed by her doula, Dadreama Sandiford. "If they're saying that they're experiencing pain, they're experiencing pain," Sandiford said of her role as a liaison between a mother and her doctor. "For the physicians, listen. For the lawmakers, make it accessible for everyone." Both families turned to the Caribbean Women's Health Association (CWHA), a nonprofit founded in 1982 that has since become the largest free, community-based doula service provider in New York City. Cheryl Hall, CWHA's executive director, pointed to research that supports the impact of doula care to improve outcomes. "There's a whole birth plan put in place and what the expectations are," Hall said. "Doulas, of course, they are providing psychosocial care. They're not providing clinical care." According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Black women in the U.S. are nearly 3.5 times more likely to die from pregnancy-related complications than white women. In Brooklyn, home to the city's largest Black population, Hall said that disparity sparked action. Asked what could be done to address the root causes of the crisis, Hall pointed to a lost opportunity. "We were participating in a big study with [National Institutes of Health] and Mount Sinai to focus on a seven-year grant to try to ... get the answer to that question," she said. "Within the first month of the new administration, the grant was taken away from us." CWHA provides workshops and services across the city in multiple languages, covering everything from sleep safety and lactation to postpartum recovery. "We're mostly representing clients that may not always be able to represent themselves or advocate for themselves," said full-spectrum doula Marlyn Williams. The organization's goal: provide care that goes beyond the delivery room, empowering families long after the baby comes home. Have a story idea or tip in Brooklyn? Email Hannah by CLICKING HERE.
Associated Press
a minute ago
- Associated Press
Trump says he plans to put a 100% tariff on computer chips, likely increasing costs of electronics
The Associated Press is an independent global news organization dedicated to factual reporting. Founded in 1846, AP today remains the most trusted source of fast, accurate, unbiased news in all formats and the essential provider of the technology and services vital to the news business. More than half the world's population sees AP journalism every day.
Associated Press
a minute ago
- Associated Press
Army sergeant shot 5 fellow soldiers at Georgia's Fort Stewart, official says
The Associated Press is an independent global news organization dedicated to factual reporting. Founded in 1846, AP today remains the most trusted source of fast, accurate, unbiased news in all formats and the essential provider of the technology and services vital to the news business. More than half the world's population sees AP journalism every day.
