Debate over "that" try continues long after the Lions clinch a series win over Australia
From the Northern Hemisphere, Jac Morgan's cleanout of Carlo Tizzano at the last breakdown Saturday was fair and perfectly executed. From the Southern Hemisphere, Morgan breached rugby's law 9.20 by striking Tizzano above the shoulders which likely in most matches in the south would have been considered endangerment and would have been penalized.
While the Lions woke with the sore heads of celebrants, the Wallabies were left to brood over what might have been.
Australia coach Joe Schmidt was emphatic after the match that Italian referee Andrea Piardi had erred in not penalizing Morgan and ruling out the last-minute try to Hugo Keenan which prevented the Wallabies from leveling the series.
Piardi and his assistant referees closely studied replays of the final ruck before waving away the entreaties of Wallabies captain Harry Wilson and awarding the try. In explanation, Piardi said Tizzano and Morgan had arrived at the ruck at the same time and their collision was part of the normal rough and tumble of the game.
'You just have to read law 9.20 and I guess you just have to listen to the description from the referee and then watch the vision,' Schmidt told a news conference after the match. 'When two players are described as arriving at the same time, just watch the footage.
'Players make errors. Match officials make errors. Our perspective is we felt it was a decision that doesn't really live up to the big player safety push that they're talking about. You cannot hit someone above the level of the shoulders and there's no wrapping with the left arm, the hands on the ground. That's what we've seen, and we've watched a number of replays from different angles. It is what it is. We just have to accept it.'
From the northern perspective, Morgan makes contact with Tizzano below the neck and shoulders. It was, Lions coach Andy Farrell said 'brilliant'.
Some Lions fans even went as far as to accuse Tizzano of 'simulation,' by trying to exaggerate the incident to influence the referee.
'I thought it was a brilliant clear-out, honestly, didn't you? It depends on what side of the fence you come from,' Farrell said.
'I thought it was a good clear-out live. I couldn't understand what they were going back for. They seem to go back for everything these days. But I'm so pleased that the referee held his nerve. It was the right decision in my opinion.
'I can understand people's opinions.'
Wallabies and Lions fans clashed on social media long after the crowd of more than 90,000 fans — the most ever to watch the Lions — had left the Melbourne Cricket Ground. Fans from the north and south agreed only that this had been one of the great test matches and most memorable of rugby occasions.
___
AP rugby: https://apnews.com/hub/rugby
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Beveridge responds to question about in-demand free agent after rival coach uproar
Luke Beveridge says interest from rival clubs in Carlton's Jack Silvagni is inevitable, but he's refused to divulge further details about the Western Bulldogs' pursuit of the player. It comes after Collingwood coach Craig McRae revealed details of a promising 'first date' he had with Silvagni after meeting with the out-of-contract Carlton star recently, prompting a swipe from Blues boss Michael Voss and Geelong coach Chris Scott. Voss and Scott both insisted the Magpies coach should have respected Silvagni's privacy by not going on public record about the meeting. They both pointed out the awkward situation it has created for third-generation Blues star Silvagni, who now has to walk back into the Carlton locker room alongside teammates who know he's thinking about leaving the club. The Magpies and Bulldogs have been the teams most heavily linked with a move for Silvagni, with reports Collingwood are ready to match Carlton's four year, $650,000 per season offer to the star defender. Silvagni is an unrestricted free agent meaning he can sign with any team during the upcoming window. And Beveridge admits every club's 'antenna' goes up when players of his calibre become available. But the Bulldogs coach is mindful about getting caught up in a similar situation to McRae by going public with the club's courting of Silvagni. Instead, Beveridge has chosen to remain tight-lipped about the Silvagni trade situation out of respect for the Carlton star and his own Bulldogs playing group. "I think with any free agent like Jack, every club's antenna is up," Beveridge told reporters on Thursday when asked about the Silvagni situation. "But I've always maintained the line of not talking about who we're chatting with behind the scenes, just purely out of respect for our playing group. "Some of our lads are still un-contracted, they don't need to be thinking too much about who might take their spot. And also probably out of respect for someone like Jack ... in that he's got to spend time at his current club, if he is planning to move on." The Bulldogs coach hit back at suggestions his stance on Silvagni was a bit hypocritical, considering he revealed earlier in the year how he met with Matt Rowell to try and convince the Gold Coast star to join the Dogs. Beveridge says the difference was he already knew Rowell planned on staying at the Suns when he made the meeting public record. "Everyone knew that we had met with Matthew because he was thinking of coming back to Melbourne," Beveridge said. But the Dogs coach accepted that their pursuit of the former No.1 pick had failed when he chose to reveal details of the meeting. RELATED: Max Gawn breaks silence on Simon Goodwin axing amid $1.2m fallout Abbey Holmes responds amid backlash over decision post-birth Eagles face decision as Victorian club 'not prepared' to pay Harley Reid Several AFL clubs competing for Jack Silvagni's signature Essendon coach Brad Scott also reportedly met with Silvagni at his home in Melbourne last week. But like Beveridge, the Bombers have refused to divulge details or provide comment on the situation. It's understood Essendon have yet to present a formal offer to Silvagni but the club is looking to bolster its defensive playing stocks and could land the Blues star without having to trade for a draft pick. Speaking about the Silvagni saga this week, Geelong coach Scott said this week it was naive to suggest clubs wouldn't expect some of their players to meet with rival players. And he said it was unrealistic to expect players to wait until October to speak to clubs about their future, giving them 'two weeks notice' when the trade window or free agency window was open. "I think most people in the footy industry know that players, especially with free agency coming in, they really have an obligation to do their research," he said. "It's not clubs chasing players... I don't think it's the clubs preying on these players."
Associated Press
2 hours ago
- Associated Press
The dog ate my passport: Family pooch dogs rookie's All Blacks call-up
WELLINGTON, New Zealand (AP) — Rookie Leroy Carter was still coming to terms with his inclusion in the All Blacks squad to play in Argentina in the opening rounds of the Rugby Championship when he made the shocking discovery. 'The dog ate my passport.' The utility back with the Hamilton-based Chiefs was one of four uncapped players included in Scott Robertson's Championship squad. The phone call from Robertson informing him of his selection had come as a massive surprise. Carter was rushing to get things together for the squad's assembly and departure when he realized the family dog had intercepted his passport. 'I got my passport out to take a photo to send to the (team) manager and I just left it on my bedside table,' Carter said. 'My partner went to the gym and left my dog home alone and it's gone down the hallway, jumped on the bed and just chewed up the passport and my teeth aligners. 'It was a bit of a shambles yesterday. I was trying to get an emergency one but I think it's all (sorted) now. I thought it would happen to me, something like that, so no point getting stressed about it.' The All Blacks squad leaves Friday to play Argentina in Cordoba on Aug. 17 and Buenos Aires a week later in the first two rounds of the Rugby Championship which also includes Australia and South Africa. ___ AP rugby:
Associated Press
2 hours ago
- Associated Press
Injuries shake up Wallabies' flyhalf options ahead of Rugby Championship
SYDNEY (AP) — Tom Lynagh's concussion and Noah Lolesio's neck injury leaves utility Ben Donaldson, 35-year-old James O'Connor or rookie Tane Edmed as Australia's flyhalf options for Rugby Championship tests in South Africa. Rugby Australia unveiled a 35-man squad Thursday for the two tests against the World Cup champion Springboks, making injury-enforced changes to the squad that won the third test in a 2-1 series loss to the British and Irish Lions. Edmed went on as a replacement in his one and only test to date — a narrow loss to Ireland last November — and wasn't in the Wallabies squad for the series against the Lions. O'Connor, a 64-test veteran who played for the Super Rugby-winning Crusaders last season, was in the wider Wallabies squad but not selected for matches. Donaldson went on as a replacement for Lynagh in the third test after the 22-year-old playmaker sustained a concussion from an illegal tackle from Lions hooker Dan Sheehan that resulted in a four-game suspension for the Irishman. An injury to Jake Gordon has delayed veteran scrumhalf Nic White's international retirement. White, regular finisher Tate McDermott and uncapped Ryan Lonergan were the scrumhalves picked for the squad to take on South Africa in two tests on Aug. 16 in Johannesburg and Aug. 23 in Cape Town. Lonergan is one of three uncapped players in the squad, along with winger Corey Toole and former New Zealand All Blacks prop Aidan Ross, who joined the Queensland Reds from the Chiefs following the Super Rugby final. Backrower Lukhan Salakaia-Loto, who played in three tour games against the Lions but wasn't part of the Wallabies set up, has returned to the top squad. 'It's pleasing to be able to keep the core of the group together, while also leaning on some depth and fresh bodies,:" Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt said. 'We're very conscious of how difficult it is going to be, playing South Africa on their home turf over two consecutive weekends. 'The group has made some positive steps throughout the start of the test season but we all know there is a lot of hard work ahead of us.' ___ Australia squad: Forwards: Angus Bell, Nick Champion De Crespigny, Nick Frost, Langi Gleeson, Tom Hooper, Fraser McReight, Josh Nasser, Zane Nonggorr, Brandon Paenga-Amosa, Billy Pollard, Tom Robertson, Aidan Ross, Lukhan Salakaia-Loto, Will Skelton, James Slipper, Carlo Tizzano, Taniela Tupou, Rob Valetini, Jeremy Williams, Harry Wilson. Backs: Ben Donaldson, Tane Edmed, Josh Flook, Len Ikitau, Max Jorgensen, Andrew Kellaway, Ryan Lonergan, Tate McDermott, James O'Connor, Hunter Paisami, Dylan Pietsch, Joseph-Aukuso Sua'ali'i, Corey Toole, Nic White, Tom Wright. ___ AP rugby:
