Are Dialogues, Dialectics True Sources Of Wisdom?
dialogue
', as used in the ordinary sense, means conversation, discussion, and exchange or interchange of ideas. 'Dialectic' refers to a formal method of discovering what is true by considering opposite theories. It is used to designate 'the method of investigating nature of truth by
critical analysis
of opposing concepts and hypotheses.'
Plato
described a dialectician as the midwife who helps us in arriving at knowledge through 'a skilfully directed technique of questioning.' Plato nowhere gives an explanation as to why he chose the method of dialogue, rather than writing reasoned treatises for exposition of his thesis. The closest one comes to understanding the reason for it is in his dialogue
Phaedrus
.
He explains it with the help of an Egyptian tale. Egyptian inventor Theuth presented his most notable invention of technique of writing as a tool for learning to reigning king Thamus, saying, "Here O king, is my technique of memory and wisdom, a branch of learning that will make people of Egypt wiser and help them improve their memories."
King Thamus contradicts him by saying that learning technique of writing would have opposite effect. The king reprimanded Theuth, "What you have discovered is a recipe not for memory, but for reminder." About writing as a source of knowledge, the king argued, "If men learn this, it will implant forgetfulness in their souls; they will cease to exercise memory because they rely on that which is written, calling things to remembrance no longer from within themselves, but by means of external marks."
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Bring home all new SP125 & get an instant cashback up to ₹4000#
Honda
Learn More
Undo
Writing, the king argued, does not result in wisdom but only in its semblance. By telling them of many things without teaching them, you will make them seem to know much, while for the most part, they know nothing.
Supporting King Thamus' criticism of writing, Plato says that writing provides us with 'dead discourse'. According to him, written words "seem to talk to you as though they were intelligent, but if you ask them anything about what they say, from a desire to be instructed, they go on telling you just the same thing forever."
The second reason for denouncing writing is that there is always a danger of the written word falling in the hands of undeserving persons. "Once a thing is put in writing," according to him, "drifts all over the place, getting into the hands not only of those who understand it, but equally of those who have no business with it; it does not know how to address the right people, and not address the wrong. And when it is ill-treated and unfairly abused, it always needs its parent to come to its help, being unable to defend or help itself."
On the other hand, the '
living speech
' is treated by Plato as the "brother to the written speech...goes together with knowledge and is written in the soul of learner, (it) can defend itself, and knows to whom it should speak and to whom it should say nothing."
But not every dialogue can be a source of wisdom. Only those dialogues - inquiries which are conducted or directed by the one who knows, who is thoroughly skilled in techniques of questioning, who has mastered the art of dialectic, according to Plato - the father of this method, yield fruitful results.
Authored by: Ashok Vohra
Why Arjun Was Chosen: The Untold Secret of Bhagavad Gita Chapter 4, Verse 3
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
KTET June 2025 registration begins at ktet.kerala.gov.in: Examination to be held in August, direct link to apply here
The Kerala Pareeksha Bhavan has opened the registration window for the Kerala Teacher Eligibility Test (KTET) June 2025 session. Aspiring teachers across the state can now apply online at the official website — — until July 10, 2025. The KTET is a mandatory certification for candidates aiming to teach in government and aided schools in Kerala and is conducted to assess the teaching aptitude and subject knowledge across various levels. The exam is scheduled to be held on August 23 and 24, with admit cards set to release on August 14. Candidates are advised to check their eligibility criteria, category-wise syllabus, and exam pattern before applying. KTET Schedule 2025 Check important dates for KTET 2025 session below: Event Date Registration Start July 3, 2025 Registration Deadline July 10, 2025 Admit Card Release August 14, 2025 Exam Dates August 23 & 24, 2025 KTET exam shifts 2025 KTET will be conducted in two shifts each day — 10 am to 12:30 pm and 2 pm to 4:30 pm. The examination will be held for four categories: Category I – Lower Primary classes Category II – Upper Primary classes Category III – High School Category IV – Language teachers, specialist teachers, and physical education How to apply online Candidates interested in appearing for the KTET June 2025 examination must complete the registration process through the official portal. Here's how to apply: Visit the official website – Go to Click on 'KTET June 2025 Registration' – On the homepage, select the active registration link for the June session. Fill in the application form – Enter personal, academic, and communication details accurately. Upload required documents – This includes a recent passport-size photograph and signature in the prescribed format. Pay the application fee – ₹500 for General/OBC and ₹250 for SC/ST/PwD candidates via online payment modes (credit/debit card, net banking). Final submission – Review the form, submit it, and download a copy of the application for future reference. Direct link to apply for KTET 2025 session Each paper consists of 150 multiple-choice questions to be answered in 2.5 hours. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Why seniors are rushing to get this Internet box – here's why! Techno Mag Learn More Undo The minimum qualifying mark is 60%, with a relaxation of 5% for reserved categories. What's next? After qualifying the KTET, candidates will be eligible to apply for teaching posts in government aided, and select unaided schools across Kerala. The KTET certificate remains valid for lifetime, as per the revised NCTE guidelines. Candidates are advised to stay updated via the official website and prepare thoroughly based on the category they are applying for. Is your child ready for the careers of tomorrow? Enroll now and take advantage of our early bird offer! Spaces are limited.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Japan's Megaquake: Why the next big tremor could be catastrophic
Japan is intensifying its earthquake preparedness following a sudden spike in seismic activity in the Tokara Islands, where over 900 tremors have been recorded in the past eleven days. The Japan Meteorological Agency confirmed a magnitude 5.5 earthquake on Wednesday. Though it caused no major damage, the sheer frequency of tremors has heightened public anxiety and renewed fears of a larger disaster. At the center of national concern is the Nankai Trough, an 800-kilometer fault off Japan's southeastern coast where two tectonic plates converge. Historically, this region produces massive earthquakes every 100 to 200 years. The last major rupture occurred in 1946. According to government experts, there is now a 75 to 82 percent chance that a magnitude 8 or higher earthquake will strike this area within the next 30 years. Such an event would likely trigger a tsunami and cause widespread destruction. New damage projections reveal scale of risk In March, the Japanese government released updated projections based on current topographical and structural data. In a worst-case scenario, an earthquake in the Nankai Trough could kill up to 298,000 people and completely destroy 2.35 million buildings. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Đăng ký Undo These figures slightly revise earlier projections made in 2014, which estimated 332,000 deaths and 2.5 million buildings lost. Despite the updated numbers being somewhat lower, the scale of risk remains among the highest ever recorded for a potential natural disaster. Original safety goals not met Following the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami, which caused around 18,000 deaths and led to the Fukushima nuclear disaster, Japan introduced a national disaster prevention plan focused on the Nankai threat. That plan, created in 2014, aimed to reduce potential deaths by 80 percent and cut building destruction by 50 percent within ten years. Those targets were not met by the 2024 deadline. Nevertheless, government officials say they are keeping the same targets in place, calling them aspirational goals that reflect the seriousness of the threat. In response to both the updated damage estimates and the recent surge in tremors, the central government is accelerating key measures. These include expanding emergency evacuation shelters and reinforcing coastal sea walls in areas likely to be hit by tsunamis. During a recent cabinet meeting, Prime Minister Fumio Kishida emphasized the need for coordination between government agencies, local authorities, private companies, and non-profit organizations to ensure maximum protection of life and property. Public anxiety fuelled by culture and speculation Social media discussions and references in popular culture have added to the rising sense of concern. A well-known manga has gained attention for predicting a major disaster on July 5, 2025. While the storyline is fictional and not backed by scientific evidence, the date has gone viral and is contributing to the current mood of unease, particularly in areas like the Tokara Islands that continue to experience repeated tremors. Japan experiences around 1,500 earthquakes every year, but the threat posed by the Nankai Trough is serious due to its potential for destruction. Thus the authorities in Japan are taking the threat seriously and increasing their level of disaster preparedness.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Birds that depend on clean waterbodies and wetlands are at risk: PAU expert
Ludhiana: As International Plastic Bag Free Day is observed on July 3, rising use of plastics, including plastic bags, are posing an unprecedented threat to bird population. Ornithologists and conservationists are sounding urgent alarms about the growing menace of plastic pollution — that is choking habitats, contaminating food chains, and pushing several bird species to the brink of collapse. Plastic has turned into a long-lasting hazard in natural ecosystems. Each year, over 400 million tonnes of plastic are produced globally, and a staggering amount finds its way into the open environment. In India, this translates into clogged village ponds, polluted rivers, and shrinking wetlands, all vital habitats for birdlife. "Plastic pollution is now a leading factor contributing to bird population decline across India," Dr Tejdeep Kaur Kler, principal ornithologist and head of the zoology department at Punjab Agricultural University (PAU), Ludhiana. "Carnivorous and insectivorous birds that depend on clean water bodies and wetlands are especially at risk." Village ponds, traditionally key sources of drinking water and biodiversity, in most villages have become open dumping grounds for domestic waste, especially plastic wrappers, single-use bags, and packaging material. "Even if this waste is thrown far from water bodies, the rains wash it into ponds, which generally are in low lying areas. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Đăng ký Undo The result is suffocating layers of plastic waste around aquatic ecosystems right where many birds feed and nest," explains Dr Kler. Plastic impacts birds in multiple deadly ways. Many mistake colorful plastic fragments for food bottle caps resemble eggs or snails, shredded bags look like worms or jellyfish. Ingested plastics fill the gut and block the digestive system, causing starvation and death. Parents also feed these items to their chicks unknowingly, mistaking them for prey. Recent field reports from Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh, and Assam reveal deaths of kingfishers, herons, and egrets with plastics inside their stomachs, she stated. Species such as vultures, eagles, and the Ruddy Shelduck, crans, and many more species of birds that rely heavily on clean aquatic habitats and a balanced food chain are facing alarming declines. "Hundreds of species are witnessing population drops. The Ruddy Shelduck has declined sharply. So have scavenging raptors and fish-eating birds," notes Dr Kler, citing a 2023 national study which identified 178 of 942 recorded bird species in India as needing immediate conservation attention. Another 323 species were classified under moderate conservation concern. The plastic threat extends beyond ingestion. Birds often become entangled in plastic ropes, packaging bands, and kite strings, leading to injuries, restricted movement, and death. Urban species such as kites and pigeons are increasingly seen with deformed limbs or wings due to plastic threads, especially during kite flying festivals. 'Bird nests no longer safe' Even bird nests are no longer safe. Many urban birds now incorporate synthetic fibers and plastic strips into their nests, which leach toxins, retain excess heat, and entangle chicks before they can fledge. Insects, fish, and other prey consumed by birds are themselves contaminated with microplastics tiny fragments that carry hazardous chemicals like DDT and PCBs, known to disrupt hormones and immunity. A 2022 study by the Indian Institute of Science even detected microplastics in crow feces in Bengaluru, indicating how deep and invisible the plastic infiltration runs, she said. Wetlands and marshes, which host a wide range of migratory and resident birds, are particularly vulnerable. Plastic clogs aquatic vegetation, reduces fish nurseries, and alters the food web. In places like Chilika Lake in Odisha and East Kolkata Wetlands, scientists have linked falling bird counts to plastic contamination in water bodies, she stated. 'Weak enforcement of plastic ban' Despite bans on single-use plastics at the national level in 2022 and earlier initiatives like Punjab's 2016 prohibition on plastic bags, enforcement remains weak. Informal dumping continues unabated, and waste collection and segregation mechanisms are often inadequate or non-functional in rural and peri-urban areas. "Birds are indicators of environmental health. When they disappear, it is not just their loss it is a warning to humanity. If plastic continues to poison our rivers, ponds, and skies, the silence of the birds will soon echo our own ecological failure," she stated.
