Julian Smith says David Cameron was 'cavalier' in handling of Brexit
'Some sort of Eton game'
"I joined the Conservative Party because of David Cameron, because he was dynamic... but looking back on it, it was unforgiveable that this fundamental question was put to the British people when you have a whole range of issues, not least the border between Northern Ireland and Ireland," he told the BBC's Red Lines podcast."It was put to the British people as if it was some sort of Eton game."
Brexit referendum in 2016
Lord Cameron is among a number of former British politicians who were educated privately at Eton College in Berkshire.After a majority voted to leave the EU, Lord Cameron resigned as prime minister.Speaking in 2016, after leaving office, he defended his decision to call the referendum. "I believe and still believe that the fact that we hadn't had a referendum on this issue for 40 years, despite the fact that the European Union was changing ... was actually beginning to poison British politics - it was certainly poisoning politics in my own party. "And I think, more broadly, people felt 'well, we have been promised referendums and they haven't been delivered' and people were beginning to feel very frustrated about this issue."
When Lord Cameron quit as prime minister others in the Conservative Party were left to handle the Brexit process.Smith was part of that government under Theresa May, which struggled to get agreement on how it should be done.
'Pretty disastrous'
The former cabinet minister said issues such as how to maintain an open border between Northern Ireland, which is part of the UK and therefore would leave the EU, and the Republic of Ireland, which remains in the EU, should have been foreseen during the campaign."Instead the UK was led into years of contemplating an answer to that question."As time went on moderates turned into purists on either side, it was a pretty disastrous period."
After Theresa May resigned as prime minister due to an inability to pass Brexit legislation, Boris Johnson took over and appointed Smith as Northern Ireland Secretary in July 2019.Smith was a key player in getting devolution at Stormont restored the following January, after three years of deadlock, but he was sacked from the job a month later due to disagreements with Johnson.Smith said he "loved" the job, but was not surprised to lose it given he had been an ardent supporter of Theresa May.He remained an observer of Northern Ireland issues after moving to the Commons' backbenches, and called on the Stormont Executive to take "tough decisions" on public services.
Border poll
Asked about the potential for a border poll, Smith said he did not think the conditions were "right" for one."Look at all the other things that need to be done."Don't let politicians in Northern Ireland off the hook on dealing with social mobility, dealing with the health service, revenue raising - this constitutional discussion is basically an excuse for not dealing with these priority issues," he added."I cannot in any world see a border poll with interest from Ireland, acceptance from the UK... I just don't see that happening at the current time so we're better focusing on making people's lives better."You can listen to Smith's interview on Red Lines on BBC Sounds from 06:00 BST.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
Canada to recognize Palestinian State in September, PM says
Canada will recognize a Palestinian state in September, Prime Minister Mark Carney has announced. Carney made the announcement on Wednesday, following France and the UK in a shift towards a broader global shift against Israel's policies in Gaza. 'The level of human suffering in Gaza is intolerable,' Carney said.
The Guardian
42 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘At 80, to be treated like a terrorist is shocking': arrested on suspicion of supporting Palestine Action
Palestine Action's co-founder has won a bid to bring a high court challenge over the group's ban as a terrorist organisation, which has made membership of or support for the direct action group a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison. About 200 people have been arrested on suspicion of publicly protesting in support for PA since it was banned. They include: Retired teacher Farley was picked up by police at a silent demonstration in Leeds for holding a sign that made a joke about the government's proscription of Palestine Action taken from an issue of the fortnightly satirical magazine Private Eye. He was arrested under section 12 of the Terrorism Act 2000, which he described as a 'pretty terrifying and upsetting experience'. Farley, who had never been arrested before, told the Guardian: 'I clearly wasn't any kind of physical threat.' The Private Eye editor, Ian Hislop, said the arrest was 'mind-boggling'. Retired teacher Sorrell, from Wells, Somerset, was arrested for holding a placard at a pro-Palestine rally in Cardiff, and she was held by police for almost 27 hours, during which officers forced their way into her house and searched it. She said officers removed 19 items from her home, including iPads, a Palestinian flag, books on Palestine, material related to Extinction Rebellion and the climate crisis, as well as drumsticks for – and a belt that holds – her samba drum. 'At 80, to be treated like a dangerous terrorist is deeply shocking. I've been very traumatised by this. Every morning I wake up feeling sick, nauseous. [I have] had to take anti-sickness pills,' she told the Guardian. Retired teacher Also from Wells and a friend of Sorrell, Fine was held for the same period of time. The women have been bailed until October. Their bail conditions prohibit contact with each other and spending any nights away from their homes. She said that during her detention officers refused to let her have the antibiotics she was taking for a serious gum infection, and failed to call her husband, who is recovering from cancer treatment, to tell him about her arrest, despite having agreed to do so. Retired priest Parfitt, from Henbury in Bristol, was arrested on the same day the group was outlawed. She was attending a demonstration in Parliament Square in London. She was sitting in a camp chair surrounded by other protesters, holding a placard stating her support for Palestine Action. As she was led away by police, she called the ban 'total nonsense' and said it symbolised a 'loss of civil liberties in this country', according to the BBC. Hinton is a retired magistrate; Baines is a former charity director Hinton and Baines were among eight people arrested by Devon and Cornwall officers at a peaceful demonstration. 'She's a pillar of the community, so it's a very brave thing for her to have done,' Baines said of Hinton. 'Part of why we were protesting is that this mission creep of laws against protests is really frightening people. This is about freedom of speech,' he told Cornwall Live. He added: 'We're not advocating for Palestine Action. We're resisting the proscription of Palestine Action. We're resisting the politicised use of terror laws to suppress a non-violent campaign of sabotage. We're resisting the criminalisation of peaceful protest because it's already being used to intimidate and threaten people just for having Palestine flags.'
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Authoritarian states operating without impunity to silence dissidents in UK, report finds
Authoritarian states are operating without impunity in attempts to silence dissidents on UK soil - and the government needs to take urgent action, parliamentarians have warned. Transnational repression has increased in recent years, with foreign states using online harassment, lawsuits, surveillance and physical violence to intimidate people in the UK, a report published on Wednesday by the Joint Committee on Human Rights said. There has been a 48% increase in MI5 investigations into threats from other states in the UK since 2022, the report said. Chairman Lord David Alton warned the rise in threats was "going unchecked" in the UK and said the government "lacks a clear strategy" to address transnational repression (TNR). He said: "This risks undermining the UK's ability to protect the human rights of its citizens and those who have sought safety within its borders. "We have seen prominent cases of Hong Kongers with bounties placed on their heads, Iran intimidating journalists - but evidence submitted to the inquiry suggests this may be the tip of the iceberg." Amnesty International called the report "damning" and said it shows the UK has become a "hunting ground" for authoritarian regimes. The committee called on the government to adopt a formal definition of TNR, a dedicated reporting mechanism for victims, data collection, specialised police training and to work with "like-minded states" to coordinate international action against authoritarian regimes using TNR. The cross-party committee said the government is not doing enough to help victims and should develop a "proactive outreach strategy" aimed at individuals and communities at risk of TNR within 12 months. It said strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs) - aimed at exhausting a defendant financially and psychologically - are increasingly being used to "intimidate and silence" people, especially journalists, who expose or criticise authoritarian regimes. The MPs and Lords called on the government to expand protections for defendants in SLAPP cases where it is used as a TNR tool, as there is currently only protection if it is an economic crime. 1:55 Dozen countries carrying out TNR They said China, Iran and Russia were the "most flagrant" perpetrators of TNR, but they also heard evidence from people being targeted by Bahrain, Egypt, India, Pakistan, Rwanda, Saudi Arabia, Turkey and the United Arab Emirates. The committee also received "substantial" evidence of TNR carried out by the Eritrean government, including being forced to pay a 2% "diaspora tax" and those who refuse "are considered government opponents and face harassment, intimidation and ultimately social isolation", the UN Special Rapporteur on Eritrea told the committee. Interpol red notices The committee criticised Interpol "red notices" - international requests for arrest - saying they were being used to harass dissidents and said Interpol has refused to acknowledge there is a problem. Nearly half of the 6,550 current public red notices have been issued at Russia's request "to intimidate and silence journalists, activists, and other critics", the report said. Lord Alton, who is sanctioned by China, said the UK government needs to press Interpol for action on abuse of red notices and introduce a mechanism to alert people they are subject to a red notice, if there is a strong basis to believe it is politically motivated. China and Hong Kong While Iran and Russia are more obvious with their tactics, the committee said China uses a "broad range", including surveillance, online harassment, and threats to family members abroad. It highlighted the Hong Kong government placing bounties on several democracy protesters who have fled to the UK, naming 20-year-old Chloe Cheung. She gave evidence, telling them it has affected her "mentally, emotionally and physically in profound ways that I never expected" and she now carries lots of self-protection devices and her first thought about people who suddenly want to make friends or approach her is they must work for the Chinese government. Ms Cheung, now an advocacy manager for the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation, said it is "important the UK government doesn't just acknowledge this report, but actually acts on it" to help protect dissidents like her. Concern was also raised about unofficial Chinese "police stations" in the UK, used to monitor and pressure the Chinese diaspora, and the proposed Chinese "super embassy", with fears it could serve as a spy base. The committee repeated calls made by MPs last month for China to be placed in the highest tier of the foreign influence registration (FIRS) scheme, saying its omission risked "undermining the credibility and coherence" of the scheme. Russia The report said Russia has engaged in the "most serious forms" of TNR, including direct threat to life - and highlighted the Salisbury nerve agent attack as creating a "chilling effect" among Kremlin critics. Iran Iran represents "one of the highest kidnap and assassination state threats to the UK", with tactics including physical attacks, smear campaigns, hacking, assassination plots, and "cultural centres" as surveillance fronts, the report said. Kerry Moscogiuri, campaign director at Amnesty International, said the government needs to "now act on these recommendations, not just in principle, but in practice". An Interpol spokesperson said: "Every year, thousands of the world's most serious criminals are arrested thanks to Interpol's systems. "Children are saved from sexual exploitation and terrorists, cyber criminals and traffickers are brought to justice. "Interpol knows red notices are powerful tools for law enforcement co-operation, which is why we have robust processes for ensuring that all Interpol notices and diffusions comply with our rules. "Our constitution forbids Interpol from undertaking activities of a political, military, religious or racial character and all our databases and activities must also comply with the universal declaration for human rights." A Home Office spokesperson said: "We take the threat of transnational repression extremely seriously. "Any attempts by a foreign state to coerce, intimidate, harass, or harm individuals on UK soil are considered a threat to our national security and sovereignty, and will not be tolerated. "The committee's review echoes many of the same findings and recommendations from the Defending Democracy Taskforce report on TNR, published in May, and we are already taking action arising from those recommendations to further strengthen our response."
