logo
Trump's big, beautiful Bill means massive, ugly tax cuts for American aristocrats

Trump's big, beautiful Bill means massive, ugly tax cuts for American aristocrats

Irish Times5 days ago
On July 4th, in a mockery of the best American democratic traditions, Donald Trump signed into law his signature piece of domestic legislation. His so-called 'big, beautiful Bill' offers massive tax cuts, mostly to the benefit of the very rich: today's American aristocrats.
Yet, while it might be good news for the luxury yacht industry, it will leave an estimated 12 million without health insurance through cuts to the Medicaid programme. Trump's ability to pass such ugly legislation through a tightly divided Congress reflects his political power, and yet it could well lead to his undoing in the 2026 mid-term elections.
The more the Republican Party changes, the more it stays the same. For all the talk about the party appealing to the working class, it remains fundamentally committed to a regressive agenda that puts the interests of the very rich above those of ordinary Americans and future generations.
This legislation is ripped straight from the playbook of Ronald Reagan. Reagan reduced the tax rate on the highest earners from 70 per cent to 28 per cent, inaugurating a new era of massive upward redistribution of wealth. He did so by slashing programmes benefiting the poorest Americans: child nutrition, housing assistance and payments to single mothers.
READ MORE
Trump's Bill also resembles Reagan's agenda in another respect: it is as irresponsible as it is cruel. The most expensive social welfare programmes in the US – social security (old age pensions) and Medicare (health insurance for those over the age of 65) – are too popular to cut.
Trump, like Reagan has also increased the budget for the major area of American spending: the military. Reagan justified his cuts with the fantasy of supply-side economics, claiming that slashing taxes would generate so much economic growth that it would actually result in increased government revenue. Republicans today justify their irresponsible spending with the accounting trick that, because they only extended tax cuts due to expire, they aren't really adding to the deficit.
When Reagan left office, the federal debt had tripled. Trump's Bill is set to increase the federal deficit by more than $3 trillion.
Trump's Bill was not much loved by many of the Republicans who voted for it. Deficit hawks worried about adding to the national debt; they like the tax cuts, but would have preferred more social spending cuts to finance them. Elon Musk's criticism of the Bill on these grounds led to his public falling out with Trump.
Moderate Republicans, meanwhile, worried that cuts to Medicaid would hurt the party's chances in 2026. Thom Tillis,
one of only three Republican Senators to vote against the bill
, wondered how he could face his voters 'when President Trump breaks his promise by pushing them off of Medicaid because the funding's not there anymore'.
Trump's ability to pass such legislation reflected his considerable political muscle. He could only afford to lose three out of 53 Republican votes in the Senate (he lost three, with vice-president Vance breaking a 50-50 tie) and, even more challenging, only three of 219 Republican votes in the House of Representatives (he lost only two).
Trump held his party together by threatening Republicans who voted against the Bill that he would support primary challengers against them. For decades, the Republican Party has been distorted by the fact that most of its politicians are elected from heavily Republican districts or states. As a result, the threat to their re-election lies in primary challenges from the right rather than in winning the general election against a Democrat.
Yet Trump was able to exploit this fact like no previous leader. His personal hold on the party means that his endorsement of a primary candidate all but ensures their success.
Yet the thing about being at the pinnacle of your power is that everything is downhill from there. The passage of Trump's beautiful Bill may well lead to an ugly Republican defeat at the polls in 2026. Polling shows that only 29 per cent of Americans support it.
It seems likely that Republicans will lose their slim majority in the House of Representatives. But it also seems possible that Democrats might re-take the Senate, even though they face a very challenging map there.
Tillis, after voting against Trump's bill, announced that he would not seek re-election rather than face a primary challenge. The forced retirement of a popular incumbent increases the chances that Democrats can win his vacated seat in North Carolina.
This bill is so extreme and irresponsible that it will enable Democrats to win back moderate voters in contested electoral districts. But perhaps more importantly it will enable them to make the case that Bernie Sanders and others have been pushing: that whatever they say, the Republicans are the party of the billionaires, and the Democrats can be the party of working Americans.
Still, the massive federal deficit the Bill creates has planted a ticking time bomb for Democrats. If, and when, they do regain control of the federal government, they will be hampered in pursuing an ambitious agenda because they will be forced first to clean up the Republicans' mess. That, too, is part of a pattern in American politics evident since the Reagan era.
How can Republicans retain popularity when their agenda so clearly favours the few at the expense of the many?
As they have done since Reagan, they will double down on culture war politics to distract from their economic agenda. Expect to see ramped up assaults on trans rights and racialised attacks on migrants. Republicans will promote misinformation so that Americans don't realise what they're really doing.
And, finally, if push comes to shove, Trump may employ authoritarian measures to retain his hold on power. Even so, the biggest legacy of Trump's big, beautiful Bill might be that it shatters Republicans' credibility as the party of working Americans.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump says EU to face a 30% tariff from 1 August
Donald Trump says EU to face a 30% tariff from 1 August

The Journal

time42 minutes ago

  • The Journal

Donald Trump says EU to face a 30% tariff from 1 August

LAST UPDATE | 19 mins ago US PRESIDENT DONALD Trump has threatened to impose a 30% tariff on the European Union and Mexico, ramping up pressure for deals in his trade wars. Both sets of duties would take effect 1 August, Trump said in separate letters posted to his Truth Social platform, citing Mexico's role in illicit drugs flowing into the United States and a trade imbalance with the EU respectively. In a letter addressed to President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen, Trump wrote that the US-EU trade relationship has been 'far from reciprocal' resulting in his decision to impose the 30% tariff from the beginning of next month. He said that if the EU were to retaliate and raise its own tariffs on US goods, the US would add the retaliatory amount to the 30%. Advertisement 'Please understand that these Tariffs are necessary to correct the many years of European Union Tariffs, and Non-Tariff, policies and Trade Barriers, which cause the large and unsustainable Trade deficits against the United States,' he wrote. 'The Deficit is a major threat to our Economy and, indeed, our National Security!' The EU tariff is markedly steeper than the 20% levy Trump unveiled in April, as negotiations with the bloc continue. The EU, alongside dozens of other economies, had been set to see its US tariff level increase from a baseline of 10% on Wednesday, but Trump pushed back the deadline to 1 August just days before the elevated rates were due to take effect. Since the start of the week, Trump has sent out letters to more than 20 countries with updated tariffs for each. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Trump announces 30% tariffs on the EU and Mexico to start in WEEKS crushing hopes of trade deal
Trump announces 30% tariffs on the EU and Mexico to start in WEEKS crushing hopes of trade deal

The Irish Sun

time2 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

Trump announces 30% tariffs on the EU and Mexico to start in WEEKS crushing hopes of trade deal

DONALD Trump has announced the EU and Mexico are set to face a whopping 30 per cent tariffs on imports to the US starting from August. Trump announced the tariffs on two of the US's biggest trading partners in letters posted to his social media account. 2 US President Donald Trump speaks to the press before boarding Marine One Credit: AFP 2 Tariffs are levies paid on bringing a good or service into a country Credit: Getty And he threatened to impose even higher import taxes if either of the US trading partners decided to retaliate. In his letter to the EU, Trump said that the US trade deficit was a national security threat. "We have had years to discuss our Trading Relationship with The European Union, and we have concluded we must move away from these long-term, large, and persistent Trade Deficits, engendered by your Tariff, and Non-Tariff Policies, and Trade Barriers, Trump wrote in the letter to the EU. "Our relationship has been, unfortunately, far from Reciprocal." EU chief Ursula Von Der Leyen hit out Saturday at new tariffs threatened by US President Donald Trump, but said the EU still wanted to work for a trade deal with Washington. "Imposing 30 percent tariffs on EU exports would disrupt essential transatlantic supply chains, to the detriment of businesses, consumers and patients on both sides of the Atlantic," von der Leyen said in a statement. "We remain ready to continue working towards an agreement by August 1. "At the same time, we will take all necessary steps to safeguard EU interests, including the adoption of proportionate countermeasures if required." Most read in The US Sun Meanwhile, fresh duties for Mexico announced by Trump would be higher than the 25 per cent levy he imposed on Mexican goods earlier this year. Although products entering the United States under the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) are exempted. In his letter to Mexico's leader, Trump acknowledged that the country has helped stem the flow of undocumented migrants and fentanyl into the United States. But he said the country has not done enough to stop North America from turning into a Narco-Trafficking Playground. He wrote: "Mexico has been helping me secure the border, BUT, what Mexico has done, is not enough. "Starting August 1, 2025, we will charge Mexico a Tariff of 30% on Mexican products sent into the United States." Since returning to the presidency in January, Trump has unleashed sweeping tariffs on allies and competitors alike, roiling financial markets and raising fears of a global economic downturn. But his administration is coming under pressure to secure deals with trading partners after promising a flurry of agreements. So far, US officials have only unveiled two pacts, with Britain and Vietnam, alongside temporarily lower tit-for-tat duties with China. Meanwhile, three EU officials told Reuters that the tariff announcement on EU goods was rather a negotiating tactic by Trump. Canada had earlier received a similar letter setting out 35 per cent tariffs on its goods. A US official earlier told AFP that the USMCA exemption was similarly expected to remain for Canada. The EU tariff is also markedly steeper than the 20 per cent levy Trump unveiled in April, as negotiations with the bloc continue. Read more on the Irish Sun More to follow... For the latest news on this story, keep checking back at The U.S. Sun, your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, sports news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures, and must-see videos . Like us on Facebook at

US President Donald Trump announces 30 per cent tariffs on imports from EU starting in weeks
US President Donald Trump announces 30 per cent tariffs on imports from EU starting in weeks

The Irish Sun

time2 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

US President Donald Trump announces 30 per cent tariffs on imports from EU starting in weeks

DONALD Trump has imposed a 30 per cent tariff on imports from Mexico and the European Union - and it's due to come into effect NEXT MONTH. The shock decision comes after weeks of negotiations with the prime trading allies failed to reach a more comprehensive trade agreement with the United States of America President Advertisement The fresh tariffs were announced in separate letters on his Truth Social platform, revealing that the tariffs will come into effect on August 1. The EU tariff is also reported to be significantly higher than the 20 per cent that Donald Trump announced in April, while negotiations with the bloc are still ongoing. 1 US President Donald Trump has announced new tariffs on imports from the EU Credit: Getty Images - Getty

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store