Bombay HC allows 31-yr-old woman to terminate her 25-week pregnancy
Observing that the petitioner was 'left in lurch by her own circumstances as well as refusal of her partner to offer support or assistance to her in any manner, despite being an active participant in bringing about the present situation', the court said the petitioner was 'naturally apprehensive about social stigma and facing her own parents, who may not be supportive in the circumstances'.
The HC also asked her ex-partner to give Rs 1 lakh to the petitioner for her medical expenses in addition to legal expenses and accompany her to the hospital, if she so desired and remain with her during the procedure.
A division bench of Justices Revati Mohite-Dere and Neela K Gokhale on June 19 passed an order on the plea by the woman unwilling to continue with the pregnancy.
The petitioner woman had submitted that she was in a consensual relationship with her partner and the pregnancy occurred due to failure of a contraceptive device. She also submitted that she was no longer in the said relationship.
On June 13, the HC had directed the medical board of state-run JJ Hospital to examine the petitioner. The expert who conducted her psychiatric evaluation found that the petitioner had a history of sadness and stress due to financial constraints and inter-personal conflicts along with a history of alcohol consumption and smoking. The Board unanimously found her fit to undergo the procedure under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act.
The petitioner, through advocate Nikita Raje, sought termination of her pregnancy and argued that she has no financial or emotional support to carry the pregnancy to its full term. The continuation of the same would hamper her mental health due to anguish of her situation, Raje added.
The petitioner also informed the court that she had quit her job a few months ago and today, instead of looking for a new job, she was required to run from pillar to post to consult doctors to terminate her pregnancy.
The HC noted that as per the report, the petitioner has a history of illness and her parents/family was not aware of the pregnancy. As per petitioner, if her parents learn about the same, they would not accept it, 'leaving her in a complete lurch to fend for herself'.
After interacting with the petitioner in the chamber, the judges noted that she appeared to be 'extremely disturbed, having to face these challenges'.
The bench noted that petitioner had made 'conscious decision to terminate pregnancy' and the judges ascertained that she made the 'choice of her own free will'.
The HC considered past Supreme Court verdicts, petitioner's right to reproductive freedom and bodily autonomy, findings of the medical board related to her psychological condition.
'We are satisfied that continuance of the pregnancy shall adversely affect the already disturbed psychological condition of the petitioner. Hence, in the peculiar facts of this case, we permit the petitioner to medically terminate the pregnancy,' the court held and allowed the woman's plea.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Work on Jeypore economic corridor to start soon: CM Majhi
BHUBANESWAR/ JEYPORE: Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi on Sunday announced that construction of the six-lane Bhubaneswar-Berhampur-Jeypore economic corridor will be started soon. On the second day of his visit to Koraput district, Majhi also inaugurated the 650-bed hospital at Saheed Laxman Naik Medical College built at a cost of Rs 280 crore. Addressing a function on the occasion, the chief minister said the economic corridor will play a vital role in all-round development of Koraput district by boosting connectivity to different parts of the state. The expansion of the hospital of the medical college will be a boon for the people of the district and neighbouring region as they will no longer have to travel to other cities for availing quality treatment and health services. The new hospital will benefit the people of Koraput, Malkangiri, Nabarangpur, Rayagada and also the neighbouring areas of Andhra Pradesh and Chhattisgarh, he said. Announcing that all vacancies in medical and allied posts at the SLN MCH will be filled up soon, Majhi said a cancer hospital is also being built on an area of two acre adjacent to the hospital at a cost Rs 41.15 crore. Emphasising focus of his government to provide best of healthcare in every district, the CM said there are 12 government medical colleges in the state at present and four more are coming up in Dhenkanal, Jagatsinghpur, Bhadrak and Nabarangpur districts. He also said the implementation of Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PM-JAY) has greatly benefitted the people of the state with more than 3.46 crore covered under the scheme along with Gopabandhu Jan Arogya Yojana (GJAY). The government has already released Rs 900 crore in lieu of cashless treatment provided to the people in best of hospitals, he said. Under the Ayushman Vay Vandana Yojana, 8,644 senior citizens aged above 70 have received free treatment worth Rs 35.60 crore. In Koraput district alone, over three lakh AB-PMJAY and GJAY cards have been distributed, with 9,006 people enrolled under the senior citizens' scheme, he added. The chief minister said four private hospitals in Koraput district are empanelled under the ABPMJAY-GJAY, enabling local access to cashless treatment. Health and Family Welfare minister Mukesh Mahaling was present among others.
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Raighar nursing student's death: BJD to observe bandh today
UMERKOTE/BHUBANESWAR: The BJD has called a 12-hour bandh in Raighar block of Nabarangpur district on Monday in protest against the death of the 21-year-old nursing student at AIIMS-Bhubaneswar. The woman had allegedly consumed poison on July 17 following circulation of her private photos by a youth, who is said to have been in a one-sided love with her. She died during treatment at AIIMS-BBS on Saturday. Addressing the media on Sunday, BJD general secretary and former Nabarangpur MP Pradeep Majhi remarked that the BJP government has failed to protect women in the state. He further sought resignation of deputy chief minister-cum-Women and Child Development minister Pravati Parida in this connection, and compensation of Rs 1 crore for the deceased's family. Media coordinator Priyabrata Majhi said the residents of Raighar block in Nabarangpur district have been requested to extend full support to the hartal. Government and private institutions, shops, markets, transport, schools and colleges have been requested to support the bandh. He, however, added that emergency services will not be disrupted during the strike. The woman's body is expected to reach her native village Dumurimunda by midnight. Raighar IIC Raghunath Majhi said, 'Police are on alert for maintenance of law and order. Patrolling has been tightened and more police forces will be deployed in sensitive areas.'
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
SC refuses to reverse Bombay HC ban on pigeon feeding
The Supreme Court on Friday refused to interfere with the Bombay High Court's orders directing the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to prosecute those feeding pigeons at Mumbai's 'kabutarkhanas' – pigeon feeding spots, in defiance of civic directives. The Bombay High Court had initially stayed the demolition but barred feeding. (PTI file photo) A bench of justices JK Maheshwari and Vijay Bishnoi noted that proceedings in the matter remain pending before the Bombay High Court, which is expected to take up the case again on August 13. 'Parallel indulgence by this Court is not proper. Petitioner can move the High Court for modification of the order,' said the bench, refusing to interfere. The Bombay High Court, hearing multiple petitions by animal lovers and rights activists challenging the BMC's demolition of decades-old kabutarkhanas, had initially stayed the demolition but barred feeding. On July 30, after noting continued feeding and obstruction of civic officials, the high court ordered criminal cases under relevant provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), calling the acts a 'public nuisance likely to spread diseases and endanger human life.' Also Read: HC directs formation of 'expert committee 'to address pigeon feeding dispute in Pune Earlier, on July 24, the high court had warned that pigeon breeding and large congregations at kabutarkhanas posed a 'grave social concern', stressing the decision was in the 'larger interest of societal health, from children to senior citizens.' In court, BMC presented medical evidence that pigeon droppings and feathers can trigger asthma, hypersensitivity, pneumonitis, and lung fibrosis -- conditions with no cure once advanced. The civic body argued that many victims realise the damage only after irreversible harm to the lungs. Petitioners in the Supreme Court, including Pallavi Sachin Patil, argued that pigeon feeding is a long-standing religious practice, particularly among Hindu devotees and the Jain community, with some 51 feeding spots in Mumbai operating for decades. They claimed health concerns were overstated and that asthma was more directly linked to pollution from vehicles and open burning. They proposed alternatives such as bird towers to allow human-pigeon coexistence. The crackdown has sparked street protests. On August 6, hundreds clashed with police at Dadar 'kabutarkhana', tearing down tarpaulin sheets erected to block feeding. Two days earlier, over 1,000 community members protested after the site was barricaded with bamboo poles and covered.
