Cannes 25 : Jafar Panahi's "It Was Just an Accident" – A Darkly Humorous Triumph of Resistance
A Haunting Tale
The narrative follows a former political prisoner who, upon a chance encounter with a man, becomes convinced he's face-to-face with his past torturer. A seemingly ordinary moment—a simple incident—jolts his memory. He hears a voice and is suddenly transported back to the interrogation room. Could this man in front of him be the one who tortured him? He can't be certain—his eyes were always blindfolded during those harrowing sessions.
Darkness with Humour
From there, director Jafar Panahi leads us into a haunting yet deeply engaging detective story. The protagonist seeks out fellow survivors, hoping to piece together the truth. What follows is a journey of collective memory, trauma, and camaraderie, where each character contributes a piece of the puzzle—and reveals their own scars.
Panahi's genius lies in his ability to infuse dark subject matter with moments of humour. In scenes that could easily become unbearably heavy, the filmmaker dares to insert levity—not for cheap relief, but as a testament to the survivors' resilience. The audience laughs not because the pain is lessened, but because it is deeply human to seek light in the darkest of places.
The film's epic climax—a confrontation between the survivors and the suspected torturer—is masterfully executed. The tension is suffocating, the emotions raw. You feel everything: rage, confusion, fear, even a glimmer of compassion. It's a scene where emotions run high and the lines between victim and perpetrator blur. The audience, much like the characters, is left questioning the nature of justice and the reliability of memory. In a masterstroke, Panahi reveals how easily perceptions can be manipulated, leaving viewers both shocked and contemplative.
Lens Through Memory
Visually, "It Was Just an Accident" is a triumph. The director uses the camera like a memory—often uncertain, jittery, sometimes fading in and out of clarity. Tight close-ups force us into the characters' emotional spaces, while stark lighting and muted palettes reflect the trauma that never truly leaves them. The cinematography turns small moments—a flicker of recognition, a trembling hand—into profound beats of storytelling.
"It Was Just an Accident" is more than just a film; it's a testament to the power of storytelling in challenging oppressive systems. Panahi's ability to weave a tale that's both harrowing and humorous showcases his mastery as a filmmaker.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
The Crunch: how desperate Palestinians are struggling to find food and aid in Gaza
Hello and welcome to another edition of The Crunch! More Palestinians died of starvation in the past week than in the preceding 21 months, prompting widespread condemnation of Israel's actions. As a result, much of the media's focus has been on the desperate suffering of the Palestinians. So we are doing something slightly different in this newsletter: a spotlight on data-visualisation about how people in Gaza are being killed and injured while seeking aid. There's also a collection of other things that caught our eye this fortnight towards the end of the newsletter. The four aid distribution sites across Gaza run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) are only open for a few minutes a day – the Saudi site was open for an average of 11 minutes in June. Our colleagues in the UK put together this visual explainer on 'how aid points in Gaza became death traps'. This chart shows the time between aid sites opening and closing through June and July: Palestinians in Gaza have to queue and walk kilometres – through evacuation zones that civilians have been told to leave – to reach aid sites. The piece also includes maps if, like us, you are having trouble getting your head around this geography. 2. Average daily calories in Gaza Our colleague Mona Chalabi also posted this devastating graphic on Instagram comparing the average calories consumed by someone in Gaza in May, to the daily recommended amount: We've often featured Mona's spectacular work, including this one on Gaza's population as 100 people, and the population density of bombed cities. 3. Aid sites and access routes The Economist also covered the GHF aid sites ($), with a series of excellent maps and satellite images showing the long walks and the huge crowds forming at checkpoints. Among other things, this really drives home the distances that families are forced to travel to get aid. 4. Huge crowds for aid convoy Sign up to The Crunch Our data journalists showcase the most important charts and dataviz from the Guardian and around the web, free every fortnight after newsletter promotion To give more context around the scale of the desperation for aid, the New York Times reports on a satellite image of huge crowds gathering around aid trucks taken in Gaza last week: Not a lot is known about where these trucks were going or what they were carrying. The NYT has also published a map showing which countries have already recognised a Palestinian state. 5. Environmental devastation in Gaza Environmental devastation is an under-reported aspect of the destruction in Gaza. Bloomberg analysis of satellite data has found nearly 350 sites where waste has been piling up since the conflict began. This map shows Souk Feras, which was a market before the conflict began but now holds an estimated 200,000 metric tons of rubbish: The Bloomberg team estimates that new garbage sites cover more than 1 sq kilometre, about 60% of the areas are close to tents, and 15% are near water, sanitation or other 'hygiene sites'. Read (and see) more here. We published this One Big Chart on increasing student debt held by younger Australians The Pudding launched an amazing project to make signs and other text in New York City streets searchable The Australian Bureau of Statistics made a bar chart about all the other charts they've made this year We couldn't stop playing with the Mac emulators in this story about Mac settings (we're counting this as data-vis as you can actually manipulate spreadsheets in some of the emulated computers) Reuters have an illustrated explainer of the crash of Air India flight 171 If you would like to receive The Crunch to your email inbox every fortnight, sign up here.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Erin Molan Stellar magazine cover sparks furious backlash over her views about Israel's war in Gaza: 'Never reading this publication again'
A magazine cover featuring Erin Molan has sparked a ferocious backlash over the TV presenter's strong stance supporting Israel in its conflict with Gaza. This weekend's edition of Stellar, which is published in News Corp's Sunday newspapers, is being promoted on Instagram and some readers are furious that Molan appears on the front. The former Sky News Australia host has publicly condemned Hamas since its raids on the Jewish state on October 7, 2023, and in recent months has been reporting from Israel on the Middle East war. While some fans - including model and influencer Bec Judd - were quick to congratulate Molan on taking out the cover position, others could not see past her pro-Israel views. 'No thanks Stella... No one I would support,' wrote one. 'So tone deaf,' said another. A third posted: 'Free Palestine ps never reading this publication again.' Several other users threatened to boycott Stellar. Some of the comments are too inflammatory to publish. The Times of Israel ran a profile piece on Molan in May under the headline 'Erin Molan vs. the world: From Australian news anchor to pro-Israel firebrand.' 'Molan has found herself increasingly recognized in Israel, where people on the street often flock to her, eager to thank her for her support,' it reported. The story quoted Molan, who is Catholic, describing her reaction to the October 7 outrages. 'It was never complex to me or grey or fuzzy,' she said. 'It was black and white as to who evil was in this scenario.' Molan has maintained that stance amid Israel's retaliation and the ongoing human crisis in Gaza. Former Sky News Australia colleague Sharri Markson moved quickly last year to quash a conspiracy theory that Molan had been sacked from the network for her pro-Israel views. In December, Markson wished Molan her well in her future pursuits and wrote on X that it was 'categorically untrue' the 41-year-old had been booted off Sky 'because of her Zionism'. in their reporting of the onetime Footy Show presenter's removal by Sky. Daily newspaper Israel Hayom referred to Molan's response to the October 7 massacre in which more than 1,200 Israelis - mostly citizens - were killed and 254 taken hostage. 'Molan has been a vocal supporter of Israel on her Sky News Australia program,' the newspaper stated. 'Strongly condemning both Hamas' actions against Israeli civilians and the pro-Hamas demonstrations that have erupted worldwide, repeatedly using her platform to address the ongoing war.' Israel National News covered the presenter's axing under the headline: 'Sky News Australia fires pro-Israel host Erin Molan.' 'Australian news anchor Erin Molan, who repeatedly defended Israel in the year since the October 7 massacre, has been fired by Sky News Australia,' its story began. Molan posted an impassioned nine-minute video to X in December, repeatedly mentioning the Middle East conflict and thanking everyone who had supported her. 'So that's done now,' she said of her Sky job. 'But I am not. In fact, I'm just getting started. 'So I'm sorry to those who had hoped otherwise. I'm somewhat surprisingly much harder to kill off than you'd think. 'You see the problem is - and it's always been this way with me - I just care too much. 'About you, about the world, about a peaceful existence for every single child.' Molan has called Hamas terrorists 'blood-thirsty killers' and said she would continue 'fighting for every single hostage still captive in Gaza'. Markson's post on X came shortly after Molan's video went live. 'I have to clear up this notion that her departure from Sky is because of her Zionism - this is categorically untrue,' she said. 'No media outlet globally has shown more leadership or clarity on Israel's fight against terrorism and our own battle against antisemitism than us at Sky News Australia and News Corp.' Although network insiders suggested Molan was caught off-guard by the decision to cancel her show, Sky insisted they had ended their partnership with the host on amicable terms. Molan presented her weekly news program, Erin, for the final time on November 29. The decision to cancel Molan's show comes just months after the breakfast radio program she co-hosted alongside comedians Dave Hughes and Ed Kavalee was scrapped by Southern Cross Austereo's struggling 2DayFM station in August. The cancellation of Molan's two key hosting roles is understood to have come at a significant financial cost to the journalist. Sources said she had been pulling in about $200,000 a year for her 2DayFM radio gig and a further $150,000 a year from her job with Sky. Molan joined Sky News Australia in July 2022 after parting ways with Nine after 11 years at the network.
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Where do France, Britain and Canada stand on a Palestinian state?
Canada has now joined France and Britain in saying it intends to recognise the state of Palestine at the United Nations general assembly in September. If a week is a long time in politics, then a month is even longer in the Middle East, and what Israel, the West Bank and Gaza will look like by then is an open question. France has decided to ignore all that, and make its recognition unconditional — at least in theory. President Macron's statement said: 'True to its historic commitment to a just and lasting peace in the Middle East, I have decided that France will recognise the state of Palestine. 'We must also guarantee the demilitarisation of Hamas, and secure and rebuild Gaza.' In other words, although he is — like most western states — demanding the disarming of Hamas and its removal as the governing force in Gaza, he would recognise Palestine anyway. He would argue that recognising Palestine in practice means recognising Hamas's rival, the Palestinian Authority, as its government, so this would not be 'rewarding Hamas'. Britain tried a different tack, in keeping with Sir Keir Starmer's constant attempts to forge a middle way between his backbenchers and his desire to keep good relations with the pro-Israel Trump administration. David Lammy, the foreign secretary, in a statement to the UN conference on the two-state solution, used similarly grandiose terms to Macron's. He said: 'It is with the hand of history on our shoulders that His Majesty's government therefore intends to recognise the state of Palestine when the UN general assembly gathers in September here in New York.' But unlike Macron, he gave Israel, which is deeply hostile to the idea, a way out. 'We will do it unless the Israeli government acts to end the appalling situation in Gaza, ends its military campaign and commits to a long-term sustainable peace based on a two-state solution,' he said. In his speech, Lammy also made 'absolute and unwavering' demands on Hamas. 'It must immediately release the hostages, agree to an immediate ceasefire, accept it will have no role in governing Gaza and commit to disarmament,' he said. • What will happen to the West Bank if Palestine becomes a state? But there was 'no conditionality' attached and no statement that anything Hamas might do or not do would cause the British government to change its mind. The main criticism raised by pro-Israel critics is that this gives Hamas an incentive to stall any ceasefire deal, since only Israel will be punished if one is not agreed. Lammy said: 'No one side will have a veto on recognition through their actions or inactions.' But only Israel would want to veto this development. The critics are now demanding the government explicitly insert balancing conditions on the 'other side'. Mark Carney, the Canadian prime minister, appears to have hewed more to the British path. His statement said that Canada 'intended' to recognise Palestine but also made the decision conditional. His conditions, though, were aimed at the Palestinian Authority of President Abbas, rather than Israel. He said: 'This intention is predicated on the Palestinian Authority's commitment to much-needed reforms, including the commitments by Palestinian Authority President Abbas to fundamentally reform its governance, to hold general elections in 2026 in which Hamas can play no part, and to demilitarise the Palestinian state.' Many people have demanded reforms of the Palestinians — the West, the Gulf states, Palestinians themselves. Few have been forthcoming.
