logo
Congress demands scraping of digital attendance system for MNREGA workers

Congress demands scraping of digital attendance system for MNREGA workers

The Hindu17-07-2025
Digitally capturing attendance of MNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act) workers through web platform National Mobile Monitoring System (NMMS) that depends on photo uploads of the workers is 'unworkable' & 'counterproductive' and must be withdrawn, Congress general secretary (Communications) Jairam Ramesh said in a statement here.
The Hindu had reported on Tuesday (July 15, 2025) Union Rural Development Ministry's July 8th directions to the States flagging the various ways NMMS, which was aimed at bringing in transparency, was being manipulated. Three years back the government had made it mandatory for all MNREGA workers to use this platform for marking their attendance. It required them to upload their photographs twice a day at the worksite. It was found that to meet this requirement, irrelevant photographs were being uploaded among other discrepancies.
'FAST is the self-declared motto of the Modi Government. It actually stands for First Announce Second Think,' Mr. Ramesh said in a statement here taking a dig at the government. Since its introduction, Mr. Ramesh said the Congress has highlighted the operational problems with NMMS and the government's July 8 notification is a final 'acknowledgement' of the problem.
The NMMS, Mr. Ramesh said, ended up excluding many genuine workers because of internet connectivity and other reasons without effectively checking the fake workers since they can go twice a day to be photographed, get paid without working for a minute. 'However, the Modi Government, post its acknowledgment of the issue, has identified solutions that are worse than the problem,' he said. Engaging the administration from top to bottom to verify the photos is going to waste the precious time of MNREGA functionaries. He demanded that the government must affirm 'task-based payments' which is the essence of MNREGA.
Nikhil Dey, founder member of Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, said, that the July 8th order is a confession that NMMS doesn't work but the solution offered is misplaced and misdirected. 'The government is paying the MNREGA labourer for the work carried out not simply for showing up. A photo, even if clicked twice a day doesn't show whether any work was carried out,' Mr. Dey said.
Instead of imposing newer and more complicated measures on the workers, Mr. Dey argued that the government must hold the supervisory authorities and the engineers accountable. 'A worker is paid on the basis of measurements by the engineers, first in carving out the work and then in appraising how much of it has been done. Instead of tasking the entire administration to look at photographs, shouldn't the government come up with monitoring mechanisms for supervisory authorities and engineers. Let them need to produce geo-tagged and geo-fenced photographs of the times they go to the field,' Mr. Dey said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

No protest, sloganeering in M.P. Assembly, says circular for Monsoon Session; Congress slams move
No protest, sloganeering in M.P. Assembly, says circular for Monsoon Session; Congress slams move

The Hindu

time39 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

No protest, sloganeering in M.P. Assembly, says circular for Monsoon Session; Congress slams move

The Madhya Pradesh Assembly Secretariat has prohibited protests and sloganeering in the Assembly premises in the upcoming Monsoon session that is scheduled to start from July 28, with the move drawing a criticism from the Opposition Congress. The ban was issued in a circular dated July 10 issued by A.P. Singh, Principal Secretary, M.P. Assembly concerning security protocols ahead of the upcoming session. 'Hon'ble Members are also requested that under the Standing Order 94(2) of Hon'ble Speaker, sloganeering and demonstrations in the Assembly premises by Hon'ble Members are prohibited,' said the circular, that also includes various other security protocols. Slamming the move, Leader of Opposition in the Assembly Umang Singhar said that the decision was taken 'under pressure from the government'. 'The government, which gives false and fake statistics in the Assembly, is issuing such rules and orders by pressurizing the Speaker to protect itself from being exposed. This is the murder of democracy,' he said, while reiterating the Congress's demand of live streaming the House proceedings. 'Article 194 of the Constitution gives special powers to the MLAs to raise the public's issues in the House. We strongly oppose this move and like before, we will raise public issues loudly in the upcoming session,' he said. Speaking to The Hindu, Mr. Singh, however, said that this was a routine circular that is issued for security purposes ahead of each session. 'There is no new or special provision in it. No ban has been imposed separately. Such circulars are issued before each session with such requests and the rest is left on the members' wisdom,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store